Table 1.
- Characteristics of 17 articles.
| Studies ID | Sample sizes | Mean age (years) | Interventions | Treatment duration | PRG/CRG | Menopausal status | Endocrine therapy | Outcomes | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Trials | Controls | Trials | Controls | Trials | Controls | ||||||
| Yu et al5 | 37 | 38 | 34-52 | 36-53 | Liuwei Dihuang pill, 30 pills bid + Jiawei Xiaoyao pill, 6g bid + TAM 10mg, bid | TAM 10mg bid | 2 months | PRG | Premenopausal | Yes | Kupperman, KPS |
| Ren6 | 32 | 32 | 48 (30-60) | 47 (30-60) | CHM 200ml bid + endocrine therapy | Premenopausal (TAM 10mg bid or 20mg qd, toremifene 60mg qd); postmenopausal (letrozole 2.5mg qd or anastrozole 1mg qd or exemestane 25 mg qd) | 3 months | PRG | Both premenopausal and postmenopausal | Yes | Kupperman, FACT-B, E2, FSH, LH |
| Sun et al7 | 31 | 30 | 36.23±5.72 | 37.31±4.89 | CHM 200ml bid +TAM 10mg bid | TAM 10mg bid | 2 months | PRG | Premenopausal | Yes | Kupperman, E2 |
| Zhang et al8 | 64 | 48 | 46.1±9.1 | 45.8±8.6 | Xiaoyao pill 8 pills tid + Liuwei Dihuang pill 8 pills tid | Oryzanol 20mg tid | 20 days | PRG | Unclear | Part of them | kupperman |
| Tian9 | 41 | 41 | 30-64 | 31-65 | Oryzanol 20mg tid + CHM bid | Oryzanol 20mg tid | one month | PRG | Unclear | Yes | Kupperman, E2, FSH, LH |
| Sheng10 | 23 | 20 | 45-70 | 45-70 | Oryzanol 20mg tid + VitB1 20mg tid + CHM tid | Oryzanol 20mg tid + VitB1 20mg tid | 3 weeks | PRG | Postmenopausal | Yes | Kupperman, E2, LH |
| Sui11 | 29 | 30 | 45-80 | 45-80 | Anastrozole 1mg qd or letrozole 2.5mg qd or exemestane 25mg qd + CHM bid | Anastrozole 1mg qd or letrozole 2.5mg qd or exemestane 25mg qd | 2 months | PRG | Postmenopausal | Yes | Kupperman, KPS, FACT-B, CEA, CA125, CA153 |
| Zhou et al18 | 25 | 25 | 44-58 | 43-57 | Remifemin 0.28g bid + CHM bid | Remifemin 0.28g bid | 3 months | CRG | Premenopausal | Unclear | E2, FSH, LH |
| Sun12 | 30 | 30 | 20-45 | 20-45 | CHM 200ml bid | Oryzanol 20mg tid | 3 months | CRG | Premenopausal | Part of them | Kupperman, E2, FSH |
| Wu13 | 36 | 36 | 31-52 | 31-52 | Endocrine therapy + CHM 200ml bid + Tianwang Buxin Dan one pill bid | Endocrine therapy | 2 months | CRG | Unclear | Yes | Kupperman, KPS, E2, FSH |
| Wu et al19 | 39 | 39 | 43-63 | 42-64 | TAM 10mg bid + oryzanol 20mg tid + VitB1 10mg bid + CHM bid | TAM 10mg bid + oryzanol 20mg tid + VitB1 10mg bid | 3 months | CRG | Unclear | Yes | E2, FSH, LH, CA125, CA153 |
| Zhu et al14 | 61 | 60 | 59.43±6.4 | 59.7±6.61 | Letrozole 2.5mg qd + CHM bid | Letrozole 2.5mg qd | 2 months | CRG | Postmenopausal | Yes | Kupperman, FACT-B, CD4, CD8, CD4/CD8 |
| Xie15 | 30 | 30 | 30-55 | 30-55 | TAM 10mg bid + CHM bid | TAM 10mg bid | 3 months | CRG | Premenopausal | Yes | Kupperman, KPS, E2, FSH, CD4, CD8, CD4/CD8,CEA, CA125, CA153 |
| Guo et al20 | 30 | 30 | 36-72 | 36-72 | CHM bid | Oryzanol 20mg tid | one month | CRG | Both premenopausal and postmenopausal | Unclear | E2, FSH |
| Xiao et al16 | 25 | 25 | 60.8±8.7 | 62.1±9.4 | Letrozole 2.5mg qd + CHM bid | Letrozole 2.5mg qd + oryzanol 10mg tid | 2 months | PRG +CRG | Postmenopausal | Yes | Kupperman, CA153 |
| Liu17 | 22 | 20 | 67.33±5.33 | 68.08±4.77 | Letrozole 2.5mg qd + CHM bid | Letrozole 2.5mg qd | 3 months | PRG +CRG | Postmenopausal | Yes | kupperman, E2, CEA, CA125,CA153 |
| Li et al21 | 25 | 25 | 53.76±8.86 | 54.96±8.55 | Endocrine therapy + CHM bid | Endocrine therapy + alprazolam | 2 weeks | CRG | Unclear | Yes | PSQI, kupperman, KPS, E2, FSH, LH |
Xiao et al16 reported the outcome indicators at 4 weeks and 8 weeks, and finally included the outcome indicators at 8 weeks for meta-analysis. TAM: tamoxifen, PRG: processed Rehmannia glutinosa (Shudihuang), CRG: crude Rehmannia glutinosa (Shengdihuang), CHM: Chinese herbal medicine, KPS: Karnofsky performance status, FACT-B: functional assessment of cancer therapy - breast, E2: estradiol, LH: luteinizing hormone, FSH: follicle stimulating hormone