Table 7.
Comparison of results of CCST and benchmark models on BCI IV 2b dataset.
| DA Type | Model | Sub 1 | Sub 2 | Sub 3 | Sub 4 | Sub 5 | Sub 6 | Sub 7 | Sub 8 | Sub 9 | Avg ± SD |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| With DA | CCST | 70.14 | 58.53 | 58.47 | 86.08 | 83.11 | 79.17 | 81.25 | 79.08 | 86.25 | 75.79 |
| EEGConformer | 71.53 | 58.24 | 57.08 | 90.81 | 72.84 | 61.25 | 72.36 | 78.95 | 80.14 | 71.47 | |
| ShallowConvNet | 72.08 | 57.06 | 55.83 | 90.81 | 74.46 | 80.14 | 74.31 | 79.87 | 79.03 | 73.73 | |
| EEGNet | 74.17 | 59.71 | 56.53 | 91.22 | 73.38 | 84.03 | 73.19 | 80.00 | 79.86 | 74.68 | |
| DeepConvNet | 73.61 | 58.97 | 58.61 | 90.54 | 73.78 | 73.19 | 74.44 | 79.47 | 80.14 | 73.64 | |
| TCN | 69.86 | 57.65 | 55.14 | 89.46 | 75.27 | 75.97 | 72.50 | 79.34 | 76.11 | 72.37 | |
| TIDNet | 69.17 | 57.94 | 56.25 | 87.43 | 68.51 | 77.92 | 72.92 | 75.26 | 75.28 | 71.19 | |
| MSCFormer | 76.81 | 55.59 | 55.69 | 91.62 | 74.86 | 65.14 | 73.06 | 76.97 | 80.56 | 72.26 | |
| TCANet | 72.08 | 57.21 | 56.53 | 92.43 | 73.38 | 66.81 | 75.69 | 77.24 | 78.19 | 72.17 | |
| CTNet | 73.75 | 57.35 | 55.56 | 91.62 | 71.22 | 77.22 | 74.17 | 78.68 | 79.31 | 73.21 | |
| EEGInception | 56.25 | 52.65 | 53.33 | 82.70 | 65.00 | 65.00 | 69.17 | 78.29 | 72.08 | 66.05 | |
| Without DA | CCST | 69.31 | 58.09 | 57.92 | 88.24 | 86.22 | 82.78 | 81.11 | 79.74 | 86.11 | 76.61 |
| EEGConformer | 70.42 | 54.41 | 55.00 | 88.65 | 70.81 | 77.50 | 71.53 | 78.29 | 79.58 | 71.80 | |
| ShallowConvNet | 71.94 | 57.79 | 54.58 | 91.76 | 73.38 | 78.75 | 74.72 | 79.21 | 80.83 | 73.66 | |
| EEGNet | 70.69 | 57.21 | 57.36 | 88.38 | 73.38 | 81.94 | 74.31 | 80.00 | 79.72 | 73.67 | |
| DeepConvNet | 70.00 | 56.03 | 57.22 | 88.11 | 67.43 | 72.78 | 69.58 | 79.34 | 77.50 | 70.89 | |
| TCN | 68.75 | 56.18 | 54.44 | 86.76 | 73.65 | 79.03 | 73.06 | 78.42 | 77.50 | 71.98 | |
| TIDNet | 68.06 | 56.03 | 56.53 | 87.30 | 67.57 | 71.67 | 69.03 | 79.21 | 73.33 | 69.86 | |
| MSCFormer | 75.00 | 56.03 | 56.53 | 92.84 | 71.22 | 77.92 | 74.17 | 79.34 | 78.47 | 73.50 | |
| TCANet | 68.19 | 60.59 | 57.50 | 89.46 | 69.19 | 71.25 | 70.83 | 78.42 | 76.53 | 71.33 | |
| CTNet | 67.36 | 56.03 | 57.08 | 91.49 | 71.22 | 75.69 | 75.00 | 79.21 | 77.78 | 72.32 | |
| EEGInception | 68.33 | 52.06 | 55.28 | 87.16 | 65.41 | 71.81 | 70.83 | 78.16 | 74.44 | 69.28 |
Significant values are in [bold].