Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2026 Apr 19.
Published in final edited form as: Head Neck. 2025 Apr 19;47(9):2486–2498. doi: 10.1002/hed.28167

Table 1:

Descriptive Features of Included Studies

References Country Year Published Patients (n) Male (n) Female (n) Mean Age (years) Treatment Groups
Aksu et al 14 Turkey 2006 80 41 39 - Surgery + Radiation, Radiation
Bossi et al 15 Italy 2014 171 141 30 - Surgery + Radiation, CRT
Chung et al 16 Korea 1997 33 30 3 58.4 Surgery, Radiation
Culie et al 11 France 2021 382 280 102 61.6 Surgery + CRT, CRT
Culie et al 12 France 2021 474 356 118 60.3 Surgery + CRT, CRT
Debenham et al 17 Canada 2016 233 203 30 56 Surgery + CRT, CRT
Fein et al 18 USA 1994 170 117 53 60 Surgery + Radiation, Radiation
Givens et al 19 USA 1981 104 - - 60 Surgery, Surgery + Radiation, Radiation
Hicks et al 4 USA 1998 76 - - - Radiation
Inagi et al 20 Japan 2002 87 73 14 - Surgery, Surgery + CRT, Radiation, CRT
Jones et al 21 UK 1998 105 78 27 - Surgery + Radiation, Radiation
Jones et al 22 UK 2007 123 82 41 - Surgery + Radiation, Radiation
Kajanti et al 23 Finland 1991 75 54 21 - Surgery + Radiation, Radiation
Kamran et al 24 USA 2018 22676 19036 3640 - Surgery + CRT, CRT
Kano et al 25 Japan 2013 186 164 22 - Surgery, CRT
Kao et al 26 Australia 2018 98 79 19 57.3 Surgery + CRT, CRT
Kim et al 27 Korea 2010 133 104 29 61.5 Surgery + CRT, CRT
Kobayashi et al 28 Japan 2016 62 45 17 63.6 Surgery, Surgery + Radiation, CRT
Kokemueller et al 29 Germany 2011 341 226 115 58.8 Surgery + CRT, CRT
Kravets et al 30 Ukraine 2020 211 176 35 56.1 Surgery + CRT, CRT
Kurita et al 31 Japan 2003 64 38 26 - Surgery + CRT, CRT
Lanza et al 32 Italy 2000 115 108 7 63 Surgery + Radiation, CRT
Ling et al 33 China 2013 210 113 97 - Surgery, Surgery + Radiation, CRT
Lybak et al 34 Norway 2017 226 174 52 62 Surgery + CRT, CRT
Mahmoud et al 35 USA 2018 1873 1571 302 - Surgery + CRT, CRT
McDowell et al 36 Australia 2014 31 21 10 61.6 Surgery + CRT, CRT
Meccariello et al 37 Italy 2020 129 102 27 62.6 Surgery + CRT, CRT
O’Connell et al 38 Canada 2013 344 141 203 58.7 Surgery + Radiation, Surgery + CRT, Radiation, CRT
Park et al 39 Korea 2013 114 103 11 - Surgery + Radiation, Surgery + CRT, CRT
Park et al 40 Korea 2018 102 85 17 - Surgery + CRT, CRT
Rana et al 41 Germany 2011 398 224 174 49.5 Surgery + CRT, CRT
Rash et al 42 USA 2018 51 38 13 - Surgery + CRT, CRT
Seikaly et al 43 Canada 2016 200 158 42 55.4 Surgery + CRT, CRT
Sessions et al 44 USA 2002 332 209 23 - Surgery, Surgery + Radiation, Radiation
Sher et al 45 USA 2018 884 727 175 61.5 Surgery, Surgery + Radiation, Surgery + CRT, Radiation, CRT
Sher et al 46 USA 2019 2754 1978 776 - Surgery + CRT, Radiation, CRT
Shirazi et al 47 USA 2006 74 61 13 - Surgery + CRT, CRT
Smith et al 48 USA 2015 80 61 19 - Surgery, Surgery + CRT, CRT
Song et al 49 Korea 2017 586 523 63 55 Surgery + CRT, CRT
Thakar et al 50 India 2021 146 135 11 54.6 *
Tsai et al 51 Taiwan 2021 1180 1052 128 - Surgery, CRT
van de Pol et al 52 Netherlands 2004 88 64 24 53.4 Surgery + Radiation, Radiation
Yen et al 53 Taiwan 2022 60 57 3 - *
Zubair et al 54 UK 2021 272 - *

-Data not provided in text.

*

Reported on hazard ratios between treatment groups.