Skip to main content
Scientific Reports logoLink to Scientific Reports
. 2025 Nov 27;15:42532. doi: 10.1038/s41598-025-29003-4

Service preferences of printing houses as a basis for developing product-service system solutions

Mariusz Salwin 1,✉, Andrzej Kraslawski 2,3
PMCID: PMC12660318  PMID: 41309869

Abstract

In the current economic structure, a shift is observed from traditional production to a Product-Service System model among manufacturing companies. This transformation allows for more efficient resource utilization, focusing on higher-margin services. Integrating services with products enhances understanding of customer needs, leading to increased loyalty and improved market positioning. Developing Product-Service System solutions requires knowledge of service needs in specific sectors, a challenging yet crucial aspect. This study analyzes service preferences related to printing machines in print companies. A survey was conducted in 80 printing houses, exploring needs in four service categories: Polish Classification of Products and Services (A), printing machines (B), printing processes (C), and auxiliary services (D). To objectively evaluate the data and identify correlations between printing houses characteristics and service preferences, statistical analyses including Pearson’s correlation and One-Way Analysis of Variance with post-hoc Fisher’s Least Significant Difference test were used. The findings indicate significant differences in company size, product range, number of shifts, and type of printing houses concerning the service categories of interest.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1038/s41598-025-29003-4.

Keywords: Product-service system, Services, Printing industry, Printing machines

Subject terms: Engineering, Mathematics and computing

Introduction

In the context of Product-Service Systems (PSS), comprehending the service needs of enterprises becomes increasingly significant. PSS, by integrating products and services, offers holistic solutions that can substantially enhance customer value1,2. Understanding service needs enables the tailoring of offerings to meet specific client requirements and expectations, vital for value creation and sustainable development3,4. Consequently, firms are better equipped to respond to market shifts, innovate, and cultivate long-term client relationships5,6. Moreover, the efficient customization of services to meet customer needs can lead to increased loyalty, improved user experiences, and strengthened market positioning7,8. In an era increasingly focused on personalization and adaptability, understanding service needs in PSS is integral to business strategy formulation9,10.

The rise in the significance of the service sector within Gross Domestic Product (GDP) and increased employment in this sector are catalyzing the servicization of the economy11,12. This shift impacts the relative role of the industry, prompting manufacturing firms to explore new markets through the PSS model13,14. PSS represents a fundamental transformation of traditional business models, focusing on profits derived from the utility and availability of products rather than direct sales15,16. Implementing PSS enhances customer value through expanded services, innovations in advanced industrial sectors, and the potential for product reutilization17,18.

Understanding service needs within the context of PSS is crucial, as it enables precise tailoring of offerings to meet specific customer requirements19–21. This knowledge allows companies to better comprehend market dynamics, anticipate trends, and innovatively shape their products and services22–24. Personalization and customization to meet unique customer needs enhance satisfaction, loyalty, and market competitiveness9,25,26. In the digital era with evolving customer expectations, understanding and fulfilling service needs is essential for long-term success and sustainable business development27,28.

Gaining insight into service needs in the printing sector within the PSS framework is critically important for optimizing operations and fostering innovation. This understanding allows for the identification of key areas where companies can implement improvements and adapt their offerings to meet evolving market demands29,30. In a sector that is dynamically evolving with technological advancements, addressing specific service needs is essential for maintaining competitiveness31,32. This leads to the development of more integrated, efficient, and customer-focused solutions, crucial for long-term success in the industry33,34.

The aim of this study is to conduct an in-depth analysis of service preferences of printing houses related to printing machines. The paper presents survey results from 80 printing houses, detailing the services most sought after by them in connection with their printing machinery. This research, carried out on a representative sample, collected and categorized detailed data to provide a thorough analysis of services directly related to the Polish Classification of Products and Services (PKWiU), printing machines, printing processes, and auxiliary services. Statistical analyses such as Pearson’s correlation and One-Way Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) with the post-hoc Fisher’s Least Significant Difference (LSD) test were used to objectively evaluate the data and identify trends and relationships, enabling reliable conclusions about the characteristics of the surveyed printing houses and hypothesis testing.

This work represents a groundbreaking contribution to the scientific literature on PSS. It presents one of the few empirical studies examining the service needs of 80 printing houses with varying technological profiles and sizes, related to printing machines and their printing processes in the context of PSS. These needs were examined within a four-dimensional service structure. Statistical methods were also used to uncover patterns of relationships between printing house characteristics and their service needs. The paper also provides practical implications for PSS development, which will enable printing machine manufacturers to tailor their range of services to the specific requirements of various printing houses with specific characteristics. Furthermore, it identifies key services as elements with the highest potential value that printing houses are interested in. The scientific literature on PSS has largely ignored the printing industry, so this paper fills this gap.

This study contributes new knowledge by providing one of the first systematic evaluations of service needs specifically linked to printing-machine operation within a PSS context. Although well-established tools such as Pearson correlation and ANOVA are used, their combined application to a comprehensive, industry-wide service dataset enables the identification of relationships between organizational characteristics and service expectations. The results offer a practical decision support basis for manufacturers when designing PSS tailored to various types and sizes of printing houses. Additionally, a graphical workflow, Fig. 1, illustrating the proposed solution model has been added to highlight how the findings can be directly applied into service development practice.

Fig. 1.

Fig. 1

Decision-support workflow for identifying service priorities and developing tailored Product-Service System solutions for printing machinery.

The results provide valuable insights into current trends and needs in the printing sector, aiding the further development and optimization of the Product-Service System for printing. The paper is structured as follows: an introduction, research methodology, survey results and statistical analyses, discussion and conclusions.

Research methodology

The research aimed to acquire information about the service preferences of enterprises in the printing sector. The research question posed in this paper is:

What services related to printing machines are needed by printing houses?

To achieve the research objective and answer this question, a specified methodology was applied, including the following steps (Fig. 2):

Fig. 2.

Fig. 2

Research methodology.

  1. Survey Study: This research focused on analyzing the service preferences of 80 printing houses across various regions of Poland, predominantly representing flexographic (50%), offset (40%), and digital (10%) printing techniques. The survey included primarily micro (11.25%), small (45%), and medium-sized (28.75%) printing enterprises, along with 12 (15%) large companies. The survey was conducted between March and this year. Utilizing a questionnaire allowed for an in-depth understanding of their needs in the context of diverse services. The survey questions were categorized into four key categories directly related to:

  • PKWiU (A),

  • Printing machines (B),

  • Printing processes (C),

  • Auxiliary services (D).

These findings provide valuable insights for developing a Product-Service System model tailored to the printing sector.

  • Statistical Analysis: To analyze the relationship between the preference for services from a specific category and the specific attributes of enterprises, two advanced statistical methods were employed Pearson’s correlation and One-Way ANOVA with a post-hoc LSD test. The choice of these methods guarantees statistical reliability and the ability to accurately interpret differences in printing house performance. The significance level for these tests was set at 0.05. These methods were chosen due to the diverse characteristics of the enterprises: Pearson’s correlation was used for ordinal variables (such as company size, product range, number of shifts per day, total weekly downtime), while One-Way ANOVA was applied to nominal variables (e.g., type of printing houses). Each of the four service categories was statistically tested based on these enterprise characteristics.

  • 2.

    Analysis and discussion of results: This stage focused on the interpretation of statistically significant relationships. Particular attention was paid to the impact of printing house size, product range, and the number of changes on service demand, as well as the differences in service preferences between printing house types. The research results were interpreted in the context of the specific nature of the printing sector and PSS. The discussion aimed to highlight the practical implications of the results and their significance for PSS design and the printing sector.

This comprehensive methodology allowed for the collection and thorough analysis of specific information regarding the service preferences of printing houses.

Research results

This section presents the results of the empirical research. First, printing houses responses regarding service preferences are presented, grouped into four main categories: services classified according to the PKWiU (A), printing machinery services (B), printing process services (C), and ancillary services (D). These results were then subjected to statistical analysis, including Pearson correlation and One-Way ANOVA with a post-hoc LSD test, to identify the relationships between printing hous characteristics and their service needs.

Survey study outcomes

The conducted research focuses on the service preferences of firms in the printing industry, categorizing services into four groups directly related to: the PKWiU, printing machines, printing processes, and auxiliary services. Responses from the survey facilitated the classification of 62 services across these four areas, ranging from the most to the least desired. A total of 2529 responses regarding service preferences of printing houses were collected. The detailed outcomes are presented in Table 1, providing an exhaustive insight into the service priorities of printing enterprises. Each section of Table 1 lists specific services and indicates the percentage of firms interested in each, outlining a hierarchy of service interest from the most to the least preferred in the sector. The list of 62 services presented in Table 1 was developed based on the PKWiU and refined through consultations with printing industry experts and company representatives. These categories formed the basis of the questionnaire used in the survey of 80 printing houses.

Table 1.

Results of research on printing house service preferences according to four key categories.

Section of Services Directly Related to PKWiU (A) Interesting Non interesting
Label Service Number % Number %
A1 Expert, Analytical, and Technical Services 70 87,50% 10 12,50%
A2 Data and Telecommunication Services 60 75,00% 20 25,00%
A3 Banking and Risk Management Services 59 73,75% 21 26,25%
A4 Logistics and Warehousing 58 72,50% 22 27,50%
A5 Educational Services 55 68,75% 25 31,25%
A6 Trade-Related Services 55 68,75% 25 31,25%
A7 Organizational and Auxiliary Services 54 67,50% 26 32,50%
A8 Assistance Services 50 62,50% 30 37,50%
A9 Power Systems Services 44 55,00% 36 45,00%
A10 Water Treatment and Waste Management Services 44 55,00% 36 45,00%
A11 Manufacturing Process Services 35 43,75% 45 56,25%
A12 Healthcare and Community Services 30 37,50% 50 62,50%
A13 Property Management Services 28 35,00% 52 65,00%
A14 Recreational, Arts, and Athletic Services 24 30,00% 56 70,00%
Section of Services Directly Related to Printing Machines (B) Interesting Non interesting
Label Service Number % Number %
B1 Machine Setup and Activation 64 80,00% 16 20,00%
B2 Machine Transit to Client 61 76,25% 19 23,75%
B3 Provision of Replacement Parts 61 76,25% 19 23,75%
B4 Provision of Operational Materials 59 73,75% 21 26,25%
B5 Waste Handling Services 57 71,25% 23 28,75%
B6 Renewal, Comprehensive Overhaul, and Maintenance 50 62,50% 30 37,50%
B7 Occupational Health and Safety Services 47 58,75% 33 41,25%
B8 Product Assurance 46 57,50% 34 42,50%
B9 Economic Services 45 56,25% 35 43,75%
B10 Cloud-Based Data Archiving 44 55,00% 36 45,00%
B11 Machines Documentation (Physical or Digital) 43 53,75% 37 46,25%
B12 Technical Support Desk (Machine, Procedure, Commerce) 42 52,50% 38 47,50%
B13 Product Retrieval Service 26 32,50% 54 67,50%
B14 Sanitation Services 18 22,50% 62 77,50%
B15 Workspace Environment Management 12 15,00% 68 85,00%
B16 Acoustic Emission Minimization 12 15,00% 68 85,00%
B17 Equipment Dismantling 7 8,75% 73 91,25%
Section of Services Directly Related to Printing Processes (C) Interesting Non interesting
Label Service Number % Number %
C1 Material Utilization Enhancement 61 76,25% 19 23,75%
C2 Equipment Usage Optimization 56 70,00% 24 30,00%
C3 Comprehensive Operational Supervision Post-Usage Period 54 67,50% 26 32,50%
C4 Diagnostic and Remedial Engineering 53 66,25% 27 33,75%
C5 Monitoring, Evaluation, and Diagnostic Analysis of Machines 46 57,50% 34 42,50%
C6 Instructional Programs 46 57,50% 34 42,50%
C7 Resource Recovery and Management 37 46,25% 43 53,75%
C8 System Upgradation (Refurbishment, Modernization) 30 37,50% 50 62,50%
C9 Efficiency Enhancement Techniques 24 30,00% 56 70,00%
C10 Production Scheduling and Oversight 16 20,00% 64 80,00%
C11 Management of Specified Client Operations 8 10,00% 72 90,00%
C12 Systematic Assessments and Evaluations 7 8,75% 73 91,25%
Section of Services Directly Related to Auxiliary Services (D) Interesting Non interesting
Label Service Number % Number %
D1 Tailoring, Supply, and Efficiency Maximization in Paint Usage for Specific Orders 69 86,25% 11 13,75%
D2 Instruction Programs for Printing Operators 64 80,00% 16 20,00%
D3 Substitution of Reflective Surfaces, Filtration Units, and Ultraviolet Illuminators 58 72,50% 22 27,50%
D4 Computer-to-Plate (CTP) Board Formulation 41 51,25% 39 48,75%
D5 Enhancement of Printing Machines Setup Efficiency 41 51,25% 39 48,75%
D6 Maintenance and Cleansing of Printing Devices 39 48,75% 41 51,25%
D7 Scheduling Optimal Intervals for Print Form Replacement 32 40,00% 48 60,00%
D8 Paint Blend Formulation 32 40,00% 48 60,00%
D9 Streamlining the Delivery Schedule of Pristine Equipment to Print Machines 30 37,50% 50 62,50%
D10 Formulation of Printing Technological Processes 29 36,25% 51 63,75%
D11 Material Readiness for Production Activities 24 30,00% 56 70,00%
D12 Assurance of Supreme Quality and Purity in Printing Equipment Delivery 24 30,00% 56 70,00%
D13 Composition of Printing Materials 24 30,00% 56 70,00%
D14 Arrangement of Production Instruments 16 20,00% 64 80,00%
D15 Assistance in Marketing Pre-owned Printing Machines 12 15,00% 68 85,00%
D16 Determination of Suitable Printing Mediums 11 13,75% 69 86,25%
D17 Calibration, Configurations, and Fine-Tuning Operations 9 11,25% 71 88,75%
D18 Designing, Manufacturing, and Assembly of Printing Plates 7 8,75% 73 91,25%
D19 Paint Material Disposal Procedures 6 7,50% 74 92,50%

In the first category of services directly related to the PKWiU, there are 14 services, eliciting 666 responses. The study revealed that service A1 garners the most interest among printing houses, with 87.50% of firms expressing interest. Services A2 and A3 are also highly rated, attracting interest from 75.00% to 73.75% of surveyed printing houses, respectively. Services A4 to A6 show a similar level of interest, hovering around 70%. Services A7 to A14 exhibit gradually declining interest, with A14 being the least interesting to firms (30.00%). High interest in services A1, A2, and A3 reflects the growing complexity and technological sophistication of the printing industry. In the digital and automation era, printing houses rely on specialized technical knowledge and efficient telecommunication and data systems for process optimization and complex systems management. Service A3 is pivotal for financial stability and risk minimization in a rapidly changing business environment. Conversely, the lesser interest in services A12, A13, and A14 may be attributed to their reduced direct impact on the core operations of printing houses. While important in the broader context of enterprise management, these services may be perceived as less critical for daily production operations in the printing industry.

In the second category of services, directly related to printing machines, there are 17 services, with 749 responses received. The analysis showed that service B1 attracted the most interest, with 80.00% of printing houses expressing interest. Services B2 and B3 were also in high demand, both garnering interest from 76.25% of respondents. Interest declined for services from B6 to B17. The high interest in services B1, B2, and B3 stems from their direct impact on the operational readiness and efficiency of machines. Machine availability and reliability are crucial for maintaining continuous production processes, explaining the high interest in these services. In contrast, services like B15, B16, and B17 are perceived as less priority in the context of the immediate needs of printing houses, being important but often secondary compared to the fundamental operational requirements of printing machines.

In the third category of services, directly related to the printing process, there are 12 services, with 473 responses obtained. The analysis of service preferences in the C category for the printing sector revealed that service C1 garnered the most interest, with 76.25% of printing houses declaring interest. Services C2 and C3 also ranked highly, attracting interest from 70.00% to 67.50%, respectively. Subsequent services showed a gradual decline in interest, with C7 at 46.25% down to C12 at 8.75%. High interest in services C1, C2, and C3, which directly contribute to operational efficiency, cost reduction, and maximizing production throughput, reflects their demand in the printing industry. In the context of ongoing cost optimization and productivity enhancement, these services are crucial for maintaining the competitiveness of printing enterprises. Conversely, services like C10, C11, and C12 may be viewed as less critical for direct printing operations. Though important in the broader context of industrial printing, these aspects might not be prioritized in the daily functioning of printing houses focused primarily on technical and production aspects.

In the fourth category, auxiliary services, there are 19 services with 641 responses. The service preference study indicated that service D1 is the most popular (86.25%), followed by D2 (80.00%). Service D3 is also highly rated (72.50%). Interest gradually decreases to D19, attracting the least interest (7.50%). High interest in D1, D2, and D3 among printing houses is due to their direct impact on print quality and production efficiency. These services are essential for optimizing printing processes, ensuring print quality, and maintaining equipment efficiency and reliability. Conversely, services like D17, D18, and D19 may be selected less frequently, being perceived as less critical for daily production operations, possibly viewed as more specialized or periodic tasks not required as regularly as other services.

In a global overview of service preference research among printing houses, out of 62 services, A1, B1, C1, and D1 attracted the most interest, with over 75% of surveyed enterprises showing interest in each. The least frequently chosen services were A14, B17, C12, and D19, with A14 interesting 30% of the enterprises, while the others appealed to no more than 8.75% of surveyed printing houses.

The high interest in A1, B1, C1, and D1 among printing houses underlines their essential role in the printing industry, significantly impacting production efficiency, print quality, and cost optimization. Amidst intense competition and rapid technological evolution, these services are vital for sustaining enterprise competitiveness and innovativeness. Conversely, services like A14, B17, C12, and D19 are less sought after in the printing industry, as they are less directly connected to the primary production processes and business operations of printing houses, often considered supplementary rather than fundamental.

Statistical analysis

The statistical analysis utilized the Pearson correlation coefficient and a combination of One-Way ANOVA and the LSD test.

The Pearson correlation coefficient is one of the most common methods for examining the strength and direction of linear relationships between numerical variables. It allows for the quantitative assessment of relationships and the identification of positive and negative correlations. This fact is particularly important when analyzing complex PSS35,36. Pearson correlation has been successfully used in studies on: identifying and assessing factors influencing customer attraction in the airline industry37, recommending products available on the market to users38, analyzing the impact of the digital economy on a country’s economic growth39, the quality of banking, transportation, courier, and telecommunications services and customer satisfaction40, and factors influencing online financial services41.

In the next stage of statistical research, a combination of One-Way ANOVA and the LSD test was used. One-Way ANOVA is a well-known and commonly used method for comparing means between more than two groups. One-Way ANOVA allows for assessing whether the variability within groups is significantly lower than the variability between groups. If significant differences were found between groups, a post-hoc LSD test was used. This test is recommended in studies with a moderate number of groups and the goal is to precisely identify pairs of groups that differ from each other in terms of the analyzed factor35,36. The combination of One-Way ANOVA and LSD test has been successfully used in studies on: personalization of PSS services42, satisfaction and utilization of primary healthcare services43, analysis of the impact of various forms of service provider engagement on the dimensions of service activity necessary for servitization44, assessment and analysis of the degree of satisfaction and satisfaction with innovative banking services45 and examination of the relationship between service quality dimensions and customer satisfaction and loyalty in a mobile shopping app46.

In each of these cases, both the Pearson correlation coefficient and the combination of One-Way ANOVA and LSD testing allowed for the objective identification of important relationships35,36,47. The selected statistical methods remain very suitable for the industrial context examined, as they enable clear interpretation of factor–service relationships and provide an evidence-based foundation for practical PSS design decisions.

Pearson’s correlation

In the study of ordinal variables (such as enterprise size, range of products, number of shifts per working day, total duration of failure per week), Pearson’s correlation was employed. Formulating hypotheses for this test:

  • The null hypothesis assumes there is no correlation between the studied variables.

  • The alternative hypothesis assumes a correlation exists between them.

Confirming this hypothesis helps evaluate whether the observed relationship between variables in the sample is a mere coincidence or represents a general trend in the analyzed population. The results of the tests, including correlation coefficients and p-values for each variable pair, are presented in the Table 2.

Table 2.

Pearson correlation results.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Enterprise size1 R-Pearson 1,0000 0,4054 0,7061 −0,1903 −0,1131 0,1248 −0,2361 −0,7346
p-value --- 0,000 0,000 0,091 0,318 0,270 0,035 0,000
Range of products2 R-Pearson 1,0000 0,2733 0,0524 0,4072 0,0336 0,3081 −0,2370
p-value --- 0,014 0,644 0,000 0,768 0,005 0,034
Number of shifts per working day3 R-Pearson 1,0000 −0,1861 −0,0216 0,3264 −0,1251 −0,5412
p-value --- 0,098 0,849 0,003 0,269 0,000
Total duration of failure per week4 R-Pearson 1,0000 0,1138 0,1921 0,0719 0,1100
p-value --- 0,315 0,088 0,526 0,331
Services in area A5 R-Pearson 1,0000 0,0736 0,4119 0,1952
p-value --- 0,516 0,000 0,083
Services from area B6 R-Pearson 1,0000 0,0311 −0,1961
p-value --- 0,784 0,081
Services from area C7 R-Pearson 1,0000 0,3531
p-value --- 0,001
Services from area D8 R-Pearson 1,0000
p-value ---

The Pearson correlation results reveal various relationships between company size, product assortment, daily shift frequency, and service ownership across different categories. The analysis indicates 16 statistically insignificant correlations and 12 significant ones, with 8 being positive and 4 negative. A moderate positive correlation exists between company size and product assortment (0,4054), suggesting that larger companies tend to have a broader range of products. Negative correlations between company size and services in categories C (−0,2361) and D (−0,7346) imply larger companies may use these services less, possibly due to having their resources. Similarly, product assortment shows a weak negative correlation with the number of daily shifts (−0,2733) and services in category D (−0,2370), but a moderate positive correlation with services in categories A (0,4072) and C (0,3081). This suggests a nuanced relationship between product variety and service utilization. A moderate positive correlation between the number of shifts and services in category B (0.3264) contrasts with a strong negative correlation with category D services (−0,5412). Overall, moderate positive correlations, especially between categories A and C (0,4119) and C and D (0,3531), all statistically significant, indicate that using certain services often coincides with using others.

Each Pearson Correlation uncovers unique service preferences and needs in the printing industry. The findings reveal diverse interrelations within the sector. Positive correlations between company size and product range, and among various service categories, suggest larger firms may offer a wider array of services and products. Negative correlations between company size and certain service categories could indicate larger enterprises’ lesser reliance on external services. These relationships might reflect differences in resources, capabilities, and strategies of printing companies of varying sizes.

One-way ANOVA with additional post-hoc LSD test

In the study focusing on nominal variables (type of printing house), a One-Way ANOVA was used. This ensures the identification of relationships between the type of printing company and its service needs35,36. Formulating hypotheses for this test:

  • The null hypothesis assumes that the type of printing house and the desire to possess services from a specific area are independent, suggesting that the type of printing house does not influence service preferences.

  • The alternative hypothesis posits that these variables are dependent, implying that the type of printing house impacts service preferences.

Table 3 presents detailed One-Way ANOVA test results (Fischer Statistics, p-value, Mean, Standard Deviation) for each service area (A, B, C, and D), highlighting statistically significant differences between types of printing houses. These values provide a thorough statistical analysis of service preferences among different types of printing firms.

Table 3.

Results of One-Way ANOVA.

Service areas Fischer Statistics p-value Digital printing house Flexographic printing house Offset printing house Overall group
Mean Standard deviation Mean Standard deviation Mean Standard deviation Mean Standard deviation
Services from area A 5,7560 0,0047 8,3750 2,6152 8,9750 1,7020 7,5000 1,7780 8,3250 1,9407
Services from area B 0,5289 0,5913 9,0000 1,6036 9,6000 2,2960 9,1563 1,9362 9,3625 2,0882
Services from area C 2,8930 0,0615 5,3750 1,1877 6,4000 2,0229 5,4375 1,6449 5,9125 1,8569
Services from area D 1,3778 0,2583 6,7500 2,2520 8,7250 4,2607 7,4375 3,9180 8,0125 3,9984

In service area A, One-Way ANOVA revealed statistically significant differences between types of printing houses, with a value of F = 5,7560 and p-value = 0,0047. The low p-value (0,0047) indicates that differences in average service ratings among different types of printing houses (digital, flexographic, offset) are statistically significant, suggesting a significant variance in at least one group. Flexographic printing houses showed the highest average rating for services in area A (mean = 8.9750), indicating their particular interest in these services. Conversely, offset printing houses showed the lowest average rating in area A (mean = 7.5000), suggesting less interest in these services.

In the previous One-Way ANOVA analysis, differences between groups were identified. Subsequent testing of populations contributing to the rejection of the null hypothesis in the One-Way ANOVA was conducted. Additional tests using the LSD test, the oldest method for multiple comparisons of mean pairs, were performed to determine differences among types of printing houses. This test is recommended in studies in which the number of groups is moderate and the goal is to precisely identify pairs of groups that differ from each other in terms of the analyzed factor48,49. The hypotheses for the LSD test were as follows:

  • Null Hypothesis: There is no difference between the mean values of the analyzed factor pairs.

  • Alternative Hypothesis: There are differences in the mean values of the analyzed factor pairs.

This statistical method applies the t-Student test for comparing all pairs of the independent variable while adjusting the significance level for multiple comparisons. The relationships identified in service area A are presented in Table 4.

Table 4.

The post-hoc LSD.

Type of printing house Digital printing house Flexographic printing house Offset printing house
Mean 8,3750 8,9750 7,5000
Digital printing house 8,3750 0,4008 0,2310
Flexographic printing house 8,9750 0,4008 0,0011
Offset printing house 7,5000 0,2310 0,0011

The post-hoc LSD test in service area A revealed statistically significant differences between flexographic and offset printing houses (p-value = 0,001098), indicating that their average ratings of interest in services from category A significantly differ. No other significant differences were observed among groups. The post-hoc LSD test corroborates the results of the One-Way ANOVA, confirming that the identified differences between groups are indeed statistically significant. This confirms that flexographic printing houses (mean = 8,9750) show particular interest in these services, whereas offset printing houses (mean = 7,5000) show significantly less interest.

The statistically significant differences identified by the One-Way ANOVA and post-hoc LSD test between flexographic and offset printing houses in service category A could stem from the differences in their printing technologies and consequent service needs. Flexographic and offset printing houses vary in production processes, materials used, and the nature of orders they handle, leading to distinct service preferences related to category A. These differences might be associated with the unique requirements of each type of printing house in terms of equipment handling, maintenance, and customization to meet specific needs.

The absence of statistically significant differences in the One-Way ANOVA and post-hoc LSD test in service categories B, C, and D among flexographic, offset, and digital printing houses might indicate a similarity in service needs and requirements across these areas, irrespective of the printing technology used. This could suggest that certain fundamental aspects of operations and support are common across different types of printing houses, despite their specific technologies and processes.

Discussion

This paper fills a gap in the literature regarding printing house preferences for services. It provides information on the specific needs of printing houses that arise during the operation of a printing machine. The research indicates the potential for developing PSS-based solutions for the printing sector. The research emphasizes that printing machine manufacturers should create and develop their service offerings in a segmented manner, tailored to the size of the printing house and the printing technology used. It seems crucial to include services that encompass resource utilization and process optimization. These received high ratings in the study and can also serve as a source of long-term customer relationships. From a theoretical perspective, the paper makes a new contribution to the field of PSS in printing. The analysis conducted in this paper can be effectively used to develop business models and servitization strategies in traditionally oriented industries. Theoretically, the paper contributes to the literature on PSS in printing, demonstrating that service needs analysis can be effectively used to build business models and servitization strategies in traditional industries. The research results presented in this paper emphasize process and technical services as the foundation for building value in the industrial sector, thus being consistent with other studies in the area of PSS1,14,50. Furthermore, the paper highlights differences between different types of printing houses. Flexographic printing houses demonstrate a significantly greater demand for category A services than offset printing houses. This may be due to the higher level of complexity of processes and technologies. Until now, such relationships have not been analyzed and discussed extensively in the PSS literature, which constitutes a completely new contribution of the research conducted in this paper.

It should be noted that service priorities in the printing sector are quite different from those in the economic sectors most frequently cited in the scientific literature on PSS (automotive, heavy machinery, electronics, and IT)51–54. While research in the area of PSS emphasizes the increasing digitalization of the economy and the related demand for digital services, printing houses operating in Poland rate operational and technical services highest. This fact primarily reflects the specific nature of the printing sector, where machine reliability, production efficiency, and final product quality are paramount. Furthermore, research indicates that large printing houses are less dependent on ancillary services. This contrasts with research conducted in the automotive and aerospace sectors, where the largest companies are most often the integrators of a wide range of services.

The research results focus on the printing sector, but their application, as well as the research approach and methodology, is also possible in other sectors of the economy. It should be emphasized that PSS is a flexible solution, whose method, principles, and goals are also critical in the context of other economic sectors, particularly those utilizing high-value machines with long life cycles, complex structures, and demanding maintenance requirements. These sectors are experiencing a growing demand for customized maintenance, technical, and training services. Furthermore, the survey research and statistical analyses used in this paper for the printing sector can be successfully applied to other sectors, where similar variations in company size, technological level, and needs and requirements related to additional services are evident. Therefore, the results of this research provide a methodological and practical foundation, stimulating the development of research on services that can be offered as add-ons to PSS machines in traditional industries. Proper use of this approach can lead to increased customer satisfaction, improved competitiveness, and the transformation of business models to more environmentally friendly ones in various industrial sectors.

The results of the research conducted in the printing sector, presented in this paper, present observations that extend beyond the scope of a specific economic sector. They can be applied to other industrial sectors, particularly plastics processing and welding. In the case of these two sectors, as in the printing sector, a significant dependence on machinery is evident. Furthermore, issues related to machine availability, reliability, and optimization of production processes have a decisive impact on production efficiency and quality. Furthermore, the services most frequently selected by printing houses can be directly or indirectly tailored to the needs and requirements of plastics processing and welding plants. For example, services related to machine maintenance and configuration, as well as material consumption and process management, are crucial for companies representing each of the indicated industries. Furthermore, the research methodology used in the paper, particularly the four-dimensional service structure and closely related statistical analyses, provides an effective instrument for developing a PSS in these sectors. Furthermore, the study indicates the segmentation of services depending on the size and technological profile of the company. This is also important for plastics processing and welding plants, which have diverse technologies and resources.

Conclusions

The study analyzed the service preferences of 80 printing companies within the context of the PSS, in four main categories: services according to the PKWiU classification (A), services related to printing machines (B), services related to printing processes (C), and additional services (D). According to the results, printing companies showed the greatest interest in services A1 (expert, analytical, and technical services), B1 (machine commissioning and activation), C1 (material optimization), and D1 (ink consumption adjustment and efficiency improvement), with over 75% of companies expressing interest in each. The least sought-after services were A14, B17, C12, and D19, with fewer than 10% of respondents expressing interest. Pearson correlation and One-Way ANOVA results showed a positive correlation between company size and product mix, with larger companies less likely to use outsourced services in categories C and D. One-Way ANOVA and Fisher’s LSD test confirmed that flexographic printers showed significantly greater interest in outsourced services in category A than offset printers (p-value = 0.0011). The results indicate that machine reliability, production efficiency, and quality are key factors in service demand, while smaller companies rely more heavily on outsourced services. Overall, the study shows that PSS-based solutions rely primarily on operational and technical support, knowledge-based services, and process optimization, which enhance competitiveness and customer loyalty.

The research on service preferences of printing enterprises highlights diverse interests across a wide spectrum of services in areas A, B, C, and D, ranging from A1 to D19. A trend is observed where key industry services (e.g., A1, B1, C1, D1) attract higher interest, underlining their crucial role in production processes. The results indicate global tendencies in service preferences in the printing industry, which may shape future service development strategies and technological investments. This paper aimed to answer the research question: What services related to printing machines are required by printing houses?

The paper details one of the few survey-based studies focusing on service preferences in the printing industry. The findings provide valuable insights into the most desired services in the context of using printing machines:

  • Larger printing houses show less interest in services from areas C and D.

  • The broader the product range in a printing house, the greater the interest in services from areas A and C, but lesser in area D.

  • An increased number of shifts correlates with higher interest in services from area B, but less in D.

  • Higher interest in area C services links to increased interest in areas A and D.

  • Flexographic printing houses most frequently utilize services from area A.

The paper provides new insights into the service needs of enterprises in the context of developing Product-Service Systems (PSS) in the printing sector. This is crucial due to increasing competition and technological evolution in the industry. The knowledge in the paper enables printing machines manufacturers to tailor their services to the specific needs of printing houses, essential for adding value and standing out in the market. Understanding customer preferences in PSS allows for optimizing operations, innovating offerings, and developing long-term, profitable client relationships, vital in a dynamically changing industry environment.

The study presented in this paper has several significant limitations. The first is its cross-sectional nature, which allows only for the identification of co-occurring relationships, preventing full causal inference. The second is that the study only included printing houses operating in Poland. This prevents the generalization of the results to other international markets, where technological development, sector structure, and service levels may differ significantly. Furthermore, three statistical analyses were used (Pearson correlation, One-Way ANOVA, and the LSD test). This indicates the need for further research utilizing other advanced quantitative techniques and multivariate models.

The relevance of the findings extends beyond the printing sector. Similar production environments such as welding and plastics processing also rely on machinery availability, operator training, waste reduction, and process efficiency — meaning the identified PSS service clusters can be adapted to these domains with minimal modification. Moreover, the approach can be generalized to other manufacturing industries where multivariable equipment–service interactions influence operational performance. Future research should validate the model across additional industrial sectors, incorporate real-time performance data, and evaluate impacts on cost, downtime, and customer satisfaction. These directions will further strengthen the PSS development model and support long-term industrial adoption.

The research presented in this paper opens up new avenues for exploration, expanding knowledge about PSS in the printing sector. The study’s limited scope to the Polish printing sector and its cross-sectional nature suggest that it would be beneficial to conduct a longitudinal study in the future, allowing for the discovery of cause-and-effect relationships. Expanding the research internationally seems necessary. This will allow for a comparison of the requirements and needs for printing house services operating in entirely different technological and economic environments. The results also open new research perspectives, such as exploring service needs focused on the life cycle of printing machines. Future research directions will focus on developing an innovative business model based on PSS, which focuses on the life cycle of a printing machine. We also aim to conduct similar research in the plastics processing and welding sectors. Furthermore, further work will also focus on developing a new PSS design method and its verification. To summarize, the research results presented in this work provide a strong foundation for generating innovative solutions based on PSS, as well as significantly enhancing the service development strategy in the printing sector.

Supplementary Information

Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.

Supplementary Material 1 (20.5KB, docx)

Acknowledgements

Love and praise God. Mater Misericordiae pray for us.

Author contributions

Mariusz Salwin - Conceptualization, Methodology, Software, Validation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Resources, Data Curation, Writing - Original Draft, Writing - Review & Editing, Visualization, Project administration, SupervisionAndrzej Kraslawski - Visualization, Project administration, Supervision.

Data availability

The data supporting the findings of this study are available upon request from the corresponding author. The raw data include survey results and statistical calculations. Due to institutional policy and data privacy considerations, these datasets are not publicly available. However, interested researchers may obtain access to them upon reasonable request by contacting Mariusz Salwin at mariusz.salwin@onet.pl.No proprietary or third-party data were used in this study. Data used in this study may also be made available upon request for academic and research purposes.

Declarations

Competing interests

The authors declare no competing interests.

Footnotes

Publisher’s note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

References

  • 1.Annarelli, A., Battistella, C. & Nonino, F. Translating PSS strategy into operations. In The Road To Servitization 143–173 (Springer International Publishing, 2019). 10.1007/978-3-030-12251-5_5. [Google Scholar]
  • 2.Salwin, M., Gladysz, B. & Santarek, K. Technical Product-Service Systems—A business opportunity for machine industry. In Advances in Manufacturing (eds Hamrol, A. et al.) 269–278 (Springer International Publishing, 2018). 10.1007/978-3-319-68619-6_26. [Google Scholar]
  • 3.Azzine Shiratori, E. K., Hofmann Trevisan, A. & Mascarenhas, J. The customer journey in a product-service system business model. Procedia CIRP. 100, 313–318. 10.1016/j.procir.2021.05.072 (2021). [Google Scholar]
  • 4.Geum, Y., Lee, S., Kang, D. & Park, Y. The customisation framework for roadmapping product-service integration. Service Bus.5, 213. 10.1007/s11628-011-0111-0 (2011). [Google Scholar]
  • 5.Saccani, N., Visintin, F. & Rapaccini, M. Investigating the linkages between service types and supplier relationships in servitized environments. Int. J. Prod. Econ.149, 226–238. 10.1016/j.ijpe.2013.10.001 (2014). [Google Scholar]
  • 6.Salwin, M., Nehring, K., Jacyna-Gołda, I. & Kraslawski, A. Product-Service system design – an example of the logistics industry. AoT63, 159–180. 10.5604/01.3001.0016.0820 (2022). [Google Scholar]
  • 7.Bu, L. et al. A user-centric design approach for smart product-service systems using virtual reality: A case study. J. Clean. Prod.280, 124413. 10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.124413 (2021). [Google Scholar]
  • 8.Salwin, M., Andrzejewski, M. & Kraslawski, A. Information asymmetry in Product-Service system Design - Example of the pharmaceutical industry. Procedia Manuf.55, 282–289. 10.1016/j.promfg.2021.10.040 (2021). [Google Scholar]
  • 9.Chiu, M. C., Huang, J. H., Gupta, S. & Akman, G. Developing a personalized recommendation system in a smart product service system based on unsupervised learning model. Comput. Ind.128, 103421. 10.1016/j.compind.2021.103421 (2021). [Google Scholar]
  • 10.Zine, P. U., Kulkarni, M. S., Chawla, R. & Ray, A. K. A framework for value Co-creation through customization and personalization in the context of machine tool PSS. Procedia CIRP. 16, 32–37. 10.1016/j.procir.2014.01.005 (2014). [Google Scholar]
  • 11.Statista Distribution of gross domestic product (GDP) across economic sectors worldwide from 2007 to 2023, distribution of gross domestic product (GDP) across economic sectors worldwide, last accessed 2023/01/10.
  • 12.Salwin, M., Chmielewski, T. & Kraslawski, A. Product-Service system: A new opportunity for the welding industry. Found. Manage.17, 125–144. 10.2478/fman-2025-0009 (2025). [Google Scholar]
  • 13.Goedkoop, M., van Haler, C., te Riele, H. & Rommers, P. Product Service-Systems, ecological and economic basics. (1999).
  • 14.Tukker, A. Eight types of product–service system: eight ways to sustainability? Experiences from SusProNet. Bus. Strat Env. 13, 246–260. 10.1002/bse.414 (2004). [Google Scholar]
  • 15.Salwin, M., Jacyna-Gołda, I., Kraslawski, A. & Waszkiewicz, A. E. The use of business model canvas in the design and classification of Product-Service systems design methods. Sustainability14, 4283. 10.3390/su14074283 (2022). [Google Scholar]
  • 16.Tukker, A. & Tischner, U. Product-services as a research field: past, present and future. Reflections from a decade of research. J. Clean. Prod.14, 1552–1556. 10.1016/j.jclepro.2006.01.022 (2006). [Google Scholar]
  • 17.Reim, W. Towards a Framework for product-service System Business Model Implementation (Luleå tekniska universitet, 2018).
  • 18.Vezzoli, C., Ceschin, F., Osanjo, L., M’Rithaa, M.K., Moalosi, R., Nakazibwe, V., Diehl, J.C.: Sustainable Product-Service System (S.PSS). In: Designing Sustainable Energy for All. pp. 41–51. Springer International Publishing, Cham (2018). 10.1007/978-3-319-70223-0_3.
  • 19.Barravecchia, F., Mastrogiacomo, L. & Franceschini, F. A QFD-based approach to identify product-service systems functional requirements. In: Berbegal-Mirabent, J., Marimon, F., Casadesús, M., and Sampaio, P. (eds.) Proceedings book of the 3rd International Conference on Quality Engineering and Management, 2018. pp. 235–254. International Conference on Quality Engineering and Management, Barcelona, Spain, July 11, (2018). (2018).
  • 20.Berkovich, M., Leimeister, J. M., Hoffmann, A. & Krcmar, H. A requirements data model for product service systems. Requirements Eng.19, 161–186. 10.1007/s00766-012-0164-1 (2014). [Google Scholar]
  • 21.Salwin, M., Santarek, K., Kraslawski, A., Lipiak, J.: Product-Service System: A New Opportunity for the Printing Industry. In: Tonkonogyi, V., Ivanov, V., Trojanowska, J., Oborskyi, G., Grabchenko, A., Pavlenko, I., Edl, M., Kuric, I., and Dasic, P. (eds.) Advanced Manufacturing Processes II. pp. 83–95. Springer International Publishing, Cham (2021). 10.1007/978-3-030-68014-5_9.
  • 22.Berkovich, M., Leimeister, J. M. & Krcmar, H. Requirements engineering for product service systems: A state of the Art analysis. Bus. Inf. Syst. Eng.3, 369–380. 10.1007/s12599-011-0192-2 (2011). [Google Scholar]
  • 23.Fargnoli, M. & Haber, N. A practical ANP-QFD methodology for dealing with requirements’ inner dependency in PSS development. Comput. Ind. Eng.127, 536–548. 10.1016/j.cie.2018.10.042 (2019). [Google Scholar]
  • 24.Salwin, M., Kraslawski, A., Andrzejewski, M. & Hryniewicka, M. Product-Service system Design - A case study for parking furniture industry. In Advances in Manufacturing IV (eds Hamrol, A. et al.) 41–56 (Springer Nature Switzerland, 2024). 10.1007/978-3-031-56474-1_4. [Google Scholar]
  • 25.Hankammer, S., Nielsen, K., Piller, F. T., Schuh, G. & Wang, N. eds: (eds) Customization 4.0: proceedings of the 9th world mass customization & personalization conference (MCPC 2017), Aachen, Germany, November 20th-21st, 2017. Springer Int. Publishing Cham10.1007/978-3-319-77556-2 (2018). [Google Scholar]
  • 26.Salwin, M., Strycharska, D. & Kraslawski, A. Product-Service system for the foundry sector. In Knowledge Management in Organisations (eds Uden, L. & Ting, I. H.) 275–291 (Springer Nature Switzerland, 2024). 10.1007/978-3-031-63269-3_21. [Google Scholar]
  • 27.Aas, T. H., Breunig, K. J., Hellström, M. M. & Hydle, K. M. Service-Oriented business models in manufacturing in the digital era: toward a new taxonomy. Int. J. Innov. Mgt. 24, 2040002. 10.1142/S1363919620400022 (2020). [Google Scholar]
  • 28.Boucher, X., Coba, C. M. & Lamy, D. Smart PSS modelling Language for value offer prototyping: A design case study in the field of heating appliance offers. Comput. Ind.155, 104041. 10.1016/j.compind.2023.104041 (2024). [Google Scholar]
  • 29.Department of Strategy and International Analysis. The Printing industry. The Growing Importance of Polish Producers in the World (Powszechna Kasa Oszczędności Bank Polski, 2018).
  • 30.Sałaciński, T., Chrzanowski, J. & Chmielewski, T. Statistical process control using control charts with variable parameters. Processes11, 2744. 10.3390/pr11092744 (2023). [Google Scholar]
  • 31.Eisenstein, E. L. The Printing Revolution in Early Modern Europe (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2005).
  • 32.Lipiak, J. Methodology for assessing the factors affecting the quality and efficiency of flexographic printing process. Procedia Eng.182, 403–411. 10.1016/j.proeng.2017.03.122 (2017). [Google Scholar]
  • 33.Lipiak, J. Methods of improving the flexographic printing process using the process approach and structural and technological changes, (2018).
  • 34.Lipiak, J. & Salwin, M. The improvement of sustainability with reference to the printing Industry – Case study. In Advances in Manufacturing II (eds Hamrol, A. et al.) 254–266 (Springer International Publishing, 2019). 10.1007/978-3-030-17269-5_19. [Google Scholar]
  • 35.Montgomery, D. C. Design and Analysis of Experiments (Wiley, 2020).
  • 36.Field, A. Discovering Statistics Using IBM SPSS Statistics (Sage, 2024).
  • 37.Moghadam, A. S., Babakhani, M. & Hoseini, S. M. S. Investigating the factors influencing customer attraction in the aviation industry using regression, variance analysis and pearson correlation. UCT J. Res. Sci. Eng. Technol.6, 25–19 (2018). [Google Scholar]
  • 38.Elssaedi, M. M., Salih, O. M. & Ahmeed, A. Optimizing selection using Pearson correlation coefficient: A case study in movie industry. Presented at the International Conference on Key Enabling Technologies (Keytech 2019), Istanbul, Turkey (2019). 10.1063/1.5123689
  • 39.Li, R. & Gospodarik, C. G. The Impact of Digital Economy on Economic Growth Based on Pearson Correlation Test Analysis. In: J. Jansen, B., Liang, H., and Ye, J. (eds.) International Conference on Cognitive based Information Processing and Applications (CIPA 2021). pp. 19–27. Springer Singapore, Singapore (2022). 10.1007/978-981-16-5854-9_3
  • 40.Malik, S. U. Customer Satisfaction, perceived service quality and mediating role of perceived value. IJMS4, 68. 10.5539/ijms.v4n1p68 (2012). [Google Scholar]
  • 41.Bilan, Y., Rubanov, P., Vasylieva, T. & Lyeonov, S. The influence of industry 4.0 on financial services: determinants of alternative finance development. PJMS19, 70–93. 10.17512/pjms.2019.19.1.06 (2019). [Google Scholar]
  • 42.Hankammer, S. et al. Customization 4.0: Proceedings of the 9th World Mass Customization & Personalization Conference (MCPC 2017), Aachen, Germany, November 20th-21st, 2017. Springer International Publishing, Cham (2018). 10.1007/978-3-319-77556-2
  • 43.Deykin, E. Y. et al. Posttraumatic stress disorder and the use of health services. Psychosom. Med.63 (5), 835–841 (2001). https://doi.org/10.1097/00006842-200109000-00018. [DOI] [PubMed]
  • 44.Ayala, F., Gaiardelli, N., Pezzotta, P., Le Dain, G. & Frank, M. A. A.G.: Adopting service suppliers for servitisation: which type of supplier involvement is more effective? JMTM. 32, 977–993 (2021). 10.1108/JMTM-09-2020-0374
  • 45.Singh, K. Innovated technology in banking services. J. Internet Bank. Commer.16, 1–15 (2011). [Google Scholar]
  • 46.Sheu, P. L. & Chang, S. C. Relationship of service quality dimensions, customer satisfaction and loyalty in e-commerce: a case study of the shopee app. Appl. Econ.54, 4597–4607. 10.1080/00036846.2021.1980198 (2022). [Google Scholar]
  • 47.Masłowski, D., Salwin, M., Pałęga, M., Chmielewski, T. & Rybczyński, W. The significance of changes in fuel prices in the context of the operations of transport enterprises in Poland and Europe. Transp. Probl.19, 169–182. 10.20858/tp.2023.19.3.14 (2024). [Google Scholar]
  • 48.Ares, G. Mathematical and Statistical Methods in Food Science and Technology. Wiley (2014). 10.1002/9781118434635
  • 49.Tamhane, A. C. & Dunlop, D. D. Statistics and Data Analysis: from Elementary To Intermediate (Prentice Hall, 2000).
  • 50.Adrodegari, F., Saccani, N., Kowalkowski, C. & Vilo, J. PSS business model conceptualization and application. Prod. Plann. Control. 28, 1251–1263. 10.1080/09537287.2017.1363924 (2017). [Google Scholar]
  • 51.James, P., Slob, A. & Nijhuis, L. Enviromental and Social Well Being in the New Economy: Sustainable Services – An Innovation Workbook (University of Bradford, TNO, Bradford, 2001).
  • 52.Aurich, J. C., Mannweiler, C. & Schweitzer, E. How to design and offer services successfully. CIRP J. Manufact. Sci. Technol.2, 136–143. 10.1016/j.cirpj.2010.03.002 (2010). [Google Scholar]
  • 53.Tan, A., McAloone, T. C. & Hagelskjær, L. E. Reflections on product/service-system (PSS) conceptualisation in a course setting. Int. J. Des. Eng. (2009).
  • 54.Salwin, M. & Chmielewski, T. M. Smart Product-Service system for intelligent welding system. In Computational Science – ICCS 2025 Workshops (eds Paszynski, M. et al.) 285–304 (Springer Nature Switzerland, 2025). 10.1007/978-3-031-97573-8_20. [Google Scholar]

Associated Data

This section collects any data citations, data availability statements, or supplementary materials included in this article.

Supplementary Materials

Supplementary Material 1 (20.5KB, docx)

Data Availability Statement

The data supporting the findings of this study are available upon request from the corresponding author. The raw data include survey results and statistical calculations. Due to institutional policy and data privacy considerations, these datasets are not publicly available. However, interested researchers may obtain access to them upon reasonable request by contacting Mariusz Salwin at mariusz.salwin@onet.pl.No proprietary or third-party data were used in this study. Data used in this study may also be made available upon request for academic and research purposes.


Articles from Scientific Reports are provided here courtesy of Nature Publishing Group

RESOURCES