Table 1.
Data extraction of included studies
Author, year and country | Aim, study design and data type | Participants | Intervention and setting | Control or comparator | Description of peer leaders | Mental health measure | Key findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Psychotherapy and counselling | |||||||
Dow et al. 2020
Country: Tanzania |
Aim: To establish (1) the feasibility and acceptability of the pilot Sauti ya Vijana (SYV) intervention and (2) to conduct exploratory analyses on the impact of SYV on outcomes including mental health, stigma, ART adherence and HIV RNA Study design: Randomised controlled trial Data type: Quantitative |
Young people living with HIV who attended the adolescent HIV clinic at Kilimanjaro Christian Medical Centre (KCMC) or Mawenzi Regional Referral Hospital (MRRH) Age range: 12–24 Mean age: 18.1 N = 93 |
Intervention: Psychotherapy Description: SYV, 10 weekly group sessions (two held jointly with caregivers) and two individual sessions incorporating trauma informed cognitive behavioural therapy, interpersonal psychotherapy, and motivational interviewing. Participants were split into same sex groups with sex-concordant peer leaders. Setting: Community |
Routine monthly attendance to adolescent clinic with adherence counselling following Tanzanian guidelines | Young adults (23–30 years old) with background of either living with HIV and/or having prior experience with mental health research. They underwent a two-week intensive training with the Principal Investigator and clinical psychologists with weekly supervision sessions. |
|
|
Ferris France et al. 2023
Country: Zimbabwe |
Aim: To increase self-worth and wellbeing by reducing self-stigma among adolescents and young people living with HIV (AYPLHIV) Study design: Quasi-experimental design Data type: Qualitative |
Zvandiri Community Adolescent Treatment Supporters (CATS) living with HIV (LHIV), trained, mentored and supported to deliver structural support groups, counselling and tailored community-based adherence support to their peers. Age range: 18–24 N = 60 |
Intervention: Psychotherapy Description: The Wakakosha intervention (second delivery by peer coaches), a 10-day face-to-face intervention consisting of theory, meditation, group and individual experiences of Inquiry-Based Stress Reduction (IBSR), music reflection, sharing of insights, singing and songs, activity journaling, poem and letter writing, and podcast making Setting: Community and online (COVID–19) |
None | 15 CATS identified from the first delivery of the intervention were trained as peer coaches to lead the second delivery of the intervention. They attended residential face-to-face, six-day immersive Training of Trainers. They were supported by adult coaches when delivering the intervention |
|
|
Osborn et al. 2020a
Country: Kenya |
Aim: To evaluate if students in the Shamiri intervention would experience reductions in depressive and anxiety symptoms and improvements in social support, perceived control, and academic outcomes in a preliminary proof-of-concept trial. Study design: Randomised controlled trial Data type: Quantitative |
Adolescents with depression or anxiety Age range: 12–19 N = 51 |
Intervention: Psychotherapy Description: The Shamiri intervention consists of four weekly sessions that use didactic lectures, reading activities, group discussions and writing activities to explore self-growth, gratitude and values to address depression and anxiety Setting: School |
Didactic sessions on study skill strategies, group discussions and activities. | Five trained group leaders (17–21 years old) who are high school graduates and able to read in English. Training included 20 h of session. |
|
Depressive symptoms
|
Osborn et al. 2021
Country: Kenya |
Aim: To assess whether Shamiri intervention can alleviate depression and anxiety symptoms in symptomatic Kenyan adolescents Study design: Randomised controlled trial Data type: Quantitative |
Adolescents with elevated symptoms on standardised depression or anxiety measures Age range: 13–18 years Mean age: 15.4 N = 413 |
Intervention: Psychotherapy Description: The Shamiri intervention consists of four weekly sessions that use didactic lectures, reading activities, group discussions and writing activities to explore self-growth, gratitude and values to address depression and anxiety Setting: School |
Peer-led study skills session to teach skills on note-taking, study strategies, time management, study cycle. | High school graduates fluent in English and Kiswahili 18–26 years old who underwent 10 h of training and weekly supervision. |
|
Depression
|
Osborn et al., 2023
Country: Kenya |
Aim: To evaluate the effectiveness of Pre-Texts arts-literacy intervention for adolescent depression and anxiety in Kenyan high school students Study type: Randomised Controlled Trial Data type: Quantitative |
Students in Grades 9–11 from two community-run schools Age range: 12–19 Mean age: 16.36 N = 235 (intervention = 106 and control = 129) |
Intervention: Psychotherapy Description: An afterschool Pre-Texts art literacy intervention involving group (5–6 youth) meetings of 1 h over a one-week period for a total of five meetings. Literary, technical, scientific text extracts are provided and participants are invited to use the text as inspiration to understand and engage with themes and messages, thereby facilitating psychological change. This is followed by reflective discussions. Setting: School |
Study skills control group involving notetaking, time management, effective reading strategies. | Trained youth facilitators with a high school diploma and from around the Nairobi area. |
|
|
Simms et al. 2022
Country: Zimbabwe |
Aim: To evaluate if enhancing the counselling skills of CATS to provide problem-solving therapy (PST) reduces virological non suppression and improves mental health among adolescents living with HIV in Zimbabwe, compared with standard Zvandiri care Study design: Cluster-randomised trial Data type: Quantitative |
Adolescents living with HIV Age range: 10–19 N = 842 |
Intervention: Psychotherapy Description: Zvandiri-Problem-solving therapy (Zvandiri-PST) which consists of standard Zvandiri program (HIV care, counselling and home visits) and PST (a cognitive behavioural approach for problem solving) Setting: Health clinic |
Zvandiri standard care consisting of HIV care following Ministry of Health and Child Care guidelines, counselling and home visits by trained CATS, monthly support groups and weekly text messages | Community Adolescent Treatment Supporters (CATS) who are 18–24 years old living with HIV who are trained and mentored to provide peer counselling and support |
|
Intervention effect on prevalence and severity of common mental health outcomes
|
Venturo-Conerly et al., 2022b
Country: Kenya |
Aim: To test key, short term outcomes of a universal, classroom-based, single session version of each component of Shamiri intervention (i.e. growth, gratitude, and value affirmation) against an active control intervention. Study design: Cluster Randomised Trial Data type: Quantitative |
Students from two sub-county (lowest academic ranking) public boarding high schools in Kiambu Country, Kenya, one an all-girls and one an all-boys school N = 895 Mean age: 16.2 (all-girls school), 15.86 (all-boys school) |
Intervention: Psychotherapy Description: A single 1-h session version of the Shamiri intervention (Osborn et al., 2020b) testing each component (i.e. growth, gratitude, value affirmation) separately Setting: School |
Study skills control involving discussing helpful study strategies and implementation. | Lay-providers who were recent Kenyan high school graduates |
|
|
Venturo-Conerly et al., 2024
Country: Kenya |
Aim: To provide a more rigorous, long-term, and adequately powered examination of the Shamiri intervention, involving each intervention component, all components combined, and the study-skills condition. Study design: Randomised Controlled Trial Data type: Quantitative |
Students from four high-schools in Kenya N = 1,252 Age range: 12–21 Mean age: 16.25 |
Intervention: Psychotherapy Description: The Shamiri intervention consisting of all components (growth mindset, gratitude, and values affirmation) were tested against single-component sessions. Each intervention was tested against an active control group. Setting: School |
Study skills control involving discussing helpful study strategies and implementation | Lay-providers who were recent Kenyan high school graduates aged 18–22 |
|
Within the main sample:
|
Peer education and psychoeducation | |||||||
Balaji et al. 2011
Country: India |
Aim: To assess the acceptability, feasibility, and potential effectiveness of the pilot project Yuva Mitr in improving a range of priority health outcomes for youths 16–24 in urban and rural communities in Goa Study design: Randomised controlled trial Data type: Quantitative |
Youth living in urban communities in the wards of Margao and rural communities from the catchment area of Balli Primary Health Centre Age range: 16–24 Mean age: 19 N = 3,663 (baseline) N = 3,562 (follow-up) |
Intervention: Peer education Description: A 12-month intervention comprised of institution-based and community peer education involving group sessions and street plays, a teacher training program and dissemination of health information materials Setting: Community and school |
Not specified | Selected based on a pre-determined criteria (non-specified), trained by psychologists and social workers, and supported by community advisory board trained teachers. |
|
Rural:
|
Im et al. 2018
Country: Kenya |
Aim: To explore the effect of a trauma-informed psychoeducation (TIPE) intervention on both mental health and psychosocial domains among Somali refugee youth affected by trauma Study design: Quasi-experimental design Data type: Quantitative |
Somali youth refugees living in an urban business district affected by multiple refugee traumas Mean age: 20 N = 141 |
Intervention: Psychoeducation Description: 12 sessions of Trauma-informed Psychoeducation (TIPE) over three months that include (1) psychoeducational modules to promote refugee resilience, peace education, conflict resolution, problem-solving methods, (2) education on the impacts of trauma on the body, mind, social relationships, spirituality, and (3) psychosocial competencies such as emotional coping, problem solving, community and support systems and conflict management skills Setting: Community |
None | 25 youth leaders Week long training of trainer (TOT) training 10 youth leaders paired with five community health counsellors |
|
|
Kermode et al. 2021
Country: India |
Aim: To implement and evaluate an intervention to promote social inclusion for young people affected by mental illness Study design: Quasi-experimental design Data type: Quantitative |
Young people affected by mental illness, including those experiencing a mental health problem and those caring for a family member with a mental health problem Mean age: 18.9 N = 142 |
Intervention: Psychoeducation Description: A 4–6-month intervention consisting of the formation of 11 Youth Wellness Groups (peer-facilitated, participatory groups of young people divided by gender) guided by a series of interactive modules adapted from the Nae Disha curriculum. Setting: Community |
None | Eight peer facilitators affected by mental illness, with at least Class 12 education, ability to travel to intervention sites and communication skills. They were trained by the Burans Community Mental Health Project Team. (Qualitative outcomes of the same study has been described in Mathias et al., 2019) |
|
|
Mathias et al. 2018
Country: India |
Aim: To evaluate the effectiveness of Nae Disha intervention to reduce anxiety and depression, promote attitudes of gender equality, self-efficacy and resilience among highly disadvantaged young women outside of a school setting in India Study design: Quasi-experimental repeated measures design Data type: Quantitative |
Young women not attending school Age range: 12–24 Mean age: 16.7 N = 106 |
Intervention: Psychoeducation Description: Nae Disha, a 15-week intervention to facilitate health promotion, development of psycho-social assets to promote youth citizenship and positive youth development. Modules include exploring self-identity and esteem, identifying and managing emotions, mental health communication skills, relationship skills and forgiveness, self-care and drawing boundaries Setting: Homes of community members |
None | Local young women 20–30 years old expressing enthusiasm to work in youth resilience and have completed 12th Class. Had five days of training and two days of refresher training. |
|
|
Mathias et al., 2019
Country: India |
Aim: To assess the impact of a peer-led, community-based, participatory group intervention on social inclusion and mental health among young people affected by psycho-social disability in Dehradun district. Study type: Quasi-experimental design Data type: Qualitative |
Young people affected by psycho-social disability (PSD) in four communities in Uttarakhand, India. Age range: 12–24 N = 142 |
Intervention: Psychoeducation Description: The Nae Disha curriculum that builds on youth development and mental health promotion approaches using an interactive, participatory facilitation style of 17 learning modules (i.e. accepting differences, managing emotions, communicating confidently etc.). It also includes participation in community activities, access mental health services and visit a de-addiction centre. Setting: Community |
None | Peer facilitators selected from the four target communities that were young people aged under 30 years, with personal experience of mental ill-health and who had completed 12th class in high school (Quantitative outcomes of the same study have been reported in Kermode et al., 2021) |
|
Experienced by both genders
|
Merrill et al., 2023
Country: Zambia |
Aim: To explore youths’ experiences with Project YES! to strengthen the understanding of the intervention’s effectiveness and implementation, while enhancing the literature on peer-centered approaches to improving HIV outcomes among youth living with HIV Study design: Randomised Controlled Trial Data type: Qualitative |
Youth living with HIV Age range: 15–24 N = 276 |
Intervention: Peer education Description: Six-month peer-mentoring program, including an orientation meeting, and monthly individual and monthly group meetings with a youth peer mentor. The goal is to support youth to successfully adhere to ART and decreased internalised stigma to achieve viral suppression. Setting: HIV clinics |
Standard of care, including regular clinic visits and option of joining monthly youth group meetings. | Youth Peer Mentors (YPM), aged 21–26 years old selected by healthcare providers as successfully managing their HIV. Completed a two-week training and underwent one month of practice meetings with youth before the intervention launch. |
|
|
Mohamadi et al. 2021
Country: Iran |
Aim: To compare the methods of motivational interviewing led by a specialist and peer-to-peer education in promoting the knowledge and performance about puberty health and mental health in adolescent girls Study design: Cluster randomised controlled trial Data type: Quantitative |
Eighth grade adolescent female students Age range: 13–15 Mean age: 14.44 N = 334 |
Intervention: Peer education Description: Peer educators led one formal training on puberty and mental health to other students, followed by the informal passage of information to peers in groups of 5–6 students within 1 month Setting: School |
Two training sessions on puberty health conducted by the researcher Comparator: Group counselling involving motivational interviewing presented by a master in consultation in midwifery during five sessions of 60–90 min. |
Active volunteers who scored higher on the puberty health questionnaire prior to the start of the study, responsible for transmitting information to 5–6 other students. |
|
|
Yuksel et al. 2019
Country: Turkey |
Aim: To determine the effect of mentoring program on adjustment to university and ways of coping with stress in nursing students Study design: Quasi-experimental study Data type: Quantitative |
First-year undergraduate nursing students Mean age: N = 91 |
Intervention: Peer education Description: Eight weekly sessions of peer mentoring program including acquaintance and group awareness, life in Aksaray and its features, communication skills, techniques that facilitate communication, interpersonal communication, stress and coping Setting: University |
None | Ten fourth year students with 10 h of training over 5 days |
|
|
Peer support | |||||||
Duby et al. 2021
Country: South Africa |
Aim: To explore the perceived benefits of participation in peer-group clubs to better understand how combination interventions can incorporate social support and mental health components that ensure their relevance and effectiveness Study design: Quasi-experimental design Data type: Qualitative |
Adolescent girls and young women (AGYW) in and out of school Age range: 15–24 N = 185 |
Intervention: Peer-support Description: Peer-group clubs (The Keeping Girls in School Program and Rise Young Women’s Clubs) designed to build self-esteem, confidence, life skills, provide supportive peer networks, and offer a platform for group discussions on sexual and reproductive health rights and gender equality Setting: Community clubs and schools |
None | Trained peer-educators of similar age |
|
Peer-group clubs:
|
Harrison et al., 2023
Country: South Africa |
Aim: A pilot study to examine the acceptability, feasibility and preliminary impact of a peer support group for youth living with a range of chronic illnesses Study type: Quasi-experimental design Data type: Mixed methods |
Adolescents living with a range of chronic illness (i.e. HIV, renal disease, psychiatric conditions, diabetes, etc.) and receiving care at Groote Schuur Hospital (GSH) Age range: 13–24 Mean age: 18.74 N = 58 (intervention = 20 and control = 38) |
Intervention: Peer-support Description: The Better Together Programme, which helps adolescents with chronic conditions build social networks that enhance psychosocial support, develop a sense of belonging with peers, create a space where adolescents can share their experiences and build empathy. Setting: Hospital |
Non-peer group | Peer mentors who are also living with a chronic condition | Quantitative:
|
Quantitative:
|
Tinago et al., 2023 Country: Zimbabwe |
Aim: To test the effectiveness of a community-based peer support intervention to mitigate social isolation and stigma of adolescent motherhood Study type: Quasi-experimental design Data type: Quantitative |
Adolescent mothers who were pregnant and/or had a child or children who resided in the two selected communities in Harare Age range: 15–18 years N = 104 (intervention), 79 (control) |
Intervention: Peer-support Description: Peer support groups that met in-person twice a month and completed 12 total 75-min peer-group sessions. WhatsApp was used to schedule meetings, answer queries or further discuss peer support topics. Average of 12 participants per group. Setting: Community |
A community similarly low-income and high-density in Harare. | 12 peer educators co-facilitated the peer support groups with Community Health Workers |
|
|