Skip to main content
. 2025 Oct 22;17(2):265–276. doi: 10.1017/rsm.2025.10048

Table 2.

Deviation from ROBINS-I domains

Review ROBINS-I domains Domain modification Additional domains
D1 D2 D3 D4 D5 D6 D7
Park 2022 🗶 🗶 🗶
Saunders 2022 🗶
Thielemann 2022 🗶 🗶 🗶
Houttu 2022 🗶
Wong 2022 🗶 🗶
Lin 2022 X M M M M D4: ‘Bias due to knowledge of allocated interventions by participants and personnel’; D6: ‘Detection bias’; D5: ‘Attrition bias’; D7: ‘Reporting bias’
Scuteri 2022 M 🗶 Did not use D1 or D2 but used a domain ‘Baseline differences’
Sousa 2022 M M M M M M Described as a ‘simplified version’, D2/D5: ‘Selection bias’, D3/D6: ‘Information bias’ (relating to recall and detection bias separately), D7: ‘Reporting bias’.
Li 2022 M M Did not use D3 or D4 but added a domain ‘Bias from the interventions’; further details not provided.
Psaltis 2022 M D6: ‘Blinding of outcome assessment’ Added ‘Other bias’
Hensums 2022 🗶 🗶
Essibayi 2022 🗶 🗶 Added ‘Correlation with clinical practice’
El-Andari 2022 M M 🗶 🗶 M M 🗶 D1: ‘Confounding variables’, D2: ‘Group selection’, D5: ‘Missing data’, D6: ‘Classification of outcomes’ Added domains: ‘Recruitment strategy’, ‘Inclusion and exclusion criteria’, ‘Sample size’, ‘Matching’, Statistical methods’, ‘Missing important outcomes’, ‘Follow-up time’ and ‘Incomplete follow-up’
Burns 2022 M D2 was divided into two domains, ‘Sample selection’ and ‘Comparability of the groups’.
Ostapenko 2022 ‘Other source of bias’ (rated as ‘n/a’ for every study)

Note: ‘X’: domain omitted; ✓: domain applied; ‘M’: domain modified.