| Research Purpose | Behavioral Classification | Description | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Physical action (n = 39) | Student behaviors | Sitting, raising hand, lowering head | [84] |
| Discussion, engaged, sleeping, eating, using smart phone | [82] | ||
| Asking, boring, bowing, looking | [85] | ||
| Bend, jack, jump, walk, wave1, wave2 | [47] | ||
| Aggressive, non-aggressive | [36] | ||
| Sleeping, playing on phone, moving, eating, reading, writing, using computer | [86] | ||
| Raising their hands, bending over, walking back forth, writing on the blackboard, looking up, bowing their heads, standing, raised hands, lying on their desks | [23] | ||
| Listening, looking down, lying down, standing | [87] | ||
| Playing on cell phones, sitting with hands on face, sitting turned right, sitting turned left, bowing, sleeping, drinking water, standing, yawning, having class, unknown behaviors | [88] | ||
| Positive behaviors: standing and listening; neutral behaviors: head-down; negative behaviors: head-turning | [34] | ||
| Raise hand, sleep, stand, use phone, take note, listen to class | [22] | ||
| Hand-raising | [89] | ||
| Reading or writing, looking at the blackboard, playing with cellphone, looking around, standing up, raising hand, lying down | [90] | ||
| Write, read, look up, turn head, raise hand, stand, discuss | [77] | ||
| Listening, looking around, lying on the table, reading, writing, using cell phone, talking | [71] | ||
| Look at phone, listen, stand, sleep, sit, talk, write | [74] | ||
| Sitting, standing, raising hand, average | [91] | ||
| Looking to the right, looking left, playing with cell phones, sleeping, standing, speaking | [92] | ||
| Raising hands, reading, writing | [93] | ||
| Write, read, look up, turn head, raise hand, stand, discuss | [73] | ||
| Looking at the board, looking down, turning head/turning around, talking, standing up, raising hands, lying on the table | [94] | ||
| Raising hand, standing up, writing, slippage, listening | [95] | ||
| Focusing, raising hands, writing, sleeping, using phones | [79] | ||
| Hand-raising, interacting, sitting, turning around, writing | [46] | ||
| Listen to lecture, play on phone, raise hand, write, sleep | [43] | ||
| Raising hand, reading, writing | [41] | ||
| Read, take notes, talk, tidy hair, rest head on hand, lie on desk, listen, raise a hand, stand, use the phone | [44] | ||
| Raising their hands, reading, writing, playing on their cell phones, looking down, leaning on the table | [72] | ||
| Teacher behaviors and student behaviors | Teachers: monitoring, discussion Students: sleeping, working, unengaged, using cell phone, discussion |
[96] | |
| Teacher: explain questions, pointing to the projection, no hand gestures, gesture with both hands, head down and operate, walk around, blackboard writing, guide to raise hand Student: look up, head drop, hand raise, stand up, lying on the desk |
[50] | ||
| Teacher: explanation, writing, silence, looking, media display Student: listening, turn, speaking, raising hands, discussion, writing, reading |
[49] | ||
| Teacher: guiding Student: writing, reading, listening, turning around, raising hand, standing, discussing |
[97] | ||
| Teacher: guiding Student: writing, reading, listening, raising hand, turning around, standing, discussing |
[98] | ||
| Teacher: explaining the subject, hitting, holding books, holding cell phone, holding stick, sitting on chair, slapping, walking in classroom, writing on board Student: arguing, clapping, eating in classroom, gossip, hand raise, reading book, sitting on desk, sleeping, standing, talking, writing on textbook |
[42] | ||
| Teacher behaviors | Bowing to students, pointing to the blackboard, writing on blackboard, cleaning the blackboard, operating the interactive whiteboard, inviting students to answer questions, walking around classroom and operating the realia | [99] | |
| Positive behaviors: teaching, blackboard writing, showing; negative behaviors: watching blackboard, watching podium; neutral behavior: operating computer | [35] | ||
| Symbolic action, conscious action, indicative action, evaluative action, and adaptive action | [100] | ||
| Pointing to left, pointing to right, and non-pointing | [101] | ||
| Writing on the blackboard, without obvious intention behavior, describing the teaching content, pointing to the teaching content | [102] | ||
| Learning engagement (n = 21) | Learning engagement levels | High, moderate, low | [37] |
| Very inattentive, inattentive, attentive, absent | [52] | ||
| High, moderate, low | [103] | ||
| Engaged, non-engaged | [104] | ||
| Engaged, non-engaged | [81] | ||
| Highly engaged, nominally engaged, not engaged | [105] | ||
| Minimum learning engagement, low learning engagement, high learning engagement, highest learning engagement | [106] | ||
| Low engagement, medium engagement, high engagement | [51] | ||
| Not engaged at all, nominally engaged, engaged in the task, very engaged | [107] | ||
| Positive, negative | [108] | ||
| Serious, good, fair, poor, and other | [109] | ||
| Low engagement, medium engagement, high engagement | [110] | ||
| High, medium, low | [111] | ||
| Cognitive engagement | ICAP framework: (+2, +1, 0, −1, −2) interactive, constructive, active, passive | [55] | |
| ICAP framework: (+2, +1, 0, −1, −2) interactive, constructive, active, passive | [56] | ||
| ICAP framework: interactive, constructive, active, passive, other | [24] | ||
| ICAP framework: interactive, constructive, active, passive | [11] | ||
| ICAP framework: disengaged, constructive, active, passive, interactive | [25] | ||
| ICAP framework: disengaged, constructive, active, passive, interactive | [13] | ||
| Behavioral and emotional engagement | Low, medium, high | [112] | |
| Head posture: nine directions; facial expression: positive emotions, negative emotions | [79] | ||
| Attention (n = 10) | Attention levels | Attentive, inattentive | [78] |
| Low, medium, high | [113] | ||
| Task-unrelated thought, task-related interference; not mind wandering; intentional and unintentional mind wandering | [40] | ||
| Attention, non-attention | [57] | ||
| Engaged, not engaged | [114] | ||
| Focused states, non-concentrating states | [58] | ||
| Dedicated, normal, distracted | [12] | ||
| Attention direction | The direction of the teacher and students’ gaze and body orientation | [21] | |
| At the teacher, slides, blackboard, taking notes, not concentrated | [2] | ||
| Board, laptop, other, undetected | [38] | ||
| Emotion (n = 10) | Student emotions | Boredom, confusion, delight, engagement, frustration, and for off-task behavior | [115] |
| Happiness, sadness | [116] | ||
| Awe, amusement, confidence, disappointment, neutral | [17] | ||
| Engaged, boredom, neutral | [76] | ||
| Anger, surprise, happiness, neutral, sadness, disgust, fear | [18] | ||
| Active, focused, confused, understanding, depressed, resist, disdain | [45] | ||
| Pleasure, arousal, and dominance: neutral, happiness, sadness, surprise, fear, disgust, anger | [48] | ||
| Teacher emotions | Amusement, awe, confidence, disappointment, neutral | [39] | |
| Learning task types | Easy, medium, difficult | [29] | |
| Easy, neutral, difficult | [28] |