Table 1.
Dataset of the three national evaluations
| National Programme for Information Technology | Global Digital Exemplar Programme | Artificial Intelligence Lab | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Timeline | 2009–2011 | 2017–2020 | 2024 |
| Design | 12 longitudinal case studies | 34 longitudinal case studies | Largely retrospective |
| Number and type of participants |
431 interviews 174 IT managers, 140 healthcare staff, 10 programme staff, 10 managers of medical records libraries and the outpatient departments, 6 finance directors, 9 local service providers, 5 system vendors, 13 others |
628 interviews (143 clinical digital leaders, 140 operational staff, 112 non-clinical digital leaders, 90 programme staff, 71 senior managers, 61 policymakers, 4 engagement leads 3 vendors, and 4 others |
85 interviews 22 NHS England staff, 15 academics, 14 suppliers, 8 Department of Health staff, 6 previous AI Lab staff, 3 regulators, and 17 others |
| Number of documents | 809 | 389 | 1021 |
| Number of observations | 590 | 217 | 12 |