Table 3.
Total P uptake (kg ha-1), P uptake efficiency (PupE, kg ha-1) and P recovery efficiency (PRE, kg ha-1) of oat.
SD | FR | 2022 | 2023 | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
P uptake | PupE | PRE | P uptake | PupE | PRE | ||||
Heading stage | Maturity stage | Heading stage | Maturity stage | ||||||
L | CK | 8.97c | 12.52c | 7.49b | 9.30b | ||||
N2 | 10.25bc | 14.73bc | 10.92ab | 15.84ab | |||||
P2 | 12.73b | 15.00b | 0.17b | 0.03b | 10.00ab | 14.52ab | 0.16b | 0.06c | |
N1P2 | 16.42a | 19.32a | 0.21b | 0.08ab | 14.94a | 20.32a | 0.23b | 0.12b | |
N2P1 | 13.08ab | 17.40ab | 0.39a | 0.11a | 12.24ab | 17.15ab | 0.38a | 0.17a | |
N2P2 | 10.61bc | 14.38bc | 0.16b | 0.02b | 11.17ab | 16.23ab | 0.18b | 0.08c | |
Mean | 12.01B | 15.56B | 0.15B | 0.04B | 11.13B | 15.56B | 0.16B | 0.07A | |
M | CK | 11.23c | 11.64c | 8.80c | 15.45c | ||||
N2 | 12.82bc | 18.24bc | 10.85bc | 16.35c | |||||
P2 | 14.71bc | 16.08bc | 0.18c | 0.05c | 11.07bc | 13.45c | 0.15c | -0.02c | |
N1P2 | 25.30a | 26.86a | 0.30b | 0.17ab | 17.72a | 32.86a | 0.37b | 0.19b | |
N2P1 | 18.83ab | 23.06ab | 0.51a | 0.25a | 17.26a | 28.33ab | 0.63a | 0.29a | |
N2P2 | 16.34bc | 20.97b | 0.23bc | 0.10bc | 14.44ab | 24.63bc | 0.27c | 0.10c | |
Mean | 16.54A | 19.47A | 0.20A | 0.10A | 13.36A | 21.85A | 0.24A | 0.09A | |
H | CK | 10.26b | 13.34c | 9.51c | 8.96c | ||||
N2 | 15.40ab | 17.89abc | 11.30bc | 11.30b | |||||
P2 | 15.69ab | 15.67bc | 0.17b | 0.03c | 12.91bc | 9.77c | 0.11b | 0.01c | |
N1P2 | 17.64a | 24.09a | 0.27b | 0.12b | 17.05a | 20.41a | 0.23b | 0.13b | |
N2P1 | 17.15a | 20.77ab | 0.46a | 0.17a | 14.72ab | 19.61a | 0.44a | 0.24a | |
N2P2 | 14.23ab | 18.61abc | 0.21b | 0.06c | 10.33c | 12.50b | 0.14b | 0.04c | |
Mean | 15.06A | 18.40AB | 0.19A | 0.06AB | 12.64AB | 13.76B | 0.15B | 0.07A | |
ANOVA | SD | ** | * | * | * | * | ** | ** | ns |
FR | ** | ** | ** | ** | * | ** | ** | ** | |
SD*FR | * | * | ns | ns | * | * | ns | ns |
Data represent the mean. Different lower-case letters denote significant differences within same sowing density (SD) for different fertilizer rates (FR; P< 0.05). Different upper-case letters denote significant differences for different sowing densities (P< 0.05).
L means low sowing density; M means moderate sowing density; H means high sowing density.
ANOVA indicates analysis of variance; ** indicates P< 0.01; * indicates P< 0.05; ns indicates no significance.