Table 2. Study eligibility criteria based on the PICO framework.
GAD-7: generalized anxiety disorder 7-item scale, HRV: heart rate variability, MBBS: bachelor of medicine, bachelor of surgery, MD: doctor of medicine, PICO: population, intervention, comparator, outcome (framework), PSS: perceived stress scale, RCTs: randomized controlled trials, STAI: state-trait anxiety inventory
[12]
| Category | Inclusion criteria | Exclusion criteria |
| Population (P) | Students enrolled in an undergraduate or graduate medical degree program from different healthcare disciplines (e.g., MBBS, nursing, dentistry), irrespective of year of study. | Practicing physicians or residents. |
| Intervention (I) | Structured pranayama (e.g., Kapalabhati, Bhramari, Nadi Shodhana, slow-paced pranayama) as the primary, stand-alone intervention. The practice could be supervised or unsupervised. | Multi-modal interventions where the effect of breathing exercises could not be isolated (e.g., yoga combining asana, pranayama, and meditation); non-yogic breathing techniques (e.g., Buteyko). |
| Comparator (C) | Active control (e.g., non-pranayama relaxation, physical exercise) or passive control (e.g., wait-list, no intervention, treatment as usual). | Not applicable |
| Outcomes (O) | Primary: Validated scales measuring self-reported anxiety (e.g., GAD-7, STAI) or perceived stress (e.g., PSS). Secondary: Objective or performance-based measures of cognition (e.g., attention, memory tests), HRV parameters. | Studies reporting only qualitative outcomes or physiological measures unrelated to the review's outcomes. |
| Study design | RCTs and non-randomized controlled intervention studies (e.g., quasi-experimental, pre-post). | Case reports, case series, narrative reviews, editorials, conference abstracts without full data, and protocols. |