Table 2.
Key features of the studies.
Content and study | Purpose | Technology (number of sensors) | Placement location | Placement method | Measurement/methodology | ||||||
Motion tracking | |||||||||||
|
Yu et al [27] | Monitor upper limb motion function of stroke patients | Accelerometer (n=2) | Forearm, upper arm | Straps | ROMa: Bobath’s handshake and shoulder touch | |||||
|
Wang et al [24] | Monitor compensatory movements and evaluate their applicability in a clinical setting | 9-DOFb IMUc (n=2) | Shoulder, torso | Zipped vest, Velcro straps | Compensatory movement of the shoulder girdle | |||||
|
Li et al [18] | Evaluate upper limb motor function in hemiplegic patients | 6-DOF IMU (n=2), EMGd (n=10) | Wrist, forearm, upper arm | Wristband, armband | Movements of major upper limb joints: shoulder, elbow, wrist, and finger joints | |||||
|
Repnik et al [20] | Quantify upper limb movement for muscle activity analysis in stroke patients | 9-DOF IMU (n=7), EMG (n=2) | Hand, wrist, forearm, upper arm, sternum | Wristband, armband, straps | Movement quantified: hand smoothness, trajectory, trunk stability, and muscle activity | |||||
|
Tolvanen et al [23] | General motion tracking | Piezoresistive strain sensor (n=1) | Hand, wrist, forearm, upper arm (biceps, triceps) | Reusable adhesive layer | Opening-closing cycles (hand), muscle tension of the flexor sternum, biceps, upper arm, bicep curl, peck fly, and triceps | |||||
|
Bai et al [13] | Monitor different body movements, muscle contraction, and relaxation | GYSe sensor | Upper arm, fingers | Direct winding | ROM: instant tensing, bending, static motions of fingers, varied contractions of the bicep | |||||
|
Gu et al [15] | Identify hand motions, joint bending, hand posture, gesture, and sign language | Hydrogel-elastomer hybrid ionic sensor (n=10) | Hand, fingers | Water-borne adhesive | ROM: finger bending/extending and hand gestures | |||||
|
Lee et al [17] | Analyze data from neurologically intact individuals and the free-living environment, and develop a system to monitor stroke survivors | Accelerometer (n=4) | Wrists, fingers | Rings, wristbands | General quantification of the amount of use of upper limb function | |||||
|
Zhang P et al [26] | Monitor human movement with the use of a flexible resistance strain sensor with a porous structure | Strain sensor (n=1) | Upper arm, forearm, wrist, fingers | Velcro straps | ROM: finger wrist and elbow bending; responses to breathing | |||||
|
Lee et al [16] | Facilitate the clinically fitted measurement of fine-motor finger and wrist joint movements. Characterize age-related changes in hand functions | 9-DOF IMU (n=7) | Wrist, hand, fingers | Clip-on straps | ROM: finger movement (index finger, thumb flexion/extension) and wrist movement (ulnar/radial flexion) | |||||
|
Zhang J et al [25] | Implement 3D motion velocity measurement, and propose a functional link artificial neural network model (FLANN) | Microthermal flow sensor (n=2) | Wrist | Straps | Trunk velocity, relative limb velocity, and absolute limb velocity | |||||
|
Schwarz et al [21] | Evaluate spatiotemporal kinematic metrics for the assessment of upper limb movements after stroke | 6-DOF IMU (n=8) | Sternum, shoulder, upper arm, forearm, hand, fingers, thumb | Medical tape/3D-printed flexible straps | ROM: shoulder, elbow, thumb, index flexion/extension, and wrist supination/pronation | |||||
|
Formstone et al [14] | Develop a comprehensive system designed for the clinical environment, and quantify hand/wrist movement | 9-DOF IMU (n=3), MMGf (n=2) | Sternum, upper arm, wrist, forearm | 3D-printed housing cases attached with 3D-printed flexible resin straps | Shoulder twist angle (range), abduction, flexion, elbow twist angle, wrist flexion, and circumduction muscle activity | |||||
|
Little et al [19] | Analyze kinematic and physiological features for predicting elbow motion intention | 9-DOF IMU (n=3), EMG (n=4), stretch sensor (n=1) | Forearm, upper arm, torso | Straps, direct winding | Muscle activity, elbow flexion angle, and custom-made changes in muscle volume | |||||
|
Schwerz de Lucena et al [22] | Real-time quantification of the effect of wearable feedback on hand counts for increasing hand activity | 6-DOF IMU (n=1), magnetometer (n=4) | Wrist, fingers | Wristband, ring | “Hand counts”: finger flexion/extension, wrist flexion/extension, and wrist radial/ulnar deviation movement | |||||
Rehabilitation | |||||||||||
|
Ding et al [39] | Measure orientation and correct arm posture using vibrotactile actuators for stroke rehabilitation patients and therapists | 9-DOF IMU (n=2) | Forearm, upper arm | Velcro straps | Body segment posture; forearm and upper arm orientation; trajectory of upper arm’s yaw, pitch, and roll; elbow angle; and forearm roll | |||||
|
Kim et al [31] | Wearable upper limb motion tracking method for stroke rehabilitation therapy at home | 6-DOF IMU (n=2) | Wrist, upper arm | Velcro straps | ROM: position and orientation of the wrist and elbow joints. Accuracy of motion estimation and motion matching | |||||
|
Mohammadzadeh et al [34] | Develop and evaluate the feasibility of a wearable sensor-based motion-tracking system | 6-DOF IMU (n=3) | Forearm, upper arm, sternum | Velcro straps | ROM: elbow joint angle | |||||
|
Ploderer et al [35] | Patient monitoring system to support occupational therapists in upper limb rehabilitation work with stroke patients | 9-DOF IMU (n=3) | Shoulder, upper arm, wrist | Velcro straps, medical tape | ROM of each degree of freedom | |||||
|
Wang et al [28] | Evaluate garments equipped with sensors that support posture monitoring; used in upper extremity rehabilitation training of stroke patients | 9-DOF IMU (n=3) | Scapula (shoulder blade), torso | Vest with Velcro straps | Analytical shoulder flexion, and analytical and functional elevation in the scapular plane | |||||
|
Salchow-Hömmen et al [37] | Part of a feedback-controlled hand neuroprosthesis for the rehabilitation of patients who experience motor impairment of the hand | 9-DOF IMU (n=16) | Hand, fingers, forearm | Skin-friendly tape | ROM: combined abduction and flexion motion | |||||
|
Semjonova et al [38] | Evaluate the impact of the Double Aid (DAid) smart shirt; training process of patients with subacromial pain syndrome | Strain sensors (n=2) | Scapula | Commercial elastane-based fitness shirt | Perform exercise without moving the shoulders; detect movement or no movement of the shoulders | |||||
|
Friedman et al [29] | Nonobtrusive option for monitoring wrist and hand movement; needed for stroke rehabilitation and other applications | Triaxial magnetometer (n=2), accelerometer (n=1) | Wrist, fingers | Watch-like enclosure, small neodymium ring worn on the index finger | Accuracy of monitoring finger motion, wrist flexion/extension, and wrist ulnar/radial deviation. Accuracy in estimating different levels of movement activity | |||||
|
Kortier et al [32] | Ambulatory system using inertial sensors for hand kinematics, and evaluation of hand functioning | 6-DOF IMU (n=15), 9-DOF IMU (n=6) | Hand, fingers, thumb | Double-sided adhesive tape/mounted on polyamide/elastane-fabricated glove | Static accuracy (ROM: flexion/extension, dynamic range, and repeatability) | |||||
|
Kim et al [30] | Identify optimal sensor locations | Bending sensor (n=2) | Thumb, hand | Flexible fabric straps partially made of Lycra sewed on a glove structure | ROM; circumduction motion | |||||
|
Liu et al [33] | Primary use of conductive stretchable fabrics to sense skin deformation during joint motion and infer the joint rotational angle | Strain sensor (n=2) | Forearm | Fabric | ROM: elbow flexion by various degrees; repeat motion at 3 levels of speed. Repeat each motion and perform free-form motions | |||||
|
Pregnolato et al [36] | Define the clinical features of stroke patients while performing hand movements for rehabilitation training | 9-DOF IMU (n=1), EMG (n=1) | Forearm | Armband | Detect the total muscle activity of the forearm circumference |
aROM: range of motion.
bDOF: degrees of freedom.
cIMU: inertial measurement unit.
dEMG: electromyography.
eGYS: graphene thin-film yarn sensor.
fMMG: mechanomyography.