Table 1.

LeBel et al. (2018) replication taxonomy for this replication study to classify the methodological similarity to the original study from Baron and Hershey (1988). Each facet of the experimental design within Baron and Hershey (1988) and our current study are compared to each other for similarity, with any key differences between the two described.

DESIGN FACET	SAME/DIFFERENT TO ORIGINAL PAPER	NOTES
Effect/hypothesis	Same
IV construct	Same
DV construct	Same
IV operationalization	Same
DV operationalization	Same
Population (e.g., age)	Different	Original study recruited undergraduates.
IV stimuli	Same
DV stimuli	Similar	Original DV stimuli used, with added extensions.
Procedural details	Different	Study conducted via Qualtrics, changed from within-participants to a between-participants study design.
Physical setting	Different	Study conducted online rather than in person.
Contextual variables	Different
Overall	Close to far replication