Skip to main content
. 2025 Aug 19;13:1650793. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2025.1650793

Table 3.

Summary of round 1 expert ratings on each indicatora.

Domain Sub-domain Element Keep (n) Keep (%) Discussion result
1 37 100.0 Keep
1.1 36 97.3 Keep
1.1.1 37 100.0 Suggested revision
1.1.2 35 94.6 Suggested revision
1.1.3 34 91.9 Suggested revision
1.1.4 32 86.5 Suggested revision
1.2 36 97.3 Keep
1.2.1 34 91.9 Suggested revision
1.2.2 35 94.6 Suggested revision
1.3 36 97.3 Keep
1.3.1 35 94.6 Suggested revision
1.3.2 36 97.3 Suggested revision
1.3.3 36 97.3 Suggested revision
2 37 100.0 Keep
2.1 37 100.0 Keep
2.1.1 36 97.3 Suggested deletion
2.1.2 36 97.3 Keep
2.1.3 35 94.6 Keep
2.2 32 86.5 Suggested deletion
2.2.1 24 64.9 Suggested deletion
2.2.2 24 64.9 Suggested deletion
2.2.3 24 64.9 Suggested deletion
2.3 36 97.3 Keep
2.3.1 32 86.5 Suggested revision
2.3.2 32 86.5 Suggested revision
2.3.3 34 91.9 Suggested revision
2.4 35 94.6 Suggested revision
2.4.1 32 86.5 Suggested revision
2.4.2 35 94.6 Suggested revision
2.4.3 31 83.8 Suggested revision
3 37 100.0 Keep
3.1 36 97.3 Suggested revision
3.1.1 31 83.8 Suggested revision
3.1.2 34 91.9 Suggested revision
3.1.3 28 75.7 Suggested revision
3.1.4 30 81.1 Suggested deletion
3.1.5 32 86.5 Suggested revision
3.2 3.2.1 33 89. Keep
34 91.9 Suggested re-assigned & modified.
3.2.1 34 91.9 Suggested revision
3.2.3 33 89.2 Suggested revision
3.3 33 89.2 Keep
3.3.1 35 94.6 Suggested revision
3.3.2 36 97.3 Keep
3.4 34 91.9 Keep
3.4.1 32 86.5 Suggested revision
3.4.2 35 94.6 Suggested revision
3.4.3 35 94.6 Suggested revision
3.5 29 78.4 Suggested re-assigned
3.5.1 36 97.3 Suggested re-assigned
3.5.2 33 89.2 Suggested deletion
3.5.3 37 100.0 Suggested re-assigned
3.5.4 37 100.0 Suggested re-assigned
4 4.1 35 94.6 Suggested re-assigned
28 75.7 Retained based on subjective judgment.
4.1.1 31 83.8 Suggested revision
4.1.2 31 83.8 Suggested revision
4.1.3 34 91.9 Suggested revision
4.2 26 70.3 Retained based on subjective judgment.
4.2.1 33 89.2 Suggested revision
4.2.2 33 89.2 Suggested revision
4.2.3 33 89.2 Suggested revision
4.3 28 75.7 Retained based on subjective judgment.
4.3.1 36 97.3 Keep
4.3.2 37 100.0 Suggested revision
4.4 29 78.4 Suggested deletion
4.4.1 34 91.9 Suggested deletion
4.4.2 33 89.2 Suggested deletion

aThe contents corresponding to each serial number in this table are detailed in Table 2.