Skip to main content
. 2026 May 26;26:561. doi: 10.1186/s12888-026-07948-8

Table 3.

(Revised structure – separate maternal and fetal/neonatal safety columns)

Author (Year) Country Design Sample Size (N) Intervention Details (Protocol) Control Group Primary Outcome(s) Maternal Adverse Events Fetal/Neonatal Outcomes Key Efficacy Findings
Kim et al. (2019) [47] USA RCT 26 (Active:14, Sham:12) Site: Right DLPFC; 1 Hz, 100% MT, 900 pulses/session, 20 sessions Sham rTMS Depression: HDRS-17, BDI, EPDS, CGI-S Mild headache (n = 4); scalp discomfort (n = 2) No congenital anomalies; no adverse neonatal outcomes reported Significant time×group interaction (p = 0.003); response 81.8% vs. 45.5%
Hızlı Sayar et al. (2014) [48] Turkey Open-Label Trial 30 Site: Left DLPFC; 25 Hz, 100% MT, 1000 pulses/session, 18 sessions N/A Depression: HAMD-17 Mild headache (n = 6); neck pain (n = 2) No fetal/neonatal data reported Mean HAMD decreased 26.77 → 13.03 (p < 0.001)
Kim et al. (2011)  [49] USA Open-Label Pilot 10 Site: Right DLPFC; 1 Hz, 100% MT, 20 sessions N/A Depression: HDRS Mild headache (40%); transient uterine contractions (n = 1; resolved) No adverse pregnancy outcomes 70% response; 30% remission
Klirova et al. (2008)  [50] Czech Republic Case Series 2 Pt1: L-DLPFC, 20 Hz, 15 sessions; Pt2: R-DLPFC, 1 Hz, 15 sessions N/A Depression: BDI None reported One preterm birth (36 weeks); causality unclear One full remission; one 59% BDI reduction
Zhang et al. (2010)  [51] Not Reported Case Report† 1 Sequential unilateral & bilateral; 1 Hz, 90% MT, multiple courses N/A Depression: HDRS None reported No adverse outcomes reported HDRS 35 → 12
Nahas et al. (1999)  [52] Not Specified Case Report† 1 Site: Left DLPFC; 15 Hz, 110% MT, 25 sessions N/A Depression: Not specified None reported No fetal/neonatal data reported No symptom improvement

† Footnote: Study excluded from efficacy synthesis (n < 5 or uncontrolled design); included for safety data extraction only in accordance with eligibility criteria (Sect.  2.2)