Skip to main content
. 2025 Apr 30;26(3):145–151. doi: 10.4274/ThoracResPract.2024.24061

Table 1. Characteristics of the included studies.

First author (year)

Country

Study design

Participants

n of the defined

Age

years

Gender

n of men, (%)

Salimi et al.14 (2023)

Iran

Experimental

16 healthy volunteers

30 (IQR 25-38)

7 (44)

Mollakazemi et al.15 (2023)

USA

Experimental

12 healthy individuals

18-35

6 (50)

Zaccaro et al.16 (2022)

Italy

Experimental

12 healthy volunteers

48±12

3 (25)

Jung and Kang21 (2021)

Korea

Experimental

22 healthy volunteers

22.27±1.42

10 (45)

Hong et al.22 (2021)

Korea

Experimental

20 healthy volunteers

23.7±2.28

7 (35)

Lee et al.10 (2020)

Korea

Experimental

20 healthy volunteers

23.7±2.28

7 (35)

Zelano et al.23 (2016)

USA

Experimental

8 patients with temporal lobe epilepsy

48 (IQR 29-59)

8 (100)

Trevisan et al.6 (2015)

Brazil

Cross-sectional

39 healthy volunteers (NB)

38 healthy volunteers

22.6±2.9

22.7±3.5

11 (28)

13 (34)

Ribeiro et al.26 (2004)

Brazil

Experimental

46 healthy children

8-12

33 (72)

Tafil-Klawe and Klawe27 (2003)

Poland

Experimental

35 healthy volunteers

35 healthy volunteers

20-30

41-55

N/A

N/A

Takahashi et al.28 (2002)

Japan

Experimental

10 healthy volunteers

28.6±2.3

10 (100)

IQR: interquartile range, NB: nasal breathing, OB: oral breathing, N/A: not available