Table 2.
Alpha diversity of bacteria and fungi in Broussonetia papyrifera silage during aerobic exposure
| Items | Bacteria | Fungi | Bacteria/Fungi | ||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Richness estimator | Diversity index | Coverage | Richness estimator | Diversity index | Coverage | OS Ratio | Shannon Ratio | ||||||
| Days | Sample | OS | Chao1 | Simpson | Shannon | OS | Chao1 | Simpson | Shannon | ||||
| Fresh | 133.00b | 176.87c | 0.59e | 2.76bc | 0.993a | 414.67abc | 511.14ab | 0.81abc | 5.27abc | 0.998c | 2.64b | 0.78b | |
| 0 | CK | 60.67b | 116.95c | 0.56e | 1.59c | 0.995a | 186.67bcde | 204.08bcd | 0.95a | 5.38abc | 1.000abc | 0.54b | 0.3b |
| LP | 434.67b | 586.72bc | 0.84abcd | 4.46b | 0.975ab | 231.67bcde | 244.41bcd | 0.84abc | 4.82abc | 1.000abc | 12.98b | 1.31b | |
| LP+CE | 204.00b | 262.68c | 0.79cd | 3.26bc | 0.990a | 357.33abcd | 397.44abcd | 0.96a | 6.11ab | 0.999abc | 0.81b | 1.41b | |
| LP+XY | 283.67b | 355.70c | 0.76cd | 3.45bc | 0.985ab | 605.00a | 659.17a | 0.97a | 7.01a | 0.999abc | 0.52b | 0.78b | |
| LP+CE+XY | 251.00b | 322.35c | 0.81cd | 3.61bc | 0.987a | 385.00abc | 425.82abc | 0.88abc | 5.62abc | 0.999abc | 0.64b | 1.33b | |
| 3 | CK | 976.67a | 1497.64a | 0.97a | 7.65a | 0.948c | 473.33abc | 555.96ab | 0.91abc | 5.8abc | 0.998c | 1.80b | 0.54b |
| LP | 278.00b | 341.36c | 0.79cd | 3.49bc | 0.986a | 521.67ab | 561.61ab | 0.97a | 6.43a | 0.999abc | 0.54b | 29.26b | |
| LP+CE | 182.33b | 234.57c | 0.81bc | 3.29bc | 0.991a | 295.00abcde | 342.78abcd | 0.52bcde | 2.98cd | 0.999abc | 1.62b | 1666.31a | |
| LP+XY | 248.00b | 302.81c | 0.88abcd | 4.31b | 0.990a | 145.00cde | 212.17bcd | 0.39defg | 1.68d | 0.999abc | 9.79b | 0.54b | |
| LP+CE+XY | 237.33b | 289.63c | 0.8cd | 3.53bc | 0.989a | 420.67abc | 489.76ab | 0.97a | 6.24a | 0.998abc | 0.63b | 13.76b | |
| 5 | CK | 890.33a | 1035.22ab | 0.97ab | 7.41a | 0.962bc | 225.67bcde | 239.78bcd | 0.93ab | 5.19abc | 1.000abc | 4.99b | 1.81b |
| LP | 289.67b | 342.21c | 0.88abcd | 4.47b | 0.989a | 45.33de | 50.83cd | 0.10fg | 0.49d | 1.000ab | 11.78b | 62.41b | |
| LP+CE | 206.00b | 266.54c | 0.81bcd | 3.49bc | 0.989a | 227.00bcde | 324.55abcd | 0.51cdef | 3.11bcd | 0.999abc | 0.95b | 0.64b | |
| LP+XY | 188.00b | 267.63c | 0.76cd | 3.22bc | 0.989a | 11.67e | 11.83d | 0.20defg | 0.64d | 1.000a | 19.16b | 0.69b | |
| LP+CE+XY | 182.00b | 220.75c | 0.80cd | 3.33bc | 0.992a | 172.00cde | 179.00bcd | 0.56abcd | 2.79cd | 1.000ab | 11.26 | 12.57b | |
| 7 | CK | 194.00b | 230.18c | 0.92abc | 4.78b | 0.993a | 286.33abcde | 291.45abcd | 0.96a | 6.19a | 1.000ab | 0.89b | 80.12b |
| LP | 341.33b | 433.88bc | 0.89abcd | 4.72b | 0.983ab | 11.00e | 11.33d | 0.11efg | 0.47d | 1.00a | 65.49a | 0.52b | |
| LP+CE | 368.33b | 521.24bc | 0.91abcd | 4.70b | 0.977ab | 7.00e | 7.50d | 0.04g | 0.16d | 1.000a | 57.23a | 3.78b | |
| LP+XY | 359.67b | 472.33bc | 0.88abcd | 4.86b | 0.983ab | 11.67e | 11.67d | 0.08g | 0.35d | 1.000a | 22.56b | 31.7b | |
| LP+CE+XY | 219.00b | 294.4c | 0.75d | 3.33bc | 0.988a | 16.00e | 22.00d | 0.08g | 0.30d | 1.000a | 16.43b | 12.08b | |
| SEM | 37.40 | 53.91 | 0.02 | 0.21 | 0.002 | 29.07 | 33.13 | 0.05 | 0.35 | 0.0001 | 3.07 | 79.03 | |
| P-value | <0.01 | <0.05 | <0.001 | <0.001 | <0.05 | <0.001 | <0.001 | <0.001 | <0.001 | 0.052 | <0.05 | 0.487 | |
Different lowercase letters indicate significant differences of the same column (P < 0.05)
LP Lactiplantibacillus plantarum, LP + CE Lactiplantibacillus plantarum + cellulase, LP + XY Lactiplantibacillus plantarum + xylanase, LP + CE + XY Lactiplantibacillus plantarum + cellulase + xylanase, OS Observed species, SEM Standard Error of Mean