Table 1:
Summary of RAPID-DASH compared to other gRNA array approaches.
Study | Assembly approach | Maximum gRNAs assembled | gRNA processing method | Overall assembly time | Pre-cloning step | Scalability | Oligos pergRNA(length) | Other limitations |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
RAPID-DASH | Golden gate assembly | 10 gRNAs(up to 20 gRNA units can beassembled usingRAPID-DASH online tool) | Individual expression cassettes | 3 days | No | Scalable as gRNA oligos can be pooled during PCA toassemble gRNA arraylibraries | 1 (59 bp) | Long read sequencing required to screen clones |
Vad-Nielsen et al.26 | Golden gate assembly | 30 gRNAs(Assembled in 2 stages) | Individual expression cassettes | > 7 days | Yes | Cloning each gRNA restricts scalability | 2 (25 bp) | Labor intensive:multiple rounds ofcloning, culturing and sequence validation |
McCarty et al.18 | Golden gate assembly | 12 gRNAs | Csy4 processing | > 2 days | No | Scalable as the gRNA units can be pooledbefore adding Type IISoverhangs for the array assembly (Notdemonstrated in the study). | 1 (53 bp) | Labour intensive: multiple rounds of PCR, digestion and gelpurifications. RequiresCsy4 endonuclease for individual gRNA processing. |
Kurata et al.20 | Golden gate assembly | 10 gRNAs | Csy4 processing | > 5 days | Yes | Cloning each gRNA restricts scalability | 2 (25 bp) | Labor intensive:multiple rounds ofcloning, culturing and sequence validation.Csy4 endonuclease for individual gRNA processing. |
Zhang et al.23 | Golden gate assembly | 8 gRNAs | tRNA processing | >2 days | No | gRNA spacersequences being theGolden Gate overhangs restricts scalability. | 2 (44 to 60 bp) | The gRNA maturation could interfere with endogenous tRNA pool |
Yuan et al24 | Golden gate assembly | 10 gRNAs | tRNA/Csy4/Ribozyme processing | 3–5 days | No | gRNA spacersequences being theGolden Gate overhangs restricts scalability. | 2 (27 to 52 bp) | The gRNA maturation could interfere withendogenous tRNA pool(tRNA processing) or requires Csy4 endonuclease expression |
Breunig et al.25 | Gibson assembly | 8 gRNAs | Individual expression cassettes | 3 days | No | gRNA spacersequences mediatehomology for Gibson assembly thus restricting scalability. | 2 (36–45 bp) | Low assembly efficiency(34% for 4 gRNA assembly) |
Scalability indicates using the approach to assemble multiple gRNA arrays or libraries of arrays simultaneously.