Table 1.
Failure modes and accompanying RPN scores for identified failure modes for a standard treatment with and without a Record and Verify system
| Failure mode | Impact | RPN with record and verify (occurrence, detectability, severity) |
RPN with no record and verify (occurrence, detectability, severity) |
Percent increase (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dose not recorded, fraction repeated | Overtreatment | 126 (3, 6, 7) | 392 (7, 8, 7) | 211 |
| Wrong patient brought from waiting room for treatment | Patient treated with wrong plan | 140 (5, 4, 7) | 294 (7, 6, 7) | 110 |
| Patient does not show up for treatment | Gap in treatment | 245 (7, 7, 5) | 280 (7, 8, 5) | 140 |
| Wrong beam modifier | Wrong dose to patient | 224 (7, 8, (4) | 224 (7, 8, 4) | 0 |
| Beam interruption | One beam not delivered, partial under- or overdose | 64 (8, 2, 4) | 224 (8, 7, 4) | 250 |
| Proper IGRT not performed | Patient not aligned correctly | 96 (4, 4, 6) | 216 (6, 6, 6) | 225 |
| Patient wrongly aligned during image alignment | Dose delivered to wrong location | 168 (6, 4, 7) | 210 (6, 5, 7) | 25 |
| Patient arrival not communicated, missed treatment | Gap in treatment | 60 (6, 2, 5) | 210 (6, 7, 5) | 250 |
| Wrong positioning applied | Patient in wrong position | 180 (6, 6, 5) | 180 (6, 6, 5) | 0 |
| Wrong plan pulled up for the right patient | Patient treated with wrong plan | 84 (3, 4, 8) | 168 (6, 4, 7) | 100 |
| Partial treatment missed | Partial underdose | 60 (3, 4, 5) | 105 (3, 7, 5) | 75 |
| Patient not sent for clinic visit | Missed clinic visit | 72 (8, 9,1) | 81 (9, 9, 1) | 12 |
| Pacemaker not monitored according to instructions | Pacemaker not monitored | 10 (1, 10, 1) | 30 (3, 10, 1) | 300 |
| Patient came back twice in same day | Exceeded daily dose | 4 (1, 1, 4) | 16 (1, 4, 4) | 300 |
| Average ± SD | 110 ± 74 | 188 ± 103 | 71 |
Abbreviations: IGRT = Image Guided Radiation Therapy; RPN = Risk Priority Number.
The rows are ordered in order of highest to lowest RPN score for the situation with no record and verify system availability.