Table 3.
Characteristics of the studies included into qualitative and quantitative synthesis.
Study | Participants | Motor Task | Conditions | Outcomes |
---|---|---|---|---|
Borotikar et al. 200849 |
N = 24 females (21 ± 3 years; 176 ± 5 cm; 68 ± 7 kg); NCAA Division 1 (football/soccer, basketball, volleyball)** |
Single-leg landing and sidestep/jump (both limbs assessed and single-leg landings analysed) - land on left foot, immediately and aggressively jump laterally to the right (jumping/cutting angle unclear) - jump off the right foot, laterally to the left - land on both feet and jump vertically |
Visual (light) stimulus UP: following take-off (350 ms prior to ground contact) PP: before initiation of the jump (3 stimuli indicating motor task) |
Initial contact *** 3D ankle angles (sagittal plane) Maximum during (mid-)stance phase (approx. at 50%): *** 3D ankle angles (frontal plane) |
Meinerz et al. 201550 |
N = 18 females (20 ± 1 yrs.; 167 ± 6 cm; 66 ± 2 kg); NCAA Division (football/soccer) ** |
Single-leg landing and sidestep/cut (dominant limb and sidecut analyzed) standing on a box and perform a single-leg forward stride to land on the dominant leg and then: - running straight ahead - stop and balance on the leg - sidecut away from landing leg (cutting angle unclear) |
Visual (light) stimulus UP: stimulus, when the participant fully left the contact mat (available response time unclear) PP: prior to trial-initiation (3 stimuli indicating motor task) |
Initial contact: *** 3D ankle angles (sagittal, frontal and transverse plane) From initial contact to max. knee or hip flexion: *** 3D ankle moments (sagittal, frontal, transverse plane) |
Mache et al. 201356 |
N = 13 females (22 ± 1 yrs.; 172 ± 0.1 cm; 61 ± 6 kg) and N = 16 men (22 ± 3 yrs.; 180 ± 0.1 cm; 79 ± 10 kg); recreational athletes |
Bilateral landing with/without vertical jump (dominant limb assessed) Participants began each trial suspended in the air, hanging by the hands from a horizontal overhead bar (hanging ~ 20% of measured body height above force plates): - drop-jump landings (maintain stance/balance upon landing) - drop-jumps (jump up immediately upon landing and attempt to touch the bar) |
Visual (light) stimulus UP: stimulus, when the participant released the bar (~ 250 ms before ground contact) PP: prior to releasing the bar (2 stimuli indicating motor task) |
Initial contact and from initial contact to max. knee or hip flexion: *** 3D ankle angles (sagittal and frontal plane) From initial contact to max. knee or hip flexion: *** 3D ankle moments (sagittal and frontal frontal) |
Yom et al. 201857 | N = 18 females (21 ± 2 yrs.; 169 ± 4 cm; 63 ± 4 kg); recreational athletes |
Bilateral landing and sidestep/cut (dominant limb assessed) Participants hung from a suspended drop bar at a normalised 0.5 m drop height above force plates: - land on both feet and sidecut to the left (45° angle) - land on both feet and sidecut to the right (45° angle) |
Visual (arrow) stimulus UP: stimulus, when the participant released the bar (~ 320 ms before ground contact) PP: prior to releasing the bar (2 stimuli indicating motor task) |
Initial contact *** 3D ankle angles (frontal plane) From initial contact to max. knee or hip flexion: *** 3D ankle angles (frontal plane) |
Weinhandl et al. 201358 | N = 20 females (21 ± 1 yrs.; 166 ± 5 cm; 62 ± 6 kg); recreational athletes (e.g. soccer, volleyball, tennis, basketball |
Run and sidestep/cut (right limb assessed and sidecut analysed) - run and straight run ahead - run and sidestep to the left (45°) - run and stop quickly (approach speed: 4.5 to 5 m/s) |
Visual (light) stimulus UP: 600 ms before reaching the force plate PP: before the initiation of the run (3 stimuli indicating motor task) |
Weight acceptance/loading response phase (at peak ACL loading): *** - 3D ankle angles (sagittal plane) - 3D ankle moments (sagittal plane) |
Stoffel et al. 201051 |
N = 22 males (22 ± 2 yrs.; 185 ± 0.1 cm; 83 ± 7 kg); Semi-professional or elite Australian Rules Football players ** |
Run and sidestep/cut and straight run (dominant limb, straight run and sidestep/cut analysed) - run and straight run - run and sidestep (45°) - run and crossover cut (45°) (approach speed: 5.5 ± 0.5 m/s) |
Visual (light) stimulus UP: 400 ms before reaching the force plate PP: at the commencement of the run (3 stimuli indicating motor task) |
Weight acceptance/loading response phase (from heel strike to first trough in V-GRF): *** - 3D ankle angles (sagittal, frontal and transverse plane) - 3D ankle moments (sagittal, frontal and transverse plane) |
Whyte et al. (B)55 |
N = 28 males (21.7 ± 2 yrs.; 179 ± 15 m; 82 ± 11 kg) *; University Gaelic Football |
Single-leg landing and sidestep/cut (dominant limb and sidecut analyzed) Horizontal jump equaling 70% of the maximal jump distance and then: - crossover cut (45°) - sidecut (45°) - stop jump |
Visual (light) stimulus UP: 150 ms prior to initial contact PP: three seconds before the initiation of the task (3 stimuli indicating motor task) |
Weight acceptance/loading response phase (from heel strike to first trough in V-GRF): *** - 3D ankle angles (sagittal plane) - 3D ankle moments (sagittal and transverse plane) |
Whyte et al. (A)54 |
N = 28 males (21.7 ± 2 yrs.; 179 ± 15 m; 82 ± 11 kg) *; University Gaelic Football |
Single-leg landing and crossover cut (dominant limb and crosscut analyzed) Horizontal jump equaling 70% of the maximal jump distance and then: - crossover cut (45°) - sidecut (45°) - stop jump |
Visual (light) stimulus UP: 150 ms prior to initial contact PP: three seconds before the initiation of the task (3 stimuli indicating motor task) |
Weight acceptance/loading response phase (from heel strike to first trough in V-GRF): *** - 3D ankle angles (sagittal, frontal and transverse plane) - 3D ankle moments (sagittal and frontal plane) |
Richwalski et al. 201953 |
N = 12 females (20 ± 1 yrs.; 170 cm; 71 ± 10 kg); Volleyball at collegiate club-level |
Bilateral landing and crossover cut or vertical jump (dominant limb assessed) Drop from a 40 cm box and land on both feet and then: - crossover step left - crossover step right - vertical jump |
Visual (arrow) stimulus UP: while stepping of the box (available response time unclear) PP: prior to leaving the box (3 stimuli indicating motor task) |
Initial contact to max. knee flexion: *** 3D ankle moments (sagittal, frontal and transverse plane) |
Kim et al. 201448 | N = 37 young, male middle school football/soccer players (expertise level, exact age, and anthropometrics unclear) |
Run and side/crossover step/cut (dominant limb assessed) - run and sidecut (45°) - run and crossover cut (45°) (approach speed: 3.5 ± 0.2 m/s) |
Visual (light) stimulus UP: 90% of stride length before the force plate (available response time not reported, approx. 250 to 350 ms) PP: before the initiation of the run (2 stimuli indicating motor task) |
Maximum during (mid-)stance phase: *** - 3D ankle angles (sagittal, frontal and transverse plane) - 3D ankle moments (sagittal, frontal and transverse plane) |
Kim et al. 201647 | N = 16 young, male middle school football/soccer players (expertise level unclear; 165 ± 9 cm; 55 ± 10 kg; exact age unclear) |
Run and side step/cut (dominant limb assessed) - run and sidecut left (45°) - run and sidecut right (45°) (approach speed 3.5 ± 0.2 m/s) |
Visual (light) stimulus UP: 90% of stride length before the force plate (available response time not reported, approx. 250 to 350 ms) PP: before the initiation of the run (2 stimuli indicating motor task) |
Weight acceptance/loading response phase (approx. at 8%) and max. during (mid-)stance phase (approx. at 45%): *** - 3D ankle angles (sagittal, frontal and transverse plane) - 3D ankle moments (sagittal, frontal and transverse plane) |
Hou et al. 202459 | N = 15 physically (recreational) active participants (n = 7 females; age: 24 ± 6 years, BMI: 23 ± 4 kg/m2) |
Bilateral countermovement-jump with single-leg landing (both limbs assessed) - landing on the left side - landing on the right side |
Visual (written word) stimulus UP: landing side (left or right) automatically shown 100 ms after take-off (available response time: ~ 400 ms) PP: landing side (left or right) shown before jump (2 stimuli indicating motor task) |
~ 20 ms prior initial contact *** 3D ankle angles (sagittal plane) Peak within 200 ms upon landing (~ 120 ms after initial contact): *** 3D ankle angles (sagittal and frontal plane) |
Zou et al. 202452 | N = 21 female college soccer players (national level or above; all had finished top three national competitions), age: 18 ± 1 years; height: 1.66 ± 0.05 m; weight: 60.1 ± 5.5 kg ** |
Run and cutting (dominant limb assessed) - run and sidecut (45°) - run and crosscut (90°) - run and pivot turn (180°) (approach speed: 2.6 ± 0.3 m/s) |
Visual (arrow) stimulus UP: 2 m before the force plate (available response time not reported, approx. 750 ms) PP: before the initiation of the run (3 stimuli indicating motor task) |
Initial contact and first peak vGRF/weight acceptance/loading response phase) *** 3D ankle angles (sagittal, frontal and transverse plane) |
Rikken et al. 202460 | N = 15 male basketball players (local, regional, national level), age: 22 ± 2 years; height: 1.89 ± 11 m; weight: 85 ± 12 kg |
Run and side step/cut (dominant limb assessed) - run and sidecut left (90°) - run and sidecut right (90°) (approach speed: unclear) |
Visual (light) stimulus Each trial involved two sidestep cuts: the first with the non-dominant leg after an 8.35 m sprint (Fitlight#2), and the second—a 90° cut with the dominant leg (Fitlight#3) following a 3.5 m sprint. The trial ended with another 3.5 m sprint (available response time: unclear) UP: route indicated when reaching Fitlight#2 (available response time not reported) PP: route indicated during the entire trial (2 stimuli indicating motor task) |
Initial contact*** 3D ankle angles (plantarflexion; sagittal plane) Peak between initial contact and max. knee flexion*** 3D ankle angles (dorsiflexion; sagittal plane) (IMU-based system; Xsens MVN Analyze) |
Dutaillis et al. 202161 | N = 19 recreationally active females (age, 24 ± 3yrs; height, 164 ± 5 cm; and weight, 58 ± 6 kg), type of sports (e.g. Soccer, Australian Rules football and gymnastics) |
Single-leg landing and cutting (both limbs assessed) forward jump off a 0.31 m box placed 1.35 m from the centre of the force plate, landing on a single limb and immediately: - sidecut to the left (45°) - sidecut to the right (45°) |
Visual stimulus UP: 450 ms before initial contact PP: before the initiation of the jump (2 stimuli indicating motor task) |
Peak during stance phase (~ 60–80%) - 3D ankle angles (dorsiflexion; sagittal plane) - 3D ankle angles (inversion; frontal plane) |
* same participants, ** allocated to elite performance level.
*** used definition of stance/landing phase: (1) initial contact, (2) loading response/weight acceptance phase (1 to 20% of stance), (3) midstance/peak push off phase (21 to 60% of stance), and (4) terminal stance/final push off phase (last 15% of stance)99,100.
UP = Unplanned, PP = pre-planned, yrs = years, 3D = three-dimensional motion analysis; NCAA = National Collegiate Athletic Association