Table 3.
(Revised structure – separate maternal and fetal/neonatal safety columns)
| Author (Year) | Country | Design | Sample Size (N) | Intervention Details (Protocol) | Control Group | Primary Outcome(s) | Maternal Adverse Events | Fetal/Neonatal Outcomes | Key Efficacy Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kim et al. (2019) [47] | USA | RCT | 26 (Active:14, Sham:12) | Site: Right DLPFC; 1 Hz, 100% MT, 900 pulses/session, 20 sessions | Sham rTMS | Depression: HDRS-17, BDI, EPDS, CGI-S | Mild headache (n = 4); scalp discomfort (n = 2) | No congenital anomalies; no adverse neonatal outcomes reported | Significant time×group interaction (p = 0.003); response 81.8% vs. 45.5% |
| Hızlı Sayar et al. (2014) [48] | Turkey | Open-Label Trial | 30 | Site: Left DLPFC; 25 Hz, 100% MT, 1000 pulses/session, 18 sessions | N/A | Depression: HAMD-17 | Mild headache (n = 6); neck pain (n = 2) | No fetal/neonatal data reported | Mean HAMD decreased 26.77 → 13.03 (p < 0.001) |
| Kim et al. (2011) [49] | USA | Open-Label Pilot | 10 | Site: Right DLPFC; 1 Hz, 100% MT, 20 sessions | N/A | Depression: HDRS | Mild headache (40%); transient uterine contractions (n = 1; resolved) | No adverse pregnancy outcomes | 70% response; 30% remission |
| Klirova et al. (2008) [50] | Czech Republic | Case Series | 2 | Pt1: L-DLPFC, 20 Hz, 15 sessions; Pt2: R-DLPFC, 1 Hz, 15 sessions | N/A | Depression: BDI | None reported | One preterm birth (36 weeks); causality unclear | One full remission; one 59% BDI reduction |
| Zhang et al. (2010) [51] | Not Reported | Case Report† | 1 | Sequential unilateral & bilateral; 1 Hz, 90% MT, multiple courses | N/A | Depression: HDRS | None reported | No adverse outcomes reported | HDRS 35 → 12 |
| Nahas et al. (1999) [52] | Not Specified | Case Report† | 1 | Site: Left DLPFC; 15 Hz, 110% MT, 25 sessions | N/A | Depression: Not specified | None reported | No fetal/neonatal data reported | No symptom improvement |
† Footnote: Study excluded from efficacy synthesis (n < 5 or uncontrolled design); included for safety data extraction only in accordance with eligibility criteria (Sect. 2.2)