Table 2. Overview of the preregistered hypotheses, related theories, and explanations.
| # | Hypothesis | Related theory | Explanations |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | H1: Respondents’ willingness to participate in a survey is higher than their willingness to undergo a blood test. | Economic participation theory | A task with low burden, such as participating in a survey, would lead to a higher participation rate than a task with a higher burden, such as undergoing a blood test. This assumption is in line with the economic participation theory (Biner and Kidd, 1994 [25]; Porter and Whitcomb, 2003 [26]; Leeper, 2019 [27]), which suggests that individuals aim at minimizing their costs, while maximizing their gains. |
| 2 | H2: Respondents are more likely to participate in a survey or to undergo a blood test if the disease is less stigmatized. | Economic participation theory | HIV is expected to be more stigmatized than diabetes. Stigmatization involves psychological costs. |
| 3 | H3: Promising incentives will increase the willingness for both survey participation and undergoing a blood test. | Economic participation theory | Financial incentives are more likely to trigger economic motives for survey participation. |
| 4 | H4: Providing a cash incentive or a lottery cash incentive increases willingness to participate compared with voucher. | Economic participation theory | Direct compensation (compared with vouchers) makes payments more tangible and therefore is more likely to trigger economic motives for survey participation. |
| 5 | H5: Local universities as sponsors increase the likelihood of participation compared with governmental institutions or NGOsa. | Theory of contextual integrity | Universities are directly related to research and to a lesser extent to (1) other policy fields and (2) corruption. This assumption is in line with theory of contextual integrity (Nissenbaum, 2010 [24]), which suggests that data flaws are likely to be considered more appropriate if they align with perceptions of higher integrity. |
| 6 | H6: The higher the level of trust in the respective survey sponsor, the higher the willingness to participate. | Social exchange theory | Trust is considered important to facilitate reciprocal and altruistic behavior and therefore is conducive for social exchange (Dillman, 1978 [28]; Goyder et al, 2006 [29]). |
| 7 | H7: The more concerned respondents regarding the privacy of their blood samples, the less likely they are to be willing to undergo the blood test. | Theory of contextual integrity | Privacy concerns influence the sensitivity level of the requested data and define the data sharing context, as they influence several parameters, which are directly related to the appropriateness of a data flow. |
| 8 | H8: If a respondent is HIV positive or was diagnosed with diabetes, the person is less likely to participate. | Theory of contextual integrity | Being diagnosed with the respective disease makes a research topic more sensitive and affects the context of the data sharing request. |
NGO: nongovernmental organization.