Skip to main content
. 2026 Mar 16;14:1786959. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2026.1786959

Table 2.

Baseline characteristics of the included studies.

Author (1st author et al.) Year Country Study type Population Sample size Intervention Outcome Outcome definition/Cut-offs Effect metrics
Balasubramanian et al. (40) 2003 India Comparative Children/adolescents 80 Ca ± vit D Healing Clinical and x-ray OR 4.8 if Ca < 300 mg
Graff et al. (34) 2004 Nigeria Observational Rickets children 30 Calcium supplementation Ca absorption Fractional absorption ↑ absorption (p = 0.035)
Al-Mekhlafi et al. (41) 2010 Malaysia Cross-sectional study Aboriginal school children 250 Observational Giardiasis and vitamin A status Stool exam; serum retinol <0.7 μmol/L Giardia infection associated with poor vitamin A status
El Kholy et al. (33) 2017 Egypt Prospective cohort Children with rickets 139 Standard therapy + genetics Radiologic healing X-ray healing Genotype influenced response
Thacher et al. (42) 2009 Nigeria Dietary study Rickets children 34 Ca + ergocalciferol Ca/Zn absorption Fractional absorption ↑ Ca absorption (p < 0.001)
Thacher et al. (35) 2014 Nigeria RCT Ca-deficiency rickets 72 Ca ± vitamin D Radiologic healing Score ≤1.5 Combined therapy superior (67%)
Aggarwal et al. (39) 2012 India Case–control Rickets vs. controls 135 Dietary comparison Ca intake Below RDA Lower intake (p < 0.001)
Aggarwal et al. (36) 2013 India RCT Rickets children 67 Vit D, Ca or both Radiologic healing X-ray resolution Combination best (50%)
Ahmed et al. (43) 2020 Bangladesh Case–control Rural children 128 Diet and biochemical 25-OH-D, Ca <25 nmol/L Ca deficiency major contributor
Acoglu et al. (44) 2020 Turkey Case series Refugee children 77 Clinical evaluation Prevalence Radiographic criteria 28.5% rickets
Jain et al. (45) 2011 India Observational Breastfed infants 360 None 25-OH-D <50 nmol/L High deficiency
Wheeler et al. (46) 2015 New Zealand Surveillance Pediatric rickets 106 Monitoring Incidence Radiographic confirmed 2.2/100,000/year
Naik et al. (37) 2017 India RCT Mother-infant dyads 180 Maternal vit D Infant 25-OH-D <50 nmol/L ↑ levels (p < 0.001)
Trivedi et al. (38) 2020 India RCT Mother-infant dyads 210 Maternal vit D Infant 25-OH-D <50 nmol/L ↑ levels (p < 0.001)
Al-Atawi et al. (47) 2009 Saudi Arabia Retrospective Infants 283 Chart review Vit D status <12 nmol/L Severe deficiency common
Huybregts et al. (48) 2017 Burkina Faso and Mali Cluster RCT 6–24 mo children 2000 SQ-LNS Acute malnutrition WLZ < −2 Reduced prevalence
Van Der Kam et al. (49) 2016 Nigeria RCT Post-illness children 399 RUTF vs. micronutrients Nutritional recovery MUAC/WLZ Improved recovery
Soofi et al. (5) 2022 Pakistan Cluster RCT Pregnant women and infants 1,352 LNS supplementation Stunting LAZ < −2 ↓ stunting (p = 0.017)
Dewey et al. (50) 2022 Multicountry IPD Meta-analysis 6–24 mo children 36,795 SQ-LNS Severe wasting/stunting LAZ/WLZ < −3 PR 0.69 (wasting)
Kambale et al. (6) 2023 DR Congo RCT SAM children 400 Probiotics + RUTF Diarrhea duration Days ill Reduced duration (p < 0.001)
Sangalang et al. (7) 2022 Philippines Cluster RCT Schoolchildren 1,558 WaSH BMI, hydration BMI-for-age Improved hygiene
Chek et al. (8) 2022 Malaysia Cluster RCT (protocol) Urban poor <5 yrs 600 Positive deviance program Undernutrition WAZ/HAZ < −2 Protocol
Cazes et al. (51) 2022 DR Congo Non-inferiority RCT 6–59 mo children 981 OptiMA simplified Recovery MUAC ≥125 mm Non-inferior
Lambrecht et al. (52) 2023 Bangladesh Cluster RCT <5 yrs 2,700 Homestead food production Diarrhea, ARI 2-week recall ↓ diarrhea
Grijalva-Eternod et al. (53) 2023 Somalia 2 × 2 factorial cluster RCT IDP households 1,122 Cash transfer + mHealth Malnutrition risk MUAC <125 mm Improved food security
Hojati et al. (54) 2023 Iran RCT (protocol) Preschool children 120 Nutrition mobile app Knowledge, WAZ/HAZ <−2 SD Protocol
Daures et al. (55) 2022 Niger 3-arm RCT (protocol) 6–59 mo children 1,200 Simplified community care Recovery MUAC ≥125 mm Non-inferiority design
Tamara et al. (56) 2022 Indonesia Double-blind RCT Children with pulmonary TB 84 Vitamin D supplementation Fever and cough resolution time Clinical symptom resolution Faster fever resolution (p < 0.05)
Tickell et al. (57) 2023 Kenya RCT Caregivers and children 6–59 mo 1,200 Family MUAC + 2-way SMS Early wasting detection MUAC <125 mm Improved detection rates
Cazes et al. (58) 2023 DR Congo Non-inferiority RCT SAM children 1,282 Reduced RUTF dosage Nutritional recovery MUAC ≥125 mm and no edema Reduced dose non-inferior
Batool et al. (59) 2023 Pakistan Double-blind parallel RCT Children with severe acute malnutrition (SAM) 110 Prebiotic supplementation vs. placebo Nutritional recovery; gut health MUAC ≥125 mm; WHZ ≥ −2 Improved weight gain and gut biomarkers (p < 0.05)
Rahman et al. (60) 2025 Bangladesh RCT protocol (CRADLE trial) Pregnant women and young children 800 Installation of household concrete floors Maternal and child health; infection; growth Diarrhea prevalence; anthropometry Protocol – results pending
Vilander et al. (61) 2022 Mali and Nicaragua RCT Infants 6–12 months 95 Dietary rice bran supplementation Microbiota diversity; enteric dysfunction Fecal sIgA; microbiome indices ↑ microbiota diversity and sIgA (p < 0.05)
Soofi et al. (62) 2022 Pakistan Cluster RCT Children <18 months 2,357 Unconditional cash transfer ± LNS ± BCC Stunting prevention LAZ < −2 SD Reduced stunting risk (RR ≈ 0.80)
Bhargava et al. (63) 2023 India Open-label cluster RCT Household contacts of pulmonary TB patients 10,345 Nutritional supplementation (food rations) TB incidence Microbiologically confirmed TB ~39% relative reduction in TB incidence
Kirolos et al. (64) 2024 Malawi Prospective observational cohort study Adolescents with prior severe childhood malnutrition 352 Long-term follow-up of SAM survivors (LOSCM study) Growth, body composition, cardiometabolic risk, cognitive outcomes Anthropometry; metabolic markers; neurocognitive testing Persistent deficits in growth and lean mass; increased cardiometabolic risk indicators
Argaw et al. (65) 2023 Burkina Faso 2 × 2 factorial individually randomized controlled trial Pregnant and lactating women and their infants 1,897 Fortified balanced energy–protein supplementation during pregnancy and/or lactation Infant growth outcomes; stunting LAZ; WLZ; WAZ; stunting (LAZ < −2) Improved linear growth in supplemented groups
Liu et al. (66) 2022 China Cluster randomized clinical trial Primary school children 1,392 Multifaceted obesity prevention intervention (nutrition education + physical activity + behavioral change) BMI; overweight/obesity prevalence BMI z-scores; overweight/obesity per WHO criteria Significant reduction in BMI gain and obesity prevalence
Kohl et al. (67) 2022 Haiti Randomized controlled trial protocol Caregivers and young children 600 Integrated responsive parenting, nutrition and hygiene intervention (Grandi Byen) Child growth and development; caregiving practices Anthropometry; developmental scales Protocol – effectiveness outcomes pending
Ow et al. (68) 2025 Vietnam Randomized controlled trial Children with or at risk for undernutrition 321 Long-term oral nutritional supplementation + dietary counseling Growth; body composition; bone mineralization Height-for-age; body fat %; bone mineral density Significant improvements in growth and bone mineralization
Nuzhat et al. (69) 2023 Bangladesh Randomized clinical trial Severely malnourished young infants 160 Probiotic and synbiotic supplementation Ponderal and linear growth Weight-for-age (WAZ); Length-for-age (LAZ); WLZ Improved weight gain; modest improvement in linear growth
Sié et al. (70) 2024 Burkina Faso Randomized controlled trial (secondary analysis) Infants 21,832 Single-dose azithromycin Anthropometric growth outcomes Weight-for-age; Height-for-age; MUAC No clinically meaningful improvement in growth outcomes
Taneja et al. (71) 2022 India Factorial individually randomized controlled trial Women (preconception/pregnancy) and children to 24 months 7,500 Integrated package: health, nutrition, psychosocial stimulation and WaSH Birth outcomes; linear growth at 24 months LAZ at 24 months; birth weight Improved birth weight; modest gains in linear growth
Ricci et al. (72) 2024 South Africa Randomized controlled trial Infants aged 6–9 months 500 Egg introduced as early complementary food Growth (length and weight gain) LAZ; WAZ; WLZ Improved length gain; reduced risk of stunting
Wang et al. (73) 2022 Tanzania Double-blind randomized controlled trial Pregnant women and their children 1,000 Prenatal and postnatal maternal multiple micronutrient supplementation Child growth; morbidity LAZ; WAZ; morbidity incidence Improved child growth indicators; reduced morbidity risk
Gebretsadik et al. (74) 2023 Ethiopia (Tigray) Cross-sectional study Children aged 6–59 months in war-affected communities 614 Exposure: conflict-related, household and community-level factors Acute malnutrition prevalence WHZ < −2 SD and/or MUAC <125 mm High prevalence of acute malnutrition; associated with food insecurity, displacement, poor sanitation
Khadilkar et al. (75) 2025 India Randomized controlled trial (6 months) Children aged 3–6.9 years with growth faltering 330 Oral nutritional supplementation + dietary counseling vs. counseling alone Linear catch-up growth Height-for-age z-score (HAZ); growth velocity Significant improvement in linear growth and catch-up growth rates
Datoo et al. (76) 2022 Burkina Faso Phase 1/2b randomized controlled trial Children (5–17 months at enrollment) 450 R21/Matrix-M malaria vaccine Clinical malaria incidence; immunogenicity PCR-confirmed clinical malaria; antibody titers High vaccine efficacy maintained over 2 years; strong immunogenic response
Smith et al. (77) 2022 Zimbabwe Randomized controlled trial protocol (CHAIN trial) Infants and young children (IYCF intervention in rural communities) 1,920 Improved infant and young child feeding (IYCF) intervention integrated with agriculture and nutrition support Child growth; dietary diversity; stunting LAZ; minimum dietary diversity; stunting (LAZ < −2) Protocol – outcomes pending
George et al. (78) 2025 Democratic Republic of the Congo Cluster-randomized controlled trial Households with young children in cholera-endemic areas 2,400 PICHA7 WASHmobile program (water, sanitation, hygiene + mHealth support) Diarrhea; cholera; child growth Caregiver-reported diarrhea; confirmed cholera; anthropometry Reduced diarrhea and cholera incidence; improved growth indicators
Alam et al. (79) 2022 Bangladesh Double-blind randomized controlled trial protocol Children with severe acute malnutrition (SAM) 124 L-Carnitine supplementation vs. placebo Rate of weight gain; biomarkers of environmental enteric dysfunction (EED) g/kg/day weight gain; EED biomarkers Protocol – effectiveness outcomes pending
Lautatzis et al. (2) 2024 Bangladesh Secondary analysis of randomized trial Infants of mothers receiving supplementation 1,100 Maternal vitamin D supplementation Infantile rickets incidence Clinical and radiological diagnosis of rickets Maternal supplementation reduced risk of infantile rickets
Dabas et al. (1) 2023 India Randomized controlled open-label trial Children with nutritional rickets 120 Daily vs. weekly oral vitamin D3 Correction of rickets Radiological and biochemical resolution Daily vitamin D3 achieved faster correction than weekly regimen
Saluja et al. (9) 2022 India Randomized clinical trial Children with nutritional rickets 100 Low-dose depot oral vitamin D3 vs. daily oral vitamin D3 Rickets resolution Radiological improvement and serum 25(OH)D normalization Both regimens effective; daily dose slightly faster
Aggarwal et al. (36) 2013 India Randomized controlled trial Children with nutritional rickets 180 Standard treatment vs. structured supplementation Nutritional rickets resolution Radiological scoring and biochemical markers Structured regimen improved biochemical correction
Wu et al. (80) 2023 Global (IPD meta-analysis) Systematic review + individual participant data meta-analysis Children/adolescents with vitamin D deficiency 3,200 Vitamin D supplementation Bone density improvement BMD z-score; DXA measurements Supplementation improved bone density; effect modified by baseline deficiency
Wangeci (81) 2022 Kenya Observational study Children 6–59 months with acute malnutrition 245 N/A (cross-sectional assessment) Nutritional rickets prevalence Clinical and radiological diagnosis High prevalence of rickets among SAM children
Mondal et al. (82) 2024 India Open-label randomized controlled trial Children aged 1–10 years with vitamin D deficiency 130 Daily vs. fortnightly oral vitamin D3 Correction of vitamin D deficiency Serum 25(OH)D normalization Daily dosing more effective than fortnightly for rapid correction
Reyes et al. (83) 2024 Multinational Randomized controlled trial Young children (different latitudes) 1,560 Weekly vitamin D supplementation Prevention of acute respiratory infections Clinically diagnosed ARI episodes Vitamin D reduced incidence of ARI, effect stronger at higher latitudes
Ganmaa et al. (84) 2024 Mongolia Multicentre double-blind randomized placebo-controlled trial Schoolchildren 4,700 Vitamin D supplementation Fracture prevention (secondary outcome) Incident fractures recorded Vitamin D reduced fracture risk modestly in school-aged children
Goyal et al. (85) 2022 India Randomized controlled trial Infants 150 Sunlight exposure vs. oral vitamin D supplementation Prevention of vitamin D deficiency Serum 25(OH)D levels < 50 nmol/L Vitamin D supplementation more effective than sunlight alone
Gora et al. (86) 2023 India Randomized controlled trial Infants with symptomatic vitamin D deficiency 120 Daily vs. monthly oral vitamin D3 Correction of vitamin D deficiency Serum 25(OH)D normalization Daily dosing achieved faster correction than monthly dosing
O’Callaghan et al. (87) 2022 Bangladesh Follow-up of randomized controlled trial Offspring of mothers receiving prenatal/postpartum vitamin D 850 Maternal prenatal and postpartum vitamin D supplementation Offspring bone mass and muscle strength DXA bone mineral density; grip strength Increased bone mass and muscle strength at early childhood
Roberson et al. (88) 2023 USA Secondary analysis of RCT (VITC, thiamine, hydrocortisone in sepsis) Sepsis survivors 501 IV vitamin C, thiamine, and hydrocortisone Cognitive, psychological, functional outcomes Standardized neurocognitive and psychological assessments No significant long-term cognitive or functional benefit observed
Cashman et al. (89) 2022 Multinational (High latitude, dark-skinned populations) IPD meta-analysis of RCTs Children and adults 1,230 Vitamin D supplementation Dietary requirement estimation for vitamin D Serum 25(OH)D ≥ 50 nmol/L Provided evidence-based vitamin D intake recommendations for high-latitude dark-skinned populations
Khalil et al. (90) 2024 UK and Europe Protocol – prospective multicentre mixed-methods feasibility study Monochorionic twin pregnancies with early-onset selective fetal growth restriction 60 RCT: intervention vs. expectant management Feasibility outcomes; maternal and neonatal safety Recruitment, retention, protocol adherence Protocol study – feasibility outcomes; effectiveness pending
Yadav et al. (91) 2022 India Randomized controlled trial Term breastfed infants 140 Vitamin D3 800 IU/day vs. 400 IU/day Prevention of vitamin D deficiency Serum 25(OH)D < 50 nmol/L 800 IU/day more effective than 400 IU/day
Bashiri et al. (92) 2024 Saudi Arabia Randomized controlled trial Children with epilepsy on antiseizure medications 120 Vitamin D supplementation Serum vitamin D levels; seizure control Serum 25(OH)D; seizure frequency Improved vitamin D status; no significant change in seizures
Raju et al. (93) 2024 India Double-blind randomized controlled trial Young children 160 Vitamin D supplementation Prevention of acute respiratory infections Clinically diagnosed ARI Reduced ARI incidence compared with placebo
Sharma et al. (94) 2025 USA Randomized controlled study Children with obesity and difficult-to-treat asthma 75 1-year weight management program Asthma control; weight BMI z-score; asthma control questionnaire Improved weight and asthma outcomes
Matheny et al. (95) 2025 USA Randomized controlled trial Adults undergoing contrast procedures 210 Intervention to prevent contrast-associated AKI Incidence of AKI Serum creatinine ≥0.3 mg/dL or ≥50% increase Sustained reduction in AKI incidence post-intervention
Wiafe et al. (96) 2023 Ghana Randomized controlled trial Early adolescents 240 Nutrition education and counselling Nutritional status; anemia Hemoglobin <12 g/dL; anthropometry Improved hemoglobin levels and nutritional status
Al-Mekhlafi et al. (97) 2013 Yemen Randomized controlled trial Children 6–59 months 300 Vitamin A supplementation Iron status; anemia Hemoglobin <11 g/dL; serum ferritin Vitamin A improved iron indices and reduced anemia prevalence
Powers et al. (98) 2017 USA Randomized clinical trial Young children with nutritional iron-deficiency anemia 150 Ferrous sulfate vs. iron polysaccharide complex Hemoglobin concentration Hb < 11 g/dL Both treatments increased Hb; ferrous sulfate slightly faster response
Stewart et al. (99) 2020 Madagascar Multi-arm cluster-randomized controlled trial Children 6–24 months 1,500 Lipid-based nutrient supplementation (LNS) Anemia; micronutrient status Hb < 11 g/dL; serum ferritin Reduced anemia prevalence and improved micronutrient levels
Abrha et al. (100) 2016 Ethiopia Community-based cross-sectional study Preschool children 420 Observational Clinical manifestations of vitamin A deficiency Bitot’s spots, night blindness High prevalence of VAD in rural district; associated with poor diet
Nigusse and Gebretsadik (101) 2021 Ethiopia Cross-sectional study Children 6–59 months 500 Observational Vitamin A supplementation coverage; ocular signs Clinical VAD signs; supplementation status Moderate coverage; VAD signs present in unsupplemented children
Okyere et al. (102) 2022 Ghana Demographic and Health Survey analysis Children 6–59 months 12,000 Observational Trends and inequalities in vitamin A supplementation Receipt of VAS in last 6 months Coverage improved over 2003–2014; inequalities by region and SES
Atukunda et al. (103) 2021 Uganda Secondary analysis of RCT Children 6–59 months 400 Education trial; urine iodine markers Growth and development Height-for-age, weight-for-age, cognitive development Urinary iodine associated with better growth outcomes
Hess et al. (104) 2015 Burkina Faso Cluster-randomized trial Children 6–36 months 1,200 Small-quantity LNS + iodized salt Iodine status Urinary iodine concentration (UIC) Improved iodine status in LNS + salt group
Tariku et al. (105) 2016 Ethiopia Community-based cross-sectional study Preschool children 1–5 years 450 Observational Vitamin A deficiency and determinants Serum retinol <0.7 μmol/L VAD prevalent; associated with diet and socioeconomic factors
Williams et al. (106) 2021 Malawi Observational survey Children 6–59 months 1,100 Observational Vitamin A deficiency and excess Serum retinol; plasma retinol >1.3 μmol/L VAD declined; some children had elevated vitamin A levels
Yisak et al. (107) 2020 Ethiopia Mixed methods cross-sectional Preschool children 1–5 years 520 Observational Clinical VAD prevalence Bitot’s spots, night blindness Prevalence of clinical VAD; associated with diet and maternal knowledge
Hotz et al. (108) 2012 Zambia Observational cross-sectional Preschool children 360 Observational Plasma retinol; infection status Serum retinol <0.7 μmol/L Vitamin A intake and infection influenced plasma retinol levels
Abou-Rizk et al. (109) 2021 Lebanon Cross-sectional survey Syrian refugee mothers and children <5 years 800 Observational Anemia and nutritional status Hemoglobin <11 g/dL; anthropometry High prevalence of anemia and undernutrition among refugees
Leidman et al. (110) 2018 Bangladesh Cross-sectional survey Rohingya children 6–59 months 1,200 Observational Acute malnutrition and anemia WHZ < −2 SD; Hb < 11 g/dL High rates of acute malnutrition and anemia in refugee camp
Jeremias et al. (111) 2023 Lebanon Mixed-methods study Syrian refugee children 6–23 months 420 Observational Anemia prevalence Hemoglobin <11 g/dL High anemia prevalence; qualitative insights from mothers and healthcare staff
Ajakaye et al. (112) 2020 Nigeria Cross-sectional survey Children in IDP camps 300 Observational Malaria, anemia, malnutrition Hb < 11 g/dL; WHZ < −2 SD; malaria parasitemia High prevalence of malaria, anemia, and malnutrition; risk factors identified
Ndemwa et al. (113) 2011 Kenya Cross-sectional survey Women and children in Kakuma Refugee Camp 450 Observational Iron status and hemoglobin Serum ferritin <12 μg/L; Hb < 11 g/dL Availability of micronutrient powder associated with improved iron status
Uijterschout et al. (114) 2014 Netherlands Cross-sectional study Healthy young children 200 Observational Iron deficiency prevalence Serum ferritin <12 μg/L; Hb < 11 g/dL Identified risk factors for iron deficiency in low-risk population
Vendt et al. (115) 2007 Estonia Cross-sectional study Infants 9–12 months 180 Observational Iron deficiency anemia Hb < 11 g/dL; ferritin <12 μg/L Moderate prevalence of IDA; causes mainly dietary
Andriani et al. (116) 2023 Indonesia Repeated cross-sectional surveys; multilevel analysis Children under 5 5,000 Observational Triple burden of malnutrition Stunting, wasting, overweight Determinants include socioeconomic and feeding practices
Benedict et al. (22) 2021 Thailand Cross-sectional study Children under 5 1,200 Observational Double burden of malnutrition Stunting and overweight Associated with suboptimal infant/child feeding practices
Chee et al. (117) 2021 Malaysia Cross-sectional study Pre-adolescent children 350 Observational Vitamin D status Serum 25(OH)D < 50 nmol/L Vitamin D deficiency associated with modifiable lifestyle factors (sun exposure, diet)
Rashid et al. (118) 2022 Malaysia Cluster randomized controlled trial protocol Preschool child–parent dyads 460 Interactive Malaysian Childhood Healthy Lifestyle (i-MaCHeL) program Weight-related behaviors; BMI BMI z-scores; behavioral assessments Protocol – behavioral and BMI outcomes pending