Skip to main content
. 2025 Jun 11;36(8):1297–1311. doi: 10.1007/s00198-025-07523-z

Table 1.

Characteristics of included studies

AUTHOR(S), YEAR FRACTURE GROUP NON FRACTURE GROUP MEAN AGE
GENDER
SAMPLE FOLLOW UP PRIMARY OUTCOME MEASURE
Incidence of new fracture
*NOS SCORE

1. Martinez‐Ferrer et al. 2013 

RCT

Spain

N=17

New fracture group

N=40

71.92 yrs

72.8% Female

27.2% Male

N=57

140 vertebrae, 61% of patients>2 vertebrae per procedure, Max 4 levels treated in a single session

6 −39 months

17 patients had 29 fractures

Incidence: 30%

7

2. Zhang et al.

2023

Retrospective study

China

N=47

New fracture group

N=232

71,11 yrs

Female 81,7%

Male18,3%

N=279 >6 m

47 patients had new fractures

Incidence: 16,8%

232 did not have (83,2%)

7

3. Zhang et al., 2021

Retrospective study

China

N=362

New fracture group

N=1840

66.06 yrs

Female74,2 %

Male 25,8%

N=2.202

1,2,3,6,12

Mean follow up 14,7 months.

362 patients had a new fracture 362

Incidence: 16.43%

1840 non fractured

8

4. Xiong et al., 2021

Retrospective cohort study

China

N=48

Recompression group

N=45

78.97 yrs

Female 80.6%

Male :19.3%

N=93

>2 years

1.2–25.9 months

Mean follow up 9.3 months

Refracture was found in 48 patients (51,6%)

Incidence: 3.68%

8

5. Ren et al. 2015

Retrospective study

China

N=21

New fracture group

N=161

69,7 yrs

Female 85.2%

Male 14.8%

N=182

24–50 months

Mean follow up 26.4 months

Incidence: 11.5%

28 new fractures in 21 patients.

8

6. Li et al.,

2023

China

N=27

Adjacent fracture group

N=76

74,16 yrs

Female 75.7%

Male 24.2%

N=103 Mean follow up:24,1 months Incidence: 26.21% 7

7. Bae et al., 2017

Retrospective study

South Korea

N=25

New fracture group

N=231

71,9 yrs

Female 79,3 %

Male: 20.7%

N=256 Mean follow up 36 months

25 sustained new fractures (9.8%)

Incidence: 11.6%

7

8. Ju & Liu 2023,

Retrospective study

China

N=48

Recompression group

N=216

74,7 yrs

Female 59,8%

Male: 40.2%

N=264 1,6,12 months for the 1 st year, then once a year afterward

48 patients suffered refracture

Incidence: 18.2%

7

9. Li et al., 2022

Retrospective study

China

N=58

New fracture group

N=327

75,6 yrs

Female 80%

Male 20%

N=385 2 years Incidence: 15% 8