Table 1.
Characteristics of included studies
| Author, year | Country | Sample size (female) | Diagnosis | Age, Median (range)/Mean ± SD | Intervention | Interest outcome measures | Assessments timepoint | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Baseline (mon) | Gestational age (week) | |||||||
| Nelson (2001) [30] | America |
EG: 21(14) CG: 16(5) |
High risk of CP |
EG: 7.72 ± 0.19 of CA CG: 7.74 ± 0.21 of CA |
EG: 26.28 ± 2.24 CG: 26.75 ± 1.35 |
EG: EE + Standard care CG: Standard care |
Motor: BSID-II Cognitive: BSID-II |
12 mon of CA |
| Ohgi (2004) [31] | Japan |
EG: 12(3) CG: 11(3) |
High risk of CP |
EG: 0 CG: 0 |
EG: 30.3 ± 3.3 CG: 30.3 ± 2.7 |
EG: EE CG: Standard care |
Motor: BSID-II Cognitive: BSID-II |
6 mon of CA |
| Blauw-Hospers (2011) [32] | America |
EG: 21(12) CG: 25(14) |
High risk of CP | 3–6 of CA |
EG: 29 (27–40) CG: 30 (25–39) |
EG: EE CG: Standard care |
Motor: AIMS Cognitive: BSID-II |
6 mon of CA, 18 mon of CA |
| Morgan (2015) [33] | Australia |
EG: 6(1) CG: 7(1) |
High risk of CP |
EG: 4.10 ± 0.96 of CA CG: 4.01 ± 0.91 of CA |
EG: 35.50 ± 5.21 CG: 33.57 ± 7.76 |
EG: EE CG: Standard care |
Motor: PDMS-II | after 12-week intervention |
| Morgan (2016) [34] | Australia |
EG: 15(7) CG: 15(6) |
High risk of CP |
EG: 3.62 ± 1.10 of CA CG: 4.61 ± 1.17 of CA |
EG: 34.27 ± 5.27 CG: 35.27 ± 5.09 |
EG: EE CG: Standard care |
Motor: PDMS-II, GMFM-66 Cognitive: BSID-III |
12 mon of CA |
| Dusing (2018) [35] | America |
EG: 7(2) CG: 7(4) |
High risk of CP |
EG: 0 CG: 0 |
EG: 25 (24–27) CG: 26 (25–28) |
EG: EE + Standard care CG: Standard care |
Motor: TIMP, BSID-III Cognitive: BSID-III, EPSI |
after 15-week intervention, 12 mon of CA |
| Holmström (2019) [36] | Sweden |
EG: 19(7) CG: 20(6) |
High risk of CP, motor disfunction and preterm |
EG: 6.3 ± 1.62 of CA CG: 6.7 ± 1.96 of CA |
EG: 33 ± 6.5 CG: 33 ± 6.95 |
EG: EE CG: Standard care |
Motor: PDMS-II, GMFM-66, BSID-III Cognitive: BSID-III |
after 35-week intervention, 24 mon of CA |
| Harbourne (2019) [37] | America |
EG:11(N/A) CG:9(N/A) |
High risk of CP and CP | 15 ± 6.9 | N/A |
EG: EE CG: Optimal Pattern Intervention |
Motor: GMFM-88 Cognitive: EPSI |
after 12-week intervention |
| Hielkema (2020a) [38] | Netherlands |
EG: 23(8) CG: 20(9) |
High risk of CP |
EG: 1.4 (0.1–8.6) CG: 2.5 (0.9–9.0) |
EG: 32 (26–41) CG: 29 (26–41) |
EG: EE CG: PT |
Motor: IMP, AIMS, Bayley-II, GMFM-66, GMFM-88 Cognitive: Bayley-II |
after 48-week intervention, 21 mon of CA |
| Hielkema (2020b) [39] | Netherlands |
EG: 23(8) CG: 20(9) |
High risk of CP |
EG: 1.4 (0.7–2.8) CG: 2.5 (1.8–4.7) |
EG: 32 (29–40) CG: 29 (27–38) |
EG: EE CG: PT |
NA |
after 48-week intervention, 21 mon of CA |
| Harbourne (2021) [40] | America |
EG: 55(26) CG: 57(22) |
High risk of CP |
EG: 10.67 ± 2.57 of CA CG: 10.93 ± 2.63 of CA |
N/A |
EG: EE + Standard care CG: Standard care |
Motor: GMFM-88, BSID-III Cognitive: APSP, BSID-III |
after 36-week intervention, |
| Ziegler (2021) [41] | Switzerland |
EG: 8(2) CG: 8(1) |
High risk of CP |
EG: 1.04 (0-3.45) CG: 3.34 (0-5.06) |
EG: 27 (25–30) CG: 29.5 (26–31) |
EG: EE CG: Standard care |
Motor: IMP, BSID-III Cognitive: BSID-III |
18 mon of CA, 24 mon of CA |
| Cemali (2022) [42] | Turkey |
EG: 17(5) CG: 17(11) |
CP |
EG: 14.47 ± 1.28 CG: 13.82 ± 1.55 |
N/A |
EG: EE + PT CG: PT |
Motor: AIMS | after 8-week intervention |
| Alberge (2023) [43] | France |
EG: 63(28) CG: 59(22) |
High risk of CP |
EG: 8.5 (8.28–8.97) of CA CG: 8.5 (8.28–8.97) of CA |
EG: 27.6 ± 1.3 CG: 27.4 ± 1.4 |
EG: EE CG: Standard care |
Motor: BSID-III Cognitive: BSID-III |
9 mon of age, 24 mon of age |
EG experiment group, CG control group, CP cerebral palsy, N/A not applicable, w weeks, mon months, CA corrected age, EE environmental enrichment, PT physiotherapy, BSID-II Bayley Scales of Infant Development-Second Edition, AIMS Alberta Infant Motor Scale, PDMS-II Peabody Developmental Motor Scales- Second Edition, GMFM-66 Gross Motor Function Measure-66, BSID-III Bayley scales of infant development-Third edition, TIMP Test of Infant Motor Performance, GMFM-88 Gross Motor Function Measure-88, EPSI Early Problem Solving Indicator, IMP Infant Motor Profile, APSP Assessment of Problem Solving in Play