Skip to main content
. 2025 Nov 4;15(50):42771–42842. doi: 10.1039/d5ra06960b

Table 6. Sensing parameters of PAT as determined by various analytical techniques.

S. No. Method Analyte Electrode modifier Linear range LOD Sample/recovery Ref.
1 EC impedimetric aptasensor PAT 1–25 ng mL−1 1.25 ng mL−1 Apple juice/92.5–96% 327
2 DPV PAT rGO/SnO2/GCE 50–600 nM 0.6635 nM Apple juice/74.33–99.26% 316
3 EC PAT MIP/Au@Cu-MOF/N-GQDs/GCE 0.001–70 ng mL−1 0.0007 ng mL−1 Apple juice/97.6–99.4% 318
4 EC PAT MIP/thionine-PtNP-NGE/GCE 0.002–2 ng mL−1 0.001 ng mL−1 Apple juice/99.8–113.0% 328
Grape juice/95.4–104.8%
5 EC PAT PAT/aptamer-AuNP-BP NSs/GCE 0.1–10 μM 0.03 nM Apple juice/96.2–104% 329
6 DPV PAT PAT/MCH/Apt/DpAu/ZnONRs-CS/AuE 50 ng mL−1–0.5 pg mL 0.27 pg mL−1 Apple juice/95.6–104.8% 330
7 CE PAT 1–100 μg kg−1 0.3 μg kg−1 Apple juice/94–98% 331
8 HPLC-DAD PAT 5 ng mL−1–10 μg mL−1 1.5 μg kg−1 Strawberries/53.1–103.6% 332
9 UPLC-MS/MS PAT 42–757 μg kg−1 50 μg L−1 Apple/76–84% 333
42–1298 μg kg−1 12.5 μg kg−1 Apple juice/102–108%
10 EC PAT MIP/Fe3O4/GO/GCE 0.001 nM-250.0 nM 3.33 × 10−4 nM Apple juice 317
SWV
11 EC PAT Anti-patulin-BSA/IgG/GCE 5–200 μg L−1 5 μg L−1 325
12 EIS PAT Fe3O4NPs/rGO/PAT/TDNs-Apt/AuE 5 × 10−8–5 × 10−1 μg L−1 30.4 fg mL−1 Apple juice/96.9–105% 334
DPV
13 EC PAT 1–25 μM 3.56 ng mL−1 Apple juice/94.4% 335
14 CV PAT MIP/PtPd-NPC/GCE 0.01–10 μg L−1 7.5 × 10−3 μg L−1 Juice (apple & grape)/94–99.8% 336
EIS
15 SPES PAT Aptamer/G-Bi2S3/ITO 5.0–500 nM 0.28 nM Apple juice/97.7–104.8% 337
16 DPV PAT BSA/Apt/HPC-COOH/GCE 0.5–5.0 × 106 ng L−1 0.25 ng L−1 Apple juice and haw juice/86.2–105.4% 321
17 CV PAT cDNA/aptamer/AuNPs-BPNS/GCE 0.0154–15.4 ng mL−1 0.043 ng mL−1 Apple, pear, and tomato/95.0–106.7% 338
SWV
18 EIS PAT Patulin/pAb-patulin/GO/GCE 0.01–10 ng mL−1 9.8 pg mL−1 Apple juice/86% 339
19 EC PAT CdTe QDs/Au NRs 50 fg mL−1–500 ng mL−1 30 fg mL−1 Apple 340
PEC
20 DPV PAT MCH/PAT-aptamer & AuNPs-BSA/GCE 0.01 × 10−7–0.10 μg mL−1 Apple juice/98.20–102.70% 341
21 DPV PAT EDC/NHS In buffer & apple juice medium (1–104 pg mL−1) In buffer (0.18 pg mL−1) & In apple juice (0.47 pg mL−1) Apple juice/91.24–93.47% 342
22 Amperometry PAT Ni–NiO-streptavidin-BSA-aptamer-GCE 10–106 fg mL−1 1.65 fg mL−1 Apple juice/more than 85% 343
23 EC (EIS, CV & DPV) PAT AgPdNPs/c-DNA/reaction solution/MCH/DNAmix/AuNFs/g-C3N4/AuE 5 × 10−6–50 μg L−1 0.92 fg mL−1 Apple juice/95.5–110% 344
24 Dual-EATR PAT AuNPs/FeMOF-PEI-GO/AuE 5 × 10−7–5 ng mL−1 0.217 fg mL−1 Apple juice/91.0–103% 345
25 SPR PAT 0.5–750 nM 0.011 nM Apple juice/98.24–98.32% 346
26 SERS PAT MIP-ir-Au/PDMS/AAO 5 × 10−10–5 × 10−6 M 8.5 × 10−11 M Apple juice/96.43–112.83% 347
27 EC PAT NH2-MIL-101@MB 1.00 × 10−4–1.00 × 101 pg mL−1 0.040 fg mL−1 Crataegus pinnatifida Bge/90.6–106.3% 326
Semen Coicis/90.2–103.1%
28 FRET PAT 0.01–100 ng mL−1 0.003 ng mL−1 Apple juice/93.33–105.21% 348
29 FRET PAT 15–35 μg L−1 6 ng L−1 Apple juice/94.7–109% 349
30 MIP-SERS PAT 7.00 × 10−12–5.00 × 10−8 M 5.37 × 10−12 M Fruit products/96–108% 350
31 Fluorescence-apta assay PAT 5–600 ng mL−1 0.13 μg L−1 Apple juice/96–98% 351
32 SWV PAT Pep&Apta/AuNPs/SPE 0.1 fM–10 nM 0.03 fM Apple and orange juices/99.3–101.2% 352
DPV
33 ECL PAT Apt/PTCA/Tb MOG/GCE 0.1 fg mL−1–0.1 μg mL−1 0.02 fg mL−1 Apple and orange juices/96.28–104.0% 353
34 SERS PAT 1–70 ng mL−1 0.46 ng mL−1 Apple puree/88.77–102.20% 319
Apple juice/90.50–97.36%
35 EC PAT SiNP-CHIT/SPCE 3.2–20 μg mL−1 1.15 μg mL−1 354
36 Fluorescence PAT NCDs-SH 0.1–400 ng mL−1 0.053 ng mL−1 Apple juice/88.9–99.2% 355
Grape juice/92.5–101.8%
37 Fluorescence assay PAT CM6Lip-SH/NH2–Au@Fe3O4 0.05–20 ng mL−1 0.033 ng mL−1 Apple and grape juices/96.2–107.6% 356
38 FRET-based ratiometric fluorescence PAT 01–50 ng mL−1 0.16 ng mL−1 Grapes/95.9–105.4% 357
39 ECL PAT Anth-CQDs@SiO2/Ru@Tri/GE 0.1 pg mL−1–10 ng mL−1 0.05 pg mL−1 Fruits/96–106% 358
40 ECL PAT MIP-IL/CS-UiO66@CN/ITO 0.1–103 pg mL−1 50 fg mL−1 Apple/95.3–102.7% 359