Skip to main content
. 2026 Apr 1;15(5):1623–1645. doi: 10.1007/s40123-026-01376-3

Table 2.

Overview of the assessment of the ROBINS-I risk-of-bias tool and the certainty of evidence of the included studies

Year Author Bias due to confounding Bias in classification of interventions Bias in participant selection Bias due to missing data Bias in measurement of the outcome Bias in selection of reported result Overall risk of bias Certainty of the evidence
(GRADE)
2024 Cao et al. Low Low Moderate Low Low Low Moderate High certainty
2013 Cummings et al. Low Low Low Moderatea Moderate Low Moderate Low certainty
2023 He et al. Low Low Low Low Moderate Low Moderate Low certainty
2020 Kanellopoulos Low Low Low Low Moderate Low Moderate Low certainty
2024 Kanellopoulos Low Low Moderate Low Moderate Low Moderate Low certainty
2024 Kanellopoulos et al. Low Low Seriousb Low Moderate Low Serious Very low certaintyc
2025 Khoramnia et al. Low Low Low Low Low Low Low High certainty
2025 Luo et al. Low Low Seriousb Low Moderate Low Serious Very low certaintyc
2025 Luo et al. Low Low Seriousb Low Moderate Low Serious Very low certaintyc
2012 Schumacher et al. Low Low Moderate Low Moderate Low Moderate Low certainty
2025 Sitto et al. Low Low Low Low Moderate Low Moderate Low certainty
2025 Tan et al. Low Low Low Low Moderate Low Moderate Low certainty
2025 Thananjeyan et al. Low Low Low Low Moderate Low Moderate Low certainty
2024 Yuan et al. Low Low Low Low Low Low Low High certainty

aFor the 6-month follow-up

bExclusion of patients with adverse events

cDowngraded owing to serious overall risk of bias

NA, not applicable; NR, not reported