Abstract
Facilitation is an important, but complex strategy for implementing evidence into practice. It involves one or more individuals from within or outside an organisation taking on the role of a facilitator who enables change, provides support and problem-solves. It is often embedded or combined with multiple strategies making it challenging to study. Our objective in this qualitative follow-up study was to unpack the facilitation component of a complex implementation strategy for implementing mental health recovery guidelines for transforming services and systems called Walk the Talk toolkit. All the materials in the online toolkit are designed for facilitators to: (1) Establish an implementation team, (2) Conduct a 12-meeting planning process for implementing a recovery-oriented innovation and (3) Provide ongoing implementation coaching. We recruited 8 facilitators (researchers) and 32 Implementation Team members who had participated in the research project in which the toolkit was created and used for the first time. They participated in a semi-structured interview exploring their perspectives on facilitation. Interviews were analysed thematically. Findings emerged around three overarching themes: (1) Shifts in facilitation approaches, roles and intensity over the course of three toolkit stages, (2) Facilitator skills and attributes, such as relationship-building, simplifying implementation science concepts, and asserting equity, and (3) Facilitation challenges, which included reaching systematically excluded groups, recruiting and retaining service users and family members, confronting issues around facilitator background, and negotiating interpersonal tensions. We unpack the “black box” of facilitation and discuss the significance of deploying recovery as a shared language and vision.
Supplementary Information
The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s43477-025-00170-w.
Keywords: Facilitation, Implementation teams, Implementation strategy, Mental health recovery, Qualitative research, Toolkit
In implementation science, facilitation is an important strategy for supporting the translation of evidence into practice. It involves one or more individuals from within or outside an organisation taking on the role of a facilitator who enables change, supports individuals and problem-solves (Harvey & Kitson, 2015; Smith et al. 2024). It is an integral element of implementation science theories, models, and frameworks, for instance, the Integrated-Promoting Action on Research Implementation in Health Services framework (i-PARIHS) (Harvey & Kitson, 2015), the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research (CFIR) (Damschroder et al., 2022) and the Expert Recommendations for Implementing Change (ERIC) compilation of implementation strategies (Powell et al., 2015). It is both a process and a role, which together enable more successful implementation outcomes (Dogherty et al., 2010; Harvey & Kitson, 2015).
Despite its ubiquity across the research literature, there exists a lack of clarity around facilitation. For one, there is inconsistent use of terminology (Albers et al., 2020; Bidassie et al., 2015; Cranley et al., 2017; Smith et al., 2024). Poor theoretical grounding also contributes to a piecemeal understanding of what facilitators do (Baloh et al., 2018; Berta et al., 2015; Bidassie et al., 2015; Damschroder, 2020). As an implementation strategy, facilitation is used to mitigate a multitude of implementation barriers and is a “process that draws on a broad range of additional strategies” (Waltz et al., 2019, p. 11). These can include implementation teams, the participation of stakeholders, the identification of barriers and facilitators, and the conduct of local consensus discussions (Piat et al., 2022). However, Albers et al. (2020, p. 1) state that “while frequently used, little is known about the skills and competencies required to effectively provide such support”. Contemporary thinking revolves around recognising the inherent complexity of facilitation, a dynamic process during which stages overlap and facilitator activities vary in timing and intensity contingent on contextual conditions (Ritchie et al., 2023; Smith et al., 2024).
There are also gaps in our understanding about the facilitator role. For example, expanding on what has been portrayed as a typically task-based role (Berta et al., 2015) to explore the emotional, mental, and physical demands that can impact facilitators and influence implementation outcomes (Olmos-Ochoa et al., 2021). Harvey et al. (2023) went further in this direction and investigated the evolution from novice to expert facilitator, focusing on the way in which capacity, confidence, and knowledge developed. They found that progression was marked by the way facilitators perceive and practice facilitation, with novices shifting their focus from managing subjective requirements to ensuring the success of implementation efforts. An area that remains inconsistently understood is also the specific training and support needs of facilitators, something Tistad et al. (2023) argue could enhance the effectiveness of facilitation as an implementation strategy. A paucity of agreed, standardised, or evidence-based training for implementation facilitators worldwide exacerbates this situation (Eldh et al., 2023). Because facilitation, that is the work of facilitators, is often embedded within complex and multi-faceted implementation strategies, it can be easily overlooked when evaluating implementation efforts. Recent work by Smith et al. (2024) to determine core facilitation activities for clinical intervention implementation makes an important contribution in this regard. Our study is novel in that it is conducted outside clinical settings and focuses on implementing guidelines for transforming services towards a recovery-orientation.
The aim of this follow-up study is to explore the facilitation component of our Walk the Talk toolkit, an implementation strategy for implementing the Mental Health Commission of Canada’s Guidelines for Recovery-Oriented Practice (Mental Health Commission of Canada, 2015). The online Walk the Talk toolkit focuses on Chapter 6 of the guidelines which includes 4 sub-guidelines for transforming services and systems towards a recovery-orientation. For individuals, mental health recovery means “a way of living a satisfying, hopeful, and contributing life even with limitations caused by illness” (Anthony, 1993, p. 527). For services, adopting a mental health recovery-orientation is a radical shift from professional control, patient-dependency, self-stigma and hopelessness in services, towards service user empowerment, choice, collaborative, professional/service user relationships, and community integration (Farkas, 2007; Le Boutillier et al., 2011). In line with the general principles of recovery such as involving service users in decision making, promoting their full citizenship, and social inclusion, the Guidelines for Recovery-Oriented Practice (Mental Health Commission of Canada, 2015), including Chapter 6 and its four sub-guidelines, are broad and non-prescriptive allowing for adaptation and tailoring to fit the needs of any given implementation setting and population. However, on the ground, the uptake of these guidelines remains slow primarily because they do not provide a concrete process or explanation on how to implement them.
We created Walk the Talk toolkit to fill the gap. Implementation toolkits are complex strategies that combine multiple implementation strategies (Lee et al., 2024; Thoele et al., 2020). Broadly, the Walk the Talk toolkit combines implementation teams and a facilitated planning process. It is divided into three chronological stages: (1) establishing an implementation team, (2) conducting a 12-meeting planning process, and (3) ongoing implementation coaching. Firstly, facilitators use the toolkit to establish an implementation team made-up of service providers, service users, managers, knowledge users and family or significant others. Secondly, they conduct 12 meetings over the course of which Implementation Teams choose one sub-guideline to focus on and complete an action plan for one recovery-oriented innovation to implement. By innovation we mean a new recovery-oriented intervention, approach or service in the organization (Piat et al., 2021). Thirdly, facilitators provide implementation coaching in an ongoing way to implementation teams as they enter advanced planning following the 12-meeting planning process and finally implement their chosen innovations. Mapped to implementation phases, the toolkit’s first and second stage corresponds to the pre-implementation phase, and the third stage corresponds to the implementation phase (Goodrich et al., 2020). By “coaching” we don’t mean “practice facilitation” as it has sometimes been equated to (Cole et al., 2024). Rather we use the word coaching to define a more flexible and responsive form of facilitation compared to the highly structured facilitation in stage 2 of the Walk the Talk toolkit.
The process and materials contained in the toolkit were developed within a five-year pan-Canadian ‘living experiment’ to implement mental health recovery guidelines (Piat et al., 2022). While the toolkit can be used by internal or external facilitators, facilitators in this study were all external to the organisation as they were members of the research team. For simplicity we use the umbrella terms “facilitator” and “facilitation” in this manuscript but recognize that the absence of internal facilitators’ perspectives is a limitation of this study. We explore facilitation as both a role and a process from the perspectives of the facilitators and Implementation Team members who participated in the previous 5-year study. To the best of our knowledge, there are no known studies of facilitation as an implementation strategy for implementing mental health recovery guidelines in any country or setting.
The objective of this qualitative follow-up study is to unpack the ‘black box’ of facilitation (Ritchie et al., 2015), in this case the facilitation component of a three-stage toolkit for implementing mental health recovery guidelines. Our aim is to contribute a deeper understanding of the nuanced interaction between planned and unplanned facilitator roles, and how roles1 shift as Implementation Teams move through planning and implementing a new recovery-oriented innovation. We explore the unchartered domains of facilitation as a practice that occurs in the temporal space between and beyond implementation activities, to uncover novel insights into how and when facilitation as one component of an implementation strategy can be improved.
Methods
This is a qualitative research study. While the study was not overtly guided by theory, our theoretical perspective as a research team combines qualitative epistemologies, mental health recovery, and implementation science. We used the Consolidated Criteria for Reporting Qualitative Research (COREQ) (Tong et al., 2007) as a reporting guide for this methods section and the manuscript as a whole.
Recruitment
Participants were Implementation Team members from seven sites (Table 1) and facilitators (members of the research team) who participated in at least one of the three stages of the Walk the Talk toolkit implementation strategy (described above), used during the Partnership for Health Service Improvement research project from 2017 to 2021 (Piat et al., 2022). Potential participants were contacted by email and telephone starting in June 2022. All 8 facilitators were eligible and agreed to participate. Facilitators had facilitated in pairs of one lead researcher and one research assistant per site, with three working at more than one site (Table 2). Implementation Team members who had only very minimal exposure to the implementation strategy and who indicated that they did not want to be contacted for future research were not invited to participate. Thirty two of the 82 eligible Implementation Team members agreed to participate and were interviewed (Table 1). This represented 3 service users, 6 service providers, 13 managers, 3 family members or significant others, and 7 knowledge users. Only 10 of the 50 Implementation Team members not recruited declined the invitation to participate. The remainder were either unreachable or expressed an interest in participating but then were unreachable when it came to scheduling the interview. Recruitment challenges for Implementation Team members included the long time since the original study was completed, and no longer having up-to-date contact details for service providers who changed jobs or service users who had moved or changed telephone numbers.
Table 1.
Recruitment of eligible implementation team members per site
| Research sites (participating organisations) | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BC | MB1 | MB2 | NB1 | NB2 | ON | QC | |
| Total number of participants eligible | 3/15 | 2/8 | 5/11 | 3/11 | 7/9 | 8/14 | 4/14 |
| Rate of participation | 20% | 25% | 45% | 27% | 78% | 57% | 29% |
| Type of organisation | Non-profit housing | Non-profit housing | Non-profit housing | Publicly-funded mental health services | Non-profit housing | Non-profit housing | Publicly-funded housing and mental health services |
Note. Organisations have been anonymised and are referred to by the Canadian province in which they are located. BC: British Columbia, NB2: New Brunswick 2, MB1: Manitoba 1, MB2: Manitoba 2, NB1: New Brunswick 1, NB2: New Brunswick 2, ON: Ontario, QC: Québec
Table 2.
Facilitators- research team roles and assigned sites
| Participant | Research team role | Assigned research site |
|---|---|---|
| Facilitator 1 | Research assistant | QC |
| Facilitator 2 | Lead researcher | NB2 |
| Facilitator 3 | Research assistant | BC |
| Facilitator 4 | Lead researcher | BC |
| Facilitator 5 | Research assistant | MB1, MB2 |
| Facilitator 6 | Research assistant | NB1, NB2 |
| Facilitator 7 | Lead researcher | NB1 |
| Facilitator 8 | Lead researcher | QC, ON, MB1, MB2 |
Note. BC: British Columbia, NB2: New Brunswick 2, MB1: Manitoba 1, MB2: Manitoba 2, NB1: New Brunswick 1, NB2: New Brunswick 2, ON: Ontario, QC: Québec
Data Collection
Forty semi-structured interviews (8 with facilitators and 32 with implementation team members) lasting between 40 and 120 min were conducted by experienced qualitative researchers (LMR, MW, LMR). Some questions were adapted from the interview guide for external facilitators published by Bidassie et al. (2015) (see Supplemental File 1). The majority of interviews were conducted between June and November 2022 via Zoom (Zoom Video Communications Inc., 2016) in either French (n = 8, by MW and MPR) or English (n = 32 by LMR). LMR and MW were not facilitators. MPR was a facilitator, so to limit social desirability she interviewed francophone Implementation Team members from a different site who she did not know. The first author (MP) was a facilitator of more than one site and so was deliberately interviewed last by LMR after the rest of the interviews had been analysed and an initial set of findings were developed by LMR (May 2023). This ensured MP’s experiences and perspective did not over influence the findings. Interview guides can be found in supplemental file 1. We also prepared a visual timeline and summary of the Walk the Talk toolkit stages specific to each site and presented these to participants during the interview to help them recall their memories. This helped counteract the effect of the roughly two-year gap between experience with each of the Walk the Talk toolkit stages and this follow-up study.
Data Analysis
Step 1 – Data Reduction (Concurrent with Coding)
We created an interview summary template with eight categories - one for each of the main topics covered in the interview guide. English-language summaries of the data pertaining to each category were written by listening to the interviews and reading transcripts by LMR (English interviews) and JR (French interviews). Transcripts were created using a transcription software and corrected by MP and KS. Due to data analysis occurring concurrently to data collection, the final two interviews were not reduced to summaries but rather transcribed and immediately coded to a well-developed coding tree (step 2).
Step 2 – Coding
The summaries were coded in NVivo12 (QSR International Pty Ltd, 2018) to each of the eight categories and underwent inductive sub-coding for emergent themes. We were guided by the Braun and Clarke (2006) approach to thematic analysis. LM and JR undertook coding and checked-in with MP and KS as the coding framework developed. MW and KS provided support with the data analysis software. Summaries were also coded to cases, including site, participant, and stakeholder group to enable exploration of the data in different ways.
Step 3 – Theming
In this step LMR focused analysis on elucidating any nascent patterns, similarities, and differences across the eight categories, paying attention to the presence and prevalence of subcodes. These were discussed and expanded upon by other members of the team. Themes in this study represent recurrent ideas or topics that unify codes, elevating analysis from indexing (coding) to interpreting the data. Immersion within the data enabled reflection across the dataset, allowing themes to develop and meanings to be considered. The findings were displayed according to these themes, highlighting new understandings and meanings. Throughout each stage, memos were used to document the work process, methods, and emerging insights. Findings were validated by some facilitators who are co-authors on this manuscript, but validation was not carried out with Implementation Team member participants.
Findings
Findings emerged around three overarching themes: (1) Shifts in facilitation approaches, roles and intensity, (2) Facilitator skills and attributes, and (3) Facilitation challenges.
Shifts in Facilitation
This set of findings unpacks the shifts in the nature of facilitation over the three stages of the (removed for anonymity) toolkit: (1) establishing an Implementation Team, (2) conducting a 12-meeting planning process with the Implementation Team, and (3) ongoing implementation coaching of the Implementation Team. For context we briefly describe each stage and then report findings.
Stage 1: Establishing an Implementation Team
To establish an Implementation Team, the facilitators first needed to lay the groundwork in the organisation, including making decisions about which service/department in the organisation would be the focus for implementation, and coming to an agreement on recruitment strategies and eligibility criteria for selecting Implementation Team members. Facilitators did this by establishing and working with an Ad-Hoc Planning Committee made up of upper management and chief executive officers (CEOs) in the organisation and meeting with them regularly over three to five months up until an Implementation Team was recruited. The reasoning for recruiting those in leadership positions to the Ad-Hoc Planning Committee was that they needed to be on board from the beginning to: support staff to join the Implementation Team (e.g. liberating their time); ensure at least one manager join the Implementation Team to guarantee leadership engagement in the process; and support the allocation of financial and other resources needed to implement a recovery-oriented innovation.
When we asked facilitators and Implementation Team members to reflect on facilitation in this phase, they characterised facilitation as being about developing relationships, generating “buy-in” as well as introducing and explaining the implementation process that would be followed, even though at the time the process was still emergent. One of the key roles of the facilitator was to relationship-build - first with the members of the Ad-Hoc Planning Committee and then with potential Implementation Team members as recruitment unfolded. A facilitator shared: “Relationship building, that’s key, you know, as a facilitator, you’re building an important relationship with those people” (Facilitator 8). Building relationships was essential to establishing buy-in among stakeholders, a manager explained: “Then [facilitators] they were really good at building relationships…the respect that brought to the group. You could see she was as invested as we were” (Manager 1, New Brunswick 2).
Part of that relationship building was about explaining the project and its dual recovery and implementation science focus. While mental health recovery was a shared perspective, goal and language, implementation science was new, for both the Ad-Hoc Planning Committee and the facilitators. A challenge for facilitators was in clarifying an implementation process that was itself still emerging. In the words of one manager:
Her [the facilitator’s] role is on one hand, is explaining in the implementation side, recovery, people in general like [are] supportive of recovery so that [is] not a problem, understanding the implementation side takes a bit of learning, and then she is then motivating people to be involved in [it], I think that was her role (Manager 4, Ontario).
As implementation science represented an unfamiliar subject, facilitators generated traction via the promotion of recovery as a shared language and overarching concern. One of the facilitators explained: “There was always, recovery was always at the forefront and implementation was always sort of in the not on the back burner, but the buy-in was we got that buy-in through recovery, not necessarily through implementation” (Facilitator 6).
When recruitment strategies and eligibility criteria were finalised with the Ad-Hoc Planning Committee, the facilitator conducted outreach activities to recruit Implementation Team members. Still in this phase it was the shared interest in recovery which secured buy-in. A service provider recruited to an Implementation Team put it in the following terms: “I was sort of excited to be, have been one … selected, and because it really this whole thing [recovery] was very close to my heart. So, I personally had buy into it” (Service provider 1, Manitoba 2).
Stage 2: Conducting a 12-Meeting Planning Process with the Implementation Team
Once the Implementation Team was recruited, the facilitator turned their attention to Stage 2 - facilitating a 12-meeting planning process with the Implementation Team. One to two managers from the Ad-Hoc Planning Committee in Stage 1 were recruited to the Implementation Team to ensure continuity, and the Ad-Hoc Planning Committee was dissolved. There was a marked shift in tempo as facilitators met with the Implementation Team every two weeks for approximately 6–8 months. Over the course of 12 Implementation Team meetings the facilitators guided Implementation Teams to work towards 6 milestones: (1) Choosing a sub-guideline to focus on (Chapter 6 of the Guidelines for Recovery-Oriented Practice includes 4 sub-guidelines), (2) Selecting a recovery innovation to implement that reflects the chosen sub-guideline (e.g. peer support workers, staff training in mental health recovery), (3) Identifying barriers and facilitators to implementing their innovation, (4) Defining implementation strategies to overcome barriers, (5) Engaging stakeholders in the plan to implement the innovation and (6) Writing an implementation plan. The milestones were documented in an Action Plan co-produced by the facilitator and the Implementation Team which provided a roadmap for stage 3 of the Walk the Talk toolkit.
When asked to reflect on facilitation in this stage of the toolkit, participants described how facilitators injected energy into the lengthy planning process in order to keep Implementation Teams engaged, encouraged teams by bringing to their attention to all the progress that was being made, and kept things on track in the face of staff and service user turnover. What they could have done better was have more open conversations about working with people with lived experience and help prepare the Implementation Teams for the homework they needed to do between meetings. The 12-meeting planning process felt too long to some participants who were motivated most by implementing the recovery innovation, rather than by a lengthy planning period. Therefore, an energetic facilitator was considered essential. A service provider explained:
I think just that it was a long process and that some meetings felt productive, some meetings felt, not counterproductive, but a bit, a bit static…some pivotal people like [the facilitator] who just kept the energy up. I think without that sort of energy, it would have stalled (Service provider 4, British Columbia).
Implementation Team members appreciated how facilitators engaged ways of showing them the progress they had made and where they were in the process. This was encouraging and motivating. A service provider described:
She’d [the facilitator] give us feedback and say, OK, you’ve accomplished this and this. We’ve already, we’re already here, we’re doing well and all of that. So, I think it’s the fact is that she kind of gave us this encouragement, but also the measuring stick, we kind of knew where we were (Service provider 1, Manitoba 2).
A lot can and did happen over the course of 6 months both within the Implementation Teams and the organisations. Facilitators were credited with keeping things on track and filling-in gaps in support when challenges such as staff turnover or attrition within the Implementation Team arose (more on this in lessons learned). A manager elaborated:
They [facilitators] sort of kept us on track, they you know, provided really thorough notes, provided a lot of, ended up having to provide quite a bit more support than maybe they normally would have needed to because we had quite a bit of turnover… (Manager 4, British Columbia).
Another characteristic of what facilitators did in this stage was support a decision-making process but not take decisions for the team. A service provider explained:
They [facilitators] have an idea, but not in a directive sense, rather in a companionable sense where they gave us events, like the framework in which we had to work, and then let us make our decisions as we went along… They guided them at times, I think for a little bit… Helping us to come and weigh the pros and cons of each decision (Service provider 3, Québec).
Built-in to the second stage was homework for the Implementation Team to do in between meetings. It was up to the team how to organise this but in most cases, they chose to meet in between meetings as an Implementation Team to complete homework. This was an investment of time which not all were prepared for and so Implementation Team members recommended that facilitators make this explicit from the start. One participant suggested how to put a positive spin on the between meeting homework component:
Well, my advice would be that the [facilitator] would say…we’ve we found from our experience working with…another project…this [meeting in-between meetings to complete homework] is your opportunity as a team then to go through and discuss this stuff, prepare as a team, know how it will build your team…it’s important that you’re building that foundation for the Implementation Team if, especially if you want to continue after the time with [the facilitator] is done, after the coaching [stage 3 of the Walk the Talk toolkit] is done (Service provider 1, Manitoba 2).
Finally, although recovery continued to be mobilised as a shared language, the pace of the 12-meeting planning process and its emphasis on implementation provoked a philosophical dichotomy for some facilitators. As the meetings progressed, an incongruence between the pace and pressures of keeping on time and on target with the planned process and the philosophy of recovery was perceived by some facilitators, for example:
…it just, I don’t know, I think sometimes recovery took the back seat like, oh, we have to do this milestone and we have to get to this stage. But recovery is about taking time, so and not rushing. So, we really struggled with that (Facilitator 7).
Stage 3: Ongoing Implementation Coaching
A marked change in pace and leadership occurred during the third stage which was the implementation coaching phase, where facilitators worked to mobilise Implementation Teams to advance the implementation of their selected recovery-orientated innovations. The transition from a 12-meeting planning process to ongoing implementation coaching was intended to provide an opportunity for facilitators to withdraw intentionally from a highly structured facilitation role toward one that embraced shared ownership and a gradual transfer of responsibility for moving forward with implementation to the Implementation Teams.
Reflections from participants about facilitation in this stage demonstrated that indeed a more hands-off facilitation approach (which we define as “coaching”) permitted growth and forged a renewed sense of purpose, ownership, and accountability among Implementation Teams. However, despite efforts to hand over ownership over driving the implementation process, some found that the shift was partial, for example, one facilitator reported, “in terms of the handover, I wouldn’t say it that was 100% successful” (Facilitator 4). The transition from the 12-meeting planning stage to the ongoing coaching stage represented a pinch point where the facilitation process was vulnerable. At this point, feelings of disenfranchisement were expressed in some Implementation Teams as a change in facilitation occurred. Recommendations from facilitators and Implementation Team members emphasised the need for clarity of roles and responsibilities, for instance, revisiting the Walk the Talk Action Plan produced during the 12-meeting planning process prior to commencing the stage of “ongoing implementation coaching”. Implementation Teams who were readied for this change found it occurred in a timely manner, liberating Implementation Teams to reconfigure their leadership position. An Implementation Team member stated:
…really after a certain point there’s only so much that [the facilitators] could do for us…. They did their job in the second stage as far I was concerned because it was up to us to implement everything and put it into place after the second stage (Service provider 2, New Brunswick 2).
Facilitators maintained a supportive role, providing advice, troubleshooting, and continuing to cheerlead if motivation flagged. Multiple challenges emerged during the “ongoing implementation coaching” stage. Expectations were tested and frustrations vented, particularly when implementation efforts encountered an excess of perceived barriers. One of these barriers which compounded many others was the COVID-19 pandemic and public health measures which restricted face-to-face meetings. Some sites experienced postponement of their implementation process during the early stage of the pandemic (Piat et al., 2021). The ongoing implementation coaching sessions were an opportunity to keep facilitators updated and keep team members engaged despite the immense challenges that the pandemic posed. Despite the challenges, Implementation Teams were able to adapt to the shift in facilitation intensity. An Implementation Team member explained:
[I] think we just played it by ear… I don’t think there was any particular mourning period or sense of particular detachment. I think that we took it in stride. I mean, the nature of the whole process was a little bit chaotic and bumpy and unpredictable… by the very nature of what we were trying to do and some of the social things that came up in the pandemic and everything else kind of had to be fluid (Service provider 4, British Columbia).
Facilitator Skills and Attributes
In this set of findings, Implementation Team members discussed what they valued in terms of facilitator qualities, knowledge, and skills. Facilitators shared a mixed set of skills to create a safe environment, foster learning, and nurture cohesion. Valued facilitators contributed energy and impetus, ensuring implementation team meetings were experienced as social, convivial events, rather than as a research project. An Implementation Team member explained: “Enthusiasm, energy, [she] is a very dynamic individual…there was a social aspect that I think that she engendered and that felt… genuine” (Service provider 4, British Columbia).
While some were experienced facilitators, others were novices: early-career researchers, postgraduate students, and those who had recently qualified as social workers. All espoused mental health recovery values and principles. Their professional background shaped their approach to facilitation, in which relationship building and stakeholder parity were central. A facilitator explained: “For me, it’s always important building relationships in any project or intervention. That it be very collaborative. To be also exploratory” (Facilitator 2).
This sense of discovery and learning together was a guiding thread, as facilitators worked together with Implementation Teams to implement the recovery guidelines for the first time. Although exciting, it also provoked anxiety as facilitators navigated novel implementation science concepts and an unfamiliar process, sometimes impeding their intention to facilitate in a planned manner. One of the facilitators explained: “So, you know, when I think about this project and the way I went about facilitating, I don’t think it was a conscious, methodical process that I used” (Facilitator 8). For many, one of the challenges was communicating implementation science to the Implementation Team for whom the academic jargon could be overwhelming. Another facilitator shared: “I guess the implementation science, sometimes that bothered me, the language a bit… the concepts are great, but the language just was a bit painful” (Facilitator 4).
A key skill that facilitators demonstrated was being able to translate academic terms and concepts included in the activities and materials into more understandable terms. A manager shared:
So, one of the things that I like what she did, she really did try to find other words to describe what the research was saying and try to find ways of unpacking it. Again, and that took away time in the process. But in order to bring somebody along, you had to do that element of the work. Because if you didn’t then you create alienation within the group. And that’s not your job as the facilitator, right? So that’s the struggle that I saw it in the work (Manager 1, Ontario).
Service users valued the skill with which facilitators intentionally sought to disrupt power hierarchies. This act of asserting equity amongst the Implementation Team and their place amongst it had a powerful effect, stimulating feelings of excitement and a sense of empowerment. A service user described: “She [facilitator] valued everybody’s opinion. And always my opinion was just as important as was the CEO…she made sure we all knew that” (Service user 1, Manitoba 2). A knowledge user added: “I found them [facilitators] very good at facilitating what the needs were, specifically from those with the lived experience” (Knowledge User, British Columbia).
Service providers and managers endorsed the way facilitators sought to generate parity between members of the Implementation Team. Power disparities and dynamics between service users and providers, and between providers and senior staff, were initially tangible in some sites. This impacted on the Implementation Team in several ways; for example, some service providers were wary of voicing their thoughts in the presence of their superiors, whilst historical or current relationships between service users and service providers could add an additional layer of complexity to team dynamics. Rather than permitting these to disrupt the implementation process, skilled facilitators took stock of interpersonal interplay and focused their energies on dismantling existent hierarchies with sensitivity and equanimity. A manager elaborated:
…really levelling out the different, let’s say, natural power differentials between, you know, even management and service users and family… they [facilitators] were very, very good at making sure that everyone did have a voice in the input was there (Manager 2, Manitoba 2).
Facilitation Challenges
These findings encompass the challenges that facilitators faced during the three stages of the Walk the Talk toolkit. These included: reaching systematically excluded groups during recruitment of Implementation Teams, recruiting and retaining service users and family members on the Implementation Team, confronting issues around facilitator background, accent and class, and negotiating interpersonal tensions among Implementation Team members.
Reaching Systematically Excluded Groups
There was a shared awareness among study participants that when it came to diversity, the importance of recruiting people who came from different positionalities vis-a-vis the organisation (e.g. service users, service providers, family members or significant others, knowledge users and managers) was explicit in the Walk the Talk toolkit. But facilitators were largely mute on the topic of cultural diversity, and activities aimed at reflecting cultural diversity, positionality and background were not built into the Walk the Talk toolkit. There was a shared sense that more should and could be done to bring cultural diversity more explicitly into recruitment of the Implementation Team and early team-building.
In some cases, people of a specific heritage were “missing” from the Implementation Team. For example, Indigenous persons, people of Asian ancestry and people of colour. In New Brunswick a knowledge user reflected on the distinct cultural history of Acadians but did not know if anyone on the Implementation Team was from that community and that to their recollection the conversation never came up. Despite the use of multiple recruitment strategies such as holding pizza lunches and posting flyers in coffee shops, medical centres, and libraries, to attract Implementation Team members from excluded groups, most notably individuals from Indigenous communities, uptake was low.
I’m also very conscious that Manitoba and Winnipeg, with both of these sites will have a high Indigenous population…But looking back, I would hope that that would have been a really critical piece to ensure that there’s Indigenous voice and representation included on those committees. I think we sort of did that, I recall, but I don’t, I don’t remember it being a significant focus just in hindsight. In terms of staff, I remember being conscious that there was diversity in positions and roles, and we were successful in that (Facilitator 5).
Another facilitator reflected on intersectionality and marginalisation:
We could have done a better job…at making like cultural diversity more explicit…I think there’s like a, there’s challenges with being a minority regardless of if you’re a mental health client or living in the community. There’s like an extra layer of marginalisation (Facilitator 3).
Recruiting and Retaining Service Users and Family Members
Facilitators and Implementation Team members reflected on issues of recruiting and retaining service users and family members on the Implementation Team. The family member group was the most difficult to recruit. Despite the recognition that family members or significant others possessed vital knowledge of how and where recovery innovations could be implemented, facilitators struggled to recruit Implementation Team members from this group. A facilitator shared: “I remember it was difficult to recruit family… and I remember being really disappointed” (Facilitator 5).
Service users were less difficult to recruit than family members or significant others but experienced the most significant attrition rates of all stakeholder groups, which is also reflected in this paper as their voice is under-represented. During stages 2 and 3 of the Walk the Talk toolkit which were extended by the pandemic and impacted by the move to remote work, there was a noticeable attrition of service users, in conjunction with changes in staff. Participants explained that the attrition of service users was due to barriers to accessing digital devices, and issues around digital literacy which were revealed when the in-person meetings had to be replaced with remote videoconference meetings. This posed a challenge to facilitators who found that they could not rely on the social aspect of being on an Implementation Team to motivate participation virtually. The loss of service users on the team was noticed by all but they were unsure whether there were efforts on the part of the facilitator to recruit additional members. In some cases where service users dropped-off the Implementation Team, some service providers felt that they (staff) could have alerted the facilitators to this likelihood because they knew the service user for a long time and facilitators were out of touch with what service users were dealing with. A manager explained:
… as staff I was like ‘well they’re [the service user recruited by the facilitator] not going to, like I know this person I’ve known them for 10 years, and not going to be able to do this’… So, there you know there should be some sort of screening out and if it’s if it’s evident and clear that they’re not capable cognitively and functionally to be able to follow through then we should be thoughtful around that and not send people out for something that’s going to just be way above their capacity (Manager 4, British Columbia).
While some service providers felt that they “knew” what their service users could and could not do, a knowledge user from another site also noted that “those who work with individuals undergoing recovery can find it challenging to see individuals’ potential for recovery.” They went on to reflect:
How do we promote the sense of potential? [The] Challenge is how do we inspire staff to see the potential of individuals when there is often a revolving door, when we don’t see a lot of progress, when people stop? Our vision for potential goes down (Knowledge user 1, New Brunswick 2).
Others felt that the facilitator did not sufficiently discuss the challenges service users could face in participating and that facilitators could be better prepared for working with people with lived experience in their specific settings. A manager explained:
I think discussing more of the anticipated challenges of who we would be working with, like in terms of involving people with lived experience or involving people from housing or whatever that looked like, I think more, more up front discussions about some of the possible challenges, I think, would have been helpful. For everyone (Manager 1, Manitoba 1).
Another manager from the same site agreed and thought it would be important for the facilitator to plan whether to push on or reschedule a meeting if a service user was under the influence of drugs or alcohol on the day of the meeting or was having a bad day in terms of their mental health.
Another suggestion for supporting the participation of service users better was to add an additional preparatory stage just before the start of Stage 2 -the 12-meeting planning process. Participants felt that both facilitators and service users on the Implementation Team would benefit from being better prepared to participate in the highly structured and fast-paced 12-meeting planning process. Doing so could help allay anxieties, address specific needs, and establish expectations, including ground rules, participation, schedule and resources. Reflecting on their own experience facilitating groups with service users in their organisation, a manager explained it this way:
…you almost need to prepare a person how to be in a group…you’re actually almost socialising people to the process of being in a group because it’s not a given… we think it is. So I think there is a huge privilege and bias and misunderstanding about what it actually means for somebody from a vulnerable population just sit in a group with staff people with executives…with researchers from a university, who have no, maybe only grade 10, education or not, have lived on the street…put them in a situation like that and not prepare them ahead of time what it’s actually going to be like (Manager 4, British Columbia).
Confronting Issues around Facilitator’s Background
Another element of cultural diversity that was not built into the facilitation process was addressing differences in the facilitators in accent and their associated class connotations. One participant noted that in their site both facilitators had non-Canadian accents and were associated to Britain as an ex-colonial power and being of a higher class. They would have liked facilitators to have acknowledged this and situate themselves historically and geographically. There were also class connotations with French accents, particularly contrasting Québecois French, Acadian French and the Chiac dialect in New Brunswick. In all three sites where French was spoken either by the majority or the minority, facilitators were bilingual and encouraged participants to speak in their language of choice. In NB1 the team was co-facilitated by a facilitator from the community and a facilitator who was originally from Québec. The latter drew on her experience of negotiating her Québecois accent in New Brunswick when co-facilitating:
Because there’s like that idea that Québecois people look down on other Francophone minority francophones in Canada…So I try to like actively to dismantle that as much as I can. So, but at the beginning, I was very conscious of that, and then it’s I kind of say it almost apologetically like, yeah, I’m from Québec. I’m Québecois… (Facilitator 7).
Some participants noted the significant class differences between members of the Implementation Team and between the facilitator and the Implementation Team. One participant felt that preparatory work could help facilitators better work with staff providing services and people with lived and living experience:
I mean, there’s a socioeconomic difference that’s substantial. So, I think. Yeah, I think some advanced learning around that… would be helpful to a research team. Yeah, I think you can academically understand socioeconomic differences. I think you can academically understand trauma…. I think it would be beneficial to really understand it and maybe do some upfront research engagement to realise how people will respond (Manager 2, Manitoba 1).
Another manager from the same site thought that as academics, the facilitators may be used to processes that are quite structured and linear in terms of steps, whereas community-based organisations working with people in supported housing are “immersed in this world that is very grey all the time” (Manager 1, Manitoba 1).
Negotiating Interpersonal Tensions
A more challenging role of the facilitator was negotiating tensions between service users, family members, and service providers on the Implementation Team in some sites. These tensions highlighted entrenched power dynamics and provoked discomfort at times when frustrations were vented and discussions became heated. However, from conflict arose new opportunities for recalibration as hierarchies shifted and often silenced voices were heard. A facilitator explained:
…there’s a lot of unresolved sort of, angst, sometimes… And then…people began to see the opportunity to move forward and to work on a shared project and be able to leave some of that other stuff by the door… I think it’s important not to project that it’s not only people with lived experience who are going to have trouble, I think… the staff could also find difficulty navigating those different relationships (Facilitator 4).
Facilitators sometimes encountered tensions when working with mixed groups of stakeholders and had to create space outside of meetings for members to communicate their feelings. One facilitator had the following recommendation:
…make it clear that if things aren’t going well and you need to vent or if you need to address a situation like talk to us outside of the two hours that you have together and we’ll make space for it, we’ll help you like, get the resources that you need (Facilitator 7).
Also, when working with organisations that can discontinue service provision for service users participating on the Implementation Team, for example housing organisations that may evict a tenant, facilitators needed to be prepared to negotiate continued membership on the Implementation Team despite an association between the service user and the organisation being severed.
Discussion
In this paper our focus was on the facilitation of the Walk the Talk toolkit, a 3-stage implementation strategy (Piat et al., 2022) for implementing Chapter 6 of the Guidelines for Recovery-Oriented Practice (Mental Health Commission of Canada, 2015). The impacts of implementing the guidelines and a recovery innovation are reported elsewhere (Piat, Wainwright et al., 2022) as is the impact of the pandemic on mid-implementation outcomes (Piat et al., 2021) opinions of Implementation Teams on the toolkit (Piat et al., 2022) and specific implementation science activities within the toolkit (Piat, Wainwright et al., 2021). In this follow-up study, findings reveal what can be learned from facilitators and Implementation Team members that could support future facilitators using the Walk the Talk toolkit. Our findings lay-out what characterised facilitation in each stage of the implementation strategy, the roles and attributes of valued facilitators, and challenges facilitators encountered. While specific to the Walk the Talk toolkit, the findings are relevant to any facilitation effort that involves implementation teams and toolkits.
Our findings highlight how effective facilitators are relational leaders whose ability to develop connections builds solidarity within the Implementation Team. Facilitators must be vigilant to contextual shifts as facilitation progresses and demonstrate that they can be agile and pivot in response to changes and needs. Our findings also add a recovery-specific and implementation science angle to the work of Clarke et al. (2019), who propose that a combination of relational inclusivity alongside emotional inclusivity sustains cohesion. Facilitators must also be ready to navigate complex relationships and disrupt power asymmetries. Our final set of findings, for example, contributes new insights to the topic of facilitation challenges, reflecting the reality of having diverse perspectives on the Implementation Teams. We have not found any other study on facilitation of teams as diverse as the Implementation Teams in this study. The literature is dominated by examples of facilitation with clinical teams or staff members (Bidassie et al., 2015; Harvey et al., 2018; Olmos-Ochoa et al., 2021; Penney et al., 2021; Pimentel et al., 2019; Ritchie et al., 2017) whereas Implementation Teams for Walk the Talk were made-up of service users and family members/significant others, managers and staff members as well as knowledge users from outside the organisation. Furthermore, research in community organisations that combines the views of facilitators and the recipients of facilitation is also a novel aspect of this research, hence challenges yet undiscussed in the facilitation literature around recruiting historically excluded groups, recruiting and retaining service users and family members, and confronting issues around accent and class. Dealing with interpersonal challenges is something that has been raised in the literature, but again the examples available are usually about conflicts or confrontations within clinical team members (Olmos-Ochoa et al., 2021) or between the facilitator and clinical team members (Bidassie et al., 2015). It is reasonable to assume that the kinds of conflicts and tensions that might arise when working in groups of people who do not commonly work together in a team, who come from within and outside the organisation, and who are on the providing and receiving end of services will be different. Combined with the fact that in the toolkit process it is the Implementation Team that chooses which recovery-oriented innovation to implement, facilitators are at the forefront of a radical shift towards co-production (Graham et al., 2022). Facilitators need to be prepared to embrace disruption as a necessary challenge of facilitation if a co-productive approach is to be adopted. Facilitators must also possess self-awareness to practice cultural competence, acknowledging historical, cultural, and structural injustices.
Such a novel approach requires buy-in to succeed. Facilitators need to invest time and demonstrate a genuine commitment to building relationships to secure buy-in. Securing buy-in is a core facilitation activity (Smith et al., 2024), but in the case of Walk the Talk toolkit, unlike clinical interventions, mobilising a shared vision of recovery is important for securing buy-in. The importance of relationship-building in facilitation is supported by other research (Ritchie et al., 2020). In our case we would argue that the relationship-building needed to facilitate a recovery guideline implementation strategy, parallels the importance of relationship-building in mental health recovery innovations (Piat et al., 2021).
In line with other research which shows how facilitation changes over time in implementation projects (Smith et al., 2024), our study shows how the facilitator role evolved during the three stages of Walk the Talk to match changes in need and context. Like the facilitators in Bidassie et al.’s, 2015 study, over time their role became one of cheerleading, and empowering teams (in their case clinical teams, in our case Implementation Teams) to take the lead. However, common to all three stages was the finding that facilitators are the key champions of a shared vision for mental health recovery. The deft deployment of recovery as a shared concern enables facilitators to promote collective action, whilst simultaneously enacting and embedding equity values within the facilitation process as it progresses. Facilitators also actively deployed recovery as a shared language that allowed different Implementation Team members to work together to select and implement a recovery-oriented innovation. In this study, it became clear that the concept of mental health recovery represented a powerful shared concern, a topic of mutual meaning valued by all participants. This shared language enabled the negotiation of a common understanding and mutual goal setting among members of the Implementation Team. To the best of our knowledge, this is one of the first studies to reveal how the principles of mental health recovery represent a powerful unifying interest around which Implementation Teams can coalesce, working together to co-produce and implement a recovery-oriented innovation.
Importantly, facilitators using a shared language around recovery conferred credibility, signalled appreciation of context, and conveyed empathy. It enabled facilitators to actively dismantle power hierarchies and demonstrate their commitment to recovery as a philosophy and approach, generating traction with Implementation Teams. Skilled facilitators gravitated to using the language of recovery, rather than implementation science, to foster alliances and reconcile differences between members of the Implementation Team. This builds on the work of Rycroft-Malone et al. (2015), Melville-Richards et al. (2020) and Hassan et al. (2023), who agree that identifying and sustaining a shared vision embodying stakeholder values is crucial to coproduction and successful implementation. However, for some facilitators the pace of the toolkit and its structure felt at times incongruent with the recovery philosophy. Despite this tension, the recovery vision provided the glue with which to anchor and instil implementation science, providing a powerful shared concern around which all stakeholders could work together to implement an innovation. Viewed from this stance, the concept of recovery could be considered a reconciliatory device or boundary object for implementation efforts (Allen, 2014; Carlile, 2002; Hassan et al., 2023; Melville-Richards et al., 2020; Star & Griesemer, 1989).
From a recovery perspective, recruiting and retaining people with lived and living experience to the Implementation Teams is a core principle of the toolkit. However, this was also challenging. Some staff and managers quoted in our findings felt that facilitators could have been better prepared for working with people with lived and living experience and have drawn on them to recruit service users who in their opinion would have been more likely to stay on the team. We agree that additional preparation is never a bad thing, but we also stand by the importance of not unquestioningly defaulting to a staff member’s opinion on whether a service user is capable of participating. Recovery is about hope, about believing in everyone’s potential, it is about promoting “the dignity of risk, and the right to failure” (Le Boutillier et al., 2011, p. 1473). While there is always a risk that a person may withdraw from the Implementation Team due to mental health issues, this is not exclusive to service users, and in fact other issues such as staff turnover are serious considerations to be prepared for when planning for withdrawals from the Implementation Team. However, facilitators also need to be prepared to provide additional support to service users. From this research we learned that participants saw a need for an additional preparatory stage before the 12-meeting planning process (stage 2) to enhance equitable participation of Implementation Team members with lived and living experience. The goal would be to not only prepare service users and family members for engaging in a process that would involve working in potentially new and disruptive ways but also preparing facilitators who may need additional context and understandings of service users’ and service providers’ day-to-day realities. While facilitators from within the organisation might need less of this contextual information, they are likely to need more context for implementation science before starting and so the idea of a preparatory stage for facilitators is still relevant. The preparation of service users and family members and loved-ones in particular is reinforced by Crompton (2019), and Metz and Bartley (2020) who confirm that clarifying needs, skilling up, and establishing a shared vision, are instrumental to sustaining engagement.
Finally, it is also important to understand what motivates people, including service users, to keep coming back to Implementation Team meetings. If the social aspect is a key draw, then careful thought needs to be put into planning for substituting in-person to online meeting formats. The COVID-19 pandemic required a rapid switch to online modes of facilitation (Zbukvic et al., 2022), motivating the addition of a “Tips & Resources for Virtual Facilitation” section to the Walk the Talk toolkit. However, the role of the facilitator is not just to be adept at using online tools, but also adept at preventing and responding to the impact of such changes in mode on service user and family member/significant other participation.
Limitations
The recruitment of Implementation Team members for this study was hampered by several factors, primarily the way the pandemic disrupted the lives of so many service users, family members/significant others, and service providers. Due to the time delay between the completion of the original research project and the start of this follow-up study contact was lost, or it proved difficult to establish new lines of communication with those who had previously contributed. Pragmatically, the time lag between the end of the original study and this follow-up study meant that at times it was challenging for participants to recall their memories. In terms of representation, our follow-up study reflects the challenges of the original research project in that there was a low representation of Indigenous and other under-represented communities in Canada. The requirement that Implementation Team members speak, read and write in French or English may have excluded some people from marginalised groups, including Indigenous people, from voicing an interest in participating in the original study. We also experienced varied rates of participation per site in this follow-up study, ranging from 20 to 78%. The range of quotes we selected to present in the findings section reflects this imbalance, although we do not believe it affects the relevance of the findings to all sites. Finally, although the Walk the Talk toolkit can be facilitated by external or internal facilitators, this study involved external facilitation by research team members. An analysis of participants’ reflections on external vs. internal facilitation is published elsewhere (Piat et al., forthcoming).
Implications for Future Research and Implementation
Researchers employing implementation strategies that include facilitation would do well to build-in questions on facilitation into their data-collection tools to bring facilitation out of the shadows and into the open. While dedicating a full research study to facilitation may not be feasible, the field could benefit from more real-time reflections on facilitation. Furthermore, additional research on the experience of internal facilitation with the toolkit would make for an important comparison and would help establish whether our findings on facilitation here are reflections of external facilitation dynamics or facilitation in general. Furthermore, the inclusion of people with lived and living experience and significant others should be considered at every opportunity in implementation efforts involving facilitated teamwork both in terms of participating on teams and participating as facilitators.
Conclusions
This study unpacks the nature and role of the facilitation during the 3-stages of the Walk the Talk toolkit for implementing recovery guidelines. Guidelines are notoriously difficult to implement, and the toolkit bridges a gap between guidelines in mental health and implementing them in community-based organisations outside of mental health services. The strategy is led by a facilitator, hence the importance of unpacking their role in recruiting an Implementation Team, choosing and planning the implementation of one recovery innovation, and providing ongoing implementation coaching to see implementation through to fruition. Exploring how facilitation changes over time is a unique contribution of this work as is the importance of fostering recovery as a shared language and vision. Pragmatically, these findings will be used to create “Tips for Facilitators” on the Walk the Talk toolkit website to ultimately improve the uptake of recovery into health and social services for adults with mental health challenges. However, the findings are relevant beyond this toolkit, within and outside mental health recovery. When implementing any guideline or intervention, fostering a shared vision is likely to be important, as is being ready to adapt the role of the facilitator through implementation stages. Furthermore, the challenges uncovered are applicable to other implementation efforts in multi-cultural settings that involve bringing together diverse partners, including service users.
Electronic Supplementary Material
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank the 7 participating organisations and the members of the 7 Implementation Teams for their commitment and time in participating in this research.
Author Contributions
MP, ES, MW & IG conceptualised the study and methods and prepared the interview guides. LMR, MW and MPR conducted interviews. KS coordinated data collection and data management. MW and KS provided support for the qualitative data analysis software. LMR and JR wrote summaries and coded data with input from MP and MPR. LMR analysed the coded data and wrote the first draft of the manuscript. MW & MP, with input from ES, reworked the manuscript to its current form. ES formatted the manuscript for publication. All authors, MP, LMR, MW, MPR, ES, KS, JR, HA, IG read and commented on and approved the final manuscript.
Funding
This project was funded by the Canadian Institutes of Health Research Project # FRN 175126.
Data Availability
The datasets used and/or analysed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
Declarations
Competing Interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
Footnotes
We use the term role and not activities (Smith et al., 2024) to not cause confusion with the “activities” that are included in stage 2 of the Walk the Talk toolkit.
References
- Albers, B., Metz, A., & Burke, K. (2020). Implementation support practitioners–a proposal for consolidating a diverse evidence base. BMC Health Services Research, 20(1), 368. 10.1186/s12913-020-05145-1 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Allen, D. (2014). Lost in translation?‘Evidence’and the articulation of institutional logics in integrated care pathways: From positive to negative boundary object? Sociology of Health & Illness, 36(6), 807–822. 10.1111/1467-9566.12111 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Anthony, W. (1993). Recovery from mental illness: The guiding vision of the mental health services system in the 1990s. Psychososial Rehabilitation Journal, 5(1), 61–65. [Google Scholar]
- Baloh, J., Zhu, X., & Ward, M. M. (2018). Types of internal facilitation activities in hospitals implementing evidence-based interventions. Health Care Management Review, 43(3), 229–237. 10.1097/HMR.0000000000000145 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Berta, W., Cranley, L., Dearing, J. W., Dogherty, E. J., Squires, J. E., & Estabrooks, C. A. (2015). Why (we think) facilitation works: Insights from organizational learning theory. Implementation Science, 10, 1–13. 10.1186/s13012-015-0323-0 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Bidassie, B., Williams, L. S., Woodward-Hagg, H., Matthias, M. S., & Damush, T. M. (2015). Key components of external facilitation in an acute stroke quality improvement collaborative in the veterans health administration. Implementation Science, 10, 1–9. 10.1186/s13012-015-0252-y [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3(2), 77–101. 10.1191/1478088706QP063OA [Google Scholar]
- Carlile, P. R. (2002). A pragmatic view of knowledge and boundaries: Boundary objects in new product development. Organization Science, 13(4), 442–455. 10.1287/orsc.13.4.442.2953 [Google Scholar]
- Clarke, J., Waring, J., & Timmons, S. (2019). The challenge of inclusive coproduction: The importance of situated rituals and emotional inclusivity in The coproduction of health research projects. Social Policy & Administration, 53(2), 233–248. 10.1111/spol.12459 [Google Scholar]
- Cole, A. M., Keppel, G. A., Baldwin, L. M., Holden, E., & Parchman, M. (2024). Implementation strategies used by facilitators to improve control of cardiovascular risk factors in primary care. The Journal of the American Board of Family Medicine, 37(3), 444–454. 10.3122/jabfm.2023.230312R1 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Cranley, L. A., Cummings, G. G., Profetto-McGrath, J., Toth, F., & Estabrooks, C. A. (2017). Facilitation roles and characteristics associated with research use by healthcare professionals: A scoping review. BMJ Open, 7(8), e014384. 10.1136/bmjopen-2016-014384 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Crompton, A. (2019). Inside co-production: Stakeholder meaning and situated practice. Social Policy & Administration, 53(2), 219–232. 10.1111/spol.12466 [Google Scholar]
- Damschroder, L. J. (2020). Clarity out of chaos: Use of theory in implementation research. Psychiatry Research, 283, 112461. 10.1016/j.psychres.2019.06.036 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Damschroder, L. J., Reardon, C. M., Widerquist, M. A. O., & Lowery, J. (2022). The updated consolidated framework for implementation research based on user feedback. Implementation Science, 17(1), 75. 10.1186/s13012-022-01245-0 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Dogherty, E. J., Harrison, M. B., & Graham, I. D. (2010). Facilitation as a role and process in achieving evidence-based practice in nursing: A focused review of concept and meaning. Worldviews on Evidence‐Based Nursing, 7(2), 76–89. 10.1111/j.1741-6787.2010.00186.x [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Eldh, A. C., Hälleberg-Nyman, M., Joelsson-Alm, E., & Wallin, L. (2023). Facilitating facilitators to facilitate—Some general comments on a strategy for knowledge implementation in health services. Frontiers in Health Services, 3, 1112936. 10.3389/frhs.2023.1112936 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Farkas, M. (2007). The vision of recovery today: What it is and What it means for services. World Psychiatry, 6(2), 68. [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Goodrich, D. E., Miake-Lye, I., Braganza, M. Z., & Wawrin, N. (2020). & A.M., K. Quality enhancement research initiative. QUERI roadmap for implementation and quality improvement. https://www.queri.research.va.gov/tools/roadmap/ [PubMed]
- Graham, I. D., Rycroft-Malone, J., Kothari, A., & McCutcheon, C. (2022). Research coproduction in healthcare. Wiley.
- Harvey, G., Collyer, S., McRae, P., Barrimore, S. E., Demmitt, C., Lee-Steere, K., Nolan, B., & Mudge, A. M. (2023). Navigating the facilitation journey: A qualitative, longitudinal evaluation of ‘eat walk engage’novice and experienced facilitators. BMC Health Services Research, 23(1), 1132. 10.1186/s12913-023-10116-3 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Harvey, G., & Kitson, A. (2015). PARIHS revisited: From heuristic to integrated framework for the successful implementation of knowledge into practice. Implementation Science, 11, 1–13. 10.1186/s13012-016-0398-2 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Harvey, G., McCormack, B., Kitson, A., Lynch, E., & Titchen, A. (2018). Designing and implementing two facilitation interventions within the ‘facilitating implementation of research evidence (FIRE)’study: A qualitative analysis from an external facilitators’ perspective. Implementation Science, 13, 1–14. 10.1186/s13012-018-0812-z [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Hassan, S. M., Melville-Richards, L., Ring, A., Cloke, J., Smith, S., Saini, P., Goodall, M., Porroche-Escudero, A., Popay, J., & Gabbay, M. (2023). Minding the gap: The importance of active facilitation in moving boundary objects from in-theory to in-use as a tool for knowledge mobilisation. SSM-Qualitative Research in Health, 3, 100235. 10.1016/j.ssmqr.2023.100235 [Google Scholar]
- Le Boutillier, C., Leamy, M., Bird, V. J., Davidson, L., Williams, J., & Slade, M. (2011). What does recovery mean in practice? A qualitative analysis of international recovery-oriented practice guidance. Psychiatric Services, 62(12), 1470–1476. 10.1176/appi.ps.001312011 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Lee, J. D., Pullmann, M. D., Stone, W. L., & Locke, J. (2024). An implementation toolkit to enhance evidence-based practice among marginalized families: A Study Protocol. Global implementation research and applications, 1–10. 10.1007/s43477-024-00127-5
- Melville-Richards, L., Rycroft-Malone, J., Burton, C., & Wilkinson, J. (2020). Making authentic: Exploring boundary objects and bricolage in knowledge mobilisation through National health Service-university partnerships. Evidence & Policy, 16(4), 517–539. 10.1332/174426419X15623134271106 [Google Scholar]
- Mental Health Commission of Canada (2015). Guidelines for Recovery-Oriented Practice. https://www.mentalhealthcommission.ca/wp-content/uploads/drupal/MHCC_RecoveryGuidelines_ENG_0.pdf
- Metz, A., & Bartley, L. (2020). Implementation teams: A stakeholder view of leading and sustaining change. In B. Albers, A. Shlonsky, & R. Mildon (Eds.), Implementation science 3.0, 199–225. Springer.
- Olmos-Ochoa, T. T., Ganz, D. A., Barnard, J. M., Penney, L., Finley, E. P., Hamilton, A. B., & Chawla, N. (2021). Sustaining implementation facilitation: A model for facilitator resilience. Implementation Science Communications, 2(1), 65. 10.1186/s43058-021-00171-4 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Penney, L. S., Damush, T. M., Rattray, N. A., Miech, E. J., Baird, S. A., Homoya, B. J., Myers, L. J., & Bravata, D. M. (2021). Multi-tiered external facilitation: The role of feedback loops and tailored interventions in supporting change in a stepped-wedge implementation trial. Implementation Science Communications, 2, 1–12. 10.1186/s43058-021-00180-3 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Piat, M., Melville-Richards, L., Wainwright, M., Sofouli, E., Albert, H., Rivest, M.-P., Graham, I. (forthcoming). Perspectives on internal vs. external facilitation for implementing Canada’s guidelines for recovery-oriented practice: A qualitative study. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed]
- Piat, M., Sofouli, E., Wainwright, M., Albert, H., Rivest, M. P., Casey, R., LeBlanc, S., Labonté, L., O’Rourke, J. J., & Kasdorf, S. (2022). Translating mental health recovery guidelines into recovery-oriented innovations: A strategy combining implementation teams and a facilitated planning process. Evaluation and Program Planning, 91, 102054. [DOI] [PubMed]
- Piat, M., Wainwright, M., Cherkas, D., Leblanc, S., Sofouli, E., Rivest, M.-P., Albert, H., Casey, R., O’Rourke, J. J., & Labonté, L. (2021). Identifying and understanding the contextual factors that shaped mid-implementation outcomes during the COVID-19 pandemic in organizations implementing mental health recovery innovations into services. Implementation Science Communications, 2, 101. 10.1186/s43058-021-00206-w [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed]
- Piat, M., Wainwright, M., Rivest, M.-P., Sofouli, E., von Kirchenheim, T., Albert, H., Casey, R., Labonté, L., O’Rourke, J. J., & LeBlanc, S. (2022). The impacts of implementing recovery innovations: A conceptual framework grounded in qualitative research. International Journal of Mental Health Systems, 16, 49. 10.1186/s13033-022-00559-2 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed]
- Piat, M., Wainwright, M., Sofouli, E., Albert, H., Casey, R., Rivest, M. P., Briand, C., Kasdorf, S., Labonté, L., LeBlanc, S., & O’Rourke, J. J. (2021). The CFIR Card Game: A new approach for working with implementation teams to identify challenges and strategies. Implementation Science Communications, 2(1), 1. 10.1186/s43058-020-00099-1 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed]
- Piat, M., Wainwright, M., Sofouli, E., Vachon, B., Deslauriers, T., Préfontaine, C., & Frati, F. (2021). Factors influencing the implementation of mental health recovery into services: A systematic mixed studies review. Systematic Reviews, 10(1), 134. 10.1186/s13643-021-01646-0 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed]
- Pimentel, C. B., Mills, W. L., Palmer, J. A., Dillon, K., Sullivan, J. L., Wewiorski, N. J., Snow, A. L., Allen, R. S., Hopkins, S. D., & Hartmann, C. W. (2019). Blended facilitation as an effective implementation strategy for quality improvement and research in nursing homes. Journal of Nursing Care Quality, 34(3), 210–216. 10.1097/NCQ.0000000000000376 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Powell, B. J., Waltz, T. J., Chinman, M. J., Damschroder, L. J., Smith, J. L., Matthieu, M. M., Proctor, E. K., & Kirchner, J. E. (2015). A refined compilation of implementation strategies: Results from the expert recommendations for implementing change (ERIC) project. Implementation Science, 10, 1–14. 10.1186/s13012-015-0209-1 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- QSR International Pty Ltd (2018). NVivo qualitative data analysis software,. In (Version Version 12.).
- Ritchie, M. J., Kirchner, J. E., Parker, L. E., Curran, G. M., Fortney, J. C., Pitcock, J. A., Bonner, L. M., & Kilbourne, A. M. (2015). Evaluation of an implementation facilitation strategy for settings that experience significant implementation barriers. Implementation Science, 10, 1–3. 10.1186/1748-5908-10-S1-A4625567289 [Google Scholar]
- Ritchie, M. J., Parker, L. E., Edlund, C. N., & Kirchner, J. E. (2017). Using implementation facilitation to foster clinical practice quality and adherence to evidence in challenged settings: A qualitative study. BMC Health Services Research, 17, 1–15. 10.1186/s12913-017-2217-0 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Ritchie, M. J., Parker, L. E., & Kirchner, J. E. (2020). From novice to expert: A qualitative study of implementation facilitation skills. Implementation Science Communications, 1(1), 25. 10.1186/s43058-020-00006-8 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Ritchie, M. J., Parker, L. E., & Kirchner, J. E. (2023). Facilitating implementation of primary care mental health over time and across organizational contexts: A qualitative study of role and process. BMC Health Services Research, 23(1), 565. 10.1186/s12913-023-09598-y [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Rycroft-Malone, J., Burton, C. R., Wilkinson, J., Harvey, G., McCormack, B., Baker, R., Dopson, S., Graham, I. D., Staniszewska, S., & Thompson, C. (2015). Collective action for implementation: A realist evaluation of organisational collaboration in healthcare. Implementation Science, 11, 1–17. 10.1186/s13012-016-0380-z [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Smith, J. L., Ritchie, M. J., Kim, B., Miller, C. J., Chinman, M. J., Kelly, A., Landes, P., S. J., & Kirchner, J. E. (2024). Getting to fidelity: Consensus development process to identify core activities of implementation facilitation. Global Implementation Research and Applications, 4(2), 151–166. 10.1007/s43477-024-00119-5 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Star, S. L., & Griesemer, J. R. (1989). Institutional ecology,translations’ and boundary objects: Amateurs and professionals in Berkeley’s Museum of Vertebrate Zoology, 1907-39. Social studies of science, 19(3), 387–420. 10.1177/030631289019003001
- Thoele, K., Ferren, M., Moffat, L., Keen, A., & Newhouse, R. (2020). Development and use of A toolkit to facilitate implementation of an evidence-based intervention: A descriptive case study. Implementation Science Communications, 1, 1–12. 10.1186/s43058-020-00081-x [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Tistad, M., Bergström, A., Elf, M., Eriksson, L., Gustavsson, C., Göras, C., Harvey, G., Källberg, A. S., Rudman, A., & Unbeck, M. (2023). Training and support for the role of facilitator in implementation of innovations in health and community care: A scoping review protocol. Systematic Reviews, 12(1), 15. 10.1186/s13643-023-02172-x [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Tong, A., Sainsbury, P., & Craig, J. (2007). Consolidated criteria for reporting qualitative research (COREQ): A 32-item checklist for interviews and focus groups. International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 19(6), 349–357. 10.1093/intqhc/mzm042 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Waltz, T. J., Powell, B. J., Fernández, M. E., Abadie, B., & Damschroder, L. J. (2019). Choosing implementation strategies to address contextual barriers: Diversity in recommendations and future directions. Implementation Science, 14, 1–15. 10.1186/s13012-019-0892-4 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Zbukvic, I., Nicholas, J., Hamilton, C., Cruz-Manrique, P., Crlenjak, C., & Purcell, R. (2022). Using implementation science to inform workforce and service development in youth mental health: An Australian case study. Global Implementation Research and Applications, 2(4), 321–331. 10.1007/s43477-022-00058-z [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Zoom Video Communications Inc (2016). Security guide. In oom Video Communications Inc.
Associated Data
This section collects any data citations, data availability statements, or supplementary materials included in this article.
Supplementary Materials
Data Availability Statement
The datasets used and/or analysed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
