Table 1.
Characteristics of included studies
| AUTHOR(S), YEAR | FRACTURE GROUP | NON FRACTURE GROUP | MEAN AGE GENDER |
SAMPLE | FOLLOW UP | PRIMARY OUTCOME MEASURE Incidence of new fracture |
*NOS SCORE |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
1. Martinez‐Ferrer et al. 2013 RCT Spain |
N=17 New fracture group |
N=40 |
71.92 yrs 72.8% Female 27.2% Male |
N=57 140 vertebrae, 61% of patients>2 vertebrae per procedure, Max 4 levels treated in a single session |
6 −39 months |
17 patients had 29 fractures Incidence: 30% |
7 |
|
2. Zhang et al. 2023 Retrospective study China |
N=47 New fracture group |
N=232 |
71,11 yrs Female 81,7% Male18,3% |
N=279 | >6 m |
47 patients had new fractures Incidence: 16,8% 232 did not have (83,2%) |
7 |
|
3. Zhang et al., 2021 Retrospective study China |
N=362 New fracture group |
N=1840 |
66.06 yrs Female74,2 % Male 25,8% |
N=2.202 |
1,2,3,6,12 Mean follow up 14,7 months. |
362 patients had a new fracture 362 Incidence: 16.43% 1840 non fractured |
8 |
|
4. Xiong et al., 2021 Retrospective cohort study China |
N=48 Recompression group |
N=45 |
78.97 yrs Female 80.6% Male :19.3% |
N=93 |
>2 years 1.2–25.9 months Mean follow up 9.3 months |
Refracture was found in 48 patients (51,6%) Incidence: 3.68% |
8 |
|
5. Ren et al. 2015 Retrospective study China |
N=21 New fracture group |
N=161 |
69,7 yrs Female 85.2% Male 14.8% |
N=182 |
24–50 months Mean follow up 26.4 months |
Incidence: 11.5% 28 new fractures in 21 patients. |
8 |
|
6. Li et al., 2023 China |
N=27 Adjacent fracture group |
N=76 |
74,16 yrs Female 75.7% Male 24.2% |
N=103 | Mean follow up:24,1 months | Incidence: 26.21% | 7 |
|
7. Bae et al., 2017 Retrospective study South Korea |
N=25 New fracture group |
N=231 |
71,9 yrs Female 79,3 % Male: 20.7% |
N=256 | Mean follow up 36 months |
25 sustained new fractures (9.8%) Incidence: 11.6% |
7 |
|
8. Ju & Liu 2023, Retrospective study China |
N=48 Recompression group |
N=216 |
74,7 yrs Female 59,8% Male: 40.2% |
N=264 | 1,6,12 months for the 1 st year, then once a year afterward |
48 patients suffered refracture Incidence: 18.2% |
7 |
|
9. Li et al., 2022 Retrospective study China |
N=58 New fracture group |
N=327 |
75,6 yrs Female 80% Male 20% |
N=385 | 2 years | Incidence: 15% | 8 |