Table 1.
Characteristics of selected studies
| Author and year | Country/city | Study population | Sample size | Partici-pants’ age | Study design | Data collection methods | Focus of the study | Type of music intervention | Facilitators | Outcome measure | Results |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Anderson et al., 2022 [24] | South Africa- Limpopo province | Primary school Children/ grade3 learners | Primary school Children/ grade3 learners | Phase 1: n = 12 (Primary Schools) with n = 244 participants in song only intervention. Phase 2: n = 8 Primary schools with n = 124 participants in song only intervention | Mixed method | Pre- and post- intervention questionnaire and interview from 8 primary schools | Health literacy and behavioral education and intervention effectiveness | Culturally and Age-appropriate malaria song using participatory action research | Behavioral change, awareness, and knowledge | The result showed that culturally and age-appropriate songs can play a significant role in developing behavioral changes and spreading awareness against disease in a high-risk malaria region | |
| Manana et al., 2019 [25] | South Africa- Kwazulu-Natal province | Community | Community |
Total = 140 Community members = 100 Experts = 40 |
Mixed method | Self-administered surveys and community dialog sessions | Community participation in health education and implementation effectiveness | Genre song in IsiZulu, on Malaria and Sterile Insect Technique (SIT) for vector control | Knowledge on malaria transmission and SIT technologies | 100% of the community (Jozini) and 75% of experts agreed it was culturally appropriate and 92% of all participants agreed on content appropriateness of the song. Malaria signs and symptoms were least remembered (< 10%) | |
| McConnell et al., 2017 [26] | Gambia | The Gambia | The Gambia | N = 46 Performance groups | Qualitative | Ethnographic research of performers and health workers, observation and analysis of Ebola prevention performances | Health message dissemination and promotion | Mandinka language song in call and response form | Health messages on Ebola symptoms, transmission, and prevention | The study explained that positive emotions such as love and happiness facilitate understanding, while negative emotions such as anger and fear present an obstacle for effective communication | |
| Anderson et al., 2018 [27] | South Africa- Limpopo province | Young Children | Young Children |
N = 10 Purposively selected experts. Focus group 1: N = 7(Female caregivers and preschool teachers) Focus group 2: N = 5 (Malaria control personnel) |
Qualitative | Participatory action research, risk analysis, expert Opinion, expert interview, survey and document search | Health literacy and risk communication | Malaria prevention song with Delphi technique employing repetition | Knowledge and awareness of the link between mosquitoes and malaria |
Experts agreed on importance of linking mosquitoes to malaria and recognizing early symptoms. Initially opposed including bed nets but later approved changes post-feedback Focus groups preferred inclusion of bed nets, despite experts' earlier disagreement Rejected indoor residual spraying (IRS) for children due to safety concerns |
|
| Stone, 2017 [28] | Liberia—Montserrado County | Community | Community | NA | Qualitative | Ethnographic research | Health message dissemination and promotion | Public Health jingles and Songs, Christian Hymns repurposed for emotional support | Awareness on Ebola | Songs helped convince the public, Ebola was real, dispelling myths. Sounds, particularly sirens, proved to be powerful stimuli of attention and emotion during the Ebola outbreak | |
| Walker, 2022 [29] | South Africa—Cape town | High School Children (15–19 years old) | High School Children (15–19 years old) | N = 200 High School Students | Qualitative | Individual interviews and focus groups | “Sing” music video, Combined pop, gospel, and local South African styles. Focused on emotive imagery, powerful statistics, and musical storytelling to raise awareness about HIV/AIDS | HIV awareness music video. Experiential and firsthand responses to emotive stimuli using Qualitative analysis |
Theme 1: Messaging Fatigue Theme 2: Tool for engagement within a saturated aids-related media landscape |
||
| Flax et al., 2014 [30] | Nigeria—Bauchi State | Female microcredits clients (15–45 years) | Female microcredits clients (15–45 years) |
Total = 461 Intervention arm: N = 40 groups Control Groups: N = 37 groups |
Cluster- Randomized controlled trial | Baseline and final survey (Pre and post intervention) | Recommendations to increase adherence to breast feeding through group counselling, health messaging and participant created content |
3 component intervention: 1. Group Counselling 2. Cell phone messages 3. Songs and Drama |
Enhanced local engagement and discussions, cell phone use | Breast feeding behavior | The main study outcome, exclusive breast feeding to 6 months were increased in the intervention compared to the control arm (P < 0.01). The odds of exclusive breastfeeding to 3 month (P < 0.05), but not to 1 month (P = 0.10), were also elevated in the intervention vs. the control. The intervention also changed breastfeeding behaviors in the first days of life. The odds of initiating breastfeeding within 1 h of delivery (P < 0.001) and giving only colostrum or breast milk in the first 3 d of life (P < 0.01) were increased in the intervention vs. the control arm |
| Bastien, 2009 [31] | Tanzania | Young people, Kilimanjaro region (majorly between 13–18 age groups) | Young people, Kilimanjaro region (majorly between 13–18 age groups) | N = 65 Young People | Qualitative | Interviews, informal conversations with community members, content analysis of popular songs | Disease prevention messages | Popular Tanzanian songs (Bongo Flava Genre) addressing AIDS metaphors, Stigma, HIV prevention messages | Music cultural relevance and engaging local narratives | Public perceptions and behaviors | Emergent themes from songs are on AIDS Metahors, Stigma, HIV prevention measures. They tried to raise awareness and stimulate awareness offering low cost, wide reach for HIV |