Skip to main content
. 2013 May 31;2013(5):CD009378. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD009378.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
Agerbaek 1979 Children at baseline span the age limit of the inclusion criteria, with the study being conducted not only in a primary school
Al‐Jundi 2006 No cariogenic food content to intervention
Anaise 1976 No cariogenic food component ‐ toothbrushing only
Andruskeviciene 2008 Children too young at the start of the study for the current review (study begins at 3 years of age)
Bagramian 1976 Not a randomised controlled trial
Bagramian 1978 Not a randomised controlled trial
Bagramian 1982 Not a randomised controlled trial ‐ stratified sampling
Belloso 1999 Not a randomised controlled trial
Bentley 1983 No dental outcome data in study
Bordoni 2005 Children too old for current review
Bretz 2004 No cariogenic food component
Buischi 1994 Study participants too old for current review criteria (13 years old)
Culler 2011 Not a randomised controlled trial
Curnow 2000 No cariogenic food component to intervention
Curnow 2002 No cariogenic food component to intervention
Davies 2002 Intervention only provided free toothpaste
Davies 2002a Intervention only provided free toothpaste
de Farias 2009 Not enough description of intervention to determine inclusion criteria components
Ekstrand 2000 Not a randomised controlled trial
Ellwood 2004 No cariogenic food component ‐ free fluoride toothpaste only
Englander 1979 Study participants too old for current review criteria
Esfahanizadeh 2011 No nutritional component ‐ only toothbrushing instruction
Feldens 2010 Study participants too old for current review criteria
Fernández 1988 Not a randomised controlled trial
Fernández 1988a No cariogenic food component ‐ toothbrushing only
Ferrazzano 2008 No cariogenic food component
Fischman 1977 Has a clinical component to intervention (restorative care) so unable to determine effects of behavioural intervention
Frencken 2001 Non‐random allocation to control and intervention group (self selection into training workshops)
Graehn 1984 Not a randomised controlled trial
Graves 1975 Not a randomised controlled trial
Grimoud 2005 Not a randomised controlled trial
Grocholewicz 1999 Insufficient information to confirm if had cariogenic food component to intervention
Harrison 2007 Children in study were too young for the current review
Hartono 2002 Not a randomised controlled trial
Hebbal 2011 Conducted in secondary school even though children are 12 years old
Hietasalo 2009 Not a school‐based intervention
Hochstetter 2007 Although Hochstetter 2007 appears to meet the inclusion criteria for the review, it was not included. Unfortunately, the reporting of this study was exceptionally poor and we could not rely on the information presented. The intervention appeared to be comprehensive and incorporating parents, children and teachers. Attempts to contact the authors to obtain clarification were unsuccessful
Holm 1990a Children in study were too young for the current review
Horowitz 1976 No cariogenic food component ‐ toothbrushing only
Horowitz 1977 No cariogenic food component ‐ toothbrushing only
Huang 1996 Epidemiological survey
Jackson 2005 No cariogenic food component
Julien 1994 No cariogenic food component ‐ toothbrushing and flossing only
Kakudate 2009 Not a school‐based intervention
Kerebel 1985a No cariogenic food component to study intervention
Klimek 1987 No cariogenic food component ‐ tooth cleaning only
Kramer 1990 No cariogenic food component. Children only took part in supervised tooth cleaning and professional plaque removal and local fluoridation
Lena 2001 No cariogenic food component to study
Martinez 2004 Insufficient information unable to access paper in time frame of review ‐ appears to not be a randomised controlled trial
Mazzocchi 1997 Not a randomised controlled trial ‐ states unable to randomise due to sample size
Milejczak 2011 Not a randomised controlled trial ‐ schools are not randomly allocated to treatment or control but selected in survey manor
Moorhead 1991 No cariogenic food component ‐ supervised brushing
Morgan 1998a Study participants too old for the current review
Nyandindi 1996 Randomisation occurs between "conventional session group" and control group. The "modified session group" were from the following school year, and so there was no randomisation. Cariogenic food component was only included in the modified session intervention, so the study does not satisfy our inclusion criteria for the part that is randomised
Peng 2004 This study was not a randomised controlled trial, random allocation was not reported and therefore could not be assumed
Peterson 1979 No cariogenic food component ‐ supervised brushing
Pine 2000 No cariogenic food component to intervention
Pine 2007 No cariogenic food component to intervention
Pujol 1996 Not a randomised controlled trial
Roberts‐Thomson 2010 Children in study too young for the current review
Rodrigues 2003 No cariogenic food component to study
Rodrigues 2009 Not a randomised controlled trial
Sagheri 2009 Cross‐sectional study
Schinder 1992 Paper could not be accessed by review deadline. Paper reported on 4 different educational approaches in oral health material in kindergartens in Israel
Schwarz 1998 Not a randomised controlled trial ‐ field demonstration trial
Secades 1995 Paper could not be accessed by review deadline. Study of corrective feedback and contingency management in establishing dental hygiene
Segal 1967 No cariogenic food component ‐ supervised toothbrushing
Stadtler 1981 No cariogenic food component ‐ supervised brushing
Stadtler 1982 No cariogenic food component ‐ weekly supervised brushing with a sodium fluoride gel
Suomi 1980 No cariogenic food component ‐ toothbrushing only
Tagliaferro 2011 Unable to determine the impact of behavioural intervention due to the clinical aspects included in intervention
Tai 2009 Unable to determine the impact of behavioural intervention due to the clinical aspects included in intervention
Tapias 2001 Not a randomised controlled trial
Toassi 2002 Not a randomised controlled trial
Tolvanen 2009 No clinical outcome ‐ questionnaire on children's oral health related behaviour, knowledge and attitudes
Tolvanen 2010a Study participants too old for the current review (teachers and parents)
van Palenstein 1997 Not a randomised controlled trial
Vanobbergen 2004 Not a randomised controlled trial ‐ schools are not randomly allocated to treatment or control but selected in survey manor
Wierzbicka 2002 Cross‐sectional survey
Yamaguchi 1997 Not a randomised controlled trial ‐ purpose of this study was to investigate the causes of increasing prevalence of dental caries