Table 2.
Details of all included studies.
| First author and reference | Study type | Country | Sample size (N) and age | Aim | Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ruangkanchanasetr et al. (35) | Cross-sectional | Thailand (Bangkok) | 2,311 students (12–18 years) | To identify the prevalence of risk behaviors and related factors | High prevalence of risk behaviors (e.g., substance abuse, suicidal tendencies, injury) found; risk factors included poor self-esteem, poor school performance, and family factors |
| Habib and Seif El Din (53) | Intervention Study | Egypt (Alexandria) | 334 (12–14 years) (n = 17 completed the intervention) | To evaluate the effectiveness of a Cognitive Behavior Therapy (CBT) program in reducing depressive symptoms | The CBT intervention resulted in significant improvement in self-esteem and reduction in depression symptoms 3 months after the completion of a 9-session program |
| Zhang et al. (43) | Cross-sectional | China (Shandong Province) | 927 (14–15 years) | To investigate and compare the mental health problems and coping styles of adolescents in urban and rural areas and associations with socioeconomic status | Students in rural low-SES areas (especially females) had more mental health problems; maladaptive coping (venting/fantasizing) related to poorer mental health |
| He et al. (38) | Cross-sectional | China (Rural Hubei) | 875 590 were ‘LBC’ (9–12 years) |
To explore the risk of depression in Left-behind children and identify associated factors such as SES and social support | Left-behind children had a significantly higher risk of depression; low social support and low SES were associated with increased depression risk |
| Cortina et al. (36) | Prevalence Study | South Africa (Rural, Limpopo Province) | 1,025 children (aged 10–12) | To determine the prevalence of mental health problems (emotional, conduct, and hyperactivity symptoms) in a rural, setting, and to identify associated risk factors, including perception/ connectedness to school | Teachers identified high levels of behavioral, conduct and emotional problems; second-generation refugee status and large household size were risk factors |
| Nik-Azin et al. (33) | Psychometric Validation Study | Iran (Yazd City) | 551 students (11–19 years) | The Persian version of the Kidscreen-52 questionnaire was validated with mental health measures (anxiety, depression) and self-esteem | The Kidscreen-52 showed good internal consistency and acceptable construct validity; significant associations were found between self esteem and the KIDSCREEN-52 dimensions |
| Vawda (49) | Prevalence Study | South Africa (Durban) | 222 (13–14 years) | To investigate the prevalence of suicidal behavior and associated psychological factors (social support, coping) | Low levels of self-esteem and perceived social support were associated with higher levels of suicidal behavior; alcohol use, depression, perceived stress, friends’ suicidal thoughts or ideation were risk factors for suicidal behavior |
| Leventhal et al. (26) | RCT | India (Rural Bihar) | 2,308 rural females (12–14 years) | To evaluate the effectiveness of a 5-month school-based Resilience Curriculum (RC) program | The RCT showed significant improvements in measures of emotional resilience, self-efficacy, social–emotional assets, and wellbeing compared to controls. No effect on depression was detected. There was a small, negative effect of the intervention on anxiety. |
| Harrison et al. (32) | Cross-sectional | Jamaica (Metropolis) | 524 (mean 14.9 years) | To determine the prevalence of Disordered Eating Behaviors (DEBs) and identify associated risk and protective factors, including self-esteem and mood | Risk factors for DEBs were: being female, history of sexual abuse and higher negative affect scores. A protective factor for participants was living with their father. |
| Satyanarayana et al. (27) | Cross-sectional | India (urban setting) | 452 females (16–19 years) | To examine the associations among gender disadvantage, psychological distress, and resilience | A negative relationship was found between resilience and distress. Gender disadvantage (gender discrimination, violence and sexual harassment and barriers to personal growth) was associated with moderate and severe distress. |
| McMullen et al (25), | RCT | Uganda | 620 with 170 reported post-intervention data (13–18 years) | To evaluate if a school-based, teacher-led life skills intervention was effective in increasing self-efficacy, prosocial behavior and a sense of connectedness and reducing internalizing problems | There was a significant increase in self-efficacy and connectedness and reduction in internalizing problems (depression and anxiety symptoms) following completion of the intervention compared to the control group. |
| Gardner and Lambert (52) | Cross-sectional | Jamaica | 334 (10–18 years) | To examine the interacting effects of Trait-Emotional Intelligence (TEI) on the associations between self-esteem and depressive symptoms | Older adolescents had greater depressive symptoms and lower self-esteem. TEI’s buffered the association between self-esteem and depressive symptoms |
| Nsabimana et al. (24) | Cross-sectional | Rwanda | 178 (Aged 9–16) |
To investigate if institutionalization negatively impacts children’s psychological adjustment (externalizing/internalizing problems and self-esteem) | Institutionalized children had significantly more externalizing behavior problems. Self-esteem of non-orphans in families was highest, highlighting the protective role of family |
| Mwakanyamale et al. (54) | Cross-sectional | Tanzania | 1,000 (13–21 years) | To describe the relationship between childhood psychological maltreatment, self-esteem, psychological distress, depression and anxiety | Psychological maltreatment positively correlated with psychological distress and negatively correlated with self-esteem |
| Pandey et al. (47) | Prevalence study | Nepal | 6,531 students (12–17 years) | To estimate the prevalence of suicidal ideation and identify the associated factors | Anxiety, loneliness, and female gender were risk factors for both suicidal ideation and attempts; having 3 or more close friends was a protective factor against suicidal attempt |
| Rana et al. (34) | Prevalence study | India (Chandigarh, North India) | 667 (12-15 years) | To estimate the prevalence and correlates of bullying | Bully-victims had the highest mental health problems. Predictors of bullying included: being male, having ‘abnormal’ emotions, and poor peer relations. Self-esteem was not found to correlate with bullying. |
| Arora et al. (28) | Qualitative Study | Guyana | 40 (12–17 years) (and 17 adults) | To explore youth and adult stakeholders’ perspectives on risk and protective factors for suicide | Risk factors included: pressure and expectations, adults’ negative responses to youth, limited coping, and exposure to suicide; protective factors included: positive social support and involvement in community activities |
| El-Abbassy et al. (45) | Intervention | Egypt 54% rural, 46% urban |
80 (13–15 years) | To examine the efficacy of a Positive Psychology Intervention (PPI) in promoting mental health, life satisfaction, self-esteem, optimism and happiness | The PPI led to increases in self-efficacy, self-esteem, optimism, life satisfaction, and happiness scores from pre-intervention to post-intervention |
| Garbett et al. (31) | Pilot RCT | Urban India | 166 (11 years) | To evaluate a culturally adapted school-based body image intervention “Dove Confident Me” | The intervention demonstrated high acceptability and preliminary efficacy and significant improvements in body esteem and positive affect scores; no significant effects were found on internalization, life engagement, eating pathology, self-esteem or negative affect |
| Addy et al. (44) | Mixed-Methods Study | Ghana (rural and peri-urban) | Quantitive study - 405 (12–20 years) Qual – 53 participants including 35 students |
To investigate mental health problems, coping strategies, and the student’s support systems | Risk factors included being female, bullying, domestic violence, substance abuse, and academic pressure, coping involving isolation, substance use, and spiritual help; school counseling units were often ineffective |
| Avanci et al. (29) | Prevalence study | Brazil (São Gonçalo, Rio de Janeiro) Urban dwellers | 862 (13–19 years) | To determine the prevalence of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder symptoms in trauma-exposed students and investigate associated factors (sociodemographic, individual, and family) | Significant risk factors included social functional impairment and violence. Resilience and social support were not significantly associated with the presence of PTSD symptoms. |
| Wang et al. (42) | Cross-sectional | Rural China (Gansu province) | 2,989 (7–15 years) | To examine the relationship between primary caregivers’ mental health and school-aged children’s outcomes (mental health, resilience, academic performance) | Caregiver mental health problems were negatively correlated with all student outcomes (student mental health, resilience, academic performance) |
| Berry et al. (30) | Quasi-experimental Trial | South Africa (Cape Town Metropolitan area) |
113 (12–22 years) | To assess outcome of depression, resilience and positive parenting in young people who participated in a 20 week adolescent parenting program which included biological and nonbiological parents | Positive parenting and resilience improved in both groups. Depression rates increased for non-biological parents in the intervention group. High depression risk was associated with smaller improvements in supportive parenting. |
| (46) | Short-term Longitudinal | Peru (throughout the nation) | 1,334 (11–17 years) | To investigate whether social-ecological resilience (personal resources and caregiver relationship) related to changes in internalizing symptoms (anxiety and depression) during the COVID-19 lockdown | Adolescents with higher levels of personal, caregiver, and overall resilience had lower levels of anxiety and depressive symptoms; resilience moderated the change in anxiety symptoms over time |
| She et al. (48) | RCT | China (Shanghai, rural and urban) | 653 (9 to 16 years) | To test the feasibility and effectiveness of a volunteer-led, 8-week mindfulness intervention | No statistically significant differences were found for mindfulness, resilience, anxiety, or depression outcomes in the intervention vs. control groups |
| Alshammari (57) | Cross-sectional | Jordan (Irbid governorate) | 2,741 (13–18 years) | To explore the risk and protective factors related to health behaviors (tobacco, diet) and mental health and psychological variables (depression, life satisfaction, self-esteem) | The importance of social support (from family, friends, and significant others) was a protective factor against depressive symptoms and higher self-esteem and life satisfaction |
| Edet et al. (37) | Cross-sectional | Nigeria (Calabar) | 332 (11–20 years) | To assess the relative importance of social support and family affluence in depression and self-esteem | Social support was of greater importance than family affluence; respondents with low social support had significantly higher depression and lower self-esteem scores, regardless of their family affluence. Social support and female gender predicted depression; social support and age was positively associated with self-esteem |
| Lewis-Smith et al. (39) | RCT | India (Delhi) | 568 11–14 years) | To evaluate the efficacy of a school-based mixed-gender body image intervention (“Dove Confident Me”) | The intervention led to significant improvements in body image at post-intervention and 3-month follow-up. Significant improvements were found for internalization, life disengagement, disordered eating, self-esteem, and negative affect. |
| Tran et al. (40) | RCT | Vietnam (Hanoi) | 1,084 (15–16 years) | To evaluate the effects of a universal school-based mental health promotion program, ‘Happy House’ | At 2 weeks post-intervention, the program participants showed significant reductions in depressive symptoms and higher psychological well-being. Coping and self-efficacy were higher in the intervention group at 2-week and 6-month follow-up. The effect on depressive symptoms was no longer significant at 6 months. |
| Cherewick et al. (56) | Cross-sectional | India (Darjeeling) urban, peri-urban, and rural |
274 (10–14 years) | To analyze the relationship between autistic traits and internalizing symptoms among early adolescents and examine the moderating effect of self-efficacy | Higher internalizing symptoms were associated with higher autistic traits; self-efficacy (academic, social, and emotional dimensions) moderated the relationship |
| Coetzee et al. (50) | Pilot Test | South Africa (Western Cape) | 222 (9–11 years) | To determine the feasibility and acceptability of ‘4 Steps To My Future’ (4STMF), a universally delivered classroom-based mental health program | The program was acceptable and feasible. Exploratory outcomes showed significant pre-post improvements in self-esteem and emotion regulation. |
| Ward-Smith et al. (55) | Cross-sectional | South Africa (Western Cape) | 733 (15–18 years) | To investigate associations between depression and anxiety symptoms and Emotion Regulation (ER) | Female gender, higher depressive symptoms, anxiety, PTSD symptoms and risky-alcohol use were significantly associated with poorer ER, whereas self-esteem was significantly associated with better ER |
| Chen et al. (51) | Cross-sectional | China (Guangdong Province) |
686 (11–16 years) | To assess whether shift-and-persist strategies were associated with depressive symptoms and have Socio Economic Status (SES) may be related | Use of more frequent shift-and-persist strategies was associated with fewer depressive symptoms, with stronger effects among those with lower SES. |
| Wan et al. (41) | Cross-sectional | China (Rural, 8 provinces) | 4,708 (12 years) | To examine whether left-behind families and gender inequality places children at higher risk of Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) and depressive symptoms | There was a positive association between the number of ACEs reported and symptoms of depression and low self-esteem |
| Zook et al. (23) | Intervention Study |
Democratic Republic of Congo | 483 females (10–14 years) | To assess whether a 12 week music therapy Healing in Harmony (HiH) program improved mental health and school attendance | The HiH program was associated with improvements in depression and higher self-esteem post-intervention and at 17 month follow up |
| Fine et al. (22) | Cross-sectional qualitative Study |
9 LIMCs: Chile, China, Democratic Republic of the Congo, Egypt, Indonesia, Jamaica, Jordan, Kenya, Malawi; 4 HICs: Belgium, Sweden, Switzerland, United States | 71 (12–19 years) | To understand adolescents’ perspectives on mental health challenges, risk and protective factors, and coping strategies in multi-country settings | In LMICs and HICs young people emphasized coping, and social and contextual factors (friends, family school, poverty, violence) to be associated with mental health problems and barriers to help-seeking. |