Skip to main content
. 2026 Aug 6;16:24317. doi: 10.1038/s41598-026-56105-4

Table 1.

Comparison of our differentials with the approaches of the related work.

Dataset Degradation index(DI) Health index(HI) Piece-wise Filters Models Similarity based Time series Results

Our

proposal

Azure AI guide

for PdM

solutions

Yes Yes Yes

Savitzky

–Golay

and 

Kalman

Filter

RRF and DNN (CNN, LSTM) Yes Yes

Regression coefficient (Inline graphic) and accuracy above 90%.

We compare RMSE, and we allow failure prediction

with considerable anticipation of five days or

one hundred and twenty telemetry cycles.

Wang et al.6

PHM08

Challenge

No Yes No No

Regression Models and

Moving Average Method

Yes No

The results of the article are guided by competition.

The score of the result sent was among the best.

Zheng et al.27

C-MAPSS,

PHM08

Challenge

and Milling

No No Yes No

Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP),

Support Vector Regression (SVR),

Relevance Vector Regression (RVR),

CNN and LSTM

No Yes

The results are based on the comparing of the RMSE.

Two tables are presented comparing the models used

for each dataset.

Dong et al.33

C-MAPSS 

Jet Engine

Failure

No No No No LSTM Yes Yes Results based on RMSE and presentation of RUL graphs.
Bruneo and De Vita32 C-MAPSS No No No No LSTM No Yes

Was made comparisons with literature results and presented

the RMSE by reducing it by about 35% and 54% approaches,

with the RMSE score equal to 11.42 and a

percentage error equal to 0.12.

Liang et al.10 C-MAPSS Yes No No No

Linear Regression,

Spearman-coefficient-based model 

Yes -

Results based on MAE and presentation of RUL graphs

comparing with two other methods with considerable

improvement.

Cai et al.25 C-MAPSS No No No

Particle

Filter

Rao-Blackwellized Particle Filter

(RBPF)

Yes No

The comparison is with the Benchmarks, and using the

RMSE and score criteria, claim that improved prediction

compared with other existing RUL prediction methods.

Shi et al.37 C-MAPSS No Yes Yes

Exponential

Filter

DA-LSTM Yes Yes

A detailed proposal for a novel DA-LSTM lightweight model

based on exponential smoothing and concerns a can

achieve high prediction accuracy with fewer parameters.