Table 2. Included studies, study designs and sleep quality improvement effects (N=13).
| Author and year | TST | SOL | SE | Proportion of deep sleep | Subjective sleep quality | Symptom relief | Other indirect improvement |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Single-arm pre–post studies | |||||||
| Zhang et al, 201573 | Significantly reduced the SOL for people with difficulty in falling asleep (p=1.22e−04, Wilcoxon signed-rank test). | ||||||
| Wei et al, 202375 |
Significantly increased TST for female participants (p=0.035). | Significantly improved SE for female participants (B=2.666, sig=0.033). | Significantly decreased non-rapid eye movement N2 proportion (B=2.666, sig=0.033), and increased non-rapid eye movement N3 proportion (B=2.8, sig=0.078). Decreased ANS activity during N3 sleep. |
Significantly improved the self-rated sleep quality for female participants (p=0.025). | |||
| Verhaert et al, 201376 | Spinal alignment was significantly improved in the active support condition. | The group with active control of bed attributes (7.00±0.87) scored higher on subjective perceived sleep quality than the reference night group without control of bed attributes (5.67±1.41). | |||||
| Tang et al, 202372 | Increased total sleep duration. | Shorter sleep latency. | Average heart rate and respiratory rate stabilised, and the number of body movements decreased. | Offered help, suggestions and care plans based on disease risk prediction (including sleep disorders such as OSA). | |||
| Hu et al, 202167 |
Long sleep continuity; Frequent nap variables. | Better adherence, incorporating medically advised interventions into the care system, and improving overall quality of life. | |||||
| Ferrer-Lluis et al, 202169 | The percentage of time subjects spent supine before and after postural therapy (45.6% → 2%). | ||||||
| Pilot study | |||||||
| Zhao et al, 202074 | The users’ deep sleep time and deep sleep frequency increased significantly. | Sleep score increased and the effect was more obvious (81 → 92; 92 → 98). | |||||
| Van der Loos et al, 200364 | Gently encourages a person to roll over to alleviate snoring and OSA. | ||||||
| He et al, 202268 |
The average snoring time (135 → 15 min). |
||||||
| Development study | |||||||
| Liao et al, 202465 | Effectively promoted restful sleep and improved nightly rest in noisy environments. | ||||||
| Kim et al, 201966 | Set the temperature at the optimal sleep condition and monitored the sleep condition based on the telemedicine system. | ||||||
| RCT | |||||||
| Donati et al, 202170 | Sleeping hours (6 hours to almost 8 hours) |
|
|||||
| Crossover RCT | |||||||
| Bogan et al, 201771 |
|
||||||
ANS, autonomic nervous system; FQSQ-10, Short Functional Outcomes of Sleep Questionnaire; OSA, obstructive sleep apnoea; PedsQL, Paediatric Quality of Life Inventory; PGWBI, Psychological General Well-Being Index; PSQI, Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index; RCT, randomised controlled trial; SE, sleep efficiency; SOL, sleep onset latency; TST, total sleep time.