Table 2.
The interaction impacts of the soil application of biochar × foliar-spraying of chitosan under varying soil moisture levels on the chemical compositions of the yarrow essential oil during two years of study.
| Row | Compositions | RI | Experimental treatments | p-Value | |||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Irrigation at 80–85% F.C | Irrigation at 60–65% F.C | Irrigation at 40–45% F.C | |||||||||||||
| Non-Biochar | Biochar | Non-Biochar | Biochar | Non-Biochar | Biochar | ||||||||||
| Non-Chitosan | Chitosan | Non-Chitosan | Chitosan | Non-Chitosan | Chitosan | Non-Chitosan | Chitosan | Non-Chitosan | Chitosan | Non-Chitosan | Chitosan | ||||
| 1 | α-Pinene | 939 | 9.07j ¶ | 9.63hi | 9.92gh | 9.39ij | 10.05fg | 10.88e | 10.31f. | 11.29d | 12.05c | 12.87b | 13.13ab | 13.39a | 0.01* |
| 2 | Camphene | 954 | 0.66h | 0.85g | 1.00f. | 1.08ef | 1.34d | 1.17e | 1.42d | 1.55c | 1.63bc | 1.66bc | 1.75b | 2.19a | 0.01* |
| 3 | Sabinene | 975 | 1.73j | 1.84i | 1.94h | 0.98k | 2.34d | 2.42c | 2.70a | 2.57b | 2.07g | 2.21ef | 2.16f. | 2.29de | 0.000** |
| 4 | β-Pinene | 979 | 1.44j | 1.69i | 1.63i | 1.83h | 2.40g | 2.55ef | 2.51f. | 2.61e | 2.73d | 2.94c | 3.22b | 3.60a | 0.000** |
| 5 | β-Myrcene | 985 | 3.58i | 3.82h | 3.98gh | 3.89h | 4.09fg | 4.23f. | 4.27f. | 4.60e | 4.83d | 5.03c | 5.20b | 5.73a | 0.02* |
| 6 | α-Phellandrene | 1003 | 2.03g | 2.15f. | 2.07g | 1.23h | 2.25e | 2.38d | 2.33d | 2.44c | 2.55b | 2.61a | 2.60ab | 2.56ab | 0.03* |
| 7 | p-Cymene | 1029 | 0.28g | 0.33f. | 0.29g | 0.36e | 1.37c | 1.42b | 1.40b | 0.44d | 1.50a | 1.51a | 1.51a | 1.49a | 0.000** |
| Sum of hydrocarbon monoterpenes | 18.79 | 20.31 | 20.83 | 18.76 | 22.84 | 25.05 | 24.94 | 25.50 | 27.36 | 28.83 | 29.57 | 31.10 | |||
| 8 | 1,8-cineole | 1031 | 9.33h | 10.22f. | 10.40f. | 9.84g | 12.79d | 13.25c | 13.40c | 11.55e | 14.78b | 15.12ab | 15.29a | 15.34a | 0.01* |
| 9 | Pinocarveol < trans- > | 1139 | 0.86h | 0.90h | 0.87h | 0.94g | 2.24b | 2.41a | 2.43a | 1.52f. | 2.00e | 2.15c | 2.10d | 2.23b | 0.000** |
| 10 | Verbenol < trans- > | 1144 | 0.13i | 0.17h | 0.20g | 0.22g | 1.24e | 1.27d | 1.29d | 0.31f. | 1.33c | 1.36b | 1.34bc | 1.45a | 0.000** |
| 11 | Camphor | 1146 | 2.90h | 3.22g | 3.08g | 3.55f. | 5.51c | 5.99b | 6.17ab | 6.30a | 3.83e | 4.38d | 4.00e | 4.51d | 0.000** |
| 12 | Borneol | 1169 | 5.50gh | 5.78g | 5.57g | 5.13h | 6.33f. | 8.78e | 9.38d | 6.40f. | 10.52c | 10.88c | 12.71b | 14.79a | 0.000** |
| 13 | Terpinen-4-ol | 1177 | 1.87j | 2.04i | 1.95ij | 2.19h | 2.37g | 2.90e | 2.74f. | 3.15d | 3.21d | 3.79c | 3.96b | 4.18a | 0.000** |
| 14 | Bornyl acetate | 1285 | 2.13k | 2.72i | 2.59j | 2.83h | 3.74g | 4.97d | 4.56e | 4.31f. | 5.22c | 5.35b | 5.33b | 7.02a | 0.000** |
| Sum of oxygenated monoterpenes | 22.72 | 25.05 | 24.66 | 24.71 | 34.22 | 39.57 | 39.97 | 33.57 | 40.89 | 43.03 | 44.73 | 49.52 | |||
| Sum of hydrocarbon and oxygenated monoterpenes | 41.51 | 45.36 | 45.49 | 43.46 | 58.06 | 64.62 | 64.91 | 59.04 | 68.25 | 71.86 | 74.3 | 80.77 | |||
| 15 | Longifolene | 1400 | 0.73b | 0.78ab | 0.86a | 0.93a | 0.59c | 0.71b | 0.65bc | 0.67bc | 0.42d | 0.48d | 0.53cd | 0.56c | 0.04* |
| 16 | Germacrene-D | 1479 | 1.28a | 1.34a | 1.33a | 1.29a | 0.98b | 1.10b | 1.06b | 1.17ab | 0.75c | 0.87bc | 0.79c | 0.96b | 0.02* |
| 17 | α-Curcumene | 1481 | 2.63b | 2.82b | 2.68b | 3.47a | 1.20d | 0.47e | 1.70d | 0.81d | 1.94c | 1.01d | 2.33bc | 1.98c | 0.000** |
| 18 | β-Bisabolene | 1509 | 11.68b | 12.05ab | 12.96a | 13.12a | 9.98bc | 9.60bc | 8.80c | 10.89b | 7.85c | 8.19c | 5.70d | 1.37e | 0.001** |
| 19 | delta-Cadinene | 1521 | 1.68a | 0.81bc | 1.05b | 1.26b | 1.20b | 0.60 | 1.39ab | 1.47ab | 0.69c | 0.87bc | 1.03b | 1.11b | 0.02* |
| 20 | α-Calacorene | 1546 | 1.87b | 1.99ab | 2.09ab | 2.56a | 1.46bc | 0.73cd | 0.57d | 0.82c | 0.92c | 0.54d | 1.11c | 1.36bc | 0.01* |
| 21 | α-Bisabolene < cis- > | 1548 | 1.85a | 1.96a | 2.00a | 2.04a | 1.44b | 1.52b | 1.56b | 1.49b | 1.58b | 1.69ab | 1.61ab | 1.75ab | 0.02* |
| Sum of hydrocarbon sesquiterpenes | 21.72 | 22.75 | 23.97 | 25.65 | 16.84 | 17.73 | 16.72 | 19.32 | 14.15 | 15.12 | 13.11 | 9.08 | |||
| 22 | Nerolidol | 1538 | 7.86b | 8.45a | 8.21ab | 8.44a | 6.16d | 5.76de | 5.48e | 6.9c | 4.72f. | 4.51f. | 3.62g | 1.00h | 0.000** |
| 23 | Caryophyllene oxide | 1579 | 11.68c | 12.05b | 12.36ab | 13.11a | 9.97e | 9.59f. | 8.79g | 10.88d | 7.85i | 8.18h | 5.69j | 1.36k | 0.000** |
| 24 | Guaiol | 1595 | 5.02a | 5.22a | 5.35a | 5.57a | 2.24b | 2.71b | 2.93b | 3.82b | 1.04c | 1.25c | 0.67d | 2.07b | 0.000** |
| 25 | Spathulenol | 1635 | 1.38a | 1.52a | 1.51a | 1.46a | 1.14b | 1.28b | 0.24e | 0.35e | 0.85d | 1.04c | 0.96c | 1.09c | 0.02* |
| 26 | Chamazulene | 1723 | 4.08b | 5.16a | 4.43b | 5.39a | 2.61d | 2.91cd | 2.77d | 3.61c | 1.58e | 1.83e | 2.10d | 2.36 | 0.000** |
| Sum of oxygenated sesquiterpenes | 30.02 | 32.40 | 31.86 | 33.98 | 22.12 | 22.25 | 21.21 | 26.56 | 15.77 | 16.46 | 14.04 | 7.88 | |||
| Total | 93.24 | 99.58 | 99.86 | 99.95 | 96.02 | 99.84 | 99.76 | 99.86 | 98.17 | 99.87 | 99.48 | 97.58 | |||
¶ Different letters within a row indicate significant difference at p < 0.05 according to Duncan’s test.
*: Significant at the five percent level and **: Significant at the one percent level.