Skip to main content
NIHPA Author Manuscripts logoLink to NIHPA Author Manuscripts
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2025 Apr 1.
Published in final edited form as: J Appl Gerontol. 2024 Sep 12;44(4):628–637. doi: 10.1177/07334648241280041

Unmet Needs and Factors Impacting Home and Community-Based Service Use among Rural Appalachian Caregivers of People with Alzheimer’s and Dementia

David Russell 1, Christina E Miyawaki 2, Jennifer M Reckrey 3, Erin D Bouldin 4
PMCID: PMC11896892  NIHMSID: NIHMS2017528  PMID: 39263814

Abstract

Family caregivers of persons with Alzheimer’s disease and related dementias (ADRD) living in rural areas face significant health and healthcare challenges. Limited research, however, has explored factors shaping their use of home- and community-based services (HCBS). This study identifies unmet needs among caregivers of people with ADRD in rural Western North Carolina and highlights contextual factors that facilitate HCBS use. Nineteen qualitative interviews were conducted with 21 family caregivers and 1 person with ADRD between 2021-2022. Thematic analyses revealed unmet needs among caregivers for information, service navigation, and caregiving support. HCBS use was shaped by multiple factors including illness needs, cultural beliefs, preferences for home-based care, and place-based resources. These findings suggest that culturally-tailored HCBS are needed to support people with ADRD and their caregivers in rural Appalachian communities, especially those which facilitate access to paid caregiving, clearly communicate program eligibility requirements, and emphasize service availability.

Keywords: dementia, home and community based care and services, rural, qualitative methods, caregiving

Introduction

There are marked differences in health and health care access between people living in rural and urban areas in the U.S. (Bolin et al. 2015). Rural residents have greater odds of dying from preventable causes than their urban counterparts, a finding linked with impoverished conditions in rural areas that limits provision of health-promoting resources (Roth et al. 2020). These disadvantages extend to Alzheimer's disease and related dementias (ADRD): risk factors for ADRD are higher in rural than urban areas, and people living with ADRD in rural areas have more difficulty accessing memory care and other services than their urban peers (Roth et al. 2020; Bieber et al. 2019). People with ADRD living in rural areas also have shorter survival times after diagnosis than their urban counterparts, explanations for which may include delayed diagnosis as well as geographical care inequities, including lesser access to community-based services like adult day programs, home-delivered meals, paid caregiving, and self-help groups in rural compared to urban areas (Rahman et al. 2021; Arsenault-Lapierre et al. 2023).

Family caregivers of persons with ADRD living in rural areas also face difficulties that put them and the people for whom they care at higher risk for poor health outcomes, including financial challenges, lower socioeconomic status, limited service availability, and cultural beliefs and family norms that impede service use (Gibson et al. 2019; Ruggiano et al. 2018; Lethin et al. 2019; Moholt et al. 2020). Additionally, rural caregivers are more likely than their urban counterparts to provide daily functional assistance to care recipients and to serve in a caregiving role for two or more years (Cohen et al. 2022). As ADRD progresses, the needs of care recipients for services and support may exceed the capacities of caregivers. Unmet needs emerge when caregivers have needs for, but have not accessed, available services and support, such as assistance with ADRD evaluation and diagnosis, navigating health insurance, addressing home safety issues, or making advance care plans (Black et al. 2013). When present, unmet needs among informal caregivers can increase risk for institutional care (Brenner et al. 2023). Home and community-based services (HCBS), including home health, paid caregiving, home-delivered meals, adult day programs, and support groups, can help address unmet needs of informal caregivers for persons with ADRD. However, family caregivers in rural areas face challenges securing HCBS due to limited knowledge of ADRD, delayed ADRD diagnosis, financial and/or insurance constraints, distance to care recipients and key community resources, and their own health and healthcare needs (Shuffler et al. 2023; Williamson et al. 2022).

Rural communities in Western North Carolina represent an important site for studying family caregivers of persons with ADRD and their unmet needs for HCBS because of significant regional economic development and demographic changes that have increased demand for dementia-specific services–one in four family caregivers in North Carolina provide care to someone with ADRD (Alzheimer’s Association 2024), while at the same time representing a place with variable HCBS use due to cultural (i.e., acceptability, reluctance to seek help) and practical factors (e.g., service funding) (Chwalisz, Buckwalter, and Talley 2011).

Recognizing this, the present study sought to: (1) identify unmet needs among caregivers of people with ADRD living in rural Appalachian communities in Western North Carolina, and (2) explore factors shaping their service use. We were guided by a conceptual framework (see Figure 1) informed from theories of caregiving and health service use (Taylor et al. 2001; Roberto et al. 2022). This work suggests that family members often carry out a range of activities to meet the care needs of care recipients with ADRD, which in some cases can exceed the caregiver’s capacity to provide that care, influencing their consideration of HCBS and other resources (Taylor et al. 2001). Service use decisions are shaped by predisposing factors (e.g., education), enabling factors (e.g., finances, insurance, and social networks), and Illness-level factors (also referred to as “need”) factors (e.g., diagnoses, symptoms) (Roberto et al. 2022). Together, these factors interact with one’s culture, beliefs, norms, and local or regional context (Roberto et al. 2022). Research in rural Virginia found that family caregivers’ decisions to use HCBS are influenced by illness-level factors related to the care recipient’s memory, behavior, and activity limitations, predisposing factors such as the caregiver’s attitudes towards community services and deference to the care recipient’s preferences (e.g. for care by family rather than private caregivers), and enabling factors like family support and a sense of belonging formed by long-term relationships with extended kin and other community members (Roberto et al. 2022; Savla et al. 2022; Vipperman et al. 2022). While this work informed our study, there is substantial heterogeneity across Appalachian communities, not only across measures of education, income, and accessibility, but also in the identities, perspectives, beliefs and attitudes of community members.

FIGURE 1.

FIGURE 1.

Conceptual Model of Unmet Care Needs and Home and Community-Based Service Use among Rural Appalachian Caregivers of Older Adults with Alzheimer’s and Dementia

NOTE: This model was informed by the Sociocultural Model of Care Decisions and Service Use formulated by Karen A. Roberto and colleagues (2022), as well as by the Theory of Dependent-Care formulated by Susan G. Taylor and colleagues (2001).

Design and Method

This study used qualitative semi-structured interviews with family caregivers of people with ADRD living within rural Appalachian communities of Western North Carolina to identify unmet needs and factors shaping service use. Twenty one caregivers were recruited from counties across Western North Carolina, including Watauga (n=7), Buncombe (n=4), Ashe (n=3), Catawba (n=1), Caldwell (n=1), Cherokee (n=1), Transylvania (n=1), Rutherford (n=1), Madison (n=1), and Surry (n=1). These counties are mostly rural, representative of all three tiers of the state’s designations for economic well-being, and enable sampling across a range of identities, perspectives, beliefs and attitudes. Eligible participants included family caregivers who: (1) were 18 years or older, (2) read and spoke English, (3) provided assistance to someone with ADRD at least 8 hours per week, (4) lived with the care recipient or saw their care recipient at least twice a week, and (5) lived within the study catchment area. We interviewed current, former, and never users of services with the goal of including perspectives of all groups. We allowed caregivers to participate if their care recipient had recently died within the past year. To compare perspectives of family caregivers with those living with ADRD, we also interviewed one care recipient in Watauga county who self-reported an ADRD diagnosis, received 8 or more hours per week of caregiving from her live-in husband, and met criteria (1), (2), (4), and (5) above. This participant, who was beginning to navigate an early-onset ADRD diagnosis and increasingly relied on her husband for support, provided a complimentary perspective to those of caregivers on her emerging needs and factors shaping HCBS use.

Data Collection Protocols

We circulated a brief electronic screening survey to potential participants with the assistance of three regional Area Agency on Aging offices, two local caregiving organizations, one caregiver support group, and faculty/staff at one large regional state university. Information about the study and a link to the brief screening survey were circulated throughout these organizations through emails, paper flyers, meeting announcements, and postings to electronic list-servs. Twenty nine persons responded to our survey, all of whom were contacted and invited to complete an interview with a member of our study team. Nineteen interviews were completed with 22 persons between August 2021 and April 2022 via video conference (n=10), phone (n=8), and in-person (n=1) depending on preferences. Seventeen interviews included one participant (i.e. caregiver or person with ADRD). Two interviews were conducted with multiple family caregivers who partnered in providing care to persons with ADRD, including a mother and daughter who cared for the mother’s spouse, and a father, brother, and sister who cared for the father’s spouse. Verbal informed consent was obtained from all participants prior to the interview. To ensure that the participant with ADRD could provide informed consent, we used the University of California, San Diego Brief Assessment of Capacity to Consent to gauge their motivations for participation, understanding of study purpose and and research activities, and comprehension of voluntary participation (Jeste et al. 2007). The interview guide, informed by our conceptual framework, included questions about service needs and family support; social, emotional, physical, and financial circumstances; care preferences and future plans; and contextual factors shaping caregiving and HCBS use in rural Appalachia (see Appendix 1). Interviews lasted an average of 55 minutes (Standard Deviation=19; Range=27-107). With participants’ permission, interviews were audio recorded and transcribed verbatim. Participant names were changed to pseudonyms to protect anonymity. All protocols were approved by the Appalachian State University IRB (Protocol #21-0203).

Data Analysis

We conducted a thematic analysis of our qualitative interviews that was informed by our conceptual model (Nowell et al. 2017). We used NVivo to support the analytic process. The trustworthiness of our analytic process was maximized through the use of an audit trail to document analytic steps involved with developing our codebook and identifying themes, investigator triangulation involving multiple researchers to compare findings and conclusions, and peer-debriefing with an experienced qualitative investigator who was impartial to the study (Stahl and King 2020). The first author (DR) began by reviewing transcripts line-by-line to identify patterns in the data and an initial set of codes. These codes were a combination of categories derived deductively from the conceptual model, as well as codes that were identified inductively. After this initial coding, two other authors joined (EB, CM) to review and discuss the coding framework, identify codes which could be grouped together, and began to discuss how categories in the data fit into broader themes. Individual transcripts, and selected transcript excerpts aligned with domains of the conceptual model, were reviewed by the team in an iterative fashion across multiple meetings to refine themes and bolster their description until a consensus was reached that they accurately reflected the meaning evident in our interviews.

Results

Nineteen interviews were conducted with 21 family caregivers and 1 person with ADRD. Family caregivers had an average age of 56 (Standard Deviation=13; Range=28-83), were mostly female (80%), non-Hispanic White (100%), and educated, with all participants having received at least some college education (20%) or a four-year degree (80%). A majority of family caregivers were currently employed (55%), with the remainder retired (35%), unemployed (5%), or identifying as a homemaker (5%). Most family caregivers lived with the care recipients (62%) or resided within an hour's driving distance (38%). The participant with ADRD was a non-Hispanic White female over the age of 65 with some college education who lived with her spousal caregiver. Table 1 displays themes organized according to conceptual model domains, including caregivers’ unmet needs, and predisposing, enabling, and need factors that influenced their decisions regarding HCBS.

TABLE 1.

Conceptual Domains, Themes, and Representative Quotes

Conceptual
Domain
Theme Representative Quote
Unmet Needs Limited Knowledge about ADRD and How to Navigate HCBS “It feels like you are working without a [safety] net. We don’t know what to expect … as far as the speed of his decline and what that means behaviorally and physically. I just feel like we just take each day as it comes and hope for the best.” [Annie, Age 54, Woman]
Insufficient Caregiving Support “I need someone to be here with mom to watch her to make sure she’s not getting ready to slide out of the chair, to help me get her up when she can’t help me by herself to go to the restroom. It’s not that we need someone here 24/7, it’s just we need someone to help.” [Jo, 75, Woman]
Need Factors ADRD Symptoms and Progression "[The care recipient's] diagnosis was very fast … and very aggressive. I had to act fast and had to do a lot of research myself." [Everlynn, 60, Woman]
Co-Occurring Health Conditions "He has trouble standing up. He already had trouble standing up straight, but it's even more so. He's in a lot of pain, so he's actually seen an orthopedist, probably going to have some cortisone shots in his spine because of arthritis. We're hopeful that that will let him be a little more comfortable and more mobile because I know that he didn't exercise." [Jennifer, 44, Woman]
Predisposing Factors Preferences for Home-Based Care "In my family, everybody's always disparaging nursing homes. They don't want to have any part of that. There's a lot of pressure on me as her daughter to take care of her." [Lynn, 47, Woman]
Guilt "I feel guilty to apply for a vacuuming, home maid … because there's such a huge need and we have so many seniors who live alone who don't have a daughter who's able bodied and capable, who don't have financial means. I haven’t taken advantage of some of the things that I probably could take advantage of because I know in our community how many seniors suffer … They don’t have any family support. They live totally alone and they struggle to do their laundry [and] to go buy their groceries. I’m not going to take that resource away from somebody who needs it when, yeah, it would make my life easier, but I know our resources in this area are so taxed. I just can’t allow myself to use those services. I just can’t." [Lynn, 47, Woman]
Education, Training, and Work Experiences "At work, I try to be a team player, and no matter what the patient needs, I'm happy to help the nurses, hook them to the monitor, walk them, do whatever if I have the time and they don't have the time. So I don't just do the doctoring. I try to help out in other ways too. And I think that would probably add to my ability to be a caretaker." [Susan, 47, Woman]
Enabling Factors Finances "[The Area Agency on Aging] gave me access to a $600 grant that allows you to pay non-family members for care taking services. And obviously $600 isn't that much, but the purpose of it is to be used as a tester. So you can kind of test this out on different caretakers and see if it works for you, or if there's an emergency and you need your neighbor to do something because you're out of town, you could call them and then you could pay them with this grant money, essentially." [Benjamin, 28, Man]
Place “I think up here [rural Western North Carolina] the services aren’t the best. People go ‘off the mountain’ as they say for medical care and stuff.” [Janice, 67, Woman]
COVID-19 Pandemic “Just being able to talk to people and [have them] know what you’re going through is helpful. And people help each other out. And right now, one of the people … And I visit one once a week as a social thing, mainly because of COVID right, you can’t… We lost a lot of services, a lot of contact, social contact. And it’s good for the dementia people to also talk to someone who is not me, is not the person that they’re always with. You have more interaction.” [Angela, 65, Woman]

Unmet Needs

Two themes were identified within the domain of unmet needs, including (1) limited knowledge about ADRD and HCBS navigation, and (2) insufficient caregiving support.

Limited Knowledge about ADRD and HCBS Navigation

Family caregivers lacked a full understanding about ADRD, its progression, and described needing to “act fast” to learn more about the condition, including managing symptoms and handling difficult behaviors. They sought clarity about HCBS options, their costs and coverages, and felt behind in preparing for the future. Caregivers voiced how not knowing what to expect made them feel as if they were coping day-to-day without a safety net. These feelings were most acute for those who were just beginning to navigate an ADRD diagnosis given to the care recipient. Information and referral assistance about HCBS options and resources were perceived by caregivers as limited, particularly assistance with navigating and selecting suitable options beyond respite care that would allow their care recipients to remain at home. Caregivers expressed uncertainties about qualifications of care recipients for HCBS including home-delivered meals and adult day care. These knowledge gaps contributed to unmet needs among caregivers, especially for those whose paid-work responsibilities necessitated reliance on informal help from other family members or neighbors, for supervision and meal preparation while they were away from home.

Insufficient Caregiving Support

Caregivers occupied precarious positions characterized by insufficient caregiving support to meet the needs of care recipients. They pondered what would happen if there were changes to their existing support systems or increases in the care needs of the person with ADRD. They felt changes such as a loss of function or incontinence could overwhelm their capacity to provide care at home. Caregivers who felt more secure in managing their caregiving responsibilities lived in close proximity to (or with) the person with ADRD and/or had family members who could pitch-in to provide respite when needed. Amy (daughter), Aaron (son), and Thomas (spouse), felt more secure in managing the needs of their parent/spouse with ADRD by alternating turns providing care, staying in frequent contact with one another about their schedules, and purchasing a condominium where the two siblings could stay in-town when they visited. However, inequitable caregiving workloads between family members, in which one sibling or family member took on a greater share of caregiving responsibilities, contributed to unmet needs for intermittent support, respite, and supervision to ensure the safety of the person with ADRD. Unmet needs for caregiving support also arose due to caregivers’ difficulties finding paid caregivers within their rural communities whom they felt confident had the qualifications, experience, and scheduling availability to provide reliable services, especially when they were needed in a pinch. Lynn noted that while her community offered respite vouchers, she was ultimately responsible for finding the right person(s) to provide that service. Structural factors, including low paid caregiving wages and caps on available respite services, were attributed as factors driving their unmet needs.

Predisposing Factors

In the presence of unmet needs, predisposing factors shaped family caregivers’ service use decisions. Themes under this domain included: (1) education, training, and work experiences, (2) preferences for home-based care, and (3) guilt.

Education, Training, and Work Experiences

Education and training in fields such as human development and pastoral counseling, provided caregivers with knowledge about ADRD. Previous work experiences, which were varied and included leadership roles within service organizations, medicine, social work, insurance claim resolution, auditing, family therapy, and mental health counseling, increased caregivers’ familiarity with service offerings, aided them with navigating interactions with service providers and approaches to managing the care of persons with ADRD. Lynn, who held a position as the director of a senior center, was familiar with local HCBS offerings. Susan, an emergency physician at a regional hospital who cared for two parents with ADRD, spoke about her experiences working with clinical teams and families that enhanced her caretaking skills, increased her awareness of challenges facing families of persons with ADRD, and facilitated “difficult conversations” with her parents about their unmet needs for paid caregiving services they were reluctant to use.

Preferences for Home-Based Care

Family caregivers expressed strong preferences to care for persons with ADRD at home. Within the home, they preferred to arrange caregiving support from family rather than paid caregivers and other home-based care professionals, who were not always trusted to visit when scheduled or to recognize signs and symptoms of changing illness in persons with ADRD. Preferences for home-based care from family members were influenced by caregivers’ beliefs they could ensure more consistent care and higher quality of life for care recipients at home compared with institutional settings that enforced visitor restrictions, isolation precautions, lockdowns, and limited communal dining options. However, preferences for home-based care placed extra responsibility on family caregivers to remain the sole caregiver for the person with ADRD. Lynn, a caregiver living with her mother with ADRD, indicated that her family’s strong preferences for home-based care, combined with an inequitable caregiving workload between family members, placed “pressure” on her to take full responsibility for her mom’s care.

Guilt

Caregivers expressed reluctance to draw on HCBS like home-delivered meals and household (e.g. cleaning) services based on perceptions that these resources were scarce within their communities. They believed they would be taking these resources away from others with greater needs, despite acknowledging they faced their own financial challenges with securing HCBS. Everlynn, who worked full-time and cared for her mom whose ADRD behavioral symptoms included verbal and physical abuse, expressed how home-delivered meals would be helpful but felt “guilty to take a spot because I am capable of handling it for now [cooking meals for her mom and family after work].” She was reluctant to have a “pity party” out of a belief that other caregivers have a worse predicament than herself, securing care for persons with ADRD who have greater chronic health and/or mobility challenges.

Enabling Factors

Themes falling under the domain of enabling factors that facilitated HCBS use by family caregivers included: (1) finances, (2) place, and (3) the COVID-19 pandemic.

Finances

Income, savings, and grants from Area Agencies on Aging enabled caregivers to finance paid caregiving. Taylor described how her mother with ADRD’s modest personal savings allowed her to finance paid caregiving, but she expressed concerns about how exhausting those resources could jeopardize her ability to stay at home. Caregivers who were unable to finance paid caregiving drew on flexible work schedules, paid time off, and retirement options to redistribute their time to assist the person with ADRD. Caregivers expressed frustration that levels of care higher than HCBS within their rural communities, including assisted living and skilled facilities, while seen as resources, had limited insurance coverage and were beyond their financial reach.

Place

Caregivers perceived limited funding for, and availability of, HCBS for persons with ADRD in rural Western North Carolina. Caregivers viewed their communities as overlooked and lacking resources compared with urban centers in the Southeast. Limited access to specialty care, referral services, day care, respite, senior companionship programs, and elder care attorneys were each highlighted. Local agencies and organizations were described as necessary HCBS providers by caregivers, but were also viewed as insufficient to meet their needs and lacking coordination in their service offerings. While some promising HCBS were developed in caregivers’ communities, including an adult day care program spearheaded by a local church, they were not sustained due to volunteering and staffing issues. In the absence of formal HCBS, caregivers relied on relationships with rural community members to care for their family members with ADRD. Lynn, who occasionally depended upon neighbors for caregiving tasks and made special arrangements with her local transit and sheriff’s offices to ensure her mother with ADRD safely traveled to and from her shopping trips, remarked on how she felt “the whole community is helping me watch mom.” Distance also presented barriers to HCBS, including caregiver support groups that, while appealing, were too far from caregivers’ homes. Some caregivers addressed this by moving closer to care recipients.

The COVID-19 Pandemic

The COVID-19 pandemic impeded caregivers’ access to HCBS by limiting respite and social activities they engaged in prior to the pandemic. Day care and senior centers used by family caregivers we interviewed closed or shifted online during the pandemic, disrupting their daily routines, and limiting opportunities for social interaction amongst care recipients. In an effort to reduce infection risk, caregivers were reluctant to invite home health, hospice, and paid caregivers into their homes due to unknown infection control and prevention practices of visitors.

Need Factors

Family caregivers’ service use decisions were also shaped by need factors related to the person’s: (1) ADRD symptoms and illness progression, and (2) co-occurring health conditions.

ADRD Symptoms and Illness Progression

ADRD was highlighted as being different from other conditions in needs for information, support, and caregiving. Some of the unique illness characteristics of ADRD that family caregivers described included behavioral disturbances and impaired decision making that jeopardized safety and increased caregiver strain. Events such as losing one’s direction when running errands around town were mentioned by caregivers as significant turning points in illness progression that increased caregivers’ recognition of ADRD and needs for HCBS. The speed with which ADRD symptoms progressed also shaped the urgency with which family caregivers searched for, and sought out, information and opportunities for HCBS. Everlynn, a caregiver for her husband, described how the rapid progression of his ADRD, manifested by a car accident and lapsed bill payments, sparked a search for information, resources, and strategies to manage his care. ADRD progression also exacerbated caregivers’ and care recipients’ social isolation within rural communities, due to withdrawal from social activities (e.g., meals with friends) and increased caregiving role demands.

Co-Occurring Health Conditions

Persons with ADRD often had co-occurring health conditions, such as diabetes, arthritis, cataracts, or a hip replacement that further increased needs for HCBS. Family caregivers’ own health challenges, including overweight and chronic conditions, also complicated their abilities to care for persons with ADRD and factored into their planning and decision-making around service use. Jennifer, who cared for her father-in-law with Parkinson’s disease dementia, described how his compounding health problems, including arthritis and cataracts, limited his function and increased his needs for assistance, leading the home health agency to suggest the family “were at the limits of [their] capabilities.”

Discussion

Family caregivers of persons with ADRD residing in rural communities of Western North Carolina described unmet needs for HCBS, including for information to clarify eligibility for home-delivered meal and adult day care programs that could alleviate role conflicts and reduce caregivers’ reliance on weaker informal ties, as well as with arranging sufficient levels of paid caregiving support from a small pool of qualified, experienced, and reliable workers subsisting on low wages, limited public support, and inconsistent scheduling. Caregivers’ limited knowledge of, and difficulties arranging, HCBS, contributed to a sense of uncertainty and insecurity. While these unmet needs share similarities with caregiving challenges uncovered in previous work (Strommen et al. 2020), pandemic-related program closures and labor shortages have introduced additional structural barriers to accessing HCBS in rural Appalachian communities. HCBS availability in rural communities tends to be perceived as scarce (Siconolfi et al. 2019). Surprisingly, many rural caregivers we interviewed who had work and educational experiences that predisposed them towards HCBS use, including healthcare training and positions within organizations serving older adults, saw available HCBS as zero-sum, and expressed guilt that their use of this limited pool of resources would supplant opportunities for persons with greater needs. While earlier research has highlighted how rural ADRD caregivers often lack awareness of, do not receive information about, or fail to see a clear path to obtaining, HCBS (Disbrow et al. 2021; Martinez et al. 2022; Vipperman et al. 2022), our findings also suggest rural family caregivers faced with decisions about pursuing available HCBS may be less likely to use those services if they harbor guilt that other community members could potentially benefit more from using that service than themselves.

Several of the family caregivers whom we interviewed expressed strain, especially those who were reluctant to increase their reliance on other family members and who cared for persons with ADRD who had comorbid health conditions, severe cognitive impairment, and difficult-to-manage behavioral symptoms (e.g., anger, wandering, abuse). While these themes echo findings that family caregiving can have negative health consequences in the presence of multiple demands and inadequate support with meeting a care recipient’s daily needs for assistance, medical support, medication and care management (Adelman et al. 2014), they may also help to account for the high levels of social loneliness observed among rural family caregivers, specifically, as this group may perceive their social networks as lacking and feel they have few persons to whom they can turn to for support (L’Heureux et al. 2022).

This study identified predisposing factors including education, training, and work experiences that increased caregivers’ awareness of HCBS–findings also documented among rural family caregivers of persons with ADRD in Virginia, whose experiences in home health, nursing and social work provided tools to navigate enrollment processes (Roberto et al. 2022). However, we found that even those caregivers in our study with such experiences still reported substantial challenges in obtaining HCBS. Preferences for home-based care from family/friends and feelings of guilt, each acted at times as deterrents to service use. These findings may suggest that efforts to promote HCBS among rural caregivers may need to reinforce their availability and benefits to eligible community members to facilitate use.

Enabling factors like finances facilitated service use. Previous research indicates that rural caregivers are more likely to use HCBS when they report greater family support and have available funds to cover expenses (Vipperman et al. 2022; Savla et al. 2022). HCBS use assumes availability, however, and several family caregivers we interviewed had difficulties securing consistent paid caregiving support, a finding that resonates with research in rural North Dakota, where paid caregivers were also in short supply and available services were located far away (Strommen et al. 2020). COVID-19 further exacerbated HCBS availability, including senior center and adult day care programming. Expanding consumer-directed home care programs, like Home Care Independence in North Carolina, in which older adults with personal care needs can hire family, friends, or others as a caregiver or personal care assistant, could help address these needs (NC Department of Health and Human Services 2024b). However, these programs are currently available to only a small fraction of state residents.

Beyond the approaches mentioned above, additional strategies to support rural family caregivers include caregiver assessments that lead to family-centered plans of care and HCBS service referrals (i.e. to address gaps in knowledge about ADRD and limited awareness of available services), tax deductions for HCBS (i.e. to offset out-of-pocket costs incurred by caregivers), a national public long-term care social insurance program (i.e. to ensure broader coverage for HCBS), and expansion of recruitment, training, and financial support to the direct care workforce (i.e. to increase availability of reliable and trained paid caregivers for persons with ADRD) (The Recognize, Assist, Include, Support, and Engage (RAISE) Act Family Caregiving Advisory Council and The Advisory Council to Support Grandparents Raising Grandchildren 2022). The 2018 “Building Our Largest Dementia (BOLD) Infrastructure for Alzheimer’s” Act has opened additional funding for work to identify, translate, and disseminate research findings and evidence-informed strategies to persons with ADRD and their caregivers across the U.S., including those focused on early ADRD detection of dementia and programming for caregivers. BOLD resource hubs offering information and toolkits might consider focusing outreach on rural caregivers.

Limitations

Non-White, younger, male, and less-educated caregivers were under-represented in our study. All caregivers had at least some college education–a figure far higher than the regional average (“Education in Appalachia” 2021). Incorporating alternative interview methods, such as conducting interviews in Spanish, could help improve racial/ethnic diversity within samples of caregivers in rural areas. Given the importance of enabling factors like socioeconomic status and insurance in facilitating HCBS access, further studies might expand recruitment to caregivers of persons with ADRD enrolled in Medicaid-funded HCBS programs, like the Community Alternatives Program for Disabled Adults (NC Medicaid Division of Health Benefits 2024).

Conclusion

Family caregivers of persons with ADRD in rural Appalachia have unmet needs for information and educational programming about ADRD progression and available HCBS options that can be accessed along the care recipient’s illness trajectory, as well as for reliable paid caregiving support. To address these unmet needs, we recommend strengthening outreach through existing caregiving networks and expanding their connections and support to family caregivers who are not currently within their reach. In North Carolina, Project C.A.R.E. (i.e. “Caregiver Alternatives to Running on Empty”) represented one state-funded dementia-specific support program for family caregivers that helped to foster support networks among family caregivers, increase their knowledge of ADRD, and connect them with available resources including respite care (NC Department of Health and Human Services 2024a). Leveraging these networks to promote connections between family and paid caregivers who are trusted and well-compensated may help to facilitate reliable and consistent care for persons with ADRD and their family caregivers. Offering options for self-directed care, in which persons with ADRD hire their own caregivers, could help address unmet needs for paid caregiving. Increasing awareness of information and referral service liaisons at local Area Agency on Aging offices who are familiar with family norms, customs, and program availabilities could also aid with dispeling guilt among caregivers and assist them and those they care for in navigating complex HCBS eligibility requirements and care planning (Roberto et al. 2022).

What this paper adds:

  • Rural caregivers have unmet needs for information about ADRD, including disease progression and associated turning points in care, and challenges securing sufficient levels of paid caregiving support.

  • Guilt represents a powerful psychological deterrent to using certain HCBS options among rural family caregivers for persons with ADRD, including against decisions to use home-delivered meals and housekeeping.

Applications of study findings:

  • HCBS geared towards rural caregivers of older persons with ADRD should be tailored to address their beliefs and preferences during recruitment and enrollment processes, including by reinforcing availability, service benefits and limitations, and eligibility criteria.

  • Expansion of consumer-directed personal care options, together with informational services about ADRD diagnosis and HCBS navigation could help to address unmet needs among rural family caregivers.

Acknowledgements:

This work was supported by a pilot grant from the National Institute on Aging (NIA)-funded Interdisciplinary Network on Rural Population Health and Aging (INRPHA).

Appendix 1. Semi-Structured Interview Questions

The purpose of this interview is to understand more about services and support that can help people with Alzheimer’s and Dementias stay at home with the help of a family caregiver. The following questions are directed to you as the caregiver, the care recipient, or sometimes both of you. I will be asking you questions about your experience as a caregiver, your life as a care recipient, and the services you may use to help with caring for [care recipient]. Please answer these questions to the extent that you feel comfortable with. There are no right or wrong answers to these questions. We’re just interested in your honest and open feedback.

  1. [For care recipient] Starting out, can you tell us about how changes in your memory and thinking have affected your daily life and activities?

  2. [For caregiver] Could you walk me through how [care recipient]’s cognitive functioning has changed over time, and how these changes have impacted your day-to-day life and responsibilities as a caregiver?
    1. Probe: How has their disease affected their daily life, in terms of the types of activities they can no longer do or need assistance with?
    2. Probe: What types of ADRD symptoms and/or behaviors does [care recipient] have?
    3. Probe: Could you describe the severity of these symptoms and/or behaviors?
    4. Probe: Are there any types of decisions you help [care recipient] with day-to-day?
  3. [For caregiver] Could you talk more about the types of day-to-day things you do to help [care recipient]? These might include things like helping with dressing, bathing, preparing meals, cleaning, or other tasks.
    1. Probe: What motivates you to help [care recipient] with these activities?
    2. Probe: Have you made any changes to your home since [care recipient] became sick? These could include things like putting new locks on doors or placing certain appliances away in the kitchen that might be a safety risk. Did someone help you with this? [If yes: Who helped you make those changes to your home?]
    3. Probe: Is there anything in your past that has helped prepare you to care for [care recipient]?
  4. [For caregiver] Does anyone assist you in caring for [care recipient], either regularly or once in a while to give you a break? This could include a friend, family member, or someone who is paid to help you, like a home health aide or home attendant.

  5. [For caregiver]Are there any social, emotional, physical, or financial challenges you face with providing care to [care recipient]?
    1. Probe: Could you describe your stress levels in this role?
    2. Probe: How would you describe your quality of life as a caregiver?
    3. Probe: How has your life changed since you started caregiving for [care recipient]?
  6. [For caregiver and care recipient] Is there anything you would like more help with?
    1. Probe: Are there any services that you wish were available to help you care for [care recipient]?
    2. Probe: Are there any services that you think would not be helpful?
  7. [For caregiver and care recipient] Could you describe any in-home services you have used? Examples could be having someone to come help with cleaning or to stay with [care recipient] while you were at work or away?
    1. Probe: Can you tell us a bit more about how you started to use that service?
    2. Probe: How did you learn about those services?
    3. Probe: Have you used any in-home assistive technology services, counseling, nursing, occupational, physical, or speech therapy, or exercise programs?
    4. Probe: Are there any types of medical equipment or supplies that have helped you with caring for [care recipient], such as lift chairs or medication reminders?
  8. [For caregiver and care recipient] Can you describe any other programs or groups you’re involved with? For example, these might include in-person or online support groups, community or senior centers, adult day programs, or anything else?

    Note: Make a list of each program/service mentioned by interviewees.
    1. [For caregiver and care recipient] How has _____ been helpful to you?
    2. [Ask about each program/service described by the interviewee(s)]
    3. Probe: Can you tell us a bit more about how you started to use that service?
    4. Probe: How did you learn about those services?
    5. Probe: What needs were you hoping to get help with through that program/group?
    6. Probe: Do you feel like the program/group is helping you meet those needs?
    7. Probe: What issues do you feel still need to be addressed?
  9. [For caregiver and care recipient] Are there any services that might help you manage [care recipient’s] needs but that you feel like you can’t use or don’t have access to? This could be because of where we live.
    1. Probe: Do you feel that there are enough services available in your area (rural Appalachia)?
    2. Probe: Have you ever faced any economic challenges when accessing services?
    3. Probe: Are there any services that you haven’t used because you are worried about how others would view you or [care recipient]?
  10. [For caregiver and care recipient] What types of plans have you made for the future?
    1. Probe: What types of help do you think you might need down the line?
    2. Probe: Are there any services you think you might need later that you don’t need now?
  11. [For caregiver and care recipient] Do you prefer to get help and support at home versus somewhere like an assisted living facility or nursing home that is designed to help people with cognitive changes? Why or why not?

  12. Is there anything else you’d like to mention regarding your experience living in this community with memory loss or as a caregiver?

Footnotes

Conflict of Interest Statement:

The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.

Institutional Review Board (IRB) Approval:

All study protocols are approved by the Appalachian State University IRB (Protocol #21-0203).

Contributor Information

David Russell, Department of Sociology, Appalachian State University, ASU Box 32115, 480 Howard Street, Boone, NC 28608.

Christina E. Miyawaki, Graduate College of Social Work, University of Houston.

Jennifer M. Reckrey, Department of Geriatrics and Palliative Medicine, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai.

Erin D. Bouldin, Health Services Research & Development, Department of Veterans Affairs Medical Center, Salt Lake City, Utah, Assistant Professor, School of Medicine, University of Utah.

References

  1. Adelman Ronald D., Tmanova Lyubov L., Delgado Diana, Dion Sarah, and Lachs Mark S.. 2014. “Caregiver Burden: A Clinical Review.” JAMA: The Journal of the American Medical Association 311 (10): 1052–60. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  2. Alzheimer’s Association. 2024. “North Carolina State Overview.” 2024. https://www.alz.org/professionals/public-health/state-overview/north-carolina. [Google Scholar]
  3. Arsenault-Lapierre Geneviève, Bui Tammy X., Berre Mélanie Le, Bergman Howard, and Vedel Isabelle. 2023. “Rural and Urban Differences in Quality of Dementia Care of Persons with Dementia and Caregivers across All Domains: A Systematic Review.” BMC Health Services Research 23 (1): 102. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  4. Bieber Anja, Nguyen Natalie, Meyer Gabriele, and Stephan Astrid. 2019. “Influences on the Access to and Use of Formal Community Care by People with Dementia and Their Informal Caregivers: A Scoping Review.” BMC Health Services Research 19 (1): 88. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  5. Black Betty S., Johnston Deirdre, Rabins Peter V., Morrison Ann, Lyketsos Constantine, and Samus Quincy M.. 2013. “Unmet Needs of Community-Residing Persons with Dementia and Their Informal Caregivers: Findings from the Maximizing Independence at Home Study.” Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 61 (12): 2087–95. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  6. Bolin Jane N., Bellamy Gail R., Ferdinand Alva O., Vuong Ann M., Kash Bita A., Schulze Avery, and Helduser Janet W.. 2015. “Rural Healthy People 2020: New Decade, Same Challenges.” The Journal of Rural Health: Official Journal of the American Rural Health Association and the National Rural Health Care Association 31 (3): 326–33. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  7. Brenner Rachel J., Hansen Jared, Brintz Ben J., Bouldin Erin D., Pugh Mary Jo, Rupper Randall, Munoz Richard, Garcia-Davis Sandra, and Dang Stuti. 2023. “Association between Specific Unmet Functional Needs and Desire to Institutionalize among Caregivers of Older Veterans.” Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, February. 10.1111/jgs.18307. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  8. Chwalisz Kathleen, Buckwalter Kathleen C., and Talley Ronda C.. 2011. “Caregiving in Rural America: A Matter of Culture.” In Rural Caregiving in the United States: Research, Practice, Policy, edited by Ronda C, Chwalisz Talley Kathleen, and Buckwalter Kathleen C., 1–16. New York, NY: Springer New York. [Google Scholar]
  9. Cohen Steven A., Ahmed Neelam, Brown Monique J., Meucci Marissa R., and Greaney Mary L.. 2022. “Rural-Urban Differences in Informal Caregiving and Health-Related Quality of Life.” The Journal of Rural Health: Official Journal of the American Rural Health Association and the National Rural Health Care Association 38 (2): 442–56. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  10. Disbrow Elizabeth A., Arnold Connie L., Glassy Nathaniel, Tilly Collette M., Langdon Kate M., Gungor Deniz, and Davis Terry C.. 2021. “Alzheimer Disease and Related Dementia Resources: Perspectives of African American and Caucasian Family Caregivers in Northwest Louisiana.” Journal of Applied Gerontology: The Official Journal of the Southern Gerontological Society 40 (2): 209–19. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  11. “Education in Appalachia.” 2021. Appalachian Regional Commission. June 1, 2021. https://www.arc.gov/about-the-appalachian-region/the-chartbook/education-in-appalachia/. [Google Scholar]
  12. Gibson Allison, Holmes Sarah D., Fields Noelle L., and Richardson Virginia E.. 2019. “Providing Care for Persons with Dementia in Rural Communities: Informal Caregivers’ Perceptions of Supports and Services.” Journal of Gerontological Social Work. 10.1080/01634372.2019.1636332. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  13. Jeste Dilip V., Palmer Barton W., Appelbaum Paul S., Golshan Shahrokh, Glorioso Danielle, Dunn Laura B., Kim Kathleen, Meeks Thomas, and Kraemer Helena C.. 2007. “A New Brief Instrument for Assessing Decisional Capacity for Clinical Research.” Archives of General Psychiatry 64 (8): 966–74. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  14. Lethin Connie, Hallberg Ingalill Rahm, Vingare Emme-Li, and Giertz Lottie. 2019. “Persons with Dementia Living at Home or in Nursing Homes in Nine Swedish Urban or Rural Municipalities.” Healthcare (Basel, Switzerland) 7 (2). 10.3390/healthcare7020080. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  15. L’Heureux Tanya, Parmar Jasneet, Dobbs Bonnie, Charles Lesley, George Peter Tian J, Sacrey Lori-Ann, and Anderson Sharon. 2022. “Rural Family Caregiving: A Closer Look at the Impacts of Health, Care Work, Financial Distress, and Social Loneliness on Anxiety.” Healthcare (Basel, Switzerland) 10 (7). 10.3390/healthcare10071155. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  16. Martinez Iveris L., Gonzalez Elaine Acosta, Quintero Caroline, and Vania Marsha Jenakovich. 2022. “The Experience of Alzheimer’s Disease Family Caregivers in a Latino Community: Expectations and Incongruences in Support Services.” The Journals of Gerontology. Series B, Psychological Sciences and Social Sciences 77 (6): 1083–93. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  17. Moholt Jill-Marit, Friborg Oddgeir, Blix Bodil H., and Henriksen Nils. 2020. “Factors Affecting the Use of Home-Based Services and out-of-Home Respite Care Services: A Survey of Family Caregivers for Older Persons with Dementia in Northern Norway.” Dementia 19 (5): 1712–31. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  18. NC Department of Health and Human Services. 2024a. “Project CARE.” 2024. https://www.ncdhhs.gov/divisions/aging/project-care-caregiver-alternatives-running-empty. [Google Scholar]
  19. —. 2024b. “Home Care Independence.” February 2, 2024. https://www.ncdhhs.gov/divisions/aging-and-adult-services/home-care-independence. [Google Scholar]
  20. NC Medicaid Division of Health Benefits. 2024. “Community Alternatives Program for Disabled Adults (CAP/DA).” February 2, 2024. https://medicaid.ncdhhs.gov/providers/programs-and-services/long-term-care/community-alternatives-program-disabled-adults-capda. [Google Scholar]
  21. Nowell Lorelli S., Norris Jill M., White Deborah E., and Moules Nancy J.. 2017. “Thematic Analysis: Striving to Meet the Trustworthiness Criteria.” International Journal of Qualitative Methods 16 (1): 1609406917733847. [Google Scholar]
  22. Rahman Momotazur, White Elizabeth M., Mills Caroline, Thomas Kali S., and Jutkowitz Eric. 2021. “Rural-Urban Differences in Diagnostic Incidence and Prevalence of Alzheimer’s Disease and Related Dementias.” Alzheimer’s & Dementia: The Journal of the Alzheimer's Association 17 (7): 1213–30. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  23. Roberto Karen A., Savla Jyoti, McCann Brandy Renee, Blieszner Rosemary, and Knight Aubrey L.. 2022. “Dementia Family Caregiving in Rural Appalachia: A Sociocultural Model of Care Decisions and Service Use.” The Journals of Gerontology. Series B, Psychological Sciences and Social Sciences 77 (6): 1094–1104. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  24. Roth Adam R., Denney Justin T., Amiri Solmaz, and Amram Ofer. 2020. “Characteristics of Place and the Rural Disadvantage in Deaths from Highly Preventable Causes.” Social Science & Medicine 245 (January): 112689. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  25. Ruggiano Nicole, Brown Ellen L., Li Juanjuan, and Scaccianoce Monica. 2018. “Rural Dementia Caregivers and Technology: What Is the Evidence?” Research in Gerontological Nursing 11 (4): 216–24. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  26. Savla Jyoti, Roberto Karen A., Blieszner Rosemary, and Knight Aubrey L.. 2022. “Family Caregivers in Rural Appalachia Caring for Older Relatives With Dementia: Predictors of Service Use.” Innovation in Aging 6 (1): igab055. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  27. Shuffler Jon, Lee Kathy, Fields Noelle, Graaf Genevieve, and Cassidy Jessica. 2023. “Challenges Experienced by Rural Informal Caregivers of Older Adults in the United States: A Scoping Review.” Journal of Evidence-Based Social Work 20 (4): 520–35. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  28. Siconolfi Daniel, Shih Regina A., Friedman Esther M., Kotzias Virginia I., Ahluwalia Sangeeta C., Phillips Jessica L., and Saliba Debra. 2019. “Rural-Urban Disparities in Access to Home- and Community-Based Services and Supports: Stakeholder Perspectives From 14 States.” Journal of the American Medical Directors Association 20 (4): 503–8.e1. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  29. Stahl Norman A., and King James R.. 2020. “Expanding Approaches for Research: Understanding and Using Trustworthiness in Qualitative Research.” Journal of Developmental Education 44 (1): 26–28. [Google Scholar]
  30. Strommen Jane, Fuller Heather, Sanders Gregory F., and Elliott Dustin M.. 2020. “Challenges Faced by Family Caregivers: Multiple Perspectives on Eldercare.” Journal of Applied Gerontology: The Official Journal of the Southern Gerontological Society 39 (4): 347–56. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  31. Taylor Susan G., Renpenning Kathie E., Geden Elizabeth A., Neuman Bonnie M., and Hart Marcella A.. 2001. “A Theory of Dependent-Care: A Corollary Theory to Orem’s Theory of Self-Care.” Nursing Science Quarterly. 10.1177/08943180122108030. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  32. The Recognize, Assist, Include, Support, and Engage (RAISE) Act Family Caregiving Advisory Council, and The Advisory Council to Support Grandparents Raising Grandchildren. 2022. “National Strategy to Support Family Caregivers.” [Google Scholar]
  33. Vipperman Andrew, Savla Jyoti, Roberto Karen A., and Burns Derek. 2022. “Barriers to Service Use Among Dementia Family Caregivers in Rural Appalachia: Implications for Reducing Caregiver Overload.” Prevention Science: The Official Journal of the Society for Prevention Research, December, 1–11. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  34. Williamson Heather J., Begay Andria B., Dunn Dorothy J., Bacon Rachel, Remiker Mark, Garcia Yolanda E., McCarthy Michael J., and Baldwin Julie A.. 2022. “‘We Live on an Island’: Perspectives on Rural Family Caregivers for Adults with Alzheimer’s Disease and Related Dementias in the United States.” Qualitative Report 27 (10): 2343–58. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]

RESOURCES