Skip to main content
. 2025 May 30;11:13. doi: 10.1186/s42234-025-00173-w

Table 1.

Summary of AI methods in breast cancer immunotherapy prediction

Omic Biomarker Task Data source Tumor Model/Algorithm Year Reference
Transcriptomic Expression of M2-like tumour-associated macrophages Immunotherapy response TCGA TNBC Simple neural network-based deep learning 2020 Bao et al. 2020)
Expression of antigen processing and presentation machinery Prognostic TCGA BC LASSO logistic regression and RF 2023 Müller et al. 2023)
Expression of costimulatory molecule genes TIME status TCGA TNBC LASSO and SVM-RFE 2024 Zhang et al. 2024)
Expression of genes Immune-related cells Institutional and public Dataset BC and melanoma Gaussian mixture modeling, Kullback–Leibler (KL) divergence, and mutual nearest-neighbors criteria 2023 Zou et al. 2023)
Expression of redox-related gene Prognostic Institutional and public dataset BC RF, LASSO, GBM, Survival-SVM, superpc, Ridge Regression, plsrcox, coxboost, Stepwise Cox regression, and Enet 2024 Wang et al. 2024)
Expression of genes pCR Institutional and public dataset BC LASSO, SVM-RFE, and xgboost 2024 Lu et al. 2024)
Expression of DPP4-related genes Prognosis Institutional and public dataset TNBC Xgboost, RF, adaboost, KNN, ANN, and LR 2023 Kang et al. 2023)
Proteomic IHC and H&E TMA PD-L1 expression Public dataset Breast cancer CNN model with residual connections 2022 Shamai et al. 2022)
IHC images PD-L1 Status Institutional dataset Pan-cancer Weakly supervised deep learning with ResNet-50 and attention-based MIL 2024 Ligero et al. 2024)
Expression of signature proteins Immunotherapy response Institutional dataset TNBC RF 2024 Li et al. 2024)
Pathology H&E WSI Prognostic Institutional and TCGA dataset TNBC Dual CNN 2022 Zhao et al. 2022)
WSI TIL Clinical studies and TCGA datasets BC CNN architectures with segmentation and attention-based classifier 2024 Perera et al. 2024)
WSI Immunotherapy-related gene TCGA BC MIL architecture with resnet-18 2025 Zhang et al. 2025)
H&E TMA pCR Clinical studies TNBC Regularized logistic regression 2023 Wang et al. 2023a)
H&E WSI lncRNA–metabolism class prediction Institutional and TCGA dataset BC Resnet50 for feature extraction and gated attention 2024 Yu et al. 2024)
H&E WSI TMB TCGA TNBC LR, KNN, RF, and DT 2025 Bendani et al. 2025)
H&E WSI TIL and ki-67 Public dataset BC U-net-like backbone with CNN and residual dilated inception module 2021 Negahbani et al. 2021)
Radiomic DEC-MRI pCR Institutional dataset TNBC Lasso regression 2023 Ramtohul et al. 2024)
DCE-MRI TME subtypes TCGA BC RF 2024 Han et al. 2024)
CE-CT Immunotherapy response Clinical studies BC Multivariable logistic regression 2023 Zhao et al. 2023)
MRI TIL Institutional dataset BC LR, RF, MLP, SVM, LDA, and GB 2022 Huang and Lin 2022)
PET/CT pCR Institutional dataset TNBC LR 2023 Seban et al. 2023)
Epigenetic Methylation level of CpG sites Prognostic TCGA BC Cox and LASSO regression 2021 Zhang et al. 2021)
Expression of senescence-relevant lncRNAs Prognostic TCGA BC Cox and LASSO regression 2023 Yu et al. 2023b)
Expression of nine hub lncRNAs CD8 T-cell levels TCGA BC DT, GBM, GLM, ANN, RF, SVM 2022 Chen et al. 2022b)
Expression of Mitochondrial DNA methylation Prognostic TCGA BC Cox and LASSO regression 2023 Ma et al. 2023)
Microbiology Abundances of microbe Prognostic TCGA BC Cox and LASSO regression 2021 Mao et al. 2022)
Genus-level intratumor microbiome Prognostic TCGA BC Cox and LASSO regression 2024 Li et al. 2024)
Omic 256 multi-modal biomarker signatures from (gene expression, cellular morphometric biomarkers, and abundance of microbe) Prognostic TCGA BC Multivariate Cox regression 2022 Mao et al. 2022)
Radiological features and gene expression Axillary lymph node metastasis TCGA BC Multivariate LR analysis 2024 Lai et al. 2024)
Pathology images, lncRNA data, immune cell scores, and clinical features Prognostic Institutional and TCGA dataset BC CNN architecture with attention-module, concatenation fusion, and a conclusive regressor 2024 Yu et al. 2024)
Mammogram, MRI, radiological, histopathological, personal, and clinical data Pcr Institutional and public Dataset BC Resnet18 architecture for feature extraction, cross-modal knowledge mining, and ensemble model for final prediction 2024 Gao et al. 2024)
Genomic RNA-seq data Somatic copy number aberrations TCGA Pan-cancer Sequence models and graph neural networks 2024 2024)
Whole-exome sequencing and RNA sequencing Neoantigen immunogenicity Institutional dataset Pan-cancer Ensemble model (LR and xgboost) 2023 Jin et al. 2021)
Genomic instability-related lncRNA signature Prognostic TCGA BC Multivariate Cox regression 2022 Jiao et al. 2022)

TCGA The cancer genome atlas, TNBC Triple-negative breast cancer, BC Breast cancer, LASSO Least absolute shrinkage and selection operator, RF Random forest, SVM-RFE Support vector machine-recursive feature elimination, GBM Gradient boosting machines, SuperPC Supervised principal component, plsRcox partial least squares cox regression,Enet Elastic net, xgBoost extreme gradient boosting, AdaBoost Adaptive boosting, KNN K-nearest neighbor, ANN Artificial neural networks, LR Logistic regression, DT Decision tree, MLP Multilayer perceptron, LDA Linear discriminant analysis, GB Gradient boosting, GLM Generalized linear models, CNN Convolutional neural network, MIL Multiple instance learning, xgBoost extreme gradient boosting, IHC Immunohistochemistry, H&E Hematoxylin and eosin, TMA Tissue microarray, pCR pathological complete response, DPP4 dipeptidyl peptidase 4, TIL Tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes, TME Tumor microenvironment, DCE-MRI Dynamic contrast-enhanced MRI, CT Computed tomography, PET Positron emission tomography, WSI Whole slide imaging, TMB Tumor mutation burden, lncRNA long non-coding RNA