Table 1.
Methodological characteristics of included studies
| Study | Design | NiBS | SLT | Sessions | Stimulation parameters | Stimulation target | Linguistic test(s) | Post-treatment evaluation | Follow-up(s) evaluation(s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cotelli et al. (2014) | Parallel | tDCS | Picture-naming training | 10 daily sessions(× 2 weeks) | 5 × 5 electrodes; 2 mA, 20 min |
Anode: 8 cm frontally and 6 cm laterally with respect to Cz Cathode: right arm |
Picture naming, AATg, grammar comprehension (BADAh), phonemic fluency, semantic fluency | Immediate post-treatment | 12 weeks from baseline |
| McConathey et al. (2017) | Crossover | tDCS | None (narrative task only) | 10 daily sessions (× 2 weeks) | 5 × 5 electrodes, 1.5 mA, 20 min |
Anode: F7 Cathode: O1 |
Sentence repetition, grammar comprehension (TROGi), semantic fluency, picture naming (BNTj), semantic associations (PPTk) | Immediate post-treatment | 6 and 12 weeks post- treatment |
| Roncero et al. (2017) | Crossover | tDCS | Picture-naming training | 10 daily sessions (× 3 weeks) | 5 × 7 electrodes, 2 mA, 30 min |
Anode: TP9 Cathode: right fronto-orbital area |
Picture naming | Immediate post-treatment | 2 weeks post-treatment |
| Ferrucci et al. (2018) | Crossover | tDCS | None | 5 daily sessions (× 1 week) | 5 × 7 electrodes, 2 mA, 20 min |
Anode: F7 and F8 Cathode: right deltoid |
Phonemic fluency, picture naming | Immediate post-treatment | 1 and 4 weeks post-treatment |
| Hosseini et al. (2019) | Crossover | tDCS | None (narrative task only) | 10 daily sessions (× 2 weeks) | 5 × 5 electrodes, 1.5 mA, 20 min |
Anode: F7 Cathode: O1 |
Semantic fluency, grammar comprehension (TROG), semantic associations (PPT), picture naming (BNT) | Immediate post-treatment | 6 and 12 weeks post-treatment |
| Benussi et al. (2020) | Parallel | tDCS | None | 10 daily sessions (× 2 weeks) | 5 × 7 electrodes, 2 mA, 20 min |
Anode: F3 Cathode: right deltoid |
Phonemic fluency, semantic fluency | Immediate post-treatment | 3 and 6 months from baseline |
| de Aguiar et al., (2020a, 2020b) | Parallel | tDCS | Picture-naming training | 12 daily sessions on average (± 2) (× 3 weeks) | 5 × 5 electrodes, 2 mA, 20 min |
Anode: F7 Cathode: right cheek |
Written picture naming | Immediate post-treatment | 2 weeks and 2 months post-treatment |
| Pytel et al. (2021) | Mixed | rTMS | None | 15 daily sessions (× 3 weeks) | 20 Hz, 20-s inter-train, 1500 pulses, 100% RMTa | Personalized target: LIFGb (9 patients), LSFGc (3 patients), LDLPFCd (6 patients), RSFGe (1 patient), LATLf (1 patient) | Story description, picture naming, story reading, repetition | Within the first 2 weeks post-treatment | None |
| Nissim et al. (2022) | Crossover | tDCS | Constraint-induced language therapy (CILT) | 10 daily sessions (× 2 weeks) | 1-cm diameter round electrodes, 1.5 mA, 20 min |
Anode: FT7 Cathodes: F7, T7, FC5, FT9 |
Western aphasia battery-revised (WAB-R) | Immediate post-treatment | 6 weeks post-treatment |
| Wang et al. (2022) | Parallel | tDCS | Picture-naming training | Approximately 12 daily sessions (× 3 weeks) | 5 × 5 electrodes, 2 mA, 20 min |
Anode: F7 Cathode: right cheek |
Semantic and phonemic fluency | Immediate post-treatment | 2 weeks and 2 months post-treatment |
| Borrego-Ecijia et al. (2023) | Crossover | tDCS | Unspecified SLT type | 10 daily sessions (× 2 weeks) | 1-cm radius round electrodes, max 4 mA, 26 min |
Anodes: F7, FC1, FC5, P7 Cathodes: PO8, C1, FPZ |
Phonemic fluency, semantic fluency, picture naming, single-word comprehension, semantic associations (Camel and Cactus test, PPT), reading | Immediate post-treatment | 1 and 3 months post-treatment |
| Huang et al. (2023) | Parallel | rTMS | None | 20 daily sessions (× 4 weeks) | 10 Hz, 2-s inter-train, 1000 pulses, 120% RMT | LDLPFC | Picture naming, WAB | 1-month post-treatment | 3 and 6 months post-treatment |
aRMT resting motor threshold
bLIFG left inferior frontal gyrus
cLSFG left superior frontal gyrus
dLDLPFC left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex
eRSFG right superior frontal gyrus
fLATL left anterior temporal lobe
gAAT Aachener Aphasie Test
hBADA battery for the analysis of the aphasic deficit
iTROG Penn-Test for reception of grammar
jBNT Boston Naming Test
kPPT Pyramids and Palm Trees Test