Table 6.
The elements of self-harming (suicidal) behaviors among disaster responders, as determined by theme content analysis and systematic review
| N | Category | Theme | Sub-theme | Code | References |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Epidemiology and Prevalence | Occupational Disparities | High-Risk Groups | Firefighters: 46.8% career suicidal ideation, 15.5% attempts | [11–13] |
| EMS personnel: 10× higher risk than general population | [14–16] | ||||
| Wildland firefighters: 22% suicide attempt history | [17] | ||||
| Dispatchers: 32% suicidal ideation | [18] | ||||
| Demographic Variations | Female firefighters show higher suicidality | [13, 19–21] | |||
| Native groups: Elevated risk | [15, 22] | ||||
| Retirees: Highest suicide risk (PMR = 234) | [23] | ||||
| Trauma Exposure | Cumulative Trauma | 91.5% of firefighters experience high trauma exposure | [19] | ||
| 94% dispatchers exposed to work-related trauma | [18] | ||||
| 98% EMS personnel exposed to suicide scenes | [16] | ||||
| PTSD Link | PTSD prevalence: 18.9% (firefighters) (Article 12); 25.4% (wildland) | [17] | |||
| PTSD symptoms correlate with suicide exposure | [13, 24, 25] | ||||
| 2 | Psychological and Occupational Risk Factors | Mental Health Comorbidities | Depression/Anxiety | PHQ-9 (mean = 8.35) and GAD-7 (mean = 6.88) scores elevated | [24, 26] |
| - Depression (OR = 8.92) linked to suicidal ideation | [20, 27] | ||||
| Substance Use and Sleep | Hazardous drinking: 38.8% | [26, 28] | |||
| AUD mediates PTSD-suicide link | [25, 29] | ||||
| Insomnia mediates PTSD-suicidal ideation | [23, 25] | ||||
| Occupational Stressors | Work Culture | Culture of independence” increases risk | [12, 24, 30] | ||
| Bullying predicts suicide plans/attempts | [31] | ||||
| Burnout | Emotional exhaustion correlates with SBQ-R scores | [15, 32] | |||
| Burnout linked to suicide exposure (β = 0.42) | [16] | ||||
| 3 | Systemic and Cultural Barriers | Stigma and Help-Seeking | Underreporting | Fear of job repercussions | [13, 24, 30, 33, 34] |
| Male-dominated norms hinder help-seeking | [13, 14] | ||||
| Access Barriers | Rural vs. urban EAP gaps | [26, 30] | |||
| Only 27% dispatchers comfortable discussing mental health | [18] | ||||
| Resource and Training Gaps | Training Deficits | Lack of standardized prevention programs | [24, 30] | ||
| Need for culturally competent care | [15, 32] | ||||
| Leadership and Policy | Grassroots leadership drives programs | [30] | |||
| Mandatory officer training (85% completion) | [34] | ||||
| 4 | Interventions and Solutions | Clinical and Peer Support | Evidence-Based Therapies | CPT/PE reduce PTSS and suicidality | [22, 29, 34] |
| Peer programs for trauma coping | [13, 16, 29] | ||||
| Early Identification | Routine mental health screenings | [20, 22] | |||
| Screen for PTSD/alcohol abuse | [23] | ||||
| Organizational Strategies | Policy Reforms | Houston’s 3-phase program: 5-year zero suicides | [34] | ||
| Restrict lethal means access | [14] | ||||
| Cultural Shifts | Destigmatization campaigns | [21, 22] | |||
| Promote help-seeking | [13, 21] |