Skip to main content
. 2023 Sep 27;8(3):vetevid-8-3-664. doi: 10.18849/ve.v8i3.664

Kanaan et al. (2012).

Population: York X Landrace, Piglet, (US).
Sample size:

56 litters.

Before weaning: 48 litters.

After weaning: 192 piglets selected (48 post-weaning groups of piglets consisting of 16 post-weaning groups per pre-weaning treatment group).

Intervention details:

Pre-weaning treatment groups: Group 1 control, no socialisation (CM0): n = 16 litters. Housing design: Standard farrowing crates from birth until weaning on day 18.

Group 2 socialisation with one unfamiliar litter (CM1): n = 16 litters. Socialisation housing design: co-mingle with one unfamiliar litter from days 10–18. Socialisation was facilitated by removing the barrier between adjacent farrowing pens. Socialisation group size: two litters per pen (socialisation group size is the number of litters that interact with one another during lactation).

Group 3 socialisation with two unfamiliar litter (CM2): n = 16 litters. Socialisation housing design: co-mingle with one unfamiliar litter from days 10–14 then another unfamiliar litter from days 14–18. Socialisation was facilitated by removing the barrier between adjacent farrowing pens. Socialisation group size: two litters per pen.

Study design: Non-randomised controlled trial.
Outcome studied:

Weaning age: approximately day 18.

Socialisation length: 8 days.

Regroup condition: One male and one female from one litter, plus one male and one female from another litter, within the same pre-weaning treatment group. Both pairs of littermates had similar weight and were unfamiliar to one another.

Post-weaning group size: four piglets.

Familiarity ratio: 1:1.

Growth performance:

  • Mean daily weight gain / average daily weight gain (ADWG): days 2, 9, 13, 17, 21 and 25.

    Behavioural indicators:

  • Behavioural tests.

  • Behaviour: 48 hour post-mixing (using 10 min scan sampling).

  • Ear injuries: days 2, 9, 13, 17, 21 and 25. Average ear injuries score for the entire experiment and time points.

    • Social challenge: days 13, 17 and 21. Two unfamiliar piglets = one focal piglet + one piglet from another litter. Observed social interactions for 10 min.

    • Social recognition: days 16 and 25. Social investigation (frequency, duration, and latency).

Main Findings (relevant to PICO question)

Growth performance:

  • Mean daily weight gain / Average daily weight gain (ADWG): no significant difference found for the entire experiment or at any time point.

    Behavioural indicators:

  • Ear injuries: no significant difference found.

  • Behaviour: 48 hours post-mixing.

    • Belly-nosing: CM2 spent a higher proportion of observations performing belly-nosing than CM0 (significant, P = 0.05). CM2 > CM1 > CM0 (trend only).

    • All aggressive interactions: CM1 spent a lower proportion of observations in this than CM0 (significant, P < 0.05). CM1 < CM2 < CM0 (trend only).

    • Aggression towards non-littermates: CM1 spent a lower proportion of observations in this than CM0 (significant, P < 0.05). CM1 < CM2 < CM0 (trend only).

    • All activities with non-littermates:  CM1 < CM0 (trend only), CM2 no significant difference from the two.

  • Behavioural tests – not examined in this review because it did not specifically report post-weaning results.

Limitations:
  • Treatment group allocation method was not stated.

  • The pre-weaning selection criteria of 48 litters out of 56 litters was not explained.

  • Outcomes were measured in focal piglets only.

  • Selection criteria for focal piglets included sex and weight only.

  • Ear injury scoring system was not quantified (vague definition such as score 1 = few scratches).

  • For social challenge or social recognition, the post weaning result was not isolated from the pre weaning result.

  • Total number of piglets before weaning was unknown.

  • Number of piglets in each treatment group pre-weaning and post-weaning was not specified.

  • The number of assessors for behaviours and ear injuries was not specified.