Abstract
Gender disparities in academic medicine persist despite gender parity among medical school graduates. Women remain underrepresented in higher academic ranks and leadership roles, with significant differences in retention, promotion, and compensation. Via scoping review, we explore the role of networking and social capital in exacerbating these disparities. The literature reviewed highlights the importance of networking in obtaining leadership roles, decreasing social isolation, and enhancing retention. Sponsorship, distinct from mentorship, is vital for career development and has a direct impact on professional growth. However, women are often under-sponsored compared to men, limiting their access to influential networks. Additionally, virtual networking platforms and women-focused organizations offer promising alternatives to traditional, male-dominated networking activities. Despite the progress made, informal networking practices and gender biases continue to exclude women from key opportunities. Our findings underscore the need for targeted interventions aimed at enhancing the social capital of women in academic medicine to help close the gender gap. Proposed interventions prime for further evaluation include the implementation of formal sponsorship programs, the development of structured networking opportunities, and the promotion of women-focused organizations.
Keywords: gender disparities, academic medicine, networking, social capital, implicit bias, sponsorship
Precis:
This review highlights the critical role that networking and social capital play in perpetuating gender disparities in academic medicine. Overcoming the barriers women face in this arena will likely require targeted strategies such as creating formalized sponsorship programs, increasing structured networking opportunities, fostering women-focused organizations, and leveraging virtual platforms to overcome traditional networking limitations.
Introduction
There is an established body of literature describing gender disparities in academic medicine, as evidenced by lower rates of promotion, retention, leadership positions held, compensation, and scholarly productivity, among other variables.1 Despite gender parity in medical school graduates, women remain under-represented in higher academic ranks, with men are more likely than women to be full professors even after controlling for experience, academic productivity, and specialty.2 In 2023, 25% of department chairs were women, and women comprised 27% of medical school deans.3 Although these figures are slowly increasing, about 10% higher than a decade prior, the rise in the representation of women leaders has not kept pace with the influx of women physicians, who accounted for 40% of medical graduates in the 1990s.3 This phenomenon has been described as the “leaky pipeline”, and a wide range of proposed reasons for this persistent gender gap exist, ranging from less access to mentors and networking opportunities, societal gender norms affecting work-life balance, implicit bias, as well as frank harassment.4,5 This complex problem is clearly multifactorial and multifaceted and increased understanding of the contributing features, particularly those amenable to systemic changes, is needed.
Networking refers to a series of actions focused on establishing and sustaining interpersonal relationships that can potentially support work-related tasks by offering access to resources and mutually enhancing the benefits for all parties involved.6 It is the means by which an individual can grow her or his social capital, which is a critical resource linked to enhanced career opportunities and career satisfaction.6 In a separate but linked ideology, sponsorship is an important contributor to career success, not to be confused with mentorship, by which a more senior individual leverages their influence to directly benefit a junior colleague.7 An effective sponsor aims to increase the recognition, reputation, and professional connections of the sponsee. Thus, sponsorship can contribute to social capital or facilitate networking opportunities. We propose that inequality in social capital, as exemplified by networking practices and opportunities, is a major contributor to gender inequities in academic medicine because it has the potential to play a role in many of the disparate variables noted above. In this review, we critically evaluate the available literature studying gender disparities in academic medicine as they relate to professional networking. We propose a mechanism where, in an interconnected system, social capital is connected to retention, promotion, scholarly productivity, and attainment of leadership roles. Consequently, disparities in access to this resource can significantly contribute to the observed gender gap in academia.
Methods
We chose to implement a scoping review of the literature to gain insight into the breadth and depth of the available literature on a topic that is frequently evaluated via qualitative data and further explored through insightful perspective pieces.8 A literature search of three major databases including PubMed, Embase, and Web of Science was performed using the following search terminology: ((“gender bias”) OR (“gender equity”) OR (gender[tiab])) AND (“academic medicine”) AND ((“network analysis”) OR (“networking”) OR (“networks”) OR (“network”) OR (“social network”) OR (“social capital”) OR (“collaboration”)). Additional studies were identified via reference matching. Studies were eligible for inclusion in this review if the population of interest was women in academic medicine, the primary focus of the article is the role of networking, collaboration, or social connectivity, and a full-length manuscript in English was available for review. Studies were excluded from this review if they centered on trainees (medical or graduate students) or professionals in related but separate fields like dentistry or veterinary medicine, if they focused on classic dyadic mentoring without deeper discussion of network growth via sponsorship, if they were aimed at gender inequities in the setting of the COVID19 pandemic, or if they were intervention-based but the intervention focused exclusively on skills building without support of network-building or collaboration. Perspective or commentary pieces without an adequate component of narrative review were also excluded. PRISMA guidelines were followed, and the flow diagram can be found in Figure 1.
Figure 1.
PRISMA Flow diagram
Results:
Twenty-seven articles were considered for qualitative synthesis (Table 1). Six core themes emerged upon review of the relevant literature and are further described herein.
Table 1.
Summary of the reviewed sources.
| Author and year | Origin | Purpose | Type of source | Research Design | Target population | Key findings in relation to networking |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Abramson et al 2019 | United States (US) | Describe experiences with a single network mentorship model | Perspective/ Narrative review | N/A | Women in academic medicine | - Network mentorship model entails a group mentoring approach of colleagues at various academic ranks in which all participants mutually benefit from the expertise and experiences of group members - Involves consistent meeting times allowing for discussion of personal and professional lives as well as time to advance scholarly work |
| Athanasiou et al 2016 | United Kingdom | Evaluate gender disparities in research performance | Prospective observational study | Survey-based | Faculty at a large public university | - No significant differences identified between genders in regard to: mentoring quality, mentoring frequency, mentoring skill, research skills, social capital - This lack of gender gap is attributed to cultural changes implemented on the organizational level at this public institution: workshops, new recruitment and advertisement strategies, mentoring program with female role models, an annual discussion about “research and Family Life”, networking opportunities |
| Ayyala et al 2019 | US | Explore how sponsorship relationshipsin academic medicine | Qualitative study | Semi-structured interviews | Faculty member (department chairs or participants of leadership course) at a single medical school | - A fundamental feature of effective sponsorship relies on access to and influence in professional networks - Junior faculty women are more likely than their male colleagues to value gender concordance in mentoring relationships and may fail to recognize the need for support from more senior faculty and from leaders and mentors outside their own department or institution |
| Carr et al 2009 | US | Investigate the faculty experience of collaboration | Qualitative study | Semi-structured interviews | Faculty at diverse US medical schools | - Female faculty frequently focused on the process of collaboration: generation of ideas, enjoyment of actual participation, formation of interpersonal relationships - Male faculty frequently focused on outcomes of collaboration: research opportunities, recognition of potential political gain, a way of networking - Often opportunities to collaborate are initiated via informal pathways, e.g. “you are sitting there and talking about your work” |
| Carr et al 2017 | US | Understand the interventions implemented by academic medical centers to increase recruitment, promotion and retention of women faculty | Qualitative study | Semistructured interviews | Faculty member in academic medicine | - Encouraging strong networks for women faculty was described as essential to retain faculty - Mentoring networks as a strategy to support recruitment, retention, and promotion |
| Chaiyachati et al 2019 | US | Measure gender disparities in retention or promotion among graduates of research-intensive fellowships and how mentorship influences them | Prospective observational study | Survey based | Physician generalists who graduated from research-intensive fellowships | - Men and women generalists graduating from research-intensive fellowships have similar mentorship network measures including number of mentors per mentee, importance of each mentor (based on betweenness centrality), and size of community membership - Men and women in this group have similar rates of retention 5 years after completing fellowship, but fewer women had achieved promotion (8% versus 19% of men, P = .033) |
| Chaudron et al 2020 | US | Assess the impact of a career development program on self-assessed knowledge, competence, self-identified goals, and promotions | Prospective cohort study | Survey based | Mid-career women in academic medicine at a single medical school | - The program entailed four days over the course of 6 months with lectures and workshops and informal networking events in the evening - The most valuable aspect of this program for majority of participates was the opportunity to network - Programs to help form national networks can be beneficial, but supporting local interdepartmental networking may have an even greater impact in terms of career advancement and retention |
| DeCastro et al 2013 | US | Gain understanding of mentoring issues from the perspective of a large and diverse group of faculty clinician-researchers | Qualitative study | Semi-structured interviews | Former recipients of National Institutes of Health mentored career development awards and their mentors | - Traditional dyadic mentoring paradigms are limiting and unrealistic: it is unlikely that a single mentor can fulfill the diverse mentoring needs of a mentee, in reality faculty need to develop a network of mentors - Within this network of mentors, women faculty mentees benefit from having at least one woman mentor; a role model of success in workplace communication, negotiation, work-life balance - “Horizontal mentorship”, or peer relationships and collaborations are valuable - One female K awardee noted that despite help with technical aspects like grant writing, her mentor didn’t help with facilitating networking and collaborations which was a huge weakness of their relationship |
| Fassiotto et al 2024 | US | Describe the effectiveness of a program aimed at community building and enhancing social support in an effort to enhance leadership skills | Prospective observational study | Survey-based study of program participants | Women physicians from diverse racial and ethnic backgrounds | - Having an established community of peers from diverse backgrounds reduced feelings of social isolation, increased feelings of self-empowerment, improved self-reported leadership skills, inspired members to accomplish meaningful scholarly work, and in turn encouraged retention and promotion - Members of the program also felt encouraged to empower other individuals underrepresented in medicine |
| Flexman et al 2021 | Canada | Identify potential systemic barriers that impede advancement for women in academic anesthesia | Perspective/ Narrative review | N/A | Women in academic anesthesiology | - Conferences allow for networking opportunities, but women are invited to these as speakers and panelists less than men - Informal networking opportunities like dinners, social outings, or sporting events may unconsciously exclude women - Institutional support to attend gender-specific educational conferences is important |
| Foster et al 2000 | US | To determine how faculty’s perceptions of medical school gender climate differ by gender, track, rank, and department | Prospective observational study | Survey-based | Faculty at a single medical school | - 24% of women (compared with 6% of men; p < .001) felt that informal networking excluded faculty based on gender - 67% of women surveyed felt that men faculty with comparable expertise were more likely to be sought for collaborative research efforts |
| Gottlieb and Travis 2018 | US | Describe two successful sponsorship models that exist within academic medicine | Perspective | N/A | Women in academic medicine | - Sponsorship can happen organically, but formal sponsorship initiatives provide opportunities for talented faculty who have traditionally been excluded from informal professional networks - To support gender equity, institutional leadership needs to recognize and promote the importance of sponsorship |
| Guptill et al 2018 | US | Explore the leadership pathway among women in emergency medicine | Qualitative study | Semi-structured interviews | Female leaders in emergency medicine | - Half of the subjects credited their success to national organizational involvement and the resulting networks they developed, affiliations with people who have doors to open and to finding collaborators who are like-minded in their ambition and goals - Women hold belief that “men do networking much better” - We need more women sponsors not mentors - Women interested in leadership, a chair or a Dean, need a network |
| Hamzaoui et al 2022 | France | Describe ten actions to promote and achieve gender equity in an academic medical society | Perspective | N/A | Women in critical care medicine | - Concrete sponsorship opportunities can be encouraged via quota policies for executive boards, speakers, and committees - Workshops for women faculty that focus on improving “women assertiveness” to increase confidence can be beneficial, including those on networking and communication |
| Hastie et al 2023 | US | Describe four common misconceptions that surround women in leadership in academic medicine | Perspective/ Narrative review | N/A | Women in academic medicine | - A common misconception: women need more mentoring; what is truly necessary is more sponsorship - Women in most need of sponsorship, but also less likely to receive sponsorship from both women and men sponsors - The more advanced in career stage women become, the less likely they are to find sponsors, but sponsorship is still necessary for growth |
| Helitzer et al 2014 | US | To evaluate skills acquired by women in academic medicine via career development programs | Prospective cohort study | Survey based | Women faculty members who completed one of 3 specific career development programs | - Women faculty at all ranks selected networking and interpersonal skills as two of the top five skills gained with these interventions |
| Ibrahim et al 2019 | US, Qatar, Singapore, United Arab Emirates | Provide tips to promote gender equity in international academic medicine, focusing on the essential process of networking and developing women physicians’ groups | Perspective/ Narrative review | N/A | Women in academic medicine | - Academic medicine women’s groups can facilitate networking opportunities by creating a mass of individuals who provide career and social support - Even though it is a women’s group, inviting men to events can be beneficial as men often holder leadership positions - Social media can be utilized as a means of virtual networking |
| Laver et al 2018 | Australia | Summarize quantitative evaluations of interventions designed to support the careers of women in academia | Systematic review | Systematic review without meta-analysis | Women in academic medicine | - Most studied interventions were multicomponent and involved some aspect of networking - Peer mentoring programs lead to increased self-rated networking skills - Overall, the studies identified provided limited high-quality evidence to guide programmatic design |
| Lewis et al 2018 | US | Explore the role of Twitter as a supplemental method for networking | Perspective / Narrative Review | N/A | Women in academic medicine | - Twitter provides access to large pool of potential mentors and sponsors with whom women may not have had opportunity to connect otherwise; it can allow for the initial interaction that then leads to a more substantial relationship offline - Twitter allows users to create “personal learning networks” with intra- and inter-disciplinary peers, an alternative form of professional development and ultimately networking |
| Lin et al 2019 | US | Describe the impact of a national woman-focused organization on retention and advancement | Qualitative study | Semistructured interviews | Emergency medicine physicians who acted as past or present women-focused organization leaders, as well as members at varying career stages | - Women-focused organizations created networks for women faculty, allowing for new opportunities for: mentorship, sponsorship, reduced professional isolation, increased confidence, employment or promotion opportunities, enhanced opportunities for awards, leadership and speaking experience - These groups enhanced academic productivity of women by facilitating scholarly collaboration |
| Margolis et al 2021 | US | Evaluate a pilot program aimed to reduce networking barriers | Prospective cohort study | Survey based | Women in academic pediatric anesthesia | - Program provided facilitating networking sessions in online format (Zoom) - Benefit: not only does it provide a formal space for networking, it also provides structured discussion which allows participants to find common ground |
| Messman et al 2022 | US | Evaluate gender difference in perception of positive and negative factors affecting the process of promotion to associate or full professor | Prospective observational study | Survey-based | Associate and full professor faculty at a single medical school | - Gender-specific networking was cited by women as a significantly more important positive factor in their most recent promotion as compared to their male counterparts |
| Murphy et al 2022 | US | Describe women’s and men’s perceptions of men’s networking practices and how these influence gender inequity | Qualitative study | Semi-structured interviews | Women and men faculty of varying rank and from diverse medical schools | - Women and men acknowledge a “boys’ club” in academic medicine, which has tangible benefits like promotion, raises, and awards - Men discussed obtaining professional advantages from informal interactions with other men, but no women interviewed discussed this benefit from informal interactions with women - Many networking activities inadvertently exclude women due to the nature of the activity as a traditionally male (e.g. golfing, fishing); even if a woman wanted to participate, she may not be invited due to the perception that she would not want to participate - When women make efforts to bring other women together, it can be seen as exclusionary |
| Patton et al 2017 | US | Determine if sponsorship differs among men and women i | Prospective cohort study | Survey based | Recipients of NIH K08 and K23 grants who are in academic medicine | - Sponsorship was significantly associated with success (P < .001) - Sponsorship experience was more commonly reported by men than women |
| Stadler et al 2021 | US, Qatar, Singapore, United Arab Emirates | Provide suggestions for overcoming gender bias | Perspective/ Narrative Review | N/A | Women in academic medicine | - Lack of networking opportunities is one of several barriers to women physician advancement - Networking is also important to combat professional and personal isolation often experienced by female faculty - Social media platforms can be used to form communities to share knowledge, address isolation, facilitate networking, and provide mentoring - Academic women’s groups can also facilitate networking and professional advancement |
| Suurna and Leibbrandt 2021 | US | Examine differences in organizational relationships between men and women, and how these differences correlate with promotion | Prospective cohort study | Network analysis of professional internal email communication | Faculty members from all surgical departments at an academic medical center | - Data showed strong gender homophily in the professional network relationships among surgical faculty - Overall, men had more relationships with men, women had similar number of relationships with men and women - Men had more relationships with other lower-ranked men than lower-ranked women and women have more relationships with other lower-ranked women than lower-ranked men - Higher academic rank can be predicted by male gender, tenure, and number of meaningful relationships |
| Van den Brink et al 2011 | Netherlands | Evaluate gender inequalities in professorial recruitment | Qualitative and quantitative data collection | Semi-structure interviews and analysis of selection committee reports | Full professors at academic medical schools | - A majority (77%) of positions are being filled via a closed appointment procedure-- recruitment in which applicants are invited by “scouts” (influential senior academicians) to apply - Men are overrepresented in senior academic positions, and men are more likely to have homogenous male networks; thus more likely to select a male candidate - Male scouts viewed women candidates as more “risky”, perceived that they have less ambition and commitment to academic medicine |
Networking is a crucial component of career advancement (promotion and leadership positions)
The vital role of networking in career advancement has been widely recognized in business and management fields, along with the unique challenges women face in navigating professional connections and relationship building.9 It is no surprise that the significance of networking extends to the field of academic medicine, which similarly continues to grapple with gender disparities. A key theme throughout the literature evaluated was the critical role of networking as it applies to career opportunities and advancement in academia. In fact, in a study evaluating career success in academic medicine, faculty acknowledged that leadership positions and promotions were most frequently granted by leaders based on interpersonal relationships.10 Consequently, unequal access to networking based on gender becomes a significant barrier to professional growth.4 When women have been able to overcome these barriers and obtain leadership positions, they frequently cite involvement in national organizations and affiliations with influential leaders as drivers of their success.11
A systematic review of interventions aimed at addressing the gender leadership gap in academic medicine and other fields suggests that evidence to support each intervention is limited.12 A majority of faculty leadership programs emphasize skills training as opposed to establishing social networks, which presumes access and ability/confidence to navigate existing social networks.13 However, many studies have found that a key cited benefit by the participants of these leadership oriented programs is actually the involved formal and informal networking opportunities.14–17 However, the few studies that have evaluated interventions have been limited by lack of objective efficacy and durability measures, underscoring the limited evidence of the impact of any intervention tested. The limited rigor of these studies make it hard to discern program elements that contribute most to success based on objective metrics such as retention, promotion, scholarly productivity, and attainment of leadership positions.
Networking decreases social isolation and increases retention
In one community-building leadership development program aimed at creating a space to refine leadership skills and career strategic planning, the most important aspect according to participants was the building of a supportive network of peers.18 Being part of an established, diverse peer community helped reduce social isolation, fostered self-empowerment, enhanced self-reported leadership skills, motivated members to pursue meaningful scholarly work, and ultimately promoted retention and advancement.18 One survey-based study of women in medicine found that in addition to institutional culture and interactions with supervisors, the development of interpersonal relationships within an institution is crucial in preventing attrition and fostering a sense of belonging in the workplace.19 Networking opportunities tailored to women in medicine or within women-focused organizations have been shown to reduce feelings of social isolation, as participants recognize that many of the challenges they face are shared by their female colleagues.20
Sponsorship is vital to career advancement and can lead to network development
After taking the corporate world by storm, the importance of sponsorship as opposed to mentorship has recently gained prominence in academic medicine. This awareness of sponsorship’s potential influence came from the corporate sector, where it became clear that mentoring and coaching programs had not done enough to elevate more women into leadership positions.21 Though mentorship has a time and place and can be valuable throughout one’s career, its direct link to measures of career advancement is much less pronounced than sponsorship.7 In the words of Ibarra and Kirby, “While a mentor is someone who has knowledge and will share it with you, a sponsor is a person who has power and will use it for you”.9 Sponsorship is typically offered rather than directly asked for, but it is not entirely uncommon to seek it out through proactive relationship-building. Sponsorship entails highlighting visibility and credibility of high performing individuals in order to open doors to career advancement. However, it is recognized not only for its role in advancing careers but also for the disparities that result due to inequal access to this valuable resource. Women are “over-mentored and under-sponsored,”9 a finding that is consistent throughout not only the business literature, but academic medicine as well.7,22,23 Though sponsorship was associated with success in a survey of over 1000 recipients of NIH grants (p<0.001), men were more likely than women to report sponsorship experiences.22 In fact, women physicians are less likely to receive sponsorship from both men and women sponsors.23 There are many proposed reasons for this discordance. Due to relationships built through networking, men and women are likely to receive sponsorship opportunities unequally.21 Furthermore, women junior faculty are more likely than their male colleagues to value gender concordance in mentoring relationships and in doing so may fail to recognize the need for support from more senior faculty and from leaders and mentors outside their own department or institution.7 Efficacy of sponsorship relies on the power and influence of the sponsor, which may not always be the most sought after characteristics when women choose mentors and sponsors.24 Additionally, women may need or be perceived as needing other forms of mentorship, such as guidance on overcoming gender-related professional challenges or balancing work and life. This can take up time that mentors and potential sponsors might otherwise devote to sponsorship.22 Other proposed theories for the sponsorship divide include implicit bias that may result in sponsors failing to think of female mentees when opportunities for sponsorship arise.25 Finally, studies have demonstrated higher rates of imposter syndrome in women academicians as compared to men, which may hinder women from proactively seeking potential sponsors through networking, mentorship, or showcasing value in high-visibility projects.26
Chaiyachati et al. found that amongst a group of physicians who had graduated from research-intensive fellowships, mentorship network measures including the number of mentors per mentee, , and the size of community membership was no different based on gender, yet fewer women achieved promotion five years after completing fellowship.27 Perhaps this finding speaks to the limitations of quantitative measures of mentor networks, which are unable to elucidate the quality of these relationships including which of these mentor relationships includes sponsorship. Ultimately, measuring and evaluating sponsorship is a complex undertaking, but doing so may allow for the development of more equitable sponsorship programs.28 While sponsorship can occur organically, formal sponsorship programs create opportunities for talented faculty who have traditionally been excluded from informal professional networks, like women and other groups underrepresented in medicine.29
Virtual networking is emerging as a promising adjunct to traditional networking
Several studies propose virtual networking in the form of social media as a way to augment traditional networking outlets.4,30,31 Lewis et al. specifically address utilization of the Twitter platform by women in academic medicine and science, citing it as a resource that can be used to promote networking and foster relationships with individuals who would otherwise be inaccessible.30 Twitter has the advantage of providing access to large pools of individuals who are geographically disparate, yet have similar career interests, allowing for networking connections that may have otherwise had no opportunity to flourish. The authors acknowledge a limitation of Twitter’s reach, noting that only 10% of individuals over age 50—who are often higher-ranking and have the most academic influence, making them ideal mentors and sponsors—use the platform.32 Stadler et al. acknowledge the power of social media to build global communities of women with shared goals to facilitate networking.4 Ibrahim et al. echo these sentiments, and further emphasize that the continuous monitoring and upkeep of social media platforms specifically for women’s groups introduces an opportunity for leadership in managing these platforms.31 Unfortunately, despite the large potential that exists in the virtual realm, it is important to acknowledge that networking on social media relies on self-promotion, which has been show to be a relative weakness in women as compared to men.33 While social media has helped amplify the dissemination of scientific research, increasing visibility and resulting in more citations, this significant benefit may not be equally accessible or utilized by everyone. Specifically, Peng et al. found that women were 28% less likely to promote their scientific papers on Twitter.34 This differential was not explained by differences in adoption of Twitter, and interestingly the gap exists even when comparing men and women on the same papers.34
Finally, it is important to acknowledge opportunities that exist to network virtually via video capabilities. Following the global COVID-19 pandemic, the use of Zoom and other video conferencing tools has become an integral part of our daily work routines. These platforms can and should be leveraged to make networking opportunities more accessible. Margolis et al. evaluated a pilot program aimed at reducing networking barriers for women in pediatric anesthesia, which entailed networking sessions facilitated in an online format (Zoom).17 This format provided flexibility, allowing participants to join from home and more easily accommodate the sessions around their responsibilities outside of work, such as caretaking. The authors found, unsurprisingly, that full engagement including keeping cameras on throughout the discussions was crucial to program success. An unexpected benefit was the connection through shared humanity that occurred when participants were able to see other participants in a more casual home environment.17
Informal networking can inadvertently exclude women
In a qualitative study by Murphy et al., women and men alike acknowledge a “boys’ club” in academic medicine, which has tangible benefits like promotion, raises, and awards.35 Many networking activities inadvertently exclude women due to the nature of the activity as traditionally male (e.g. golfing, fishing, viewing of sporting events, , drinking at the bar).35 Furthermore, even if a woman desired inclusion, she may not be invited due to the perception that she would be uninterested in the activity.36 In a survey-based study of faculty members at a U.S. medical school, 24% of women compared to 6% of men felt that informal networking opportunities were exclusionary based on gender.37 Suurna et al performed a network analysis of academic surgeons, evaluating professional network relationships based on email correspondences.38 These authors found that men had more relationships with men, while women had similar number of relationships with men and women.38 The tangible benefit of such a “boys’ club” can be felt in a study by Van den Brink, who describes recruitment to full professor positions via closed appointment procedures, in which influential senior academicians, with over-representation of men, choose candidates from homogenous male networks.39 In order for a woman to be considered as a candidate, Van den Brink found that she would have had to already been proven to have a reputation of excellence.39
Formal networking opportunities are consequently even more important for women. This includes gatherings sponsored by institutions or organizations as a means to network, as well as conferences and speaking engagements which allow for additional networking. Another benefit of formal networking programs is the ability to include structured discussions, which promote the exchange of ideas and establish a shared foundation for building stronger relationships. This technique was utilized by Margolis et al. in a well-received networking program, and the facilitated networking time was considered especially valuable. Participants highlighted the value of structured discussions, particularly for those who are more introverted or junior and less likely to speak in a group setting.17 While this study implemented the format in an all-women group, it could be equally beneficial in networking sessions involving all genders. Hamzaoui et al. found that workshops for women faculty focusing on enhancing assertiveness and building confidence can improve networking skills, but a structured networking format may address these challenges effectively as well.40
Women-focused organizations and groups are valuable networking tools
There was a clear and consistent emphasis in the literature on the importance of women-focused organizations to promote gender equality in academic medicine. Ibrahim et al. cite women’s groups as ways to promote networking, decrease isolation, and provide a platform for women to uplift other women.31 Lin et al. performed a qualitative study through semistructured interviews evaluating a professional organization developed for women in academic emergency medicine.20 The cited benefits of membership in this organization as discussed by interviewees were numerous, including but not limited to: access to mentorship and sponsorship, facilitating scholarly collaborations, increased self-confidence, decreased sense of professional isolation, increased opportunities for award, and increased leadership opportunities.20 Messman et al. found that gender-specific networking was cited by women as a significantly more important positive factor in their most recent promotion as compared to their male counterparts.41
Still, a key takeaway from a perspective piece on establishing a women’s professional organization is the importance of involving men in specific events and activities to foster allyship and to provide members with opportunities to connect with potentially important sponsors with whom they may otherwise not have the opportunity to do so.31
Academic women-focused organizations and communities can be variable in size and scope. Fassiotto et al. describe a leadership program aimed at community building, with the first cohort involving 10 women of diverse racial and ethnic backgrounds. The authors found that having an established community of peers from diverse backgrounds reduced feelings of social isolation, increased feelings of self-empowerment, improved self-reported leadership skills, inspired members to accomplish meaningful scholarly work, and in turn encouraged retention and promotion.13 Thus, it is important to acknowledge the potential benefits of networking within smaller women-focused groups in addition to larger institutional, regional, national, or even international women’s groups, though studies that direct compare networking formats are lacking.
Discussion
Our review of the literature on gender disparities in networking within academic medicine underscores the significant role that differences in social capital play in intensifying overall gender inequities, particularly in relation to retention, promotion, and leadership opportunities. We identified six themes supported by this body of literature specific to women in academic medicine, including 1) Networking is a crucial component of promotion and attainment of leadership positions 2) Networking decreases social isolation and increases retention 3) Sponsorship is vital to career advancement and can lead to network development 4) Virtual networking is emerging as a promising adjunct to traditional networking 5) Informal networking can inadvertently exclude women, and 6) Women-focused organizations and groups are valuable networking tools. Networking is intimately associated with social capital, and based on our synthesis of the available literature we propose a direct relationship between social capital and career advancement metrics (Figure 2). This relationship highlights how factors linked to social capital contribute to the widening gender disparities in academic medicine.
Figure 2.
Proposed multidirectional interplay between networking, sponsorship, social capital, and indicators of career advancement in academic medicine
Many gender-specific barriers to networking became apparent. Women’s traditional roles within the family, including the unequal division of time spent on domestic work and child care, limit their ability to build social capital through informal networking opportunities with colleagues outside the workplace.42 A concrete example of this is the lack of childcare at a majority of scientific meetings, which are prime networking events, which disproportionally affect women with children.43 Women in academic medicine are being held back by a lack of investment in social capital– time spent socializing with colleagues is thought to be dispensable, when in reality it has been shown to play a major role in career advancement. However, even when women recognize the critical nature of these informal relationships and strive to prioritize networking opportunities outside of the workplace, barriers to entry into the “boys’ club” may prevent them from doing so. Implicit bias exacerbates this issue, as studies show that physicians tend to associate men with careers and women with family responsibilities.25 This bias can lead to the exclusion of women, particularly those with children, from important networking events on the assumption that they are busy with caretaking duties.35
In this review, we recognize sponsorship as a vital component of networking. Sponsorship provides access to networks that may otherwise be unavailable to mentees without the advocacy of their sponsors. Networking opportunities, in turn, help faculty identify effective sponsors (Figure 2). The importance of sponsorship may be even greater for women than it is for men. Self-promotion poses a risk for women due to societal expectations that they should remain modest.42 Research shows that women may face penalties for being perceived as overly ambitious or self-promoting, and demonstrates that women are less like to partake in self-promotion, rating their performances less favorably than equally performing men on self-evaluations.7,33 A sponsor can mitigate this by advocating and promoting a woman’s achievements without the backlash that she may receive for doing so herself. Men are more likely to gain sponsorship organically, so formal initiatives to encourage sponsorship are more likely to be fruitful in achieving gender equality. These initiatives need to have explicit goals and expectations, and care must be taken in matching sponsors and proteges.44 Quota systems can help encourage sponsorship, for example, ensuring that a certain percentage of leadership seats on committees, executive boards, and speakers or panelists are held by women.40
This review is limited by the quality and quantity of the literature investigating the role of networking in academic medicine, which is an area that warrants future study based on the high potential impact of social capital as it pertains to the gender gap in academic medicine. Specifically, future studies need to evaluate the impact of networking-specific interventions, such as those that provide formal and structured networking opportunities. Though many leadership programs aimed at addressing gender disparities include some aspect of networking-- typically an informal networking opportunity that occurs after scheduled lectures and workshops—the evaluations of these programs fail to objectively identify which programmatic components contribute most meaningfully to future success and career advancement for participating women, and do not compare outcomes with a control group. In addition to subjective data collection from program participants, future studies highlighting interventions to address the gender gap should also involve data collected from peers and colleagues (e.g. 360 leadership review format), and objective performance variables like years to promotion, publication numbers, new leadership roles obtained, etc. This data should be compared to a peer group of individuals who have not participated in the intervention.
Many institutions and leaders in academic medicine are increasingly adopting formalized and transparent procedures for recruitment, promotion, and leadership appointments. This shift is expected to mitigate some of the unintended inequities that arise when these processes are conducted informally through personal connections and networks. However, the significance of social capital remains paramount, as it continues to play a crucial role in various aspects of academic success and professional advancement. Many interventions proposed to improve gender equity in academic medicine focus on professional development via workshops and lectures, but these are often inadequate on their own to facilitate change and are likely lower yield than interventions that specifically aim to enhance social capital.45 In addition to spreading awareness about the importance of cultivating social capital amongst women academicians, we offer practical strategies that can be implemented at both the institutional and individual levels. These include structured networking opportunities that are safe and open to all, formalized sponsorship programs and quota systems for leadership opportunities, support of women-specific organizations, and support and training for the use of social media as a complement to traditional networking.
Conclusion:
In conclusion, this scoping review highlights the critical role that networking and social capital play in perpetuating gender disparities in academic medicine. Although progress has been made, significant barriers remain, particularly in informal networking opportunities and access to sponsorship opportunities. These disparities are reflected in the ongoing gender gap in career advancement for women in academic medicine, including lower rates of retention, delays in promotion, and underrepresentation in leadership roles. We propose that leveling the networking playing field will prove vital to closing the gender gap in academic medicine and cultivating a more equitable professional environment. Overcoming the barriers women face in this arena will likely require targeted strategies such as creating formalized sponsorship programs, increasing structured networking opportunities, fostering women-focused organizations, and leveraging virtual platforms to overcome traditional networking limitations.
Footnotes
Funding and Conflict of Interests:
The authors have no funding, financial relationships, or conflicts of interest to disclose.
References:
- 1.Carr PL, Gunn CM, Kaplan SA, Raj A, Freund KM. Inadequate progress for women in academic medicine: findings from the National Faculty Study. J Womens Health (Larchmt). Mar 2015;24(3):190–9. doi: 10.1089/jwh.2014.4848 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 2.Li B, Jacob-Brassard J, Dossa F, et al. Gender differences in faculty rank among academic physicians: a systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ Open. Nov 2 2021;11(11):e050322. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2021-050322 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 3.The State of Women in Academic Medicine 2023–2024: Progressing Toward Equity (AAMC) (2024).
- 4.Stadler DJ, Ibrahim H, Cofrancesco J Jr, Archuleta S. Fixing the leaky pipeline: Tips to promote gender equity in Academic Medicine. The Asia Pacific Scholar. 2021;6(4):1–6. doi: 10.29060/taps.2021-6-4/gp2451 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- 5.Zhuge Y, Kaufman J, Simeone DM, Chen H, Velazquez OC. Is There Still a Glass Ceiling for Women in Academic Surgery? Annals of Surgery. 2011;253(4):637–643. doi: 10.1097/sla.0b013e3182111120 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 6.Wolff HG, Moser K. Effects of networking on career success: a longitudinal study. J Appl Psychol. Jan 2009;94(1):196–206. doi: 10.1037/a0013350 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 7.Ayyala MS, Skarupski K, Bodurtha JN, et al. Mentorship Is Not Enough. Academic Medicine. 2019;94(1):94–100. doi: 10.1097/acm.0000000000002398 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 8.Arksey H, O’Malley L. Scoping studies: towards a methodological framework. International Journal of Social Research Methodology. 2005/02/01 2005;8(1):19–32. doi: 10.1080/1364557032000119616 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- 9.Ibarra H, Carter NM, Silva C. Why men still get more promotions than women. Harv Bus Rev. Sep 2010;88(9):80–5, 126. [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 10.Han H, Korte R, Prakash V, Hingle ST. Faculty Experiences Related to Career Advancement and Success in Academic Medicine. Teaching and Learning in Medicine. 2023/10/20 2023;35(5):514–526. doi: 10.1080/10401334.2022.2104851 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 11.Guptill M, Reibling ET, Clem K. Deciding to lead: a qualitative study of women leaders in emergency medicine. Int J Emerg Med. Nov 16 2018;11(1):47. doi: 10.1186/s12245-018-0206-7 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 12.Laver KE, Prichard IJ, Cations M, Osenk I, Govin K, Coveney JD. A systematic review of interventions to support the careers of women in academic medicine and other disciplines. BMJ Open. 2018;8(3):e020380. DOI: 10.1136/bmjopen-2017-020380. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2017-020380 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 13.Fassiotto M, Jerome B, Stefanac L, et al. Stanford Network for Advancement and Promotion: The impact of a community building-focused leadership development program on the success of underrepresented groups in academic medicine. Health Care Manage Rev. Oct-Dec 01 2024;49(4):272–280. doi: 10.1097/hmr.0000000000000413 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 14.Zipkin DA, Ramani S, Stankiewicz CA, et al. Clinician-Educator Training and Its Impact on Career Success: a Mixed Methods Study. J Gen Intern Med. Dec 2020;35(12):3492–3500. doi: 10.1007/s11606-020-06049-w [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 15.Chaudron LH, Anson E, Bryson Tolbert JM, Inoue S, Cerulli C. Meeting the Needs of Mid-Career Women in Academic Medicine: One Model Career Development Program. J Womens Health (Larchmt). Jan 2021;30(1):45–51. doi: 10.1089/jwh.2019.8062 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 16.Helitzer DL, Newbill SL, Cardinali G, Morahan PS, Chang S, Magrane D. Narratives of Participants in National Career Development Programs for Women in Academic Medicine: Identifying the Opportunities for Strategic Investment. J Womens Health (Larchmt). 2016;25(4):360–370. doi: 10.1089/jwh.2015.5354 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 17.Margolis RD, Berenstain LK, Janosy N, et al. Grow and Advance through Intentional Networking: A pilot program to foster connections within the Women’s Empowerment and Leadership Initiative in the Society for Pediatric Anesthesia. Paediatr Anaesth. Sep 2021;31(9):944–952. doi: 10.1111/pan.14247 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 18.Fassiotto M, Hamel EO, Ku M, et al. Women in Academic Medicine: Measuring Stereotype Threat Among Junior Faculty. J Womens Health (Larchmt). Mar 2016;25(3):292–8. doi: 10.1089/jwh.2015.5380 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 19.Schaechter JD, Starr JR, Silver JK. Institutional Culture of Belonging and Attrition Risk Among Women Health Care Professionals. J Womens Health (Larchmt). Sep 23 2024;doi: 10.1089/jwh.2024.0321 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 20.Lin MP, Lall MD, Samuels-Kalow M, et al. Impact of a Women-focused Professional Organization on Academic Retention and Advancement: Perceptions From a Qualitative Study. Acad Emerg Med. Mar 2019;26(3):303–316. doi: 10.1111/acem.13699 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 21.Travis EL, Doty L, Helitzer DL. Sponsorship: A Path to the Academic Medicine C-suite for Women Faculty? Academic Medicine. 2013;88(10):1414–1417. doi: 10.1097/acm.0b013e3182a35456 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 22.Patton EW, Griffith KA, Jones RD, Stewart A, Ubel PA, Jagsi R. Differences in Mentor-Mentee Sponsorship in Male vs Female Recipients of National Institutes of Health Grants. JAMA Internal Medicine. 2017;177(4):580–582. doi: 10.1001/jamainternmed.2016.9391 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 23.Hastie MJ, Lee A, Siddiqui S, Oakes D, Wong CA. Misconceptions about women in leadership in academic medicine. Can J Anaesth. Jun 2023;70(6):1019–1025. Idées reçues concernant les femmes en position de leadership en médecine universitaire. doi: 10.1007/s12630-023-02458-7 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 24.Rua-Gomez C, Carnabuci G, Goossen MC. Reaching for the Stars: How Gender Influences the Formation of High-Status Collaboration Ties. Academy of Management Journal. 2023/10/01 2022;66(5):1501–1528. doi: 10.5465/amj.2021.0218 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- 25.Salles A, Awad M, Goldin L, et al. Estimating Implicit and Explicit Gender Bias Among Health Care Professionals and Surgeons. JAMA Netw Open. Jul 3 2019;2(7):e196545. doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2019.6545 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 26.Cusack CE, Hughes JL, Nuhu N. Connecting gender and mental health to imposter phenomenon feelings. Psi Chi Journal of Psychological Research. 2013;18(2):74–81. doi: 10.24839/2164-8204.JN18.2.74 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- 27.Chaiyachati KH, Liao JM, Weissman GE, et al. Gender Differences in Retention and Promotion Among Generalists Who Graduated From Research-Intensive Fellowships. J Grad Med Educ. Oct 2019;11(5):535–542. doi: 10.4300/jgme-d-19-00016.1 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 28.Schwartz R, Williams MF, Feldman MD. Does Sponsorship Promote Equity in Career Advancement in Academic Medicine? A Scoping Review. J Gen Intern Med. Feb 2024;39(3):470–480. doi: 10.1007/s11606-023-08542-4 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 29.Gottlieb AS, Travis EL. Rationale and Models for Career Advancement Sponsorship in Academic Medicine: The Time Is Here; the Time Is Now. Acad Med. Nov 2018;93(11):1620–1623. doi: 10.1097/acm.0000000000002342 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 30.Lewis JD, Fane KE, Ingraham AM, et al. Expanding Opportunities for Professional Development: Utilization of Twitter by Early Career Women in Academic Medicine and Science. JMIR Med Educ. Jul 23 2018;4(2):e11140. doi: 10.2196/11140 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 31.Ibrahim H, Stadler DJ, Archuleta S, Anglade P, Cofrancesco J Jr. Twelve tips for developing and running a successful women’s group in international academic medicine. Medical Teacher. 2019/11/02 2019;41(11):1239–1244. doi: 10.1080/0142159X.2018.1521954 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 32.Lewiss RE, Silver JK, Bernstein CA, Mills AM, Overholser B, Spector ND. Is Academic Medicine Making Mid-Career Women Physicians Invisible? Journal of Women’s Health. 2020;29(2):187–192. doi: 10.1089/jwh.2019.7732 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 33.Exley CL, Kessler JB. The Gender Gap in Self-Promotion*. The Quarterly Journal of Economics. 2022;137(3):1345–1381. doi: 10.1093/qje/qjac003 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- 34.Peng H, Teplitskiy M, Romero DM, Horv’at E-A. The Gender Gap in Scholarly Self-Promotion on Social Media. ArXiv. 2022;abs/2206.05330 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 35.Murphy M, Callander JK, Dohan D, Grandis JR. Networking practices and gender inequities in academic medicine: Women’s and men’s perspectives. EClinicalMedicine. Mar 2022;45:101338. doi: 10.1016/j.eclinm.2022.101338 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 36.Dolan RT, Butler JS, Murphy SM, Cronin KJ. Health-related quality of life, surgical and aesthetic outcomes following microvascular free flap reconstructions: an 8-year institutional review. Ann R Coll Surg Engl. Jan 2012;94(1):43–51. doi: 10.1308/003588412×13171221498749 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 37.Foster SW, McMurray JE, Linzer M, Leavitt JW, Rosenberg M, Carnes M. Results of a gender-climate and work-environment survey at a midwestern academic health center. Acad Med. Jun 2000;75(6):653–60. doi: 10.1097/00001888-200006000-00019 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 38.Suurna MV, Leibbrandt A. Underrepresented Women Leaders: Lasting Impact of Gender Homophily in Surgical Faculty Networks. Laryngoscope. Jan 2022;132(1):20–25. doi: 10.1002/lary.29681 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 39.Van den Brink M. Scouting for talent: appointment practices of women professors in academic medicine. Soc Sci Med. Jun 2011;72(12):2033–40. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2011.04.016 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 40.Hamzaoui O, Boissier F, Salmon Gandonnière C, et al. Ten actions to achieve gender equity among intensivists: the French Society of Intensive Care (FICS) model. Ann Intensive Care. Jul 2 2022;12(1):59. doi: 10.1186/s13613-022-01035-3 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 41.Messman A, Stansfield RB, Liu Y, Collins J, Matthews M, Ehrman R. Identifying Positive and Negative Factors That Affect the Promotion of Clinical Faculty at the Wayne State University School of Medicine: Does Gender Matter? Cureus. Oct 2022;14(10):e29954. doi: 10.7759/cureus.29954 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 42.Eagly AH, Carli LL. Women and the labyrinth of leadership. Harv Bus Rev. Sep 2007;85(9):62–71, 146. [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 43.Rubulotta F, Santonocito C, Rubulotta G. Gender distribution in boards of internal medicine societies and paper authorship: Networking is the key to success. Eur J Intern Med. Mar 2022;97:34–35. doi: 10.1016/j.ejim.2022.01.015 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 44.Roy B, Gottlieb AS. The Career Advising Program: A Strategy to Achieve Gender Equity in Academic Medicine. J Gen Intern Med. Jun 2017;32(6):601–602. doi: 10.1007/s11606-016-3969-7 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 45.Lydon S, O’Dowd E, Walsh C, et al. Systematic review of interventions to improve gender equity in graduate medicine. Postgrad Med J. Apr 2022;98(1158):300–307. doi: 10.1136/postgradmedj-2020-138864 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]


