Table 2.
Comparison of Charak Samhita online with traditional formats.
| Sr. No. | Parameters | Traditional format | Charak Samhita Online Edition |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Accessibility | The print editions are accessible only to book buyers limited to specific regions of trade. | Accessible to all users anywhere in the globe. |
| 2. | Cost effectiveness | The users have to purchase the books. It is additional economic burden to the students particularly in developing countries like India and Asian countries. | Open access make it free to all users without any economic burden. |
| 3. | Updates and additions of research | Updates are not possible in print books unless they are published in new editions. Again, this is a costly and time-consuming effort for publishers. | Easy updates are possible in wiki-based software used in Charak Samhita New Edition. |
| 4. | Searchability | Readers have to search the concepts manually across Charak Samhita. The time is a major concern for searching and collecting data. | Quick and easy search is possible in few seconds to get all references on the topic. Monograph section provides comprehensive information, too. |
| 5. | Interlinking, addition of graphics and multimedia files | Not possible in print form. | Cross-referencing, interlinking, and addition of multi-media files for a better understanding of the concept is always possible. |
| 6. | Multi-lingual translation | It can be published in only one language at a time. | The online edition can be read in multiple languages using translation tools. |
| 7. | Limitation of words and presentation | There is always a limit of words and pages in print form. This may limit the scope of authors' messages in print form. | The electronic form allows to presentation of all information in a comprehensive way. |
| 8. | Number of authors involved | All available translations are written either by a single author or two authors. This limits the views of presentations and experience in the translation. | The online edition involved more than 180 contributors to present their views. Thus, it included experiences and views of various eminent scholars. |
| 8. | Communication with authors | It is difficult to communicate with authors directly. | It is easy to communicate with each author in online edition. |
| 9. | Post publication citation analysis | The analysis of citations of print books and its chapters is difficult. | As each chapter has assigned DOI, it is easy to analyse citations of each chapter. These are useful in observing impact of the publication. |
| 10. | User-friendliness | It is difficult to carry and use the print books in online education platforms. | It is very easy to carry and use the digital edition in online education platforms. |