Abstract
The Chiropractic Academy for Research Leadership (CARL) was formed in 2016 as a global mentorship program for early career researchers in chiropractic. CARL is a three-year program anchored around three week-long residentials, alternating between Denmark, Australia, and Canada, with ongoing online activities and project work between residentials. This paper reports on activities and outputs of the second cohort of CARL Fellows, CARL II, that ran from 2020 to 2024. Despite disruptions from the global COVID pandemic, the CARL II cohort was successful in forming a tightly knit group of fourteen early career researchers from seven countries in Australia, Europe, and North America. CARL Fellows co-produced a range of research and leadership outputs, including 70 peer-reviewed manuscripts, and hosted two online conferences (CARLoquium) to support global research engagement during the pandemic. With the completion of the second cohort and recruitment of the third cohort completed, all underwritten by global financial support from chiropractic organizations, CARL is established as a global program building research capacity and academic critical mass in chiropractic.
Supplementary Information
The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12998-026-00641-3.
Keywords: Leadership program, Mentoring, Research capacity, Chiropractic, Early career researcher
Background
The chiropractic profession has faced significant challenges in establishing a robust research culture, essential for advancing evidence-based practice and improving patient care1–3. The lack of a mature research environment within chiropractic institutions is largely attributed to deficiencies in research capacity and leadership, exacerbated by the limited presence of chiropractic programs in major universities4. This challenge necessitates a concerted effort to build leadership and research capacity globally within the field, which is why we established the Chiropractic Academy for Research Leadership (CARL)—a global strategic initiative aimed at fostering research leadership and enhancing the evidence base for chiropractic practice2.
CARL is a competitive-entry program that aims to develop a critical mass of successful early career researchers through international networking and collaborations, all under the mentorship of senior academics. It is a three-year program anchored by yearly week-long residentials, self-directed online activities, and on-going project work. The residentials aim to provide dedicated and protected time from the day-to-day pressure of work environments, thus allowing for reflection and deeper discussions on advancing chiropractic and musculoskeletal research, academic leadership, personal and professional growth. The senior academic mentors in CARL also provide mentorship support and advice regarding individual research programs, strategic development, networking, and career pathways2,5.
The first CARL cohort consisted of 13 Fellows from seven countries and ran from 2017 to 2020. The visible output of CARL I was 38 scientific papers in 20 different journals, 81 conference presentations, professional advancement, and awards of many competitive grants. In these early years the CARL program soon became identified as a catalyst for career direction and growth, while fostering development of an effective and significant network of international collaborators in chiropractic5. The more invisible output was the personal value for the Fellows in terms of collegiality, friendship, and personal growth. As such, the CARL program demonstrated relevance and productivity that directly addressed both the challenge of fostering a mature international chiropractic research culture and infrastructure as well as the need for personal network and mentorship for early career researchers. Consequently, the three mentors in CARL decided to continue the program by recruiting a second cohort of Fellows, CARL II. This paper reports on the recruitment of the CARL II cohort, describes the selection of Fellows, the course and content of the program, summarizes the scientific and leadership activities and outputs, and finally reports on reflections from a workshop that aimed to capture the more intangible value of the program.
Main text
In August 2019, the three mentors issued a call of interest for early career researchers, i.e., PhD students or those up to 3 years post-PhD completion, interested in joining the CARL program. Forty-one candidates from eight countries applied, of which 28 were selected for online interviews with the mentors. Following interviews, 14 Fellows from seven countries (Australia 4, Canada 3, Denmark 2, USA 2, Norway 1, Switzerland 1, UK 1) were selected and included in the CARL II cohort. The CARL II cohort officially joined the program in March 2020 and completed the program in August 2024 with the planned three-year program extended by two years due to COVID.
Structure and activities in CARL II
COVID and CARLoquium
The first residential for the CARL II cohort was scheduled for May 2020 in Sydney, Australia. However, global COVID-19 travel restrictions began in March 2020, forcing the program to shift to online meetings for interaction and project planning. During these early meetings, the Fellows proposed hosting an online international conference using a virtual platform that enables participants to create avatars and navigate a virtual conference center complete with auditoriums, poster halls, and meeting spaces. The resulting event, CARLoquium, was announced on social media, with a participation fee of 35 USD to cover software costs and prize funds (Fig. 1). Due to the pandemic restrictions continuing for nearly two years, two CARLoquium conferences were eventually conducted: the first in March 2021 and the second in March 2022. Each conference was a live two-day online event featuring keynote lectures and poster sessions, moderated and organized by CARL II Fellows. The 2021 conference accepted 108 abstract submissions, and the 2022 conference accepted 77 abstract submissions. The success of CARLoquium directly informed the platform and format of the 17th International Forum for Back and Neck Pain Research in Primary Care, which was also held online in 2021 due to restrictions in international travel.
Fig. 1.
Advertising for the 2021 CARLoquium
Residentials
Three week-long residentials were held for CARL II: Odense, Denmark in August 2022, Sydney, Australia in October 2023, and Edmonton, Canada in August 2024. All Fellows participated in all residentials except one who missed one residential. Residentials included guest speakers, workshops, worktime, and daily physical activity. Guest speakers represented successful early career and senior academics from different fields who presented and discussed diverse topics with the fellows such as career planning and trajectories, work-life balance in academia, equality in research, new strategies in academic publishing, research about management and leadership, and how to navigate social media and the press. A much valued and recurrent session throughout the residentials was “Problem Solved”. Here Fellows presented a professional or personal challenge within the ‘safe space’ of the CARL Fellowship, with the Fellow and wider group then exploring and providing reflections. This format helps provide fresh, useful perspectives and an opportunity to ‘share’ issues that may not normally be aired in a local work environment. The residentials also facilitated substantial periods for Fellows to undertake group work to develop and advance project design, data analyses, and manuscript writing. Finally, one daily session was collective physical activity that included walks, yoga, football (soccer), and zumba. To further encourage collaboration and discussion, regional CARL Senior Fellows, i.e., Fellows from previous CARL cohorts local to the region where the residential was held, were invited to join one day of the residential.
Outputs
Scientific
CARL II was highly productive. The Fellows engaged in a wide range of scientific projects together, mainly based on existing data but also with regards to newly collected data and reviews of scientific literature. A CARL II publication was defined as a paper published in a peer-reviewed journal that included at least two Fellows with or without a mentor or a paper with at least one Fellow and at least one mentor. From 2020–2024, there were 70 peer-reviewed CARL II publications, and the Fellows presented 50 poster or podium presentations at national or international conferences. Outside of CARL, the Fellows collectively published a total of 171 peer-reviewed papers during the period of the program (Table 1).
Table 1.
Scientific and leadership output, awards, degrees and promotions, and research grants for the CARL II cohort 2020 – 2024
| Scientific output | |
| CARL papers* | 70 |
| Conference presentations | 50 |
| Non-CARL papers** | 171 |
| Leadership output | |
| Keynote talks, workshops, podcasts, committees, editorial | 130 |
| Awards | |
| Honorary or scientific | 23 |
| Degrees and promotions | |
| PhD degrees | 9 |
| Promotions | 22 |
| Research grants | |
| Research grants | 63 |
| Total amount € | 21,226,510 |
*A CARL paper has two CARL II Fellows or one Fellow and one mentor as authors
**A non-CARL paper has only one CARL II Fellow as author
Leadership activities and awards
The CARL II Fellows undertook numerous new leadership activities while supported by the CARL program including presenting national and international conference keynote talks, leading workshops or moderating sessions at conferences and meetings, participating in academic and research podcasts, accepting invitations to become members of scientific and professional committees and boards, directing courses, and undertaking editorial work for scientific journals. Collectively, CARL II Fellows engaged in 130 leadership activities during their time on the program. CARL II Fellows received a total of 23 awards including honorary awards and awards for scientific presentations (Table 1).
Degrees, promotions and grants
Nine fellows were awarded their PhD degree during the CARL II period. In addition, 22 promotions or appointments to new academic positions were achieved across the CARL II cohort during the program. Collectively, CARL II Fellows were awarded 63 competitive research grants from a range of funding bodies as primary- or co-investigators for a total value of € 21,226,510 during their time on the program (Table 1).
Workshop about importance of CARL
During the Edmonton residential (2024), a half-day workshop about the deeper meaning of CARL, what CARL has meant for the Fellows personally, and the perceived impact on the chiropractic profession was held. Four North American Senior Fellows (Funabashi, Pohlman, Pagé, De Carvalho) joined the CARL II Fellows for this workshop, led by a Canadian expert in learning program design, development, and delivery (https://www.flip-learning.ca/). Mentors and Fellows were divided into three groups with each group tasked with producing an image and a statement that communicated the output from their discussions (Table 2).
Table 2.
Statements recorded by the three groups of CARL II and North American senior CARL Fellows during a workshop at the edmonton residential in 2024
| Group 1 statement | Group 2 statement | Group 3 statement |
|---|---|---|
|
The CARL program gave me a unique opportunity and space to grow professionally, collaborate internationally, and become a research leader in chiropractic The deep friendships gained through CARL have been life changing |
CARL transformed me as a researcher and as a person It made me learn and think about things I didn’t necessarily think were possible Through the experience of CARL, I have grown and sustained a network of collaborators I really enjoy working with CARL demonstrated the importance of, and skills to cultivate, a thriving and joyful work-culture I attribute my tenured position to the skills and connections I built as a CARL Fellow I feel more confident to tackle complex research problems because of my own development and the backup in the group |
CARL provided the community that drove my career forward CARL provided the community that continues to drive and fuel my career and personal growth The chiropractic profession is in a better place because of CARL Leave the campground in a better shape than when you found it |
Detailed list of outputs from the CARL II cohort can be found in Online Appendix 1.
Discussion
Despite initial challenges during the global COVID lockdown, CARL II was a highly successful and productive cohort. Research and leadership outputs combined with academic professional advancement, scientific and professional awards, and award of substantial grant funding establish the CARL II Fellows as part of the future global scientific leadership in chiropractic. Importantly, with completion of the second cohort, the CARL mentorship program has become established as a key piece of infrastructure in building global chiropractic academic critical mass for the future.
Mentorship programs can significantly enhance the career development of healthcare researchers by offering a collaborative and supportive network, tailored guidance, and support. Frei et al. reviewed 14 studies dealing with academic mentorship programs in healthcare and concluded that they were beneficial particularly for those inclined towards research careers, thereby emphasizing mentorship's role in guiding strategic career choices7. Mentorship programs can foster the development of essential professional behaviors and skills vital for a successful career in healthcare research through improvements in collaboration and interprofessional teamwork, which are core elements in CARL8. Importantly, mentorship programs not only enhance individual competencies but also serve to bolster institutional and profession-related research outputs by higher retention rates and higher rates of research productivity among people who have been mentorship program participants9,10. This underscores the potential of mentorship programs such as CARL to not only enhance individual researcher capabilities but also to foster a collaborative research culture within an institution and a profession.
A regular theme of discussion among CARL II Fellows and the mentors was diversity, equity, and inclusion in research and the chiropractic profession. Discussions about gender issues were particularly prominent. Therefore, CARL is proud that 46% of CARL I Fellows and 50% of CARL II Fellows are women. Most keynote speakers at both CARLoquium conferences were women, and in 2022, poster presenters were 47% women (gender data not collected in 2021). The CARLoquium conference data outperforms the data on gender diversity at other chiropractic research conferences between 2010 and 2019, highlighted in a 2023 CARL II publication6.
Mentors for the first two cohorts were male-only, however, for CARL III a senior female chiropractic academic (Diana De Carvalho) has been included as a mentor.
The chiropractic profession still faces significant challenges in cultivating a robust research culture, necessary for the progression of evidence-based practice and the integration of chiropractic care within broader healthcare systems. One of the most prominent challenges stems from the differing views as to the importance of research and evidence within the chiropractic profession, which impedes unified efforts towards advancing research initiatives and even creates a hesitance within some groups in chiropractic to adopt evidence-based standards of care11,12. Exacerbating these challenges, current chiropractic research environments are hampered by limited resources and an absence of structured mentorship programs, resulting in a cycle where inadequate research activity fails to stimulate growth within the chiropractic research community4. CARL addresses these challenges directly, and the broad financial support for CARL from chiropractic organizations globally reveals a desire by chiropractic political leaders to improve the academic critical mass within chiropractic. This alone illustrates the need for and viability of CARL, evidence of which are the secured resources globally to support a CARL III cohort, consisting of 16 new fellows selected through a competitive process. Of note, one of the CARL Mentors (Jon Adams) is founder and mentor in similar programs for other health professions fx the SOLAR program in osteopathy that follows a similar framework13. Future developments in structure and funding models will likely be inspired between these networks.
A few months after completion of the last residential for the CARL II cohort and shortly after recruitment of CARL III, one of the founders and mentors, Professor Greg Kawchuk, became critically ill and passed away. Professor Kawchuk’s contribution to CARL as a mentor and friend for CARL I and CARL II Fellows as well as a very visible advocate for academic development in chiropractic and evidence-based patient care cannot be overestimated. He is dearly missed. Professor Diana De Carvalho, herself a CARL I Fellow, has been selected as a new mentor in CARL.
Conclusions
The Chiropractic Academy for Research Leadership, CARL, has established itself as a vehicle for building global academic capacity in the chiropractic profession. The second cohort of CARL Fellows, CARL II, was highly productive in terms of scientific and leadership outputs and many Fellows completed degrees and achieved academic promotions. In addition, the personal value of CARL for individual careers were highlighted by the Fellows. Funding for CARL III has been secured, and the new cohort of Fellows have been recruited.
Supplementary Information
Acknowledgements
This paper and all outputs are dedicated to Professor Greg Kawchuk who tragically passed away shortly after completion of the CARL II cohort.
Abbreviations
- CARL
Chiropractic Academy for Research Leadership
- COVID
Coronavirus disease
Author contributions
All authors participated in design and collection of information and data. JH drafted the first version of this manuscript. All authors reviewed critically and contributed with edits and revisions.
Funding
CARL Fellows and Mentors are grateful to sponsors of the CARL II Cohort: Australian. Chiropractors Association, European Center for Chiropractic Research Excellence, Vancouver Foundation, Chiropractic Research Council, UK, Canadian Chiropractic Association, Clinical Compass, Forward Thinking Chiropractic Alliance, Chiropractic Knowledge Hub, Chiropractic and Manual therapies.
Data availability
Not applicable.
Declarations
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Not applicable.
Consent for publication
All authors have consented the enclosed manuscript for publication.
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
Footnotes
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
References
- 1.Weis CA, et al. Assessing research culture and capacity amongst faculty at a North American chiropractic institution: an explanatory mixed methods study. Chiropr Man Therap. 2024;32:35. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 2.Adams J, et al. Leadership and capacity building in international chiropractic research: introducing the chiropractic academy for research leadership (CARL). Chiropr Man Therap. 2018;26:5. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 3.Borkowski D, McKinstry C, Cotchett M, Williams C, Haines T. Research culture in allied health: a systematic review. Aust J Prim Health. 2016;22:294–303. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 4.Coulter ID, Herman PM. The research crisis in American institutions of complementary and integrative health: one proposed solution for chiropractic profession. Chiropr Man Therap. 2019;27:32. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 5.Hartvigsen J, et al. Leadership and capacity building in chiropractic research: report from the first CARL cohort. Chiropr Man Therap. 2021;29:9. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 6.Aspinall SL, et al. Presenters at chiropractic research conferences 2010–2019: is there a gender equity problem? Chiropr Man Therap. 2023;31:28. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 7.Frei E, Stamm M, Buddeberg-Fischer B. Mentoring programs for medical students - a review of the PubMed literature 2000–2008. BMC Med Educ. 2010;10:32. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 8.Doyle NW, Gafni Lachter L, Jacobs K. Scoping review of mentoring research in the occupational therapy literature, 2002–2018. Aust Occup Ther J. 2019;66:541–51. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 9.Stefely JA, et al. A physician-scientist preceptorship in clinical and translational research enhances training and mentorship. BMC Med Educ. 2019;19:89. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 10.McSherry R, Snowden M. Exploring primary healthcare students and their mentors’ awareness of mentorship and clinical governance as part of a local continuing professional development (CPD) program: Findings of a quantitative survey. Healthcare Basel. 2019;7:113. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 11.Gíslason HF, et al. The shape of chiropractic in Europe: a cross sectional survey of chiropractor’s beliefs and practice. Chiropr Man Therap. 2019;27:16. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 12.Leboeuf-Yde C, Innes S, Young KJ, Kawchuk GN, Hartvigsen J. Chiropractic, one big unhappy family: better together or apart? Chiropr Manual Therap. 2019;27:4. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 13.McIntyre C, McLeod GA, Ferreira APA, Ceritelli F, Draper-Rodi J, Feehan J, et al. Leadership and capacity building in international osteopathic research: introducing strengthening osteopathy leadership and researcj (SOLAR) program. Int J Osteopath Med. 2025;56:100755. [Google Scholar]
Associated Data
This section collects any data citations, data availability statements, or supplementary materials included in this article.
Supplementary Materials
Data Availability Statement
Not applicable.

