Table 2.
Characteristics of the publications of quantitative data.
| Study | Research methods | Sample size | Participants | Outcome variables | Concerned dimensions of explainability or integrability |
| Liaw et al [23], 2023 | Semistructured interviews and surveys | 22 | Clinicians managing diabetes | Factors influencing the adoption of the tool, perception of the tool’s usefulness, and ease of use | Transparency, usability, and impact on clinic workflows need to be tailored to the demands and resources of clinics and communities. |
| Schoonderwoerd et al [38], 2021 | Domain analysis, interviews, surveys, and scenario experiment | 6 | Pediatrician clinicians | Diagnosis, information they have used in their decision-making, and the importance ranking of different types of explanations in various contexts | The information that is used to make a diagnosis, the information that supports the diagnosis, how certain the clinician is of the diagnosis, and the relevance of the information for their diagnosis |
| Panagoulias et al [30], 2023 | Survey | 39 | Medical personnel (including medical students and medical practitioners) | Suggested level of explainability, knowledge of AIa, ways to better integrate AI, and AI concerns | The overall system functions, user-friendly software, and impact on workflow |
| Ghanvatkar and Rajan [11], 2024 | Theoretical construction and case analysis | —b | Clinicians | Usefulness of AI explanations for clinicians | Local explanations and global explanations |
| Fogliato et al [44], 2022 | Scenario experiment | 19 | Radiologists | Anchoring effects; human-AI team diagnostic performance and agreement; time spent and confidence in decision-making; perceived usefulness of the AI | Do not waste time and no additional workload. |
aAI: artificial intelligence.
bNot available.