Skip to main content
. 2025 Aug 22;11:55. doi: 10.1186/s40729-025-00643-5

Table 3.

Risk of bias assessment of non-randomized studies using the Newcastle-Ottawa scale (NOS)

Number of awarded stars in each domain
Selection Comparability Outcome Study Quality
Chapiasco et al. 2021 3 1 3 High
Corinadelsi et al. 2009 3 1 3 High
Li et al. 2023 4 1 3 High
Pellegrino et al. 2024 3 0 3 Moderate
Rocuzzo et al. 2007 4 1 3 High
Sagheb et al. 2017 3 0 3 Moderate
Lizio et al. 2016 3 0 3 Moderate
Dellavia et al. 2021 3 0 3 Moderate
El Chaar et al. 2019 4 1 3 High
Gomes et al. 2016 3 0 3 Moderate
Hartmann et al. 2020 3 0 3 Moderate
Her et al. 2012 3 0 3 Moderate
Jung et al. 2014 3 0 3 Moderate
Poli et al. 2014 3 0 3 Moderate
Ragucci et al. 2024 3 0 3 Moderate
Miyamoto et al. 2012 3 0 3 Moderate
Louis et al. 2008 3 0 3 Moderate
Nan et al. 2023 3 0 3 Moderate
Chen et al. 2023 4 1 3 High

NOS: maximum score = 9 points. Domains: Selection (max. 4), Comparability (max. 2), Outcome (max. 3). Higher scores indicate better methodological quality