| 1 | Mandibles with a single internal tooth; paramere slender; elytra broad and rounded, often with a distinct reddish tint; femora rarely bearing yellowish-brown stripes on the underside | Lucanus ogakii |
| – | Mandibles with two or more denticles/teeth; paramere stout; elytra blackish to reddish-brown, not distinctly rounded | 2 |
| 2 | Body piceous to blackish; elytra more nitidous, with finer and sparser punctures; legs uniformly dark; mandibles generally straighter with basal tooth not very close to the base | Lucanus piceus stat. nov. |
| – | Body blackish, reddish-brown, or chocolate-brown; elytra glabrous to slightly pubescent, usually less shining; femora occasionally with yellow to orange plaque; mandibles shorter, robust, and strongly arcuate, with the basal tooth situated close to the base | 3 |
| 3 | Clypeus with well-defined lateral angles; labrum clearly separated from clypeus at the sides; elytra typically glossy; distribution in southern Taiwan mountains | Lucanus kanoi kavulunganus subsp. nov. |
| – | Clypeus without distinct lateral angles (labrum not clearly separated; lateral/frontal ridges not markedly protruding); elytra glabrous to sparsely pubescent and less nitidous; mandibles short, strongly arcuate, with basal tooth very close to the base; distribution in central to northern Taiwan | Lucanus kanoi kanoi |