Skip to main content
. 2026 Jan 22;12:1677867. doi: 10.3389/fsurg.2025.1677867

Table 2.

Quality assessment of the included studies.

Study Selection bias Study design Confounders Blinding Data collection methods Withdrawals and drop-outs Global rating
Orlicky et al. 2019 Moderate Strong Moderate Weak Strong Strong Moderate
McCarthy et al. 2002 Moderate Strong Strong Weak Strong Strong Moderate
Rocha-Neves et al. 2021 Moderate Strong Strong Weak Strong Strong Moderate
Kline et al. 2023 Moderate Moderate Strong Weak Strong Moderate Moderate
Mazzaccaro et al. 2019 Moderate Moderate Moderate Weak Strong Moderate Moderate
Pasin et al. 2015 Moderate Moderate Strong Weak Strong Moderate Moderate
Knappich et al. 2019 Moderate Strong Strong Weak Strong Moderate Moderate
Chou et al. 2016 Moderate Moderate Moderate Weak Strong Moderate Moderate
Dakour Aridi et al. 2018 Moderate Moderate Strong Weak Strong Moderate Moderate
Mendonça et al. 2014 Moderate Moderate Moderate Weak Strong Moderate Moderate
Birchley et al. 2010 Moderate Moderate Moderate Weak Strong Moderate Moderate
Markovic et al. 2012 Moderate Moderate Strong Weak Strong Moderate Moderate
Sternbach et al. 2002 Moderate Moderate Strong Weak Strong Moderate Moderate
McCarthy et al. 2001 Moderate Moderate Moderate Weak Strong Moderate Moderate