Skip to main content
. 2010 Sep 8;2010(9):CD005233. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD005233.pub3
Study Reason for exclusion
Abbott 2009 ALLOCATION: Randomised
PARTICIPANTS: High drop‐out (50%)
Andersson 2002 ALLOCATION: Randomised
PARTICIPANTS: High drop‐out (51% in the CBT group)
Davies 1995 ALLOCATION: Randomised
PARTICIPANTS: High drop‐out (43.33%)
Delb 2002 ALLOCATION: Not randomised
Goebel 2000 ALLOCATION: Randomised
PARTICIPANTS: Patients with tinnitus
INTERVENTION: Not CBT
Henry 1998 ALLOCATION: Randomised
PARTICIPANTS: Patients with tinnitus
INTERVENTION: CBT
OUTCOME: No usable data. No primary outcome
Hiller 2004 ALLOCATION: Inadequate randomisation, as patients with severe tinnitus (Tinnitus Questionnaire score > 40) were allocated to CBT and those with lower scores to the Tinnitus Education group. The randomisation was then done for receiving (or not) noise generators.
Jakes 1986 ALLOCATION: Not randomised
Jakes 1992 ALLOCATION: Randomised
PARTICIPANTS: High drop‐out (44.8%)
Kaldo 2008 ALLOCATION: Randomised
PARTICIPANTS: Patients with tinnitus
INTERVENTION: Internet CBT versus CBT. Not an appropriate comparison for this review.
Kröner‐Herwig 1999 ALLOCATION: Randomised
PARTICIPANTS: High drop‐out (39.53%)
Kröner‐Herwig 2006 ALLOCATION: Randomised
PARTICIPANTS: Patients with tinnitus
INTERVENTION: Cognitive behavioural tinnitus coping training (TCT) versus Habituation‐based Training (HT)
OUTCOME: This study looks at possible predictor factors in the participants from another already published 3‐arm trial (Zachriat 2004) which was already included in this review. Not an appropriate comparison for this review.
Lindberg 1987 ALLOCATION: Not randomised
Lindberg 1988 ALLOCATION: Not randomised
Lindberg 1989 ALLOCATION: Randomised
PARTICIPANTS: Patients with tinnitus
INTERVENTIONS: Not CBT
Robinson 2008 ALLOCATION: Randomised
PARTICIPANTS: High drop‐out (37%)
Sadlier 2008 ALLOCATION: Not randomised
Scott 1985 ALLOCATION: Randomised
PARTICIPANTS: Patients with tinnitus
INTERVENTIONS: Not CBT
Wise 1998 ALLOCATION: Randomised
PARTICIPANTS: Patients with tinnitus
INTERVENTIONS: Not CBT