Table 3.
Ergogenic aids interventions in CrossFit® participants.
Study | Sample characteristics | Study design | Intervention |
Main findings | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Supplement | Dosage | Timing | ||||
Grijota et al. [64] | 21 male CrossFit® athletes; training experience: > 2 yrs. | Double-blind crossover trial | Cyclodextrin (CHO derived from plant starch). | 30 g | During | – ↔ CrossFit® performance, heart rate, rate of perceived exertion, lactate, glucose execution speed in bench press between groups. – ↑ power values in CHO group. – Average power ↑ in CHO group whilst fatigue index ↑ placebo group. |
Główka et al. [65] | 26 male and female CrossFit® athletes; training experience: > 2 yrs. | Double-blind crossover trial | Caffeine | 3 mg.kgBM−1, 6 mg.kgBM−1, 9 mg.kgBM−1 | 70 minutes prior to the test | – ↔ of CrossFit® performance (number of repetitions in both groups). − 6 mg.kgBM−1 CAF ↑ number of repetitions. – Heart rate and rate of perceived was ↔ in both groups. – Blood lactate was ↑ in CAF 9 mg.kgBM−1 in comparison to CAF 3 mg.kgBM−1. − 6 mg.kgBM−1 CAF ↓ reaction and motor times. |
Durkalec-Michalski et al. [66] | 30 male and female CrossFit® participants; training experience: > 4 yrs. | Double-blind crossover trial | Sodium bicarbonate | 0.15 g·kg FFM −1, 0.25 g·kg FFM −1. 0. 35 g·kg FFM −1 | 2 hours prior to exercise | – ↑ blood pH 0.25 g·kg FFM
−1 and 0.35 g·kg FFM
−1 NaHCO3 to the baseline values at recovery. – ↑ blood pH 0.35 g·kg FFM −1 NaHCO3 at recovery. – Lymphocytes ↑ 0.25 g·kgFFM−1 NaHCO3 post-exercise and recovery than control. – Granulocytes, red blood cells, hemoglobin, white blood cells ↑ control at recovery. – Monocytes ↑ 0.25 g·kgFFM−1 NaHCO3 post-exercise than control at recovery. – Magnesium ↑ in control at recovery. – Creatinine ↓ in control at recovery. |
De Souza et al. [67] | 17 advanced male CrossFit® trained athletes; training experience: > 1 yr. | Double-blind crossover trial | Sodium bicarbonate | 0.30 g·kg−1 ingested with the meal | 2 hours prior to exercise | – NaHCO3 ↑ the performance in Fran CrossFit® challenge. – Performance in 500 m rowing and jumping ↔. – NaHCO3 ↑ blood pH in comparison to placebo. – No differences between groups were found for lactate, heart rate and RPE. |
Ziyaiyan et al. [68] | 20 male CrossFit participants®; training experience: > 2 yrs. | Double-blind crossover trial | Caffeine + sodium bicarbonate | 6 mg·kg−1 (CAF) + 0.1 g·kg−1 (NaHCO3) | 120, 90, 60 minutes before the protocol | – No significant effects of supplementation were noted. – HRmax ↑ CAF and CAF + NaHCO3 in comparison to control group. – RPE during Cindy challenge ↓ CAF compared to NaHCO3, CAF + NaHCO3 and control groups. |
Zawieja et al. [69] | 43 male recreationally and regularly trained CrossFit® participants; training experience: > 1 yr. | Double-blind crossover trial |
Betaine | 2.5 g·kg−1, 5.0 g·kg−1 | 3 weeks: 2.5 g·kg−1 – three capsules in the morning and two in the evening; 5.0 g·kg−1 – four capsules in the morning, three in the afternoon, and three in the evening |
– BET ↑ 8.7% Fight Gone Bad performance but, no significant differences were found compared to placebo group. – ↔ performance in Wingate test in both groups. |
Mattos et al. [70] | 9 male CrossFit® participants; training experience: > 3 months. |
Crossover | CHO | 1.0 g·kg−1 grape + banana juice; 1.0 g·kg−1 Whey Maximize | 60 minutes before the protocol | – RPE was ↓ on Whey Maximize supplement than fast state. |
Oliveira et al. [71] | 17 male trained CrossFit® participants; training experience: > 1 yr. | Double-blind crossover trial |
Capsiate | 12 mg, 24 mg | 45 minutes before the protocol | – Performance, HR and RPE was ↔in CAP and placebo. |
Martin et al. [72] | 11 female CrossFit® athletes; training experience: > 2 yrs. | Double-blind crossover trial |
Sodium bicarbonate | 0.3 g·kg−1 | Individualized approach | – NaHCO3 ↑ 2.2% rowing performance in comparison to placebo group. – Mean power ouput ↑ NaHCO3 (p < 0.05). |
Gomes et al. [73] | 6 male CrossFit® participants; training experience: > 6 months. | Double-blind parallel trial |
Sodium bicarbonate | 0.3 g·kg−1 | 90 – 150 minutes prior to the test | – No effects of NaHCO3 on RPE. |
Caetano et al. [74] | 8 male trained CrossFit® participants; training experience: > 2 yrs. | Double-blind crossover trial |
Caffeine | 6 mg·kg−1 | 60 minutes prior to the protocols | – CAF ↑ local muscular endurance and number of repetitions. – Squat maximum repetition was ↔ in both groups. |
Silvestre [75] | 19 male and female CrossFit® participants; training experience: > 2 months | Double-blind crossover trial |
Beta-alanine | 6.4 g.day−1 | 28 days. 4 times per day: 3 hours of interval (especially after meals) | – No differences between groups in performance, RPE, sleep quality, mood and well-being. |
Fernandez-Lázaro et al. [76] | 30 trained male CrossFit® participants; training experience: > 3 yrs. | Parallel single-blind trial | Tribulus terrestris | 770 mg | 6 weeks: 30 minutes prior to CrossFit® workout | – Muscle biomarkers: ↑ LDH in placebo group whilst LDH ↓ in TT supplementation. – Inflammatory markers: ↑ CRP placebo group whilst CRP ↓ in TT supplementation but without significance. – Total Oxidant Status ↑ in TT group. – Performance ↔ in both groups. |
Maroufi et al. [77] | 8 male CrossFit® athletes; training experience: > 6 months. | Crossover single-blind trial | Carbohydrates + protein | 500 ml carbohydrate-protein with different ratios (2:2, 3:1) | 60 minutes prior to the test and immediately before | – Performance in CHO + protein and placebo groups was ↔ considering the number of repetitions in CrossFit® challenges. |
Fernandez-Lázaro et al. [78] | 30 trained male CrossFit® participants; training experience: > 1.5 yrs. | Parallel single-blind trial | Tribulus terrestris | 770 mg | 6 weeks | – TT ↑ bench press performance significantly whilst the performance in control group ↔. – CrossFit® performance, RPE, hormonal indicators ↔ in both groups. |
Toledo et al. [79] | 30 male experienced CrossFit® participants; training experience: 2.2 yrs. | Double-blind crossover trial |
Sodium bicarbonate | 0.3 g·kg−1 | 60 minutes prior to the test | – Number of repetitions, lactate, average and maximal heart rate, were ↔ in both conditions. |
Stein et al. [80] | 30 male CrossFit® participants; training experience: > 6 months. | Double-blind crossover trial |
Caffeine | 5 mg.kg−1 | 60 minutes prior to the test | – Number of repetitions and RPE ↔ in both groups. |
Moro et al. [81] | 29 male and female CrossFit® participants; training experience: > 6 months. | Double-blind crossover trial |
Betaine | 2.50 g (dosages of 1.25 g) | 6 weeks: first dosage in morning, second dosage 60 minute before the work | – Significant improvements on back squat were noted for BET. – No differences between groups were found for the remaining performance variables. |
Ricordi et al. [82] | 18 male and female beginner CrossFit® participants; training experience: > 6 months. | Double-blind crossover trial |
Nitrate | 10 g.kg−1 | 2 hours before CrossFit® practice | – CrossFit® performance was ↔ in both groups. |
Garnacho-Castano et al. [83] | 12 male CrossFit® participants; training experience: > 2 yrs. | Double-blind crossover trial |
Beetroot juice | ~808 mg | 3 hours prior to exercise | – BJ ↑ the number of repetitions (after including resting time in the protocol). – Jumping and blood lactate were ↔in both conditions. – SpO2 decrease was ↑ BJ condition. – Decline in jumping performance was ↑ BJ condition. |
Fogaça et al. [84] | 9 male experienced CrossFit® participants; training experience: 2 yrs. | Double-blind crossover trial |
Caffeine | 6 mg.kg−1 | 60 hours prior to exercise. | – Negligible differences between CAF and placebo groups were found for propulsive and peak power, bench press, jump squat, countermovement jumps and handgrip strength. – RPE and DOMS were ↔ in both groups. – Concentrations of CK and CPR ↔ in post and 24 hours post workout. |
Durkalec-Michalski et al. [85] | 21 recreational male and female CrossFit® participants; training experience: > 2 yrs. | Double-blind crossover trial |
Sodium bicarbonate | Progressive dosages: 150 mg.kg−1. Each 2 days, for 8 days, ↑ 25% of sodium bicarbonate dosage. | 10 days: 3 doses per day. Training days was taken 1.5 hours before training sessions. | – Performance in FGB ↑ when participants ingested NaHCO3. – Derived from incremental cycling test, maximum workload and HR were ↔ in both groups. – Workload at ventilatory threshold was 4.6% higher (p < 0.05) in NaHCO3 than placebo. – Time to attain ventilatory threshold was 5.1% higher (p < 0.05) in NaHCO3 than placebo. – HR at ventilatory threshold was significantly higher in NaHCO3 than placebo. – Time to attain ventilatory threshold was 5.1% higher (p < 0.05) in NaHCO3 than placebo. – Pyruvate was significantly higher in NaHCO3 than placebo. |
Rountree et al. [86] | 8 CrossFit® trained males; training experience: > 3 months. | Double-blind crossover trial |
CHO | 16 g | Immediately prior and during exercise. | – Performance was ↔ in FGB on both trials. |
Howarth et al. [87] | 11 CrossFit® athletes; training experience: NR. | Crossover trial |
CHO | Ad libitium | During the workout. | – Performance and RPE were ↔ in both groups. |
Kramer et al. [88] | 12 male CrossFit® athletes; training experience: > 4 months. | Double-blind crossover trial |
Nitrate | 8 mmol·d−1 | 6 days. Two times per day: morning and evening. | – No differences between groups were noted for CrossFit® performance (Grace and 2 km rowing). – The trend was maintained for physical performance with the exception of Wingate protocol. – Substantial improvements were noted for the group (6.6%) on peak power output. |
Outlaw et al. [89] | 29 male and females CrossFit® participants; training experience: > 6 months. | Crossover | Pre-workout: tart cherry extract, beet root Extract, green tea and black tea extract. Post-workout. |
Pre-workout: 19 g Post-workout: females (20 g protein, 40 g CHO), males (40 g protein, 80 g CHO). |
6 weeks: prior to the session. | – Performance on Wingate mean power and VO2max ↑ in the supplementation group. – CrossFit® performance↑ on supplementation group but, without statistical significance. |
Jacobs et al. [90] | 16 male and females CrossFit® participants; training experience: > 6 months. | Crossover | Commercial pre-workout supplement with beta-alanine, grape seed extract, coenzyme Q10, brown rice extract, natural caffeine, vitamins and minerals. | NR | 20 minutes prior to Cindy workout. | – Cindy performance ↑ in pre-workout supplement. |