Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2025 Feb 25.
Published in final edited form as: Patient Educ Couns. 2022 Oct 30;106:17–30. doi: 10.1016/j.pec.2022.10.350

Table 2.

Characteristics of participants included in the meta-synthesis.

Source Ethnicity of
Participants
Participant
Number &
Gender
Mean
Age
Immigrant status Years in US Education level
Hesel et al. 2020[33] Hmong 10 males, 10 females 41 6 US-born, 8 born in Laos, 2 Thailand, 4 missing NR* 4 less than high school, 3 high school diploma/GED, 6 college degree, 7 graduate degree
Chang et al. 2020[26] Chinese 22 males, 35 females 71.5 All born outside the US NR Interviews: 3 less than 8th grade, 4 some high school, 2 high school diploma/GED, 2 vocational school or some college, 4 bachelor’s degree and above
Focus groups: 11 less than 8th grade, 6 some high school, 9 high school diploma/GED, 8 vocational school or some college, 8 bachelor’s degree and above
Bi et al. 2019[31] Multiple Asian subgroups 37 males, 3 females, 10 other NR NR NR 11 some college or 2-year degree, 28 college graduate, 7 more than college, 4 missing
Jun et al. 2018[23] Korean 0 males, 10 females 37.6 All born in Korea Mean = 5.7, SD = 2.5; Range = 4–14 All had a minimum of a bachelor’s degree
Fu et al. 2017[34] Multiple Asian subgroups 0 males, 35 females 51 All born outside the US Mean = 27.4; Range = 3–40 1 some elementary school, 2 elementary school, 4 middle school, 12 high school, 1 vocational school, 9 BS or BA, 3 MS, 1 PhD, 2 unknown
Lee et al. 2016[32] Chinese 0 males, 123 females 48.7 NR Median = 13.6 19 elementary or less, 40 high school, 64 college and above
Kim et al. 2015[17] Korean 0 males, 12 females 44.8 11 born in Korea, 1 born in the US Mean = 16; Range = 3–32 88.5% some college
Leung et al. 2014[24] Chinese 18 males, 11 females 63.6 All born outside the US Mean = 15; Range = 6–39 4 Grade 6 or less, 13 Grade 7–12, 4 no degree, 8 degree
Lim et al. 2012[15] Korean 0 males, 11 females 53.8 NR NR 1 less than high school, 3 high school graduate, 7 more than high school
Lee et al. 2012[18] Multiple Asian subgroups 0 males, 9 females 54 NR Mean = 18.6; Range = 7–35 2 high school or less, 7 college graduate or above
Killoran et al. 2006[19] Chinese 0 males, 69 females 56 Focus group: 30 born outside the US
Patient interviews: 21 born outside the US
Non-patient interviews: 21 born outside the US
Focus group: Mean = 17.4
Patient interviews: Mean = 17.8
Non-patient interviews: Mean = 12.2
Focus group: 14 less than 9 years, 8 were 9–12 years, 10 were 13–16 years, 2 were 17–18 years
Patient interviewees: 9 less than 9 years, 5 were 9–12 years, 12 were 13–16 years, 2 were 17–18 years
Non-patient interviewees: 4 less than 9 years, 5 were 9–12 years, 11 were 13–16 years, 1 were 17–18 years, 2 missing
Ashing-Giwa et al. 2004[20] Multiple Asian subgroups 0 males, 51 females 48 NR NR NR
Frank et al. 1998[16] Korean 0 males, 1 females 79 Born outside the US Mean = 12 NR
Leng et al. 2012[21] Chinese 16 males, 12 females 57 All born outside the US 0.5–1 year (1); 1–2 years (4); 3–5 years (2); 6–9 years (1); 10–15 years (4); 16–20 years (2); more than 20 years (13); 1 missing 1 (3–5 grades), 9 (6–9 grades), 6 (10–12 grades), 11 (more than 12 grades), 1 missing
Simon et al. 2021[27] Chinese 0 males, 56 females NR All born outside the US 0–5 years (10); 6–10 years (12); 11–15 years (11); 16–20 years (7); more than 20 years (15) 15 less than high school, 22 school graduate, 7 college 1–3 years, 9 college graduate or higher
Wang et al. 2013[22] Chinese 0 males, 44 females 57.7 37 born outside the US, 7 US-born Mean = 22.22 US born Chinese: 7 more than high school Immigrant Chinese: 19 less than or high school level, 18 more than high school
Chawla 2011[28] South Asian 0 males, 25 females 55 All born outside the US Mean = 28 1 high school, 6 college graduate, 18 graduate school or higher
Kim et al. 2017[29] Korean 0 males, 32 females 48.7 All born outside the US Mean = 16.4 14 were high school graduates or less, 18 some college
Nguyen et al. 2008[25] Vietnamese 10 males, 10 females 64.5 All born outside the US Median immigration year = 1992 US Education: 12 had no education in the US, 3 vocational or trade school, 1 some college, 4 ESL
Ashing et al. 2003[30] Multiple Asian subgroups 0 males, 34 females 56 NR NR NR
*

NR = Not reported