Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2025 Jul 7.
Published in final edited form as: Genet Med. 2022 Apr 7;24(6):1176–1186. doi: 10.1016/j.gim.2022.03.002

Table 1.

Study characteristics

Included Article Characteristics (N = 44) n % References
Intervention location type
 Academic medical center(s) 24 54.5 1942
 Community clinic(s) 6 13.6 4348
 Health system clinic(s) 5 11.4 4953
 Public health/safety-net clinic(s) 2 4.5 54,55
 More than one type of location 3 6.8 5658
 Not clinic based 4 9.1 5962
Year of publication
 2000–2005 5 11.4 27,31,41,51,56
 2006–2010 6 13.6 28,33,5962
 2011–2015 11 25.0 19,21,24,26,32,34,39,45,52,53,57
 2016–2020 22 50.0 20,22,23,25,29,30,3538,40,4244,4650,54,55,58
Study funding source
 Governmental agency 12 27.3 19,2628,31,32,40,45,46,50,52,61
 Other funding (eg, foundation, institutional) 4 9.1 30,37,60,62
 For-profit organization/company 2 4.5 25,44
 More than one type of funding 15 34.1 2022,24,34,35,41,42,48,51,5355,57,58
 No funding 11 25.0 23,29,33,36,38,39,43,47,49,56,59
Study design
 Cohort study 33 75 19,20,2226,29,30,32,3639,4149,5156,5962
 Randomized controlled trial 11 25 21,27,28,31,3335,40,50,57,58
Comparison or control group
 Present 30 68.2 19,21,22,24,2629,3138,40,41,4345,47,48,50,51,54,5659
 Absent 14 31.8 20,23,25,30,39,42,46,49,52,53,55,6062
Study interventions’ use of GC intervention domains
 Risk content and communication included 9 20.5 27,30,4244,46,48,52,55
 Educational content includeda 22 50.0 20,24,27,31,37,38,4042,44,4649,51,52,54,56,5962
 Psychotherapeutic content includedb 15 34.1 20,21,25,28,31,3436,41,43,44,49,54,57,58

GC, genetic counseling.

a

Includes education interventions targeting providers and patients.

b

Includes studies that had GC as a component of the intervention. Although GC typically includes risk communication and education, if not explicitly included as a discrete components of study interventions, GC was not counted in the risk and educational domains.