Skip to main content
Wiley Open Access Collection logoLink to Wiley Open Access Collection
. 2026 Jul 17;23(4):e70474. doi: 10.1111/tct.70474

How to Create Accessible OSCE Exams for Learners With Disabilities

Lisa M Meeks 1,✉, Jordan Juliao 1, Emily Langham 2, Anne Lewis 3, Judith Brenner 4
PMCID: PMC13377284  PMID: 42464780

1. Introduction

Objective structured clinical examinations (OSCEs) are widely used across health professions education to assess learners' clinical skills through structured encounters with standardised patients [1]. OSCEs also present a known barrier to disability access for medical students with disabilities [2, 3, 4, 5, 6], a rapidly growing population. Using trained actors, also known as standardised patients who portray the same clinical scenario for all learners, these examinations allow for assessment of medical knowledge, clinical reasoning, communication skills and elements of the physical examination in a controlled and standardised setting [1]. They may be used for formative feedback, summative assessment or progression decisions, and they frequently function as high‐stakes evaluations within medical and health sciences curricula [1].

Because OSCEs are designed to mimic ‘real‐world’ clinical scenarios, they are often perceived as fundamentally different from didactic assessments, not amenable to accommodation/reasonable adjustments “adjustments” [6, 7, 8]. A common argument is that adjustments would fundamentally alter the assessment, based on the belief that the examination measures a learner's ability to engage in a patient encounter in a particular way, and that completing the encounter within a fixed time or communicating orally with the patient is inherently essential [8].

However, many OSCEs are developmental in nature and function as educational experiences designed to provide formative feedback [1]. Moreover, OSCEs often assess several distinct competencies, including the ability to synthesise clinical information, develop a differential diagnosis, communicate in a patient‐centred manner and develop and communicate a plan of care, all essential skills for becoming a physician [1]. Accordingly, they require a precise approach to accessibility. While the literature has begun to outline adjustment strategies for OSCEs and similar clinical assessments [2, 5, 9], there remains a considerable gap in practical guidance for determining adjustments and evaluating accessibility while preserving assessment validity. To address this gap, we present a structured universal design/universal design for learning (UD/L) informed framework for determining adjustments while maintaining assessment integrity, developed through the collective expertise of disability resource professionals (DRPs) and assessment experts.

2. Structure of OSCEs

OSCEs consist of multiple discrete components, each designed to assess distinct competencies. A typical OSCE includes a pre‐encounter phase—commonly referred to as ‘chart notes’—where learners review written instructions and patient data (e.g., chief complaint, vital signs or lab values) [1]. This is followed by a patient encounter where learners obtain a history, perform relevant aspects of a physical examination, develop a working differential diagnosis and develop and communicate a plan to the patient [10]. Finally, in the post‐encounter, learners synthesise information from the clinical encounter through written documentation, such as a subjective, objective, assessment and plan (SOAP) note, and/or present the patient via an oral presentation [11].

Each component places distinct cognitive, sensory, motor and communicative demands on learners. Pre‐encounter tasks primarily involve information processing and early clinical reasoning [1]. Patient encounters emphasise interpersonal and communication skills, physical examination, clinical reasoning and professionalism [10]. Post‐encounter tasks assess clinical reasoning, documentation skills, data interpretation, reflective practice and medical knowledge [11]. Treating these components as interchangeable, or assuming they rely on the same skills, oversimplifies the competencies OSCEs are designed to assess and may obscure barriers within the assessment itself. For educators, assessment leaders and DRPs, identifying the competencies assessed within each component is essential to determining reasonable adjustments and ensuring equitable assessment. Moreover, assessment validity depends on ensuring that the observed performance reflects the intended construct rather than barriers introduced by the assessment format [12]. In OSCEs, barriers may arise from the interaction between a learner's functional limitations and the design of a specific component. For example, when the pre‐encounter phase is intended to assess synthesis of clinical information—not reading speed—limited time to review door charts may limit a learner's ability to demonstrate clinical reasoning [2, 8, 9]. Similarly, barriers may arise from physical navigation of the examination room, sensory‐related access to information or communication or constraints in how learners are expected to document their reasoning [5]. When thoughtfully applied, adjustments support assessment validity by ensuring that OSCE performance reflects clinical competence rather than access to the assessment format [2, 5, 8, 9, 12]. Their purpose is to provide learners with disabilities equal opportunity to demonstrate competence.

3. Universal Design

Universal design provides an important conceptual foundation for accessible assessment [13, 14]. Originating in architecture and environmental design, it seeks to minimise barriers through the proactive design of environments and systems that are usable by the broadest range of individuals [13, 14]. Within education, these principles have informed UD/L and contemporary validity theory, which emphasise the identification and removal of construct‐irrelevant barriers so that assessment outcomes more accurately represent the competencies being measured [12, 15]. Together, these frameworks support access while preserving validity, shifting consideration of reasonable adjustments from how performance is expressed to the competency being assessed. In the context of OSCEs, this distinction is critical. Characteristics such as station timing, communication modality and task mechanics may reflect the assessment format rather than the clinical competency of interest. Consequently, adjustments that modify the conditions under which performance is demonstrated, without altering the underlying competency being assessed, can enhance access while maintaining the validity and integrity of the examination. Figure 1 illustrates how UD/L features can be integrated across the pre‐encounter, encounter and post‐encounter phases of an OSCE. The accompanying definitions and examples introduce key concepts in UD/L and assessment validity that underpin the approach described in this paper.

FIGURE 1.

FIGURE 1

Universal design and universal design for learning (UD/L) across the OSCE continuum.

UD/L provides a complementary approach to improving access in OSCEs. By incorporating multiple means of engagement, representation, action and expression, programmes can reduce construct‐irrelevant barriers before individual adjustments are considered. In OSCEs, this may include multimodal door charts, accessible examination rooms, flexible approaches to documentation and the integration of assistive technologies.

However, UD/L does not eliminate the need for adjustments. Even in well‐designed assessment environments, learners may encounter disability‐related barriers arising from the interaction between their functional limitations and specific components of the examination. Consequently, UD/L and individual adjustments should be viewed as complementary rather than competing approaches. Table 1 illustrates how UD/L strategies can be applied to address common access barriers across the components of an OSCE.

TABLE 1.

Relationship between OSCE components, functional demands, access barriers and UD/L strategies.

OSCE component Primary competency assessed Functional demands Common access barriers Universal design and universal design for learning (UD/L) strategy Intended benefit
Door charts (pre‐encounter) Synthesis of clinical information; initial clinical reasoning Reading, information processing, visual access, time‐limited review Reading speed; processing time, inaccessible format of information Multimodal door charts (text and audio); advance access when appropriate; accessible workstations/platforms; alternative methods for viewing information (e.g., iPad) Reduces construct‐irrelevant barriers related to information access and processing
Patient encounter History‐taking; physical exam; communication skills; clinical reasoning; treatment planning; professionalism Mobility, communication, sensory access, interaction with patients and equipment Inaccessible rooms or equipment; communication and sensory barriers Accessible rooms; adjustable examination equipment; accessible room/routes; communication supports; consistent room layout Promotes equitable participation while preserving assessment of clinical skills
Post‐encounter task Clinical reasoning; differential diagnosis; plan development; communication of plan and reasoning Written expression, organisation, typing, speech production, information synthesis Documentation mechanics, processing speed; communication fluency Typed notes; dictation; structured templates; spelling and grammar support software Supports accurate expression of clinical reasoning without altering the construct assessed
Across all components Integration of clinical skills Navigation, tasks, transitions, information management Variable instruction, unnecessary cognitive load Standardised instructions; consistent layout; predictable workflow Reduces extraneous cognitive burden and improves usability for all learners

4. A Framework for Determining Reasonable Adjustments

Determining adjustments for an OSCE requires an individualised analysis of both the learner and the assessment. This begins with understanding the structure of the exam, including its discrete components, the allocation of time across tasks and the competencies assessed within each component. Equally important is identifying the purpose of each task. For example, is a component intended to evaluate clinical reasoning and communication, or the ability to perform under strict time constraints? These distinctions are critical, as adjustments that are appropriate for one component may be unnecessary or inappropriate for another.

Accordingly, decisions about reasonable adjustment should focus on barriers arising from the interaction between a learner's functional limitations and a specific component of the OSCE. This component‐level analysis helps distinguish barriers related to the assessment format from the competencies being measured. Without such analysis, adjustment decisions may default to broad conclusions about whether an OSCE can be accommodated, rather than identifying where access breaks down and how barriers can be addressed while preserving assessment validity. Although conceptually straightforward, this approach can be difficult to operationalise in practice. To support this approach, we provide a decision‐making framework that applies principles of UD/L and validity theory to identify construct‐irrelevant barriers while preserving the competencies being assessed (Table 2).

TABLE 2.

Framework for identifying and addressing access barriers in OSCEs.

Step Decision point Key questions Application to OSCEs
1 Define OSCE structure What are the component parts of the OSCE? Break the OSCE into discrete components (pre‐encounter, encounter and post‐encounter) rather than treating it as a single assessment.
2 Identify intended assessment constructs What competency is each component designed to assess? Define intended constructs (e.g., clinical reasoning, communication, physical examination and documentation) and anchor decisions in assessment validity.
3 Identify functional limitations How might the learner's disability affect participation in each assessment component? Consider the impact of time pressure, physical layout, patient interaction, sensory demands and task requirements rather than automatically transferring accommodations/reasonable adjustments from didactic settings.
4 Identify access barriers Where does access break down? Determine whether barriers occur during the pre‐encounter, encounter and/or post‐encounter phase.
5 Distinguish assessment construct from format Does the barrier affect the competency being assessed or the method used to assess it? Separate intended constructs from assessment features such as reading speed, typing, handwriting, speech fluency or physical navigation demands when these are not the focus of the assessment.
6 Consider universal design and universal design of learning (UD/L) Can the barrier be reduced or removed through assessment design? Consider multimodal door charts, accessible rooms, structured templates, assistive technology, or other universal design strategies. *Recognise that UD/L does not eliminate the need for individualised accommodations.
7 Select an accommodation/reasonable adjustment “adjustment” What adjustment best addresses the identified barrier? Match adjustments to the specific task or barrier (e.g., extended time, accessible equipment or environment and alternative formats).
8 Consult evidence and expertise Has this issue been addressed previously? Review relevant literature, guidance documents, peer practices and engage communities of practice before concluding that an adjustment is unreasonable.
9 Evaluate feasibility Can the adjustment be implemented effectively? Consider scheduling, staffing, space, staffing and exam logistics.
10 Confirm assessment validity Does the reasonable adjustment preserve the intended construct? Ensure the reasonable adjustments remove construct‐irrelevant barriers without altering the competencies being assessed.
11 Document the rationale How was the decision reached? Record the relationship between functional limitation, identified barrier, adjustment and assessed construct.
12 Re‐evaluate and refine Did the adjustment work as intended? Evaluate implementation and use findings to improve future OSCEs and assessment design.

5. Planning for Accessible OSCE Delivery

Advanced planning is critical to the delivery of accessible OSCEs. These examinations require coordination of standardised patients, faculty, space, technology and timing, and are often scheduled months in advance. Early collaboration among DRPs, assessment leaders and simulation directors allows programmes to anticipate barriers and build flexibility into assessment design.

Early collaboration among DRPs, assessment leaders and simulation directors allows programmes to anticipate barriers and build flexibility into assessment design.

Delivery of accommodated OSCEs can be achieved using several models (Table 3), including approaches grounded in UD/L and individual adjustments. Figure 2 presents three illustrative scenarios demonstrating application of the framework across different functional limitations and OSCE components. Although not exhaustive, the same approach can be applied across a broad range of disability experiences and needs.

TABLE 3.

Approaches to accessible 25‐minute OSCE delivery.

UD/L approach example 1. UD/L OSCE (reduced reliance on reasonable adjustments)
Component Standard format Optimised UD/L approach
Door charts 5 min 5 min (multimodal presentation, visual and audio options; available in advance for students, accessible door charts stations at wheelchair height, ability to change font size, contrast, etc., of visual presentation).
Encounter 10 min 10 min (accessible rooms; lowered devices; adjustable bed)
Post‐encounter 5 min 5 min (ability to use speech to text software, performed in word with spelling/grammar tools available)
Transition 5 min 5 min
Total per station 25 min 25 min
Total OSCE time (6 stations) 150 min 150 min
UD/L approach example 2. Hybrid model (UD/L + focused adjustments on door chart and post‐encounter)
Component Standard format Optimised UD/L and adjustment approach
Door charts 5 min 5–7.5 min (UD/L + focused reasonable adjustments)
Encounter 10 min 10 min (accessible environment)
Post‐encounter 5 min 5–7.5 min or end‐of‐session extension
Transition 5 min 5 min
Total per station 25 min 25–30 min
End‐of‐session block — Optional (+2.5 min)
Total OSCE time (6 stations) 150 min 150–180 min
Individualised adjustment approach example 1. End‐of‐session (time and one half) extension (post‐encounter focus)
Component Standard format Reasonable adjustment approach
Door charts 5 min 5 min
Encounter 10 min 10 min
Post‐encounter 5 min 5 min
Transition 5 min 5 min
Total per station 25 min 25 min
End‐of‐session block for extended time — +2.5 min
Total OSCE time (6 stations) 150 min 152.5 min
Individualised adjustment approach example 2. Extended time OSCE (focused pre/post‐encounter support) ( time and one half ) Recommend administering as a separate OSCE at the beginning or end of the day, though this can be incorporated into a testing matrix at any time .
Component Standard format Reasonable adjustment approach
Door charts 5 min 7.5 min
Encounter 10 min 10 min
Post‐encounter 5 min 7.5 min
Transition 5 min 5 min
Total time per station 25 min 30 min
Individualised adjustment approach example 3. Extended time during patient interaction (encounter‐focused access) ( time and one half )
Component Standard format Reasonable adjustment approach
Door charts 5 min 5 min (accessible workstation)
Encounter 10 min 15 min (with potential intermediary to assist with patient positioning, grabbing equipment)
Post‐encounter 5 min 5 min (with accessible workstation)
Transition 5 min 5 min
Total per station 25 min 30 min
Total OSCE time (6 stations) 150 min 180 min

FIGURE 2.

FIGURE 2

OSCE breakdown and scenarios to demonstrate operationalising reasonable adjustments and UD/L.

6. Conclusion

OSCEs are powerful tools for assessing clinical competence, but their effectiveness depends on thoughtful design. Viewing OSCEs as composite assessments composed of discrete tasks allows educators to distinguish the competencies being assessed from construct‐irrelevant barriers that may impede learner performance. When adjustments are determined through individualised, task‐based analysis, they can support equitable access while preserving the validity and integrity of the assessment.

When adjustments are determined through individualised, task‐based analysis, they can support equitable access while preserving the validity and integrity of the assessment.

For clinical teachers and programme leaders, anticipating adjustment needs, collaborating early with learners and DRPs and adopting flexible approaches to OSCE design are essential practices. This work also requires addressing persistent misconceptions that adjustments lower standards or confer unfair advantage. Rather, adjustments help ensure that assessment outcomes reflect a learner's clinical competence rather than barriers unrelated to the constructs being assessed. Applying principles of UD/L alongside adjustment offers an opportunity to create more accessible assessment systems for all learners. Future research should evaluate the impact of these approaches on accessibility, accommodation/reasonable adjustment utilisation, implementation feasibility, learner outcomes and assessment validity across diverse institutional contexts.

For clinical teachers and programme leaders, anticipating adjustment needs, collaborating early with learners and DRPs and adopting flexible approaches to OSCE design are essential practices.

Author Contributions

Lisa M. Meeks: conceptualization, data curation, formal analysis, funding acquisition, investigation, methodology, project administration, resources, software, supervision, validation, visualization, writing – original draft, writing – review and editing. Jordan Juliao: investigation, project administration, writing – original draft, writing – review and editing. Emily Langham: visualization, writing – original draft, writing – review and editing. Anne Lewis: visualization, writing – original draft, writing – review and editing. Judith Brenner: visualization, writing – original draft, writing – review and editing.

Funding

Dr. Meeks was supported by grant 155857 from the Ford Foundation; Rehabilitation, Research and Training Centers Equity grant 90RTHF0005 from the National Institute on Disability, Independent Living and Rehabilitation Research; and grant 82590 from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.

Ethics Statement

The authors have nothing to report.

Consent

The authors have nothing to report.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.

Acknowledgements

We thank Kaitlyn Ripaldi from YellowLeaf Design for her assistance in creating our figures.

Data Availability Statement

The authors have nothing to report.

References

  • 1. Zabar S., Kachur E., Hanley K., Gillespie C., and Kalet A., “Introduction: OSCEs: Past, Present, and Future,” in Objective Structured Clinical Examinations: 10 Steps to Planning and Implementing OSCEs and Other Standardized Patient Exercises, 2nd ed., eds. Zabar S., Kachur E., Hanley K., Gillespie C., and Kalet A. (Springer, 2025), 1–7. [Google Scholar]
  • 2. Tarafdar S. A., Seoudi N., Luo R., and Winston K., “Experiences of Medical Students and Doctors With Dyslexia: A Systematic Review,” Medical Education 12, no. 59 (2025): 797–811. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 3. Jarus T., Krupa T., Mayer Y., et al., “Negotiating Legitimacy and Belonging: Disabled Students' and Practitioners' Experience,” Medical Education 57, no. 6 (2022): 535–547. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 4. Asghar Z., Williams N., Denney M., and Siriwardena A. N., “Performance in Candidates Declaring Versus Those Not Declaring Dyslexia in a Licensing Clinical Examination,” Medical Education 53, no. 12 (2019): 1243–1252. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 5. Martin A. I., Hoffman L. A., and Russell A., “Dismantling Barriers in the Medical Curriculum for Learners With Hearing Loss: A Case Study,” Academic Medicine 100, no. 10S (2025): S173–S178. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 6. Gibson S. and Leinster S., “How Do Students With Dyslexia Perform in Extended Matching Questions, Short Answer Questions and Observed Structured Clinical Examinations?,” Advances in Health Sciences Education 16, no. 3 (2011): 395–404, 10.1007/s10459-011-9273-8. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 7. Green E. J., Brown M. E. L., Vance G. H. S., and Keenan I. D., “Undergraduate Medical Education for Neurodivergent Students: A Scoping Review,” BMC Medical Education 26, no. 103 (2025): 103. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 8. Meeks L. M. and Jain N. R., “Accommodating Students on Anatomy and Other Lab Practical Exams,” Disability Compliance for Higher Education 23, no. 3 (2017): 1–7. [Google Scholar]
  • 9. Patwari R., Ferro‐Lusk M., Finley E., and Meeks L. M., “Using a Diagnostic OSCE to Discern Deficit From Disability in Struggling Students,” Academic Medicine 96, no. 2 (2020): 228–231. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 10. Harden R. M., Stevenson M., Downie W. W., and Wilson G. M., “Assessment of Clinical Competence Using Objective Structured Examination,” British Medical Journal 1, no. 5955 (1975): 447–451, 10.1136/bmj.1.5955.447. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 11. Schaye V., Crowe R., Beltran C., and Gillespie C., “Post‐Encounter Learning and Assessment of Clinical Reasoning: Patient Notes and Reflections,” in Objective Structured Clinical Examinations: 10 Steps to Planning and Implementing OSCEs and Other Standardized Patient Exercises, 2nd ed., eds. Zabar S., Kachur E., Kalet A., and Hanley K. (Springer, 2024), 63–74, 10.1007/978-3-031-88752-9. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
  • 12. Messick S., “Validity,” in Educational Measurement, 3rd ed., ed. Linn R. L. (American Council on Education/Macmillan Publishing Co., 1989), 13–103. [Google Scholar]
  • 13. Connell B. R., Jones M., Mace R. L., et al., The Principles of Universal Design, Version 2.0 (Center for Universal Design, North Carolina State University, 1997). [Google Scholar]
  • 14. Jain N. and Varpio L., “Designing for Justice: How Universal Design Theory Could Bolster Health Professional Education Research,” Focus on Health Professional Education: A Multi‐Professional Journal 24, no. 4 (2023): 136–150. [Google Scholar]
  • 15. CAST , Universal Design for Learning Guidelines Version 3.0 [Internet] (CAST, 2024. [Cited 2026 Jun 6].), https://udlguidelines.cast.org. [Google Scholar]

Associated Data

This section collects any data citations, data availability statements, or supplementary materials included in this article.

Data Availability Statement

The authors have nothing to report.


Articles from The Clinical Teacher are provided here courtesy of Wiley

RESOURCES