Table 1.
Comparison of our differentials with the approaches of the related work.
| Dataset | Degradation index(DI) | Health index(HI) | Piece-wise | Filters | Models | Similarity based | Time series | Results | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Our proposal |
Azure AI guide for PdM solutions |
Yes | Yes | Yes |
Savitzky –Golay and Kalman Filter |
RRF and DNN (CNN, LSTM) | Yes | Yes |
Regression coefficient ( We compare RMSE, and we allow failure prediction with considerable anticipation of five days or one hundred and twenty telemetry cycles. |
| Wang et al.6 |
PHM08 Challenge |
No | Yes | No | No |
Regression Models and Moving Average Method |
Yes | No |
The results of the article are guided by competition. The score of the result sent was among the best. |
| Zheng et al.27 |
C-MAPSS, PHM08 Challenge and Milling |
No | No | Yes | No |
Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP), Support Vector Regression (SVR), Relevance Vector Regression (RVR), CNN and LSTM |
No | Yes |
The results are based on the comparing of the RMSE. Two tables are presented comparing the models used for each dataset. |
| Dong et al.33 |
C-MAPSS Jet Engine Failure |
No | No | No | No | LSTM | Yes | Yes | Results based on RMSE and presentation of RUL graphs. |
| Bruneo and De Vita32 | C-MAPSS | No | No | No | No | LSTM | No | Yes |
Was made comparisons with literature results and presented the RMSE by reducing it by about 35% and 54% approaches, with the RMSE score equal to 11.42 and a percentage error equal to 0.12. |
| Liang et al.10 | C-MAPSS | Yes | No | No | No |
Linear Regression, Spearman-coefficient-based model |
Yes | - |
Results based on MAE and presentation of RUL graphs comparing with two other methods with considerable improvement. |
| Cai et al.25 | C-MAPSS | No | No | No |
Particle Filter |
Rao-Blackwellized Particle Filter (RBPF) |
Yes | No |
The comparison is with the Benchmarks, and using the RMSE and score criteria, claim that improved prediction compared with other existing RUL prediction methods. |
| Shi et al.37 | C-MAPSS | No | Yes | Yes |
Exponential Filter |
DA-LSTM | Yes | Yes |
A detailed proposal for a novel DA-LSTM lightweight model based on exponential smoothing and concerns a can achieve high prediction accuracy with fewer parameters. |
