Skip to main content
Wiley Open Access Collection logoLink to Wiley Open Access Collection
. 2025 Oct 7;26(4):e70044. doi: 10.1111/nup.70044

On Thinking, Nursing Scholarship and the Science of the Unique

Stefanos Mantzoukas 1,✉
PMCID: PMC12503390  PMID: 41056482

ABSTRACT

In this paper, I go back to one of Gary Rolfe's seminal papers entitled “Thinking as a subversive activity: doing philosophy in the corporate university” (2012), published in the journal Nursing Philosophy, to acknowledge and possibly expand on Rolfe's work on thinking, scholarship and the future of the nursing profession. Rolfe is a prolific academic nurse author, and while there is a thread linking his extensive authorship, his work branches out on a variety of sub‐topics that this paper cannot do justice to, nor does it intend to be a comprehensive review of his work. In this paper, I aim to develop an account and provide my understanding, inspired by Rolfe's work, on how thinking, scholarship, and nursing science interlink and develop each other, and how scholarly thinking can potentially, notwithstanding certain caveats, flourish and guide the future of nursing education within the university sector.

Keywords: corporate university, nursing scholarship, nursing science of the unique, scholarship of reflective practice, subversiveness of thinking

1. Introduction

This paper is written as part of and in part for the commemoration of the 25th anniversary of the journal Nursing Philosophy. The inaugural editorial by Edwards and Liaschenko (2000) has always been the lightning rod for a quarter of a century, spelling out the intentions and direction of the journal. Edwards and Liaschenko (2000), amongst other goals for the journal, included questioning the definitions and types of knowledge, knowing, understanding and practising in nursing, and how we come to conceive effective, useful, reasonable and logical ways and/or means of dealing with nursing issues, problems and nursing spheres of interest, notwithstanding the constraints that reason and logic may have, not least the privileging of voices and the binarism in argument development. Edwards and Liaschenko (2000) concluded with a welcoming call for philosophical discussions on any aspect of nursing.

In the intervening 25 years, many authors have responded to this call by submitting work that has elaborated, expanded, developed, questioned, and moved forward the debate on knowledge, knowing, understanding, and practising in nursing. Ultimately and unavoidably, some of these authors framed the matters of discussion, debate, or questions in a more relatable way, articulating their responses to the issues at stake more meticulously, fully, or persuasively. This anniversary issue looks back to the work of these authors and forward to how they can be (re)contextualised in the current environment and challenges to inform the practice of nursing, care and well‐being for future nurse generations.

For many years, I have been a student of the work of Gary Rolfe in both senses of the word, as I formally engaged and enroled in the master's course he taught; he also was one of the examiners for my doctoral thesis, and I attentively and thoughtfully examined and studied his published work wherever he would publish. One of Rolfe's published papers in the journal of Nursing Philosophy that frames questions about nursing knowledge and practice is the paper “Thinking as a subversive activity: doing philosophy in the corporate university” (Rolfe 2013), which, in essence, is a shortened version of his book entitled “The University in Dissent: Scholarship in the Corporate University” (Rolfe 2013).

1.1. Doing Scholarly Activity in the (Corporate) University

Rolfe (2013) commences his paper by identifying a shift to the point of transformation of University institutions in the late 20th century. Rolfe argues that the primary role of universities in the Enlightenment period is principally focused on truth and reason, with the overarching aim of developing the moral character, identity, and culture of the individual and society at large. The focus was on the universality of knowledge and the pursuit of knowing for its own sake, as expressed in scholarly activity. For the Enlightenment University, scholarly activity is characterised by the creative work of thinking, communicating, and learning (Rolfe 2013). In another text, Rolfe (2019a) defines scholarly activity as the intellectual exploration emerging from the dialectical interplay of critically exchanging ideas (ideally between professor and student) as a process of discovering and producing knowledge, but above all, it is a state of being, a mode of existence and overall, and quite simply, it is a human conversational activity with others and the self to produce knowledge. In a nutshell, the summation of Rolfe's argument is that universities up to the end of the 20th century pursued knowledge through the critical exchange of ideas because it was both a noble activity and contributed to shaping the individual and collective consciousness (reality).

From the late 20th century onwards, this ideal of scholarly activity narrowed (Brown 1998) to the point that it became unrecognisable (Rolfe 2013). The focus or emphasis of any scholarly activity shifted from the critical pursuit of knowledge and defining a mode of existence to prioritising research‐driven activities that could be quantified and measured by the number of grant awards gained, research income raised, and publications produced in prestigious journals with high citation indexes. Rolfe (2013) pushes the argument further by making the point that what now passes as scholarly activity in universities has nothing (or little) to do with critical knowledge production or, for that matter, not much to do with the even narrower version of scholarly activity depicted in the research‐driven agenda, but instead, it has very much to do with “… what happens before and after the research takes place, with writing and submitting the grant proposal and with writing up and publishing the findings” (p. 30). Moreover, even this is now superseded by the size of the grant and by the overheads the awarding body is prepared to pay (Rolfe 2013).

Rolfe (2013) presents a rationally and critically developed argument, concluding that the university has evolved from a place where scholarly activity occurs to one where profit‐making, revenue earning, and money raising take precedence, creating the current university of excellence. In this context, excellence is a signifier of the corporate university. The corporate university is not so much (if at all) preoccupied with developing knowledge but with the end product of knowledge. As Rolfe (2013) notes, “… (the corporate university) is in the knowledge business: the business of manufacturing and selling knowledge, information, and qualifications on an increasingly industrial scale” (p. 31). Hence, students have become customers who purchase their working qualifications from the university, rather than evolving intellectuals who develop a scholarly mode of existence that inquisitively, critically and reflectively frames their mindset to deal with issues and problems within their specific academic discipline and, more broadly, within civil society.

While Rolfe (2013) work is not intended to be a historical overview of the development of universities, it can be argued that his view of the university up to the 1970s or 80s is possibly an idealised version rather than historically accurate. Universities' vocational and practical teaching nature has been around since medieval times. The medieval universities included fee‐paying students, with individual masters taking money for lectures given and universities charging for examinations taken to deliver concrete skills and competencies through education to meet the career aims of their students by opening the door to professional life, intended to supply the church and European States with skilled labour (Palfreyman and Temple 2017).

However, this is not the point Rolfe (2013) intends to convey in his paper “Thinking as a subversive activity: doing philosophy in the corporate university”. Rolfe argues that scholarly activity has not only evolved as universities progressed in the late 20th and early 21st centuries, but the term “scholarship” has also undergone a significant shift in meaning. Scholarly activity no longer signifies those individual qualities of meticulousness and rigorousness associated with academic reporting or living in a space capable of openly challenging the status quo through critical enquiry, logically evaluating information and rationally synthesising and applying knowledge (Brew 2010; Milner and Thorndyke 2023). Instead, the shared understanding or shared rules of the word “scholarship” or “scholarly activity” are disrupted, and the message transmitted by these words has changed and narrowed to imply the primacy of research and publication productivity over the processes of meticulous, rigorous, critical and logical argumentation.

This intentional disruption and change of what scholarly activity means can alter the power relations or the rules of the power game between speakers (Belsey 2002). For Rolfe, the commercialisation of the university or the neo‐liberal market forces, according to Brew (2010), requires measurable outcomes able to define efficiency and effectiveness explicitly, capable of drawing comparisons between universities and consequently creating a ranking system able to portray excellence that, in return, brings in more monies to enable further measurable research outcomes in a continuous loop (Rolfe 2019a). Quality aspects, such as meticulous, rigorous, critical, and logical processes in argument development, are difficult to measure and, therefore, as unquantifiable entities, are unable to generate revenue. This, in turn, negatively impacts the university's ranking and furthers financial benefits.

In conclusion, Rolfe (2012) point regarding scholarly activity is that, somewhat ironically, in the current climate of the widespread expansion of university education, the standards used to measure academic prestige are based on a narrowing of scholarliness. More and more professors and students are relying less and less on reason and reasonableness to justify their points, and instead, they are increasingly relying on methodology and the rationality of effectiveness and efficiency to achieve this. This results in the suppression of reason from rationality (Rolfe 2019a).

1.2. Thinking as a Subversive Activity

The above conclusion brings us neatly to Rolfe (2013) second point in his paper “Thinking as a subversive activity”, which focuses on thinking and the nature of thinking as an integral scholarly activity. Rolfe (2013) laments that university thinking is now dominated by efficiency and profitability, with quality being superseded by quantity, and academic accountability being supplanted by financial accountancy. Chambers and Gearhart (2019) put forward a similar argument in their sub‐heading “Subversive Singularity: Beyond Meaning and Knowledge”, where they equate knowledge with expertise and expertise with expeditiousness in doing things or solving problems. They make the case that speed matters in sports, as in education, with the assumption that the fastest swimmer is the best athlete and similarly that the student finishing first on the exam is usually a fair sign that the student knows the material very well (with the proviso that the student has not merely given up answering). Doing things quickly, they argue, usually indicates knowing them well; speedy actions or decisions are indications or proofs of expertise and knowledge. They term this the algebraisation or mathematisation of practice, whereby problems, decisions or actions are translated to numbers or symbols. Once someone is aware of the meaning the numbers or symbols convey, then the numbers or symbols do the thinking and reasoning, provided that you keep to the mathematical or algebraic rules. Like the bead and frame of the abacus that does the counting, we do not have to think or argue further as long as we agree on what the beads mean. This way, solving problems, making decisions and taking action are sped up. They are not impeded by thinking processes when making judgements. Hence, in this context, doing things quickly implies efficiency and requires doing them automatically and without thinking. Judgement calls slow things down, and thinking through options may appear as getting in the way of efficiency.

Indeed, Rolfe (2019b), citing Nietzsche on university education, suggests that modern universities are anti‐intellectual and, for that matter, antieducational for three fundamental reasons: a) do not wish to allow a person to go his (her) own way by developing own goals, b) wish to earn money and the more students they enrol the more money they earn, and c) developing a well‐round thinking individual, simply takes a lot of time that universities plainly cannot afford anymore. The core issue lurking in the substratum of this thinking is the binarism of process/product and reason/rationality. Thinking is a process that involves the receiver of a message listening to the message and reasoning based on a set of factors such as the content and arguments included in the message, the logic and sequencing of ideas that construct it and the messenger's authority of constructing and sending the message (Rolfe 2009). In a nutshell, the validity, in this case, requires a judgement call by any receiver of a message based on a process of de‐structuring the content, logic, and sequencing of ideas included in any message, as well as the authority and qualifications of the creator/sender. All this constitutes the reasoning steps of thinking, and this requires time, effort, and a degree of unpredictability, as the conclusion on the validity will depend on the receiver's thought process.

However, if the validity of a message is taken out of the hands of the receiver and somehow streamlined, then validity resides in the message rather than the receiver. In that case, the entire reasoning process of thinking becomes far less important and more of a trivial matter, and the validity and value of the message are much more predictable. This is what Rolfe (2009) considers the core achievement of technical rationality, whereby the methods section in any paper (what currently may be termed as scholarly output) provides guarantees of the validity and value of the content and message or, as Chambers and Gearhart (2019) have already suggested, the algebraisation or mathematisation of practice. In both analyses, any thinking from the reader on the validity and value of a paper becomes an impediment because it is a process that involves time to carry out, limiting the product output of how many papers are produced or how quickly value judgements can be passed out, but possibly more importantly, it involves subverting the whole idea of the internal validity of the paper. If the reader of a paper does not have to think about the validity and value of the paper because this is self‐evidently embedded in the paper (primarily in the methods section), then, irrelevant as to who writes or reads the paper, the paper is valid and valuable (or not). In simple terms, the greater the suppression of reason by technical rationality, the quicker the volume of produced papers, and the lesser the thinking, the greater the consensus of their content and results.

In this manner, Rolfe (2012) views thinking as a subversive act. To think implies breaking with the consensus that the internal validity (the method(s) section) is the sole arbitrator of the validity and value of a paper, study, or evidence that enables readers to reach a final agreement on the conclusions. By contrast, Rolfe (2013) suggests that thinking requires continuous questioning, opening up the debate rather than agreeing or reaching a consensus that closes the debate by concluding with single or correct answers. Moreover, the type of questioning and thinking Rolfe (2013) refers to is not concerned with saying things are not right as they are or defining what the case is, but rather pointing out and calling into question familiar, unconsidered and fundamental assumptions upon which judgements are made and establishing logical conjunctions using the AND. In short, thinking requires developing a sequence of conjunctive questions where one question links and leads to the next, thus establishing a logical sequence that debates the rules of knowledge development, their role, and the possibility of transgressing them. In this manner, thinking cannot but be subversive, as it constantly questions the rules or methods of justifying choices, judgments, and actions.

1.3. Scholarship, Thinking and Nursing Practice

(Re)Defining scholarship in terms of effectiveness and efficiency, where technical rationality supersedes reasoning and where consensual, single, and correct answers replace critical thinking, coincides with nursing's entry into higher education in the late 20th century and, in part, aligns with the historical narrative of nursing. According to the writings of Rolfe (2012, 2013), by the time the nursing profession wholesale moved to the university sector, scholarly activity had transformed into the knowledge economy where the number of students registered became crucial and of the utmost importance for the survival of nursing departments where students are treated as customers purchasing the product of nursing title and registration that would allow them to enter the working sector. University nursing departments compete with each other to maximise student intake, retention, and output based on student satisfaction. The more satisfied the nurse student (customer) is, the higher the retention and graduation rates will be, and the greater the attraction for future nurse students. However, like any other customer, nurse students want clear, correct, and straightforward answers to nursing issues, problems, and practices, not the messy thinking process inherent in analysing the complexity of each unique case. They are after a product rather than a process. In this customer‐driven university education, the subversiveness of thinking and the constant questioning do not sit well with the expectations of nurse‐student customers. Moreover, the deeply rooted view that nurses are doers rather than thinkers, the history of nurses being doctors' handmaidens, and the assertion that nursing is an applied or practical discipline all contribute to valuing education that emphasises doing rather than thinking.

Rolfe (2013) recognises an emerging professional and epistemological schism regarding what nurses should be taught to do or how to practice in preparation for their nursing role. He sums up this schism as a controversy amongst others “…whether nurse education is too theoretical or too practical; whether it has been ‘dumbed down’ or overintellectualised; whether nurses are over‐qualified to perform basic nursing care or not bright enough to take on extended (usually medical) roles; whether they should be educated in a university lecture theatre or trained in a hospital ward; whether nursing practice should involve conceptual problem‐solving or the technical application of research‐based procedures and directives; and whether the relationship of nurses to doctors should be that of handmaiden, assistant, partner, or replacement” (p. 32). As a result, Rolfe (2013) contends that the nursing profession is pulled in two conflicting directions. On the one hand, pulled by the demands of the corporate university to produce objective, technical, and single correct answers to nursing issues that satisfy nurse students' expectations and university demands, and on the other hand, by the subjective, context‐specific, and interactive communicative forms of nursing praxis that individuals requiring care expect. Rolfe (2013) further developed his writing by suggesting that this schismatic situation has placed nursing in an uncomfortable and possibly unattainable position. The solution is not to pretend it does not exist, to return to some sort of golden age of scholarship that perhaps never existed in the first place, or to change the current corporate university entirely to suit nursing.

On reviewing Rolfe's work on the topic, he sees the power of subversive thinking as the way forward, which can still take place within the confines of the corporate university by broadening the notion of scholarship. Subversive thinking does not imply that we can single‐handedly subvert the corporate university, but instead suggests that we need to dwell in it pragmatically and, at the same time, by thinking subversively, to do our best to dwell in it without recourse to any alibis for not posing sufficient questions to knowledge creation. It is possible within the current structures of the corporate university to create, develop and maintain the intellectual infrastructure of the nursing discipline without outrightly and overtly rejecting its trappings, values and goals but making sure each one as an individual opens up debates, poses questions, listens to critique and communicates our individual and unique experiences (Rolfe 2013; Rolfe 2009). This new scholarship includes a) being “good” in terms of being moral by intending to do good and excelling creatively in the field we debate, pose questions, critique and communicate; b) being “collegiate” by avoiding disputes and unmerited competition between colleagues and inviting critique to our work and being prepared to offer it at every opportunity as a means for sharing and communicating our thoughts and learnings with others; and c) being “radical” by making the scholarly activity not only practice relevant but fusing academia and practice to make nursing practice in its own right an academic activity (Rolfe 2012).

This last point, Rolfe (2017) expands upon in another chapter, where he invokes what he calls a reflexive alliance by bringing together writings from pragmatism, hermeneutics, and critical social science to argue that for thinking to be subversive, it ought to be reflective and reflexive in the new nursing scholarship. By this, he implies that unique practice situations are analysed by recognising their uniqueness and the biases of the nurse, negotiating meaning with all involved and developing through a dialectical interplay of ideas a shared understanding and common goals. In this way, Rolfe (2006) concludes that “…theory and practice are developed simultaneously in a process that involves the swift alternation between research and the application of that research as two sides of the same coin” (p. 40), making the role of the researcher indistinguishable from the role practitioner leading to the developing the new nursing as the science of the unique.

1.4. An Afterword

Reviewing Gary Rolfe's body of work on scholarship and thinking in nursing is both satisfyingly informative and refreshingly scholarly. It demonstrates the process of meticulously examining the intricacies of the topic of knowledge and scholarship by rigorously and critically bringing different schools of thought together to yield insights and develop logical and contingent arguments that are sequential, easy to follow, and provide a sense that naggingly unanswered questions are eventually tackled and untangled. Rolfe's work on the issue of scholarship and thinking, in one way or another, permeates his published work over three decades, and he remains active in making the arguments; as such, any suggestion of making the work current or reviving it is moot. However, looking back to Rolfe's work can inspire and is undoubtedly a worthy endeavour for developing the debate and providing direction for the future of nursing.

A few key takeaway points from the above review are that scholarship is a qualitative, open‐ended, ongoing, and process‐driven component of university life, not conducive to measurements or final products that unavoidably and inevitably become part of and affect all aspects of the individual's civic and personal life. A core element of scholarship is the potential to think; importantly, thinking is not the same as knowledge or knowing. Knowledge represents the product or content of cognition, whereas thinking is a process of finding causality (Müller 2022; Sinatra 2016). Therefore, scholarship is not so much (if at all) in the business of describing the contents or representation of cognition that are stable over time products (or change at a very slow pace over significant periods) but instead focuses on the dynamic, unfolding, and ever‐evolving process of finding relationships, causalities and connections on beliefs, experiences and information (Halpern 2003; Müller 2022).

Furthermore, and equally crucial for nursing, is that nursing now has a relatively long history of identifying limitations of applying theoretical knowledge to practice (defined in the literature as the theory‐practice gap) primarily because theoretical knowledge purports an all‐encompassing descriptions of practice that is not only unrealistic and unattainable, but stifles thinking and understanding of the context practice takes place and uniqueness each practice case (Allmark 1995; Zieber and Wojtowicz 2020). In other words, the descriptive and prescriptive elements of theoretical knowledge are (up to a point) at odds with critical thinking and scholarship about nursing practice and crucial everyday decisions, especially when faced with multiple available choices. Again, Rolfe to a large extent shares the view that theoretical knowledge embedded in technical rationality is a one‐way transmission of generalisable and decontextual knowledge that is unsuitable in dealing with particular and unique nursing situations, individuals or client groups, hospitals and experiences (Rolfe and Gardner 2005; Rolfe et al. 2025). For nursing to navigate the complexity of everyday practice, it needs to think and act mindfully and reflectively concerning the (individual) person being nursed. Rolfe and Gardner (2005) make the case for nursing science of the unique by distinguishing between nursing for a person and nursing for people, whereby a person is an individual with unique characteristics and needs, and people are a collective of persons with general features. When persons are grouped to form a collective, this results in generalisations that overlook individual differences essential in nursing care. While there is a greater discussion to be had on the notion for nursing science of the unique, for the scope of this paper, we will limit this to the necessary elements of critical scholarship, thinking, and reflexivity as processes of identifying relationships and connections between unique and individuals beliefs, experiences, and information.

The above assumptions have at least three ramifications. Firstly, thinking as a scholarly activity should not be conflated or defined as a commodified instrument or technology of rationality that merely and efficiently aggregates or transmits information. Secondly, thinking has subversive qualities, starting by simply enquiring about problems, admitting confusion on issues and seeking to elucidate (self)posed questions, and critically (and possibly argumentatively) reasoning of how information and knowledge can fit (or not) with the web of specific experiences and contexts applied without assuming the universality of this information and knowledge. Thirdly, thinking is a personal process, as different individuals must develop their own capacity for thinking and apply it to questions, construct arguments, and develop reasoning for or against using information and knowledge from their experiences and contexts.

The above final ramification has two further implications and a side point. Firstly, thinking and, by extension, scholarship have and need to have practical implications and utility (usefulness), as it is, amongst others, a process of questioning and relating information, experiences, and knowledge to specific and personal contexts, beliefs, workings, and previous ways of being or doing. Secondly, since thinking is a personal and subjective process, individuals should strive to proceed with degrees of consistency, non‐contradictory and sincere comprehensiveness in their scholarship, without the intention of deception or coercion. The side‐point for the above two implications on thinking and scholarship is for the individual to have the linguistic capacity to develop thought and action into language schemes and a genuine disposition to be useful without resorting to techniques that deceptively present the weaker argument as the stronger.

A final comment for this paper is that this notion of scholarship is not irrelevant or superfluous for nursing. This is in part (and questionably) because such qualities of sincereness, good intentions, non‐deceptiveness and doing good are part of the professional character of nursing with the cautionary approach to this as developed by Lipscomb (2024) and in part (and more persuasively) because the nursing profession has inertly a necessary practical or action element aiming to deal with individual and unique cases. Derrida (2002), in a slightly different context, while deconstructing the humanities in the university of the future, similarly echoes the view that (scholarly) thinking is not merely an act of archivation or knowledge production, but a performative act (as opposed to a constative act) of asking critical questions of the form of thought, events and authority that lead to a pledge or promise from the professional to be sincere in this act. This type of thinking is evident in nursing through reflective and reflexive thinking, where contemplation and action are viewed as two sides of the same coin, mutually influencing and reinforcing each other. Rolfe argues in his latest book for a new scholarship of reflective practice in nursing, where reflective practice sits alongside technical rationality and, rigorously and credibly, performs a critical interrogation of the self and the reflexive integration of different types of knowledge in practice (Rolfe et al. 2025). Other literature also frames reflective practice as the indispensable tool for the scholar‐practitioner and the generation of new knowledge that is useful to practitioners (Wasserman and Kram 2009; Greenberger 2020), with the American Association of Colleges of Nursing (2018) redefining its position statement of academic nursing scholarship to include the scholarship of practice. Arguably, scholarship with subversive thinking elements, as discussed in this paper, is not incompatible with nursing and may be the direction for the future of nursing scholarship and practice. This amalgamation of scholarship, subversive thinking, reflection, and reflexive practice, and nursing as a performative activity in developing the nursing science of the future, based on Rolfe's work, needs to be further developed and elaborated within the current academic context.

Conflicts of Interest

The author declares no conflicts of interest.

Mantzoukas, S. 2025. “On Thinking, Nursing Scholarship and the Science of the Unique.” Nursing Philosophy 26: 1–6. 10.1111/nup.70044.

Data Availability Statement

This article is not a research or synthesis‐based article that used data that can be shared; therefore, I confirm the absence of shared data.

References

  1. Allmark, P. 1995. “A Classical View of the Theory–Practice Gap in Nursing.” Journal of Advanced Nursing 22, no. 1: 18–23. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  2. American Association of Colleges of Nursing , 2018. Defining Scholarship for Academic Nursing Task Force Consensus Position Statement. Washington, DC. [Google Scholar]
  3. Belsey, C. 2002. Post‐Structuralism: A Very Short Introduction. Oxford: Oxford University Press. [Google Scholar]
  4. Brew, A. 2010. “Transforming Academic Practice Through Scholarship.” International Journal for Academic Development 15, no. 2: 105–116. [Google Scholar]
  5. Brown, S. C. 1998. “Redefining Scholarly Work.” Educational Forum 62, no. 1: 40–46. [Google Scholar]
  6. Chambers, J. and Gearhart, S. , ed. 2019. Reversing the Cult of Speed in Higher Education: The Slow Movement in the Arts and Humanities, 1st ed.). London: Routledge. [Google Scholar]
  7. Derrida, J. 2002. “The Future of the Profession or the University Without Condition (Thanks to the ‘Humanities,’ What Could Take Place Tomorrow).” In Jacques Derrida and the Humanities: A Critical Reader, edited by Cohen T., 24–57. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. [Google Scholar]
  8. Edwards, S. , and Liaschenko J.. 2000. “Editorial.” Nursing Philosophy 1, no. 1: 1–4. [Google Scholar]
  9. Greenberger, S. W. 2020. “Creating a Guide for Reflective Practice: Applying Dewey's Reflective Thinking to Document Faculty Scholarly Engagement.” Reflective Practice 21: 458–472. 10.1080/14623943.2020.1773422. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
  10. Halpern, D. F. 2003. Thought & Knowledge: An Introduction to Critical Thinking (4th ed.). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Inc. [Google Scholar]
  11. Lipscomb, M. 2024. “Nursing's Professional Character: A Chimera?” Nursing Philosophy 25, no. 2: e12477. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  12. Milner, R. , and Thorndyke L.. 2023. “Defining Scholarship for Today and Tomorrow.” Journal of Continuing Education in the Health Professions 43, no. 2: 133–138. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  13. Müller, M. 2022. Richard Rorty: A Short Introduction. Wiesbaden: Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden. [Google Scholar]
  14. Palfreyman, D. , and Temple P.. 2017. Universities and Colleges: A Very Short Introduction. Oxford: Oxford University Press. [Google Scholar]
  15. Rolfe, G. 2006. “Nursing Praxis and the Science of the Unique.” Nursing Science Quarterly 19, no. 1: 39–43. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  16. Rolfe, G. 2009. “Writing‐Up and Writing‐As: Rediscovering Nursing Scholarship.” Nurse Education Today 29, no. 8: 816–820. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  17. Rolfe, G. 2012. “Fast Food for Thought: How to Survive and Thrive in the Corporate University.” Nurse Education Today 32, no. 7: 732–736. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  18. Rolfe, G. 2013. “Thinking as a Subversive Activity: Doing Philosophy in the Corporate University.” Nursing Philosophy 14, no. 1: 28–37. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  19. Rolfe, G. 2019a. “Carry on Thinking: Nurse Education in the Corporate University.” Nursing Philosophy 20, no. 4: e12270. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  20. Rolfe, G. 2019b. New Ways of Thinking About Nursing: Collected Conference Papers. 2010–2019. Cambridge: Cambridge Scholars Publishing. [Google Scholar]
  21. Rolfe, G. , Freshwater D., and Jasper M.. 2025. Critical Reflection in Practice: A Guide for Health and Social Care Professionals (3rd ed.). London: Bloomsbury Academic. [Google Scholar]
  22. Rolfe, G. , and Gardner L.. 2005. “Towards a Nursing Science of the Unique: Evidence, Reflexivity and the Study of Persons.” Journal of Research in Nursing 10, no. 3: 297–310. [Google Scholar]
  23. Rolfe, G. 2017. “The Reflective Practitioner as Critical Theorist.” In Critical Approaches in Nursing Theory and Nursing Research: Implications for Nursing Practice, edited by Foth T., Hülsken‐Giesler M., Holmes D., Kreutzer S., and Remmers H., 169–186. Göttingen: V&R unipress. [Google Scholar]
  24. Sinatra, G. M. 2016. “Thoughts on Knowledge About Thinking About Knowledge.” In Handbook of Epistemic Cognition, edited by Greene J. A., Sandoval W. A., and Bråten I., 479–487. New York: Routledge. [Google Scholar]
  25. Wasserman, I. C. , and Kram K. E.. 2009. “Enacting the Scholar–Practitioner Role: An Exploration of Narratives.” Journal of Applied Behavioral Science 45, no. 1: 12–38. [Google Scholar]
  26. Zieber, M. , and Wojtowicz B.. 2020. “To Dwell Within: Bridging the Theory–Practice Gap.” Nursing Forum 21, no. 2: e12296. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]

Associated Data

This section collects any data citations, data availability statements, or supplementary materials included in this article.

Data Availability Statement

This article is not a research or synthesis‐based article that used data that can be shared; therefore, I confirm the absence of shared data.


Articles from Nursing Philosophy are provided here courtesy of Wiley

RESOURCES